Offers for readers

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Market Risk Manager
Unique opportunity to become an integral member of this highly respected market leading te...more
Australia
Senior Project Manager - APAC
Newly created role to manager projects across the Asia Pacific region within a worldwide l...more
Australia
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Financial Officer Location flexibleCompetitive Remuneration...more
Australia
Business Development Manager - Wholesale Sales
An opportunity has become available for an experienced Business Development Manager to joi...more
Australia
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Who do you think should be appointed Reserve Bank Governor to replace Alan Bollard when he retires in September?

Choices

Have your say: Should the Kiwi's fall worry the RBNZ?

Posted in News

The New Zealand dollar has fallen more than 9% since early May to a 10 and a half month low of 71.7 US cents overnight as international investors have taken the view that New Zealand's economy is slowing sharply and interest rates here are likely to fall significantly. We estimate that despite the fall in the price of crude oil to US$117 a barrel overnight, this fall in our currency means the price of regular petrol will actually have to rise to NZ$2.08 a litre from currently around NZ$2.03 a litre if the currency and oil prices stay at their current levels over the next couple of weeks and if oil companies don't change their profit margins. This sharp fall in the currency raises the question: Is it now creating an inflation problem that might force the Reserve Bank to halt its planned cuts in the Official Cash Rate (OCR)? This is what Reserve Bank Governor Alan Bollard said on July 24 when he cut the OCR to 8% from 8.25%.

Provided that the outlook for inflation continues to improve and there is no excessive exchange rate depreciation, we would expect to lower the OCR further.

The question therefore is what is excessive? The currency has fallen slightly less (7%) on a trade weighted index basis than against the US dollar  over the same 3 month period, but has actually fallen 13.3% since mid-2007, in part due to a very sharp fall in the New Zealand dollar vs the Australian dollar. Australia is a our largest trading partner. Have your say. What's your view on where the currency is headed and what the Reserve Bank needs to do?

Is the fall excessive? Should Bollard stop the rate cuts? Or do we need both a lower currency and rate cuts? Is inflation such a worry that he needs to act?

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

14 Comments

I thought we would revisit

I thought we would revisit this sooner rather than later - as was discussed some months ago on your blog their is a real risk that the FX markets give the kiwi a real kicking (why wouldn't you be short given the signals that the RBNZ has effectively given up on its inflation targeting?). What is noteworthy is that the RATE of decline is increasing. I believe the RBNZ in its model had the kiwi falling to .70US by Q1 on 2009? We are likely to hit that in August. Those carry trade investors still exposed must be taking a hell of a beating on currency losses, which can only increase the urge to dump the kiwi. FXs moves generally overshoot (in both directions), so expect increasing pressure on the kiwi. The US$ is also resurgent (largely because the Eurozone looks in worse state than the US) so its a magnified force.

Bollard forced into an about turn by the FX markets, and our 'professional' bank economists blind sided? I for one would be highly amused by their 'surprise' if so caught out. Anyone for an Icelandic experience?

Absolutely. Rates should never have

Absolutely. Rates should never have been cut last month. Certainly no more cuts please. Everything I buy is getting more expensive and that's only going to get worse. As you point out any benefit of the falling oil price is going to be negated by the falling kiwi. Also much of the oil price drop is due to the USD finding its feet so the USD buys more oil making the price seem to drop when in fact it isn't unless your buying in USD or a tied currency.

Also, as has been said previously on this site, further rate cuts are unlikely to be passed on to homeowners due to the cost of international credit. Plus any small drop in mortgage repayments will be more than wiped out by higher costs of fuel, food and everything else.

As for exporters, conditions are improving and will continue to improve without further rate cuts as the NZD settles at a lower level. Further cuts will only cause a huge overshoot.

Looking at what's happened in

Looking at what's happened in the US as its currency has plummeted over the past 2 years, I don't think RBNZ has anything to worry about. Consumers simply pulled their horns in as the currency fell and imports became more expensive. As a result the much-maligned US trade deficit has improved markedly, a factor that's now feeding a recovery in the USD. Bollard also has a firm grip on the extent to which our large importers are hedged and hence do not have to pass on the full impact of the NZD's coming fall to the consumer. Keep the rates cuts coming as planned - any further delay will simply increase the pain further down the track and put off the badly needed adjustment in asset prices.

There may be some uncomfortable

There may be some uncomfortable moments along the way as the decline in international commodities markets will be slightly out of sync with the decline in the NZD. But when all signs point towards a significant contraction both domesticaly and internationally the OCR must (and will) drop.

Mitch - you are destined

Mitch - you are destined to be very, very disappointed if you think oil (the principle commodity to which I think you are referring to) is going to drop back to where it was few years ago. As I keep saying, if the downward 'speculative' pressure continues for too long OPEC will simply cut production.

Dosser - how will cutting interest rates allow asset prices to adjust downwards? I am guessing that you are referring to assets such as houses (maybe shares?). Lower interest rate inevitably serve to inflate such asset prices (or am I missing something)?

Re;the US - the FED would very very much like to cut interest rates - and I see little sign of a meaningful US recovery (as this is its default position when confronted with anything remotely challenging). They are being prevented from doing so PRECISELY because the US $ devaluation resulting from previous cuts has led to a surge in imported inflation. Interesting parallel, perhaps?

