The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Manager Operational Effectiveness and Assurance IT
Reporting to the Senior Manager Operational Risk Effectiveness and Assurance, the key focu...more
New Zealand
Financial Controller
Reporting to the Head of Finance - Retail and Business Bank the key focus of this role is ...more
New Zealand
Manager Finance Corporate Core - 12 Month Contract role
This role in consultation with the Financial Controller provides financial, strategic and ...more
New Zealand
IT Audit Manager - Internal Audit - Auckland
If you are motivated by the prospect of seeing the big picture, developing your team and m...more
New Zealand
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Should you fix your mortgage now or stay floating?

Choices

Realestate.co.nz report shows lifeless housing market in August; high inventory levels in 'buyers market'

Posted in News

Housing inventory remained over 46 weeks worth of sales in August, meaning it remains a 'buyers market,' Realestate.co.nz's August report showed

The housing market has failed to show signs of returning to life early in the Spring sales season, according to a report from Realestate.co.nz on listings figures in August.

The number of new listings coming onto the market fell 7% to 9,804 in August from July, but sales have also been weak, meaning the inventory of unsold houses on the market still remains over 46 weeks.

Inventory rose to 46.8 weeks in July from June and edged down to 46.1 weeks in August. Asking prices rose 1% to a truncated mean of NZ$403,423.

"The month of August this year showed little signs of such a pick-up, with new listings below 10,000 and down nearly 11% on a seasonally adjusted basis. This decline in listings would ordinarily signal a tightening of the market at this time of year, were it not for the existing high levels of inventory already on the market and the flow-on impact of slow sales," Realestate.co.nz CEO Alistair Helm said. The full report is also available at Unconditional.co.nz

Sales in July of 4,411 were down 27% on the previous year to a record low for a July. August sales figures are yet to be reported by REINZ.

"These slow sales are resulting in inventory levels of unsold houses remaining above 46 weeks as compared to the long term average of 38 weeks, reinforcing the view that the market still favours buyers over sellers," Helm said.

"With consolidated long-term data indicating 38 weeks to be the national threshold between a market favourable to either sellers or buyers, current inventory levels continue to show that most parts of New Zealand remain a buyer’s market," he said.

However, the report showed a two speed property property with major metropolitan centres stronger than provincial centres.

See more regional detail below. See the full report attached here.

Auckland has inventory levels closer to long term average (36 weeks vs. 33 weeks), new listing numbers were trending lower than the national average and the asking price has been edging up for the past couple of months.

Wellington equally is now at a level of inventory only slightly above long term average, new listings are down and asking price is steady.

Canterbury at 32 weeks of inventory of unsold houses is sitting right on the long term average, it has steady asking price and new listings volumes down 10% compared to prior year.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

251 Comments

August certainly was a month

August certainly was a month of low volumes of sales as predicted. What is different where I live is the growing number of sales as low as $70k under cv as the vendors blink to get the sale through.Buyers are just getting harder and harder to committ and some of their offers are getting ridiculous.

10% below cv seems to be more

10% below cv seems to be more common now from what i am  seeing, whereas not long ago the norm seemed to be cv or just above, thats my observations anyway 

yes also seeing 10% below CV

yes also seeing 10% below CV at the moment.

Worth noting however that

Worth noting however that certain more desirable suburbs in the central(ish) Auckland area are holding their prices quite well, still selling over GV in most cases.  In particular houses in the 500k plus range seem to be attracting reasonable demand.

Its interesting as well that the recent round of CVs' has seen some downward movement (at least that I have observed)

the quality property with

the quality property with quality location (ie the upper end) always holds out longer than the less desirable stuff. the inferior stuff is where you see the market fall first, then the upper end will follow later.

"Buyers are just getting

"Buyers are just getting harder and harder to committ and some of their offers are getting ridiculous."

What you should have said is that sellers are at last discovering just how ridiculous their asking prices have been for the last half dozen years.

