In this section
Offers for readers
Follow the news from interest
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 20791
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 295
- ››
Finance sector jobs
Lead from the front utilising your strategic, technical and leadership qualities within th...more
New Zealand
Lead from the front utilising your technical expertise in this highly attractive senior li...more
New Zealand
Customer focus, high performance, exceeding client expectations and achieving profitable g...more
New Zealand
Reporting to the Senior Manager Operational Risk Effectiveness and Assurance, the key focu...more
New Zealand

The news stream
Latest news
Most commented
- BNZ cuts most fixed mortgage rates 48
- 90 seconds at 9 am 43
- Fonterra to tighten TAF rules 37
- Thursday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 33
- Govt eyes NZ$1.4b revenue grab 31
- English wants more house builds 30
- Fonterra cuts payout forecast 30
- Budget tax moves to target high income NZers 29
- Wednesday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 24
- Amanda's Take Five for Wednesday 23
Most viewed
Have your say: Greg Muir defends Hanover's peformance
Last night on TV3's Campbell Live Hanover Chairman Greg Muir defended the performance of the board of Hanover Finance. He also said shareholders Mark Hotchin and Eric Watson would put up "tens of millions of dollars" to help rescue the NZ$554 million of investments owed to 13,000 New Zealanders by the Hanover group.
This was Muir's first television interview since Hanover was frozen last month.
Muir said a moratorium and restructuring plan was before the trustees and would be put to debenture holders at a meeting in late September or early October.
"It is our intention to try and get back every cent for Mums and Dads," Muir said.
Asked if the returns would be better than the 15-50 cents in the dollar expected by Bridgecorp investors, Muir said: "We certainly hope so," Muir said. "The quality of our assets is much better. There is no hint whatsoever of any impropriety by anyone inside the company."
"This is about liquidity. It's about our ability to get the property market moving again and start to deal with some of these assets," he said.
Asked about criticism of Hotchin and Watson's decision to take dividends out of Hanover in the last two years, he said: "Over the last two years, NZ$72 million of dividends have been paid. NZ$70 million has come back into the business to retire related party loans, so there has been almost no cash gone out of the business to those shareholders at all."
"Cash is the real issue. This is a liquidity crisis in the industry and globally. Had they been paid no dividends our cash position would be exactly the same," Muir said.
Related Topics
Asked about the related party loans to companies owned by Hotchin and Watson, he said: "As at the end of June the related party loans are about NZ$60 mln and every single one of those loans was at normal commercial terms and at arms length."
Asked if there had been any discounts given to Hotchin and Watson, he said: "Absolutely not. I remember on one occasion Mark saying 'you guys are charging me more than I could have got ... it's higher than that other guy in the book.'"
Muir was asked if he was happy to stake his reputation on the performance of Hanover and that of shareholders Watson and Hotchin.
"I have seen absolutely nothing in my time around the board table to lead me to believe that the company was managed in a bad way. Quite the reverse. The executives we have are outstanding. We have a wonderful general counsel who has given very conservative legal advice and we have followed that advice to the letter," Muir said.
He was also asked how much of their own money Watson and Hotchin had at stake and how much they would put forward in a rescue plan.
"The shareholders decided at the time we were considering this freeze that they would support the company over and beyond the NZ$50 million of equity they have in the business. It's not as if these guys don't have their own money at risk. They have NZ$50 million of their own equity in their business," Muir said.
"NZ550 million in anyone's language is an enormous sum of money and that is the equity they have in the business," he said.
"They as part of the plan that we have in front of the trustees right now, and will be unveiled to our investors within the next three to four weeks, will have tens of millions of dollars more from them supporting the business as we got through the recovery plan," he said.
"I can't with certainty say that the plan will be voted for, but we believe that the support the shareholders will putting behind the plan will be far and away greater than any other entity in the finance industry and will clearly demonstrate their committment to it, and to seeing it through to the end and doing the best we possibly can to get Mums and Dads their money back."
Muir, a former chief executive of The Warehouse and the current executive chairman of Pumpkin Patch, has been criticised for his role at Hanover. Bruce Sheppard of the NZ Shareholders Association was particularly trenchant in his blog on Businessday.co.nz , in which he said Muir had lent his strong brand to Hanover and should pay back his fees.
So Greg, come clean. Front up to this mess for the time you have been on the board. Perhaps even as a gesture of contrition, pay back your fees.
Assuming you want to try and avoid the Hangover by staying out of the public light, then I say to the board of Pumpkin Patch: " Brand Muir" is caustic manure and you should dump him and quickly."
