Offers for readers

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Senior Legal Counsel
At NAB, it's all about our people reaching their full potential. And that means we drive t...more
Australia
Senior Financial Planner (Business) - Bondi - NSW - NAB
Senior Financial Planning professional to join our Business Banking team in Bondi....more
Australia
Senior Manager, Operational Risk & Monitoring
At NAB, it's all about our people reaching their full potential. And in MLC and NAB Wealth...more
Australia
Corporate Recovery Senior – Australia, Audit experience welcomed
Successful applicants will have the opportunity to work with this leading Australian Advis...more
Australia
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Who do you think should be appointed Reserve Bank Governor to replace Alan Bollard when he retires in September?

Choices

Top 10 at 10: Gaynor's attack on syndicates; Westpac's Rotorua pain; US yields up again

Posted in News

Here's my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 10 am. I'm glad I don't work in IT...

Dilbert.com

1. Brian Gaynor pointed out in his NZHerald column on Saturday that property investing syndicates are not for the faint of heart, following up a theme touched on by our own Alex Tarrant last week.

Gaynor pulls no punches in describing their syndicated commercial property deals as illiquid, unrealistic minefields.

They are not too dissimilar to the disastrous securitised property products developed by Wall St that are the foundation of the current economic crisis.

Nevertheless income-starved New Zealand investors are attracted to these syndicates because the promotional material contains a picture of a property and the numbers "9.5 per cent" or "10 per cent".

These numbers refer to the cash return per annum but there is usually an asterisk warning that this is the projected return for one year only.

Most syndicates have no termination date, annual returns may fall after the first year and it is the promoters, rather than the investors, who get rich from these schemes.

2. Westpac was unaware it had mistakenly given NZ$10 million to Rotorua service station owner Leo Gao until it got an anonymous tipoff, the Sunday Star Times reported. This looks ugly for Westpac and raises questions about the robustness of its systems.

News that the error was uncovered because of an anonymous tip-off rather than detection work by the bank itself has startled bank industry insiders.

"Clearly we're dealing with a whole litany of errors rather than one simple mistake," one insider told the Star-Times.

A manager at another trading bank, who asked that her name and bank be withheld, said a mistake of that magnitude would normally be picked up. "Warning bells get sent, anything that's out of the ordinary, anything in a person's account that's a bit different will get picked up by the Wellington office straight away, probably the next morning."

The question remains then how did a simple error with a decimal point go undetected long enough for $6.7m to be transferred out of the account, nearly $4m of it irreversibly?

Westpac is saying little but has confirmed the first error was made in early May during the "formalising" of a temporary overdraft facility, with a limit of up to $100,000.

Sources have told the Star-Times a long-serving bank employee processing the debt facility from the bank's offices in Christchurch missed out the decimal point when entering the figure on her computer.

In fact, a computer system flag was raised at the bank some time later over the size of the overdraft and a conversation did take place about it between the bank employee and her manager, but in an apparent case of miscommunication the matter was put aside and the error was not corrected.

3. Here's what happens when a government owned investment company takes over a listed Port company. The Auckland Regional Council-owned Auckland Regional Holdings (ARH) bought Ports of Auckland in 2005 and then more than doubled its debt to NZ$362.5 million. Now the Sunday Star Times reports Ports of Auckland faces a NZ$105.5 million debt timebomb due on December 18. Now everyone loves lazy balance sheets. A couple of years ago, not so much.

4. Hanover Finance, which is in moratorium, stands to lose NZ$60 million from a second mortgage in the Kawarau Falls development, which is in receivership, Greg Ninness at the Sunday Star Times reports.

5. General Motors has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, which could see another 20,000 workers lose their jobs and millions of GM pensioners lose benefits, WSJ.com reports. 14 factories are set to close and the US government will end up with a 60% stake after lending or investing more than US$60 billion in the bailout. I am so glad I'm not a US taxpayer or own a Holden. Holden explains what this means (not much it says) for Holden in Australia and New Zealand.

6. But here's the most important news in the global economy in the last couple of weeks. US treasury bond yields and US mortgage yields are rising fast as investors fear the coming wave of government bond issuance and grow very nervous about the prospect of more US money printing, Bloomberg reports.

Yields on Washington-based Fannie Mae's current-coupon 30- year fixed-rate mortgage bonds rose 29 basis points to 4.62 percent, up from 3.94 percent on May 20.

This is why I think any green shoots will wither and why we're in for a long US recession and an even longer and slower global economic recovery.

7. British Airways' CEO Willie Walsh has warned the airline is in a "fight for survival," the FT.com reported. He may just be talking tough to bully BA's unions to deliver concessions, but it's ominous talk.