Buyers are only just beginning to offer what those Kiwi shacks are actually worth.

The offers will continue to

The offers will continue to drop both in number and as to price. This is the new normal plod along pace of this economy. Get used to it. The pressure on prices will remain the exodus to aus, the drop off in immigration numbers, the rising cost of credit, the high real unemployment rate, the growing fiscal deficit and the march of the capital out of the country.

If China spits a dummy expect another sharp leg down for Noddyland. When the aussie property bubble implodes, that too will send shock waves across to this side of the ditch.

The promised export driven recovery with the 170ooo jobs is so much hot air. English has no option but to abandon "hope" and start swinging an axe to the state sector. We cannot take Bernanke's route to hell in QE handbasket. It is the austerity option or capitulation.

I'm actually quite surprised,

I'm actually quite surprised, I thought inventory levels would be higher as people sell their homes to consolidate their debt, this hasn't happened in August. I do think we are only seeing the start of the Greater Depression and I do think there is going to be increasing listings as people get poorer and poorer and try to sell their homes, bringing them down to levels pre 90's.

Tragic.

Tragic.

Cripes you a stirrer

Cripes you a stirrer Bernard...............now where did I put that crop............oh that bloody horse is lying on it.

;) Aim to please and

;)

Aim to please and tease

cheers

Bernard

then you're in the wrong

then you're in the wrong profession.

He  should be out selling

He  should be out selling real estate.

I am not suprised by the

I am not suprised by the August report. Sources from within the RE industry are telling me that sale volumes are still very weak and the buyers are getting more and more sure of their strong position. I predict the values of houses in New Zealand are going to creep down by the month over the next year and a half at least ,to values we can only dream of at present.This can only be considered great news for our kids who were shut out until it started to slip in 2007.

It is great news, as

It is great news, as fundamentals will return to the market, but are we going to see japanese style deflation in housing? I think so, but its just too hard to tell whether we are going to see inflation or deflation.

The debt burden here is

The debt burden here is probably shorter term, nor funded by our own savings, so I am picking the loss will be crystallised earlier, unless we socialise private losses..

"unless we socialise private

"unless we socialise private losses."

You mean like using tax dollars to bail out greedy finance company depositors?

The Housing market  in Japan

The Housing market  in Japan is very different to NZ, here nobody is really interested in owning property unless it is a new build. Older houses are still expensive due to the land value. after approx 30 yrs a Japanese house is essentially worthless, as any new purchaser will tear it down and build a new house on the site so the only value being the land. Still house prices are out of reach for most even with a halving or more of values since circa 1990. To give you an idea of deflation in Japan and it did not only affect housing, the Nikkei index today is around the 8-9000 mark. Back in the bubble it was at 38000.

The good thing these days is that prices remain static, electicity, gas etc does not increase in price, rents remain the same or fall, train fares remain the same. Wages actually go up a little so that makes you a little better off each year. All in all it is ok and you actually feel ahead of the ball instead of always behind it.

Japan I think had/has

Japan I think had/has deflation in housing and inflation elsewhere......over-all its deflation....

Looking at the graphs (for the US anyway) we seem to have disflation overall and I'd expect NZ will follow....

Its almost like saying is the sun rising or setting, the answer is yes depending on how long you wait....

ie Real/true inflation comes with a recovery....that could be a decade or more off...ignoring Peak Oil of course.....

regards

 

I have a feeling that the way

I have a feeling that the way this market is going we will have another 5%  drop  in residential property  prices by this year end.

What an absolute bunch of

What an absolute bunch of dreamers. Inventory levels are down so there is no panic whatsoever.

The reason sales no.s are down is because of lack of first home buyers, due to the many unemployed including the ones who are on this site constantly.

Prices will hold in most major centres unless you have a property that has something detrimental to it including location, building product etc.

