Offers for readers

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Corporate Recovery Senior – Australia, Audit experience welcomed
Successful applicants will have the opportunity to work with this leading Australian Advis...more
Australia
Transaction Services Assistant Manager/ Manager – Melbourne
Think Global Recruitment is working with this exceptionally respected Australian Boutique ...more
Australia
Audit Senior - Australia
Sought after opportunity to move to one of the most beautiful westernised countries in the...more
Australia
Research & Master Trust Relationship Manager
Strategic and Senior Appointment...more
Australia
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Who do you think should be appointed Reserve Bank Governor to replace Alan Bollard when he retires in September?

Choices

Economic weather report: Bankruptcies surprisingly stable

Posted in News

Bernard Hickey delivers an economic weather report in association with ASB, including a look at this chart showing bankruptcies have been relatively stable at a higher level for the last year or so after rising sharply early in 2008. This suggests the recession is hurting, but is not hurting more people more often, partly because interest rates are much lower. Here's the full interactive chart

Related Topics

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

Over a number of months/

Over a number of months/ maybe years time is grinding on most people's wallet- sadly. Bankruptcies will increase sharply soon, I think.

W. KunZ: Tend to agree,

W. KunZ: Tend to agree, I dont think we have seen the worst yet....

I think bankruptcies will decimate

I think bankruptcies will decimate my industry, farming. I met with a real estate agent this afternoon,its not a bed of roses in the farming sector. Accounts are going months unpaid,wages are not even being paid in extreme cases.He has almost no buyers and know idea of what the market for farms is at in $$. Banks wish to sell but only at 5k an acre, wont let new buyers pay over 3k. The banks appear to have stopped issuing credit except for the capitalisation of debt. We are facing a crisis unseen in my life time and even my fathers. Sheep prices are high but the UK is crumbling and destroying the value of its currency

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/6006215/Pound-falls-ahead-o...

Im talking to friends who find the lack of reporting of the problems facing eastcoast farmers astounding. Its a giant debt trap and its been sprung. Dont underestimate the size of the problem or its effect on our exports.
If the country is borrowing money with the expectation that the rural sector will pay it off from future earnings they are deluded. On my farm we have had no rain for nearly a month my water tables are as low as they have been in 10 years. The feed situation is critical and fatal for many. My feed situation is dire and I only have half my normal stock. This mornings rural press carried a front page story on suicide and depression in rural communities,that says a lot. Then further in a story on the problems the climatic conditions are causing to the dairy industry. No feed poor condition stock, no money for feed payout inadequate.
It sickens me to read of the bullsh*t about house prices our export sector is being dismantled in front of our eyes,house prices will be the least of our problems.

Perfect storm hits farmers http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/farmi

Perfect storm hits farmers

http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/farming/2742257/Farming-on-track-for-per...

"It's been a white goldrush; unfortunately the late arrivals are particularly vulnerable."

Wilson feared an "avalanche" of dairy farm foreclosures next autumn if farmers did not sell assets and reduce costs, or if payouts did not improve.

He warned the enforcement of proposed international banking recommendations, requiring banks to impose rigorous capital and risk management policies, would create a "perfect storm" for financially stressed farmers. "It will affect the whole country, but the primary sector in particular."

Oh Mr Hubbard, what have you gone and done.

AndrewJ, I went to a

AndrewJ, I went to a calf sale a couple of days ago, big friesian bulls were being snapped up by agents at a huge premium to send to hawkes Bay. It was a rort. Once those orders were filled, prices went from $120 down to $25. If only those farmers knew they were being done by their agents.
Apparently Dairy cows and heifers are being sent to the works flat out, as farmers cant afford to buy feed, they are reducing stock numbers and the works are paying the best price. Talking to a bloke at the sale who had travelled around a bit, he said feed in the cental to upper north island was extremely tight.
Economic weather report not good I think.
Last month, late July I was looking at colostrum tanks. Ok we are talking the very beginning of calving. The manager of the rural merchandise store told me he would do an exceptional deal, as he didnt want to be left with it. He was in panic mode and the season hadnt started. I went down the road looking at others, at the next store they had very little stuff in stock. Usually they are packed to the rafters for calving. The next store, the salesman wanted to regale stories of dairy hardship and bankruptcy.
Crikey, drystock farmers go for years with shite returns, dairy cant get through one.