To the bond holders of Hanover and to trustee Guardian Trust, I say, do not give this company any rope, push it under now. Get liquidators in and pursue the remedies available. Hotchin and Watson must be removed from having any ability to take ma and pop money or even from having the use of it under a moratorium for a moment longer.
What's your thoughts on Muir's comments last night?
Is it correct to say Watson and Hotchin are heavily exposed personally when they have NZ$50 million of equity in Hanover but have borrowed NZ$60 million back from the business? That sounds like a net negative NZ$10 million position with security over sections at Jacks Point in Queenstown thrown in.
Should Hanover (and others) be given time for the property market to stabilise?
7 Comments
“Over the last two years,
"Over the last two years, NZ$72 million of dividends have been paid. NZ$70 million has come back into the business to retire related party loans, so there has been almost no cash gone out of the business to those shareholders at all."
Ok...so if I go out and raise $2m from the public, lend $1m of that money to myself, then just as things are about to go pear shaped, use the other $1m to pay myself a nice dividend and pay back my loan, that's ok?
Please don't fall for that one people. All that has happened is that investors' money has been used pay off related party loans at the expense of the financial position of the company as a whole.
Muir and his co directors
Muir and his co directors may well be in breach of the Company's Act in paying a such dividends given the parlous state of the company's cash flow.
The fact that it was used to repay related party loans is totally irrelevant.
Mum & Dad's new cash has been used to repay directors loans.
His defense of the dividends paid while ingenious was totally pitiful.
Wait till we see what the shareholders are going to do to put " ten's of millions " into the company. Probably the bum assets they couldn't afford to repay the loans on.
With 75 % of their loans to property developers on a rollup interest basis
Director's were asleep at the wheel from any sort of rational risk analysis.
It's amazing what a fat Chairman's fee can do to capture one's powers of thought.
Muir's credibility is now and forever zip.
shit... what a load of
shit... what a load of crap.... What a pathetic attempt to justify the "unjustifiable"..
Is this the guy who runs Pumpkin Patch..... If so.... isn't he supposed to be one of our.."shining stars" of business...
These comments make me laugh/cry/vomit.......!!#@% :
"Over the last two years, NZ$72 million of dividends have been paid. NZ$70 million has come back into the business to retire related party loans, so there has been almost no cash gone out of the business to those shareholders at all."
"Cash is the real issue. This is a liquidity crisis in the industry and globally. Had they been paid no dividends our cash position would be exactly the same," Muir said.
"It is our intention to try and get back every cent for Mums and Dads,"
"As at the end of June the related party loans are about NZ$60 mln and every single one of those loans was at normal commercial terms and at arms length."
LOTS of contradictions in these statements....
Sounds like "related parties" were sleeping together.... and never gave a shit about MUM and DAD...( investors)
Look at Pumpkin Patchs share
Look at Pumpkin Patchs share price sover the last few years, and where it is now. It says it all really.
I think it is pretty rude that he has appeared on a TV show, rather than communicate directly with investors to answer their questions. Hanover were only too happy to have 'roadshows' to assure investors last year. Why don't they do this now, so investors can get some real answers. If they don't reassure investors, they will be heading towards receivership, and a firesale.
I would say Mr Muir
I would say Mr Muir and Mr Bruce Gordon are tredding water I mean look at Gordon's dopey quote!
Gordon said yesterday "someone might be trying "to make mischief" sending documents to media around the country"
What a load of rubbish from a man who is on the decline and not a legend in his own mind!
Mr. Muir has set a
Mr. Muir has set a new standard in defining impropriety when he says"There is no hint whatsoever of any impropriety by anyone inside the company.".
That there is evidence before the Courts in the USA of Hanover in-house lawyer Nadine Bernecker backdating documents, persons sent with guns to building sites with orders to keep the lawyers and accountants off site and deposition evidence of Hanover entering into illegal "bait and switch" schemes to trap joint venture partners into racketeering type loans is undeniable; except it seems by Mr. Muir.
It's about time that Mr. Muir and Mr. O'Reagn faced up to their responsibilities on the Board of Hanover and came clean to the investing public about the real Hanover. Hanover is being sued for millions of Dollars and faced many more millions in damages. Wwe all know who will pay for that in the end and it wont' be the Directors, of Hanover will it!
Hanover Castle ... put simply...doneover
Hanover Castle ... put simply...doneover again. Appease the upset peasants who loaned you their hard earned gold coins by offering them worthless gifts of non arable land and a few gold coins from your stash and throw the wolves some meat from the battlements. Run like hell under the cover of darkness with the bags of loot.Just make sure you exit quietly (the hired knaves can cover for you). Have enough of a head start and can run fast enough to catch a boat before the peasants with pitch forks and the wolves come after you when they find they have again been duped and find the Hanover Castle vaults are indeed empty.