The property world is not ending, in fact investors are doing better than they ever have at the moment.

investors are doing better

investors are doing better than they ever have at the moment 

rubbish, 2001-2004 were the best years in gisborne, houses cost 70000 rents not much different to now. my first house was $40 less per week to own than to rent

i am offering sellers 40% less than GV, anything less is not cash flow positive, forget it as an investment

Your world is falling

Your world is falling apart.

That amuses us.

And for even more amusement, the September RE sales mortgage massacre is about to begin.

wrong, i have never bougt a

wrong, i have never bougt a house that doesn't stack up, i just see more and more opportunity at the moment. If the rent covers the mortgage and expences, capital gains are irrelevant for long term investments. They become another income stream on retirement, being 37 a long way to go.

"That amuses us"

why?

who is us?

So then why do you call

So then why do you call yourself LAQC owner? Which implies a loss making enterprise, and when applied to housing, a reliance on capital appreciation?

In 2001 bought houses,

In 2001 bought houses, established LAQC in 2005 which bought properties at current market value. Profit  from the sale reduces debt in the house you live in, rentals lose money hand over foot, tax advantages (, i know so don't say it, "subsidised by tax payers"). Net debt hasn't changed, just redistributed. No reliance on capital appreciation. Provide very cheap rent as overseas and dont want high turn over and ticks over so why be greedy, happy tenants

Hi believe the housing market

Hi believe the housing market will be up this time next year, with allot of people wishing they had bought in 2010. Yes you can get a bargain now. I have not seen the jump in listings that so many have predicted. I have however seen houses (at least on the north shore where I live and own property) come on and sell within a couple of weeks for around asking price (which is often been around 2008 QV.) or slightly more. It’s clear the houses that are selling are well located, pre 90's (that is 60's, 70's and 80's) weatherboard style homes on reasonable pieces of land (in good locations). House’s that have any cladding are struggling. A recent home that I was interested in sold in two weeks and had 120 people through an open home on a wet weekend..... sold close to asking (mid 800”s). Also I don’t know about the rest of the country but rents on the north shore are stable to rising...enjoy the spring all...

Until recently I was one of

Until recently I was one of the biggest defenders of property investment, but next week I'm about to join the ranks of the officially bankrupt, and that's all down to property.

That's the most telling

That's the most telling comment yet.

 

regards

You sound like a real estate

You sound like a real estate salesperson. Hmmm

Hope is good but the reality is in most places in NZ the prices will not go up for the next 4-5 years.

As a property investor - and

As a property investor - and to stimmulate our business -

I say to the immigration department, but particularly to my "Real Estate Friends" in the government - just let more people in from all over the world.

Yeah, of course we need to be more productive - manufacturing - but later.

That's your answer? "Open

That's your answer?

"Open the door to everyone because I'm a PI and don't care what happens to the nation so long as somebody rents my houses from me."

If only you weren't a financial illiterate, or a sociopath.

Without a strong Real Estate

Without a strong Real Estate industry our economy is nothing. We need to sell houses/ properties to each other in order to get richer.

That's a piss-take, right? No

That's a piss-take, right? No seriously, you're joking, yes, and totally realise you've just recommended a ponzi scheme?

Ha ha , Walter . I don't know

Ha ha , Walter . I don't know what you're imbibing ........ but I wish I could get me some !

Hey , wanna buy a house ..........ours is for sale !

Be buggered if I'm gonna bail out SCF and all those others who signed the Gumnut Guarantee . ........... Up with this I will put no longer !    We're awayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy .

Good on you RT... oz?

Good on you RT... oz?

A quiet little beach in the

A quiet little beach in the Visayas , Phils.

Rogie- you know, debating the

Rogie- you know, debating the “Real Economy” it seems people aren’t interested, so I thought with a few BS- comments I can "help" and bring the “Housing Issue” up to another 200- 300 BS-comments again.

Of course I hate talking about the Real Estate Industry. Overall it doesn’t make us wealthier, but poorer and after all - foreigners are the profiteers.