William The climate in HB

William
The climate in HB has turned to custard. If anyone you know is rearing calves expecting farmers here to buy them they need good contracts. We have a minus 6 frost outside we are getting them every day,my creek is dry,the ridges on my hills have gone sort of grey/brown. I have finished lambing and am completely out of feed I will start losing ewes soon. Further out to the cost sleepy sickness is claiming a lot of sheep. No store market hoggets are going off to slaughter as there is zero store demand. We have no rain forecast for the rest of the month by then we will be really in the sh*t.
I looking at Techno system farmers that are aging in front of my eyes,Rabo may say they only have %10 of their clients in trouble but the ones they have got, represent a huge % of their borrowing, some of their clients dont look happy.Rumors that Baileys are looking to get out of Rural real estate as its too tough and they expect the downturn to last for years.
Farms are pouring onto the market but there is no market.

I would not want to

I would not want to be a banker in rural NZ right now, especially if I were the sod who just a year or so ago was doing the rounds, encouraging farmers to take on more debt and expand their properties.

William I wish I could

William
I wish I could get readers to understand the simple fact. Farmers that have high debt levels and there are many and many are large,simply have no way to pay off debt. They never thought it would be a problem. They believed like Hubbard that the Govt can always create inflation, they simply do not have the earning capacity to pay off debt they are 100% dependent on capital gain(tax free) They will go under unless values ris, the $ in it self will not be enough to save them. They need rising farm values improved returns,low $,low interest rates,falling costs and enough buyers out there for them to get the hell out of here.

Andrewj Says: "Farmers that have

Andrewj Says:
"Farmers that have high debt levels and there are many and many are large,simply have no way to pay off debt. They never thought it would be a problem."

I dont get it, be it farmers, home owners, property investors, any sort of business....
How can they borrow such high (over 1/3 of their total capital value) get a return of say 10%, pay interest of 5 to 8 % and expect to buy groceries, let alone improve, or cover maintenance ..and survive?
To do so they may as well put their money on the roulette table and cross their fingers, and like they occassional gambler, they may strike lucky, but the odds are against it.

Andrew_J ..Said.......I wish I could

Andrew_J ..Said.......I wish I could get readers to understand the simple fact.

There is nothing wrong with your powers of communication Andrew, and generally well supported by facts albeit not always light reading.
What does not (it appears) filter though is an "empathy" to the gravity of the situation.

I have no personal axe to grind in regard to farming (Dairy or other), but I have noticed as an unbiased observer I'd like to think, "the Machine" undermining public opinion of Farmers as some type of elitist organisation somehow disconnected from the rest of the "struggling" society and due for bad news.
That is an oversimplification but I believe true at it's heart. Case in example, ..in general conversations around the dinner table with friends etc,..I will pop in" what a dire situation faces the farming industry and exporters in general unless some type of drastic intervention takes place."

Thier responses by enlarge are unsympathetic...indifferent....and ill-informed . Is this because they ARE ignorant..? or is it a........ conditioned response ...?
My moneys on the latter if you listen to the rhetoric ,it's always the same..."they had it too good too long" etc..

Andrew , I know I keep banging on about "bolly" as the Bankers Bitchslap but right now he and Billbo sit at the heart of salvation,.... spewing export led recovery Bullsh.t yet diong f..k all about it........And NOBODY IS ASKING THE HARD QUESTIONS!! F..k..F..K..F..K.

Steptoe Farmers have 50 billion

Steptoe
Farmers have 50 billion $ of debt to the main banks at 10% interest 5 billion of interest.
Fonterra want pay 5 billion to farmers this year. Gross agricultural income will be around the $16 billion. Debt is unevenly spread %30 of farmers such as Hubbard carry most.

The problem is this is the driver of the economy our biggest earner by a country mile.
Look at this comment from a real estate agent today on another thread

# Real Estate Agent Says:
August 12th, 2009 at 9:11 am

I suspect that anyone who has their house up for auction today will have called their salesperson and increased their reserve price and the buyers will simply increase their bids to compensate!

These items in this mornings Herald:

"Auckland house prices tipped to rocket"

Infometrics' predictions on Auckland median house prices
* 2009: $440,000
* 2010: $483,200
* 2011: $506,700
* 2012: $553,000

NZ median house prices
* 2009: $339,200
* 2010: $376,200
* 2011: $391,400
* 2012: $419,400

Steven Glucina, a Ponsonby real estate agent at LJ Hooker, said the market was very active. "I sold a two-bedroom do-up villa at 61 Pine Street, Balmoral under the hammer on Saturday for $679,000, which was $109,000 over the council valuation.