8. There's another market collapsing quietly without too much noise. Calculated Risk passes on a research note from Citigroup analysts pointing out that "more than $75 billion of CMBS (Commercial Mortgage Backed Securities) market capitalization has been lost" since the S&P request for comment on changes to their U.S. CMBS rating methodology was issued two days ago. Regular readers of Top 10 at 10 might remember this was pointed out by Tyler Durden at ZeroHedge.

9. Singapore's sovereign wealth fund (or at least one of them), Temasek,  lost nearly US$40 billion between March and November last year, the WSJ.com reports. That should require a national day of mourning for the city state, assuming, of course, they were allowed to know.

10. The excellent Tyler Durden at ZeroHedge points out an IMF white paper on the US Federal Reserve's burgeoning balance sheet. The conclusions are that the Fed is now America's biggest actual bank and it is now managing fiscal risk as well as monetary policy. Is Ben Bernanke now more powerful than Barack Obama?

Dilbert.com

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

Just how screwed up is

Just how screwed up is the US economy?

...this screwed up...GM files for Chapter 11 and the "common" (i.e. worthless) stock goes up! Day traders are actually trading worthless paper?!?! It went from $0.27 to $0.90!!!

I'm told some older models

I'm told some older models have to be traded on a zero equity basis. Weird, I know! But if a trader has sold, he must then buy to zero the trade. Just having sold and keeping the money doesn't seem to compute!

Interesting evolutionary take on where

Interesting evolutionary take on where it all went wrong

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/may/31/markets-finance-smit...

Good one, SimonD! But is

Good one, SimonD!
But is the real point one of the resonses to that article?:

" ..... before (the markets) were motivated by greed and testosterone, now they are motivated by BLIND FEAR which is a whole lot worse. Whereas before they pushed things to the limit, now, panicking about their jobs, mortgage, or just because a climate of fear has been imbued in these hothouses, they are prepared to push things beyond that limit.

Do you think subprime and dodgy CDOs are as bad as it can get? Perhaps we need to stop looking at the last crisis in case we miss the next, bigger, one."

So: Is this rally in the markets, now, a fear of 'missing the boat' or as rational as the September sell off!?

The Reserve Bank of Oz

The Reserve Bank of Oz makes its announcement on rates this afternoon. Widely expected to remain the same at 3.0 .. hint hint Bollard I hope your paying attention !!

http://business.smh.com.au/business/rba-rates-move-will-they-wont-they-2...

The article also notes that even if the RBA does cut, banks are unlikely to pass on to customers.

@Janet We need to look

@Janet

We need to look closer at the rally. It can't be based on GM filling Chapter 11 that would truly mean we are living in opposite world.

Most contribute the rally to the durable goods data. The problem is that the "increase" in durable goods was exclusively due to the DOD purchasing equipment and almost nothing to do with the recession easing in the private sector.

The not so obvious theory could be that the Travelers and Cisco are replacing Citigroup and GM in the DOW.

Thx, Troy. I hadn't picked

Thx, Troy. I hadn't picked up it was Defense purchasing....Let's hope that has nothing to do with Mr. Kim.....

@DC I think the real

@DC

I think the real news nugget of the day is this:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=ajf0L9wTPq6Y

I'm sure they are just touting their book...but still!!

Troy, Interesting. Though I would

Troy,

Interesting. Though I would wonder, if a firm that hasn't bought gold in 152 years is buying it now, if that might be some sign of a top?

Check out this interesting nugget from Brad Setser at CFR:

http://blogs.cfr.org/setser/2009/05/31/more-government-borrowing-doesnt-...

"The United States is borrowing less from the rest of the world than it was. That is true even though the US Treasury is borrowing more from everyone, including more from the rest of the world...American households and businesses are borrowing a lot less, so the total amount of money that Americans are borrowing isn't rising."

Scroll down to view the chart, it's pretty amazing.

It seems that the financial sector has gone from deleveraging to re-leveraging and we are seeing this is in the re-inflation of some asset prices and the weak USD in recent months. However, I don't believe the US consumer is willing or able to re-leverage and that's where it will break down and deleveraging and deflation will resume.

That's my hypothesis anyway.

I recently came across your

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Margaret

http://lotterymegamillions.net

They're at it again ,

They're at it again , wanna remove " Margaret " , Bryan , or can I vent my spleen ?

Roger - save your spleen

Roger - save your spleen for venting at politicians :-) I do.

Thanks Bryan , but I

Thanks Bryan , but I prefer to vent something else at our politicians . They did try to tax it , once !