We need to develop a strong manufacturing culture including attractive sectors (Science & Research), which makes us Kiwis wealthier. To many good educated/ skilled young Kiwis are leaving NZ., because we are in this country not providing enough decent jobs.

You are right , Walter  :

You are right , Walter  :  Tacking  " house " into the headline guarantees a response quicker than adding  " gov't guarantee " gets a queue of cashed up oldies !

Not only are " good educated/ skilled young Kiwis leaving NZ "  , but me too !

Your not a kiwi.

Your not a kiwi.

Is your profile name of Kunst

Is your profile name of Kunst in reference to James Howard Kunstler and the 'Clusterfuck' web site?

I'm cashed up and looking for

I'm cashed up and looking for a first home/rental property.

I'm not going to fork out my cash for a house right now until rents/wages increase or prices reduce. I'm sure there are many people like me and we are not buying. So who is buying?

I reiterate investors are

I reiterate investors are doing better than ever at the moment as they are buying property at exceptionally good prices and great safe returns compared to any other investment.

Partly due, thankyou very much, to the many people in N.Z. with the wrong mindset including many on this site.

You are helping immensly. Keep it up.

Why don't you go price some

Why don't you go price some honest people out of the market? It seems thats what people like you are all you're good for. Money won't set you free, and your lust for money has cost a generation, do you think we will be looking after you in your retirement? Guess again.

incentives drive choices, get

incentives drive choices, get with the real world. its always been the same and will never change

Anon at 12.10p.m. You should

Anon at 12.10p.m. You should be thanking the property investors as the professional ones are keeping the prices down rather than forcing them up. The mum and dad investors just buy anything irrespective of fundamentals or being a good buy. Maybe you should be blaming them and not the professional investors.

"Anon at 12.10p.m. You should

"Anon at 12.10p.m. You should be thanking the property investors as the professional ones are keeping the prices down rather than forcing them up."

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAA!

A bit of sarcasm can do wonders.
Thanks for the laugh!

Exceptionally good prices on

Exceptionally good prices on the day you bought them but water has flowed under the bridge since and those investments as you call them are now worth less and that trend is going to carry on for some years yet. Why would you buy in a dropping market other than to prove how stupid you are.

Yes i'm stupid. You know what

Yes i'm stupid. You know what I am buying and how much I paid don't you?

Makes no difference what you

Makes no difference what you paid as they are going to continue to drop in price for several years to come. Simple fact,more sellers than buyers and getting worse by the day.

and yet we had someone who

and yet we had someone who was a ex-PI say he/she were bankrupt.....that is not a risk free return...

"Great safe returns compared to other investment"  better returns than some or most other areas, sure quite possible, I sold all my shares in June because I see a big meltdown coming, is any / all investmant safe right now?  no....

The two drivers in all investment are greed and fear....the dis-advantage of property is unlike shares it takes time to sell....selling shares is a phone call/fax away...right now these markets can turn on a pin....

In the past PI made sense, there was capital gain, tax right offs and low volitility and stability....that all started to change in 2005 and happened in 2008, now the game is different....One thing that strikes me is the strident sound of PIs generally....or their abuse/distain of anyone who poo poos their sector....

regards

Simpleton - no, with respect,

Simpleton - no, with respect, it's down to you. Always better to do 'mea culpa' if mea has culped.

A lot of us investors would

A lot of us investors would like to sell. But with the prices being offered in this market , we would suffer huge losses. 

Dont know how long most of us can continue to hold . Too many mortgagee sales would be bad for the economy.

I wish we property investors had some sort of govt guarantee to bail us out. 

House prices will go up

House prices will go up soon. Work hard and clear up your mortgage as soon as possible

Pardon me madam, but your

Pardon me madam, but your desperation is showing.

They cant give the abandoned

They cant give the abandoned places away in the central North Island. Free land? nobody wants it. It should have been snaped up..something is terribly wrong. All these towns in the heartland are heading for the history books.