"The market in this area is red hot at the moment. I have seen over 1,000 buyers visiting open homes in Pine Street in the past 3 months. I have never been so busy in over 12 years in real estate!"

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10590127

I take it from this that debt is being added again to our economy. I suggest that it is a second tranche to the coming second great depression
this from Bill Bonner

The stock market crashed in '29. The market then bounced. After a few months almost everyone was persuaded that the "worst was over." But the worst was just beginning. It wasn't until 1932 that the stock market finally hit bottom. By then, it was beginning to seem like a depression...and only years later did economic historians tag it as a 'great' depression.

This depression is still wet behind the ears... We're still in the bounce phase. On Friday, the Dow went 113 points higher. And as the bounce continues, more and more investors will come to believe that stocks are in a new bull market and that the economy is back in growth mode.

Neither will be true.

With the average P/E earnings in the USA approaching 140 I suggest we have a long way to fall. Adding fuel to an already overheated property market so punters with obviously little or poor business sense can climb in is absurd and some how twisted.
Our local Plumber is laying of workers he has employed for over 20 years, he is one off hundreds of businesses doing the same. What will it take to destroy confidence in housing its now beyond my comprehension.

Andrewj – you are right,

Andrewj "“ you are right, we are all deluding ourselves making predictions about anything before we find out how Wall Street pans out. You might find the first chart of this link interesting:
http://blogs.creativeloafing.com/politicalwhore/2009/08/05/does-todays-s...

neil thanks thats scary, as

neil
thanks thats scary, as was this,

http://www.energybulletin.net/node/23259

Andrewj, that comparison is not

Andrewj, that comparison is not very convincing.

Hard to compare one society with using the rule of law and the other using Stalin's regime. Also hard to argue that that the British empire collapsed, changed yes (and changed significantly) but collapse?

"The Jails Race once showed the Soviets with a decisive lead, thanks to their innovative GULAG program".

Their GULAG program was not innovative, there are many precedents for throwing opponents in a death camp to shut them up.

Andrewj ..thinks for the figures,

Andrewj ..thinks for the figures, Doesnt look good ....I was just commenting how 'good traditional commonsense' business practises had been thrown out the door

Andrewj Says:
"second tranche to the coming second great depression
this from Bill Bonner

"The stock market crashed in "˜29. The market then bounced. After a few months almost everyone was persuaded that the "worst was over." But the worst was just beginning. It wasn't until 1932 that the stock market finally hit bottom. By then, it was beginning to seem like a depression"¦and only years later did economic historians tag it as a "˜great' depression."

That has been on the back of my mind for nearly 2 yrs now...Nevellie also did an article comparing 1873 and 1928 some time back, which then more or less confirmed my gut feelings..And a couple other articles/links with overlay time graphs that show similar likely possible trends...

And A recession does have a financial definition....Depression doesnt, it is more a description of the state of mind of the people, in retorospect.....inflation, unemployment, state cant afford to pay benefits/super etc to the extent it used to.

Andrewj, where did you get

Andrewj, where did you get this jem? ....".Rumors that Baileys are looking to get out of Rural real estate as its too tough and they expect the downturn to last for years." Talking to Bayleys agents they seen somewhat shocked!
The res of the stuff you post is pretty good, 4 hours watching "a century of self" was great. Here is some data to copy and paste into excel and make a pretty (ugly) graph.

Profitability trends for the average sheep and beef farmer

Interest 00-01 01-02 02-03 03-04 04-05 05-06 06-07 07-08
& rent 27,128 28,754 34,630 34,310 41,093 47,055 54,510 58,672
Farm profit
pre tax 96,439 118,788 89,737 66,800 73,265 41,698 29,110 16,700

Copyright Meat & Wool New Zealand Economic service

SteveL from the competition of

SteveL from the competition of course reliable-no. Bet you are pleased not to be farming through this, man its tough out there.
Look at China go
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financetopics/financialcrisis/6011674...

Trying to find time to

Trying to find time to read these links is a mission at this time of the year. Thanks to everybody for finding them. I spoke to my accountant a couple of days ago, he is adamant there are plenty of farms quite able to tough this out. Now we are talking waikato farmers here, family farms, with lower debt isssues. However there were 2 properties that had expanded recently, and they were basicly being run by the banks and would be sold up depending on finding buyers, or debt reduction from the sale of sections off the property.
AndrewJ, thanks for the update on how bad things are for you in the Bay, I am asking all and sundry trying to find out if it is worthwhile for me to rear calves for sale in November December. As we know the last 3 or 4 years has been shocking for calf sales at this time. I could take them through to Jan/feb if I had to. I have a large farm down the road from me in a big financial mess, they have 2000 cows and are planning to rear 200 heifers, that leaves a lot of colostrum for me. Thats real gold, its yellow even. For $60 I can rear a calf to 10 weeks. I wouldnt bother with contracts, they are made to be broken, have been broken and who would sign one these days anyway.