Continued NZD overvaluation based on

Continued NZD overvaluation based on high interest rates in the face of economic recession, exorbitant debt levels and an awful current account deficit is a fool's paradise that wouldn't last long. This would only make the inevitable plunge even more pronounced when it does come. Expect also overseas developments to knock the NZD: commodity prices dropping (already negative for the AUD and for us by contagion) and when the US eventually decides not to debase its currency any further (signs that the USD has found a base now). Bollard's challenge will be to engineer an orderly decline in the NZD; TWI of about 0.60 looks about right from your graph. Who knows, if that happens we might even start making and selling stuff to the world again instead of borrowing to keep our economy running. If rebalancing a seriously unbalanced economy is of any importance at all to the RBNZ they will be quite content with the NZD decline.

Andy, I don't think an

Andy, I don't think an RBNZ rate cutting program will have much effect on domestic mortgage rates, which are largely being driven by rising credit spreads and pressure on banks to expand their margins and maintain profit levels. I think one paradox we'll see, at least at the initial stage, is that the fall in the NZ dollar induced by lower rates will increase the price of foreign capital to NZ banks and force them to leave their lending rates higher for longer. I don't see domestic investors being in a position to provide much more long term capital to NZ banks, which will be forced to use more expensive sources of offshore funding as carry traders run for the hills. The net effect may be that NZ house prices suffer a sharper fall than they would if NZ kept the OCR where it is and Mrs. Watanabe carried on funding us. The only wild card is Kiwibank, which has been and will be instructed to lower mortgage rates in an election year.

Dosser - interesting points. However

Dosser - interesting points. However after bleating about how the price of raising capital overseas was hurting them (co-incidentally just before the RBNZ cut rates, who'd have thunk it) the big 4 cut their mortgage rates with alacrity soon after. They have also been slashing their depositor rates so doesn't look like they are trying too hard to get local funding. The big banks must be desperately keen to get the housing bubble re-inflated so there is a massive amount of self interest at stake.
As for kiwibank - isn't their share of the mortgage market tiny ie less than 5%?

We should never underestimate the

We should never underestimate the stupidity of the Big 4. Despite clear signs that the Aussie house market has hit a brick wall the big banks are still offering 100% loans. Disquieting parallels with the situation the UK just a few months ago (before things their got really, really bad):
http://business.theage.com.au/business/anger-over-100-home-loans-2008080...

We should never underestimate the

We should never underestimate the stupidity of the Big 4. Despite clear signs that the Aussie house market has hit a brick wall the big banks are still offering 100% loans. Disquieting parallels with the situation the UK just a few months ago (before things there got really, really bad):
http://business.theage.com.au/business/anger-over-100-home-loans-2008080...

Andy, I think the big

Andy, I think the big 4 banks have realised they're the only game in town now that finance companies have been discredited, so they don't have to try too hard to attract deposits. The only problem is that the potential pool of deposits in NZ has shrunk and the well is pretty much dry now. Kiwibank's a small player but I think it punches above its weight by forcing the big 4 to follow its lead on mortgage rates. I can't believe that the big 4 would have cut rates if Kiwibank wasn't around - look at what their parent banks have done in Oz with rate increases over and above any RBA hikes. Their NZ subsidiaries don't want to lose market share as people refinance their fixed rates.

Andy, I was talking ALL

Andy, I was talking ALL commodities. Nonetheless I'm aware of your belief in the peak oil arguement and have no wish to reopen this debate with you. Suffice to say that if the arguement is generally accurate then OPEC will have no need to cut its output even in the face of a significant weakening in global demand.

The decline in the NZD is pretty much in line with expectations and I expect it to continue.

On the contrary, if, as

On the contrary, if, as I believe, OPEC defend $110 or $100 a barrel it tells us a) they know that non-OPEC suppliers (the rest of the world) are unable to increase supply to force the issue (which is pretty much general knowledge in the field anyway, just take a look at the EIA data for May out today) and b) they are unprepared to sell their oil any cheaper than that to us because they know it will be a great deal more expensive down the line, irrespective of what the price is doing now to the global economy. Ten years ago dogma was that OPEC would never let oil rise to the point that it harmed the world economy, which in turn would have stimulated a) fresh non-OPEC fields to be developed and b) alternative fuels. Since non-OPEC is largely a busted flush in a), and since there since nothing imminent in b) what OPEC does next will be very, very informative.

So lets wait and see........

The privately owned corporate central

The privately owned corporate central banks are laughing either way, they have us in what they call a Strangle or a Straddle, where those subjects trapped in the real sector in this nation are going to hurt no matter which way the dollar goes. If it is gone up, it will be because the banking sector has put interest rates up, securing them and their subsidaries more houses for next to nothing, or if they go down our net debt position with the outside world, from whom we borrow our entire money supply, increases in sync, meaning we will once again not be able to service our debts, which will be followed by another round of enforced asset sales of our vital infrastructure, including the big one this time, our urban water supplies. this neutralises any benefits of increased exports. Nothing short of reforming the debt based monetary system will ever change this.
Cheers
Iain