Yeah, work harder . Thousands

Yeah, work harder . Thousands on welfare are depending on you

Yes: SCF bludgers.

Yes: SCF bludgers.

Don't worry about 'the

Don't worry about 'the economy'. It's a totally artificial construct, given noun status via mantra-like repetition.

It was always a temporary state of affairs.

If it's you home keep it. If it's a renter, ping it - and give some young couple the chance you probably had....

"My parents and grandparents

"My parents and grandparents skimped and saved to support me, so my kids and grandkids must do the same." - The Baby Boom Generation.

Anon @ 12.10.p.m.  The

Anon @ 12.10.p.m.  The professional property investors don't need to rely on anyone for their retirement. The good ones could retire anytime. You need to be looking at your own personal circumstances and be worried I would say.

It must suck knowing you are

It must suck knowing you are so justifiably hated by almost everyone not of the baby boom generation.

Why hated? Loved, by

Why hated? Loved, by providing you with rented shelter. Caves are cold this timeof year.

Your jealousy is showing.

I wouldn't be surprised to

I wouldn't be surprised to now see a drop of 30%, taking into account inflation. I know of a property that sold 3 years ago for 650k. Now they are selling and are taking offers over 500k. The agent also said that prices are dropping and sales are almost non existant at the moment. Sounds like an actual honest realestate agent. As they work on commission, they just want the sale, it doesn't matter what it sells for, but if it sells for more, they do make more.

Auckland prices are far too

Auckland prices are far too dear in the first place. You need to realise that NZ is just not Auckland.

Yes and I know of a house

Yes and I know of a house that was purchased for $550K last year and sold for $650K this year.  You example is as pointless as mine.  Property is dead.  Just follow the stats.  When property was bubbling it was all everyone could talk about and now it's tanking nothing has changed.  Better to discuss what people should be doing with their money then flogging a dead horse.

No, it hasn't sold at

No, it hasn't sold at $500,000, it will probably sell at much less. My point was an example of one of many houses that this agent is selling that is selling for a lot less than they were puchased for just a few years ago. Also this is Lower Hutt, not Auckland. I am not aware tof too many that are currently advertised for more than the GV

For every example you have I

For every example you have I have one to the contrary.  You seem to know nothing except property

Grabbing the data for the

Grabbing the data for the Truncated Mean for Listings from Wellington and Auckland and comparing them with the National average, I saw an interesting difference over the last 3 years. 

http://web.me.com/john.butt/Wellington_Property/Johns_Blog/Entries/2010/9/1_Interesting_Observation.html

Wellington trend is definitely very different from that of Auckland, and not surprisingly due to the Auckland influence, different to the National trend.

Does that follow through to sales?  Yes it does seem to, as I have reported earlier from the REINZ stats, the Wellington market seems to be operating in its own space.

Of course it is ...

Of course it is ... government is the only growth industry at the moment.

..correct - and I’m

..correct - and I’m worried, without taxpayers fighting back - almost into a free roaming monster.

I'm ready ........Kunst.....

I'm ready ........Kunst..... as you already know my little coup ...for El Presidente'... fell over due to apathy and a lack of munitions funding...........  it wasn't covered under the Govt Grants scheme and Lassie took off when the Property market collapsed.........oh markmark where for art thou. 

Currently I'm being proactive by besmirching the good name of our right honorables  and linking them to sordid financial practices.

I must confess this is hard work and progress is slow due to the acceptability of corruption among our politicians and City officials.

I still have a T-shirt in my

I still have a T-shirt in my cupboard of Che Guevara and a red flag - lets do it..

Well I'm up for it.........

Well I'm up for it......... but the kids don't know who Che was.....so hold fire on the shirt.

That’s the trouble of

That’s the trouble of “our time” hardly anyone know about real people – they are all talking about Bernanke, Watson and other corrupt and/or criminal people.

Viva  el Presidente' : Count

Viva  el Presidente' : Count of Christov ........

....... has a nice ring to it ! And it's  odds on that  you'll make a better fist of captaining  the NZ-Debtanic than either Key or Goofy . Got my vote , buddy , and the pitchfork is ready for the incumbents  ............

ta ...GBH....I'll set to work

ta ...GBH....I'll set to work on a new plan....of course I'll need Walter to proof it..... but if you exit the Country and await instruction......

 

VIVA the Revolution...!! oh boy oh boy oh boy

For whom does the bell toll.................. Meester Dong.....Key

Well that's three of you

Well that's three of you against the mass ignorance of the general voting brainwashed public.  I wish you luck my friends !!

thanks Matt........ we will

thanks Matt........ we will fight the good fight.... as we did in Bolivia in another lifetime...

 but history will recall us............well er maybe GBH's trademark will have a fashion content by then.... but that aside.... thank you for your encouragement.... and remember all donations are welcome and your  privacy assured.

I realize you have just bought your first Hacienda and so would not expect too large a contribution.

                                  Viva the Revolution.

Good idea donation - to our

Good idea donation - to our "Revolut. Action Boss" R. Hide under: UBS (Switzerland) 076. 1234. 2133. 6660

What’s about you Matt ?

What’s about you Matt ? Are you just a bobble-head or are you with us - starting up a revolution towards a better NZ.?

Next to Russel Norman we need one or two more flag carriers, a free trade negotiator for Cuba/ Fiji and for the next 3 years a Real Estate ambassador for China to sell off NZ.

 

GBH can collect all

GBH can collect all donation(s) deposited in Switzerland and buy some Swiss pocket knives and cow bells to sound the bells for the first round of our revolution - Friday 26th of November 2010 in Wellington Central.

............note to self :

............note to self : Bring Matches ! Trying to start a fire with a flint should be left to Bear Grylls ............... don't wanna look like a fool at the revolution ...........again...........

Just leave the underpants on

Just leave the underpants on the inside this time GBH.

And lose the potato...it's not working....at least not down the back anyway.

Got a pair of those Daniel

Got a pair of those Daniel Carter under-daks ............... still a bit sweaty ............ was it a dumb idea to raid his sports bag ?

Huh , just repeated meself

Huh , just repeated meself ............. Feck ! .... It was bollocks the first time ............ undies on the inside you say ............kinda sophisticated aren't ya !

Sophisticated...........no

Sophisticated...........no GBH that's so you don't give away your super identity ..!

 as to carters up's..........lose em..! there for ball kicking only...and I have other plans for you and that big brain of yours.

Damn it's all happening so

Damn it's all happening so fast I feel like I'm on 24 .....yeah that's it I'm Jack thingamebob.

OK  Kunst 26 November Friday Welle Central.....Bells....uh that Russell Norman's a bit of a squeak aint he...?  he screamed like a girl when they took the flag away......... and I'm getting concerned about GBH's potential as a fire starter............. it seems he wants to bring real matches...?

anyways good progress Kunst....I just knew you were no slacker.

Still something in the back of my brain about Nov 26 ...eh...ah well it'll come.

Re: Simpleton at 12.01:

Re: Simpleton at 12.01: "Until recently I was one of the biggest defenders of property investment, but next week I'm about to join the ranks of the officially bankrupt, and that's all down to property".  

Actually Simpleton I'm sorry to say it was down to a ( or a set of) bad decision(s) on your part not the housing market. People made poor decisions all the time...that’s life. Sorry about your misfortune though.

Property investment is

Property investment is viable, but it all comes down to cashflow.  Used to be able to get 8-10% return which was enough to cover expenses and even repay principle so in 30 years time you had a free hold property.

It's like a good joke..always

It's like a good joke..always down to timing .Why are you going bankrupt? I would hazard a guess and say you were out of the Auckland property market.