We have had a good season here, yup big frosts, but regular rain. The rhodos are 2 weeks slow to come out in flower, but the farm looks good. I find it difficult to imagine the state of the Bay. Its a godawful feeling not watching that grass grow each day, seeing the animals struggling. Farming will never be understood by those that dont farm, our animals are our lives. It can be a bit of a love hate relationship with the farm, it is such an extraordinary tie.

Wherever I am, if I am away, my brain is ticking over, who needs a move, is the water ok, is someone ripping off my easy to rip off home, will it rain, will the sun shine, will the wind stop blowing so the grass can stand up and grow, will the exchange rate come down so my bulls are worth another $50 each, are the staff (dogs) ok. Is the neighbour going to put bulls on the boundary next to the dairy heifers, oops I forgot to move such n such mob I better just get home and do it they will be hungry.
365 days a year it gets a little exhausting for the brain.
Sometimes I yearn for a house and little section that I can lock up and walk away from. And NOT look back.
So to those that denigrate us, we have enormous responsibilities, the welfare of so many animals in our hands. And at times that welfare weighs particularly heavy when you know things arent going well. Right now so many farmers are facing financial problems that some wont get through. Yet everyday they have to go out there and face all these animals and do their best for them. Most of us love our animals and are proud of them, we are proud to send off good lambs and fat steers to the works, milk to the factory, so people in town can eat. So that our country earns export dollars, so we can all buy petrol to fill our cars, teles to watch.

William Its hard to advise

William
Its hard to advise on Calves. We have a massive shortage of stock and all are aware that when we get into a feed surplus situation its going to be crazy for a few years. The techno boys are particularly vulnerable. I say that if you can raise calves cheap and, if it rains and we get a good spring,if the dollar falls,if the US stimulus works,if the $ drops back to .40, if the works dont go broke,if we dont get an out break of Foot and mouth, I think you could do very nicely. Its just a matter of working out the risks, simple really.

Yeah simple. Plus add in

Yeah simple. Plus add in a huge dose of optimism.

Yep, Andrewj and William I

Yep, Andrewj and William I bet its tough, I farmed in negative equity for a few years after drought in the late '90s. Its stink to have the bank breathing down your neck, but it does make you focus!.
On one of the rural bankers farm visits during the drought, he sugested the possibility of the place turing into a desert permanetly (global warming or something?). Less than 10 years later he's talking to me about dairy conversions!

William, have you considered rearing dairy heifers? By the time that they are r3yr ic cows they should be quite valuable as it will be apparent that the dairy production correction cull has over corrected.

Andrewj, I don't think a couple of ex-Bayleys agents jumping ship to Wrightsons to sort out that mess is going to make Bayleys stop selling rural realestate.

Right on Steve. Thinking that

Right on Steve. Thinking that myself. Everyone keeping heifer numbers as low as possible. I think it could be a great year to hook into rearing heifers. I should do some and stick them down the back somewhere for a couple of years.
Expand on the Wrighties mess, its local to me.

stevel another good video http://informationclearinghouse.info/a

stevel
another good video

http://informationclearinghouse.info/article23240.htm

I belive there is only a tiny little bit of money chasing farms.. PGGWrightson make there money A. from finance and B. from real estate Baileys may get a bigger share of the market soon.

Video and my internet, not

Video and my internet, not compatible. Shame, it looked interesting.
Yes PGG must be suffering big time. Bringing those new agents in cant make a big difference though. Sounds like panic stations. Cor, PGG were bragging about their exposure to farm finance only a couple of months ago. Bragging. Like it was a good place to be. Note the latest Farmer mag and Straight Furrow showing more mortgagee or pressured sales. The numbers are coming on stream now. Headline on Straight Furrow 'Farmers a high risk group for suicides'

Cost $250k to get each

Cost $250k to get each of those agents over to PGG, plus some pretty tasty on going benefits for them, so no doubt PGG will be looking for some good results!.

Wow, well property is still

Wow, well property is still going to have to change hands, although the commision is going to be substantially less.