Breaking news

BNZ cuts all fixed mortgage rates for terms 1 - 7 years; seven year fixed rate now 6.99%
MORE SOON

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Manager Operational Effectiveness and Assurance IT
Reporting to the Senior Manager Operational Risk Effectiveness and Assurance, the key focu...more
New Zealand
Financial Controller
Reporting to the Head of Finance - Retail and Business Bank the key focus of this role is ...more
New Zealand
Manager Finance Corporate Core - 12 Month Contract role
This role in consultation with the Financial Controller provides financial, strategic and ...more
New Zealand
IT Audit Manager - Internal Audit - Auckland
If you are motivated by the prospect of seeing the big picture, developing your team and m...more
New Zealand
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Should you fix your mortgage now or stay floating?

Choices

Bollard says markets miss that NZ economy weaker than Australia's (Update 2)

Posted in News

Reserve Bank Governor Alan Bollard has delivered a speech on New Zealand's economic differences with Australia, arguing that financial markets have not understood how New Zealand's outlook is weaker than Australia's. (Update 2 includes statement and powerpoint.) His comments follow the Reserve Bank of Australia's decision this week to increase its official cash rate by 25 bps to 3.5%, taking it a full 100 bps above New Zealand's OCR at 2.5%. "New Zealand has had a recession, and the pick-up is slower and more vulnerable - a difference financial markets do not appear to appreciate," Bollard said. "This is particularly evident in the relatively stable cross-rate on foreign exchange markets. If financial markets can't see the differences, they will eventually lose money, and it will hurt the New Zealand economy," he said. Here is the full press statement below about the speech from the RBNZ.

NZ is not Australia, but could be their lucky neighbour Financial markets and businesses need to appreciate the different futures New Zealand and Australia are charting out of the global financial crisis, Reserve Bank Governor Alan Bollard said today. Speaking to Trans-Tasman Business Circle in Auckland, Dr Bollard said both countries have survived the crisis well, due to a mix of strong institutions and stimulative policies. "However, their immediate prospects are different. Australia has avoided negative growth, and its prospects are driven by strong terms of trade, vast mineral deposits, the Chinese market, and rapid population growth. "New Zealand has had a recession, and the pick-up is slower and more vulnerable - a difference financial markets do not appear to appreciate. "This is particularly evident in the relatively stable cross-rate on foreign exchange markets. If financial markets can't see the differences, they will eventually lose money, and it will hurt the New Zealand economy." Dr Bollard said New Zealand could improve its prospects by taking advantage of Australia's very strong future growth potential. "Australia is a lucky country, but we could be a lucky neighbour." Australia is entering a new minerals boom, investing heavily and encouraged by new finds, re-opening markets, bottlenecks and strong prices. Strong investment and export growth would mean big challenges for Australian policy. "This all means an economy that looks less like New Zealand." However, Australia's potential raised the prospects for New Zealand's manufacturers and services, which have a bigger share of exports than the same sectors in Australia. "Australia will likely be a very strong growth market, and could help New Zealand to indirectly benefit from East Asian growth. Less inflation pressure here will help our competitiveness, assisted by relative exchange rate stability and the spreading Single Economic Market. "New Zealand and Australia have very different resource endowments, financial markets treat us like Australia, but actually we are quite different. We talk about catching up with Australian incomes, but we have better chances of taking advantage of their growth."

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

11 Comments

AB sounds like Graham Henry,

AB sounds like Graham Henry, just before a big match against the Wallabies, trying to convince the reporters that the other AB's are the underdogs., when they're both better than the other opposition teams.

AB isnt the only one

AB isnt the only one who is puzzled by the strength of our dollar,you only have to go t queensland and see everything is going gangbusters when everything here is going bust.so he is warning a bet on the NZD is now a longshot and not a certainty,maybe he can talk the dollar down.

While the NZD does tend

While the NZD does tend to correlate with AUD historically, we are being propped up by them since we have done nothing to deserve such a strong currency (although we haven't QE'd either). My bet is that Allan is correct in his observations, as I type this the euro is gaining.

From a technical perspective his timing is fantastic- a little too coincidental. Take a look at the NZD/USD chart to see what I mean. There was a chance of a breakout, to which he has just given a nudge .

So Bollard is making the

So Bollard is making the case for depositors to send their cash over to Aussie and open an Aussie deposit account, is he not?

"New Zealand's high dollar is

"New Zealand's high dollar is a vote of confidence in the country's economy" says Bill English.
Full article http://bit.ly/3sVhLl
Shurely something wrong...

no gangbusters here in brisbane---building

no gangbusters here in brisbane---building industry completely stalled the only big work
going on is state govt stuff ---bridges tunnels etc---all being built with borrowed money
qld govt is trying to raise 15 billion by selling q/landrail--power co,s etc. q/land is in
worst financial shape of all aus state,s.

I agree pwilkie. My brother

I agree pwilkie. My brother lives in Brisbane and has just been redundant.

What concerns me about the Australian mining recovery is that perhaps we are seeing an increase in demand from China mainly due to the government stimulus.

There will have to be some strong follow up demand from the West to sustain it long term.

"If financial markets can’t see

"If financial markets can't see the differences, they will eventually lose money"

If Bollard seriously believes in what he's saying, then he must also believe that he can make money by betting against the market. And he's certainly got the resources and the mandate to do so. So go on Alan, I DARE you.

Now it just takes time

Now it just takes time for the message from Alan Bollard to sink in. It could have been more forceful but it was a definite change of position from him and adds to stuff already coming from people like Gareth Morgan, Don Brash and treasury. He must be feeling confident that he can speak from the position where the majority are gradually moving to. He really doesn't have the reputation of a free thinking action man does he so this is a good sign.

People who have had some success under the existing policy settings, taking advantage of no capital gains tax, investing in things that can only accumulate wealth while the government keeps borrowing and milking the future of the next generation will keep up their old behaviours until the government actually acts to change the settings.

The vested interests that don't want change (banks, foreign exchange dealers, large landowners that now includes the Maori Party backers) are powerful and will use all endeavours to slow down the changes.

Acting will require less courage when the tax group and the 'catch Australia by 2050 group' report back. Nothing will happen until then. Even then people shifting big sums of money will still not actually change behaviour straight away either because behaviour changes are difficult.

Everyone please just keep up the pressure. Commentators with more information and more time than me have been doing a grand job so far. The tipping point might only be a few weeks away, but is still in danger of stalling if the pressure isn't continuously applied.

puma shoes and adidas shoes

puma shoes and adidas shoes
www.tradertrade.com

Hi, Really informative post. This

Hi,
Really informative post. This will really help me a great deal in starting my own business. Keep posting the good work.