Alot of people are now

Alot of people are now selling because they cannot afford to pay their debts, so they are selling their homes, coming out with a loss of between 20-100K and then going bankrupt, thats why I foresee a lot of bankruptcies. People are trying to hold out for as long as they can, but I feel this will avail them little.

There should be a serious

There should be a serious debate about  a slimmer, leaner government an all levels, nationwide, regional and City Councils, all should cut expenses.

If I remember it right, government is costing close to 50% of GDP. This is horrendous!

The problem is, nobody  wants to abolish or cut  handouts  which would cut his/her  own entitlements. Hence the government in order to secure votes, does not dare to change the spending spree.

But there is no way around the problem of  too much tax  and too much rates, other than to reduce spending.

To begin with, do we really need so many MPs in parliament?

Do members of parliament really need travel and other perks despite their reasonable income?

How much could welfare cost be reduced in order that nobody needs to starve but also nobody gets the support because he/she could stand on their own feet and take responsibility for their own life?

How much of government services could be taken over by volunteers/community groups/charities?

How many commissions do we really need? The installment of a "commission" for any trivia is shocking and just wasteful.

Do we really need a "Supercity", nobody has done a costing and nobody can answer the question if there are savings at all. Considering the practical experience that the bigger an organization gets, the more costly and immovable and impersonal it gets. Examples all over the world aplenty.

What would we, the populace and taxpayer accept regarding "tightening the debt" in the interest of the higher good. How much longer could everybody work, assuming he/she stays healthy longer in life?

Any ideas anybody?

Gareth Morgan's Big Kahuna.

Gareth Morgan's Big Kahuna.

Yeah - I got one. No credit,

Yeah - I got one.

No credit, no interest, natural capital accounted in full.

I think your GDP is a red-herring (even the guy who invented it as a wartime comparitor thought it was flawed) and I think that under that regime, wages and salaries would settle down.

Slight problem - getting off this bus and onto that. Many dashed expectations, and some jostling, one would expect.

   Look most of the smaller

   Look most of the smaller towns are so welfare dependant that they would become ghost towns if the benifits were messed about with. Pension day, dole day..it all gets gobbled back up by the greater economy..the main problem is the stipends only go on basics. Remember, being a Consumer is a job as well.

Perhaps not in the short term

Perhaps not in the short term Gertraud..... but the place to start is in the minds and hearts of the young.

Re-educate their psyche to understand that over-representation is wasteful and counter-productive to achieving consensus progress.

 To that end body's to represent factions and those marginalised by the majority or simply P.C. organisations have sprung from every crack in the system and flourished to the point where the ......System itself.... gauges it's longevity  by it's ability to manipulate the opinions of those "body's"

We have got to tell them we got it wrong..... and sometimes life isn't fair....and recourse to justice is not always available to all people.

Oddly enough a lot of that springs from teaching our kids that competition need not be in earnest as a reward of some description will be afforded them .

It is in our nature to compete for survival.... we are systematically unwinding that part of our childrens DNA.  

In last sentence should read

In last sentence should read "tightening the belt"

Anon. You are obviously

Anon. You are obviously hanging arround with the wrong people. With the interest rates so low still why are they needing to sell? Have they lost their jobs? I could understand it if interest rates were a lot higher but their circumstances must have changed dramatically or not owned the property for long as interest rates have been a lot higher than they currently are.

Why would you bankrupt yourself for $20K debt?

Property prices rose; The

Property prices rose; The cost of living rose; Average incomes stagnated.

People were willing to pay continually increasing prices because they assumed prices would continue to rise indefinitely, permitting them to make capital gains.

People were able to pay continually increasing prices because banks were willing to lend almost any amount to almost any applicant.

The situation is now very different: Banks are no longer lending as they were, while the increasing CoL continually eats into everything, so would-be property buyers are demanding lower prices, and not buying when vendors refuse to face facts.

There are a lot of grossly over-extended people out there, with mortgages not servicable on current average incomes, a situation greatly exacerbated by the increasing CoL. The prospects for capital gains is zero in almost every case.

And the immigration miracle rescue package? Fantasy. It always was.

It's only a short journey

It's only a short journey from being the right people to being the wrong people for many households in New Zealand.

Amen that

Amen that

Geez only one day off talking

Geez only one day off talking about SCF then its back to the property porn talk ;)

They just can't pay their

They just can't pay their debts so they have to go bankrupt, interest is sucking the life out of them, its a sorry situation for many people.

Property shortage in

Property shortage in Auckland. Prices will rise over the next 6 months.

There. Is. No. Property.

There. Is. No. Property. Shortage.

You're clutching at straws.

Haha why do you think there

Haha why do you think there are so many listings? Theres a glut in the market...

As the recession bites people

As the recession bites people will bunk-up.( and it will; that's why the Govt. has just done the SCF thing ~ even they now think things won't get better, otherwise they would have left SCF standing a bit longer)  More into the same number of houses; that means more vacancies on the rental market at a lower tenancy price.

There is a property shortage

There is a property shortage in Auckland, that is why prices are refusing to budge. It is a very different market to the regions, but i wouldnt expect a hill-billy like you to know that.

Your squalid life of utter

Your squalid life of utter desperation is only going to get much worse.

The reason that there

The reason that there 'appears' to be a property shortage in Auckalnd is because no one is buying ( prices will fall) and no one is selling ( prices always go up). Only those that have to. or want to, sell are on the market. So it's not a shortage per se, it's still a standoff.

Agree Auckland will never

Agree Auckland will never have too many properties, but the number of houses may not be the issue. The UK as a nation needs more houses (lots more in fact), however prices are falling there regardless. The issue facing all western nations post 08 is unemployment and lending.

Attached a good article from the UK, below quote sums up the whole situation. Many first time buyers have deposits and good jobs, but the banks don't care, they are worried about losing capital and realise the property market (at present prices) is holding....then falling.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2010/aug/31/mortgages-credit-crunch-banking

"Mortgage lending has gone from feast to famine, down by two-thirds in four years. The banks went wild in the boom, but while no one is saying we should go back to 125% mortgages, this mortgage starvation punishes first time buyers with good jobs."

Well we know who will win the

Well we know who will win the stand off, and it won't be the people saddled with debt.

You justify it however you

You justify it however you want. The fact is, prices in Auckland are not falling because there is a fundamental shortage. People arent selling because they need somewhere to live and there is bugger all else on the market to buy or rent. Prices in Auckland are going up over the medium term, its just pure fundamentals.

Haha I'll entertain this

Haha I'll entertain this argument, where do you get your data from?

Go to Statistics NZ and look

Go to Statistics NZ and look up the population growth of Auckland for the last 10 years.  Then look up the number of dwellings consented.  Then overlay the two.  You will see that even in the boom years population growth was greater than the amount of dwellings being consented (not built, just consented).  You will notice that in early 2008 building consents approved falls away although population growth does not slow.

Also check out number of CBD apartments for rent.  For years there's been 800+ available (which is 4% of total - or exactly the same vacancy rate that they are designed for).  This is now down to around 560.  Also watch the number of houses in Isthmus available for rent dropping week by week.

Finally read the changes to the District Plan made over the last 4 years which will prevent the building of new dwellings in Auckland City in the future.  Plan Change 196 is a good place to start - "no apartment building shall be built in Newmarket unless 20% of the units are worth at least $1M dollars" .

It's not 1 person to a house

It's not 1 person to a house mate, more like 3 or 4...

Who said it was? look at SNZ

Who said it was? look at SNZ web site.  All the info is there, including exactly how many people there are on average per household and how many units are being consented.

How bout we start with the

How bout we start with the article that we are all commenting on.........."Auckland has inventory levels closer to long term average (36 weeks vs. 33 weeks), new listing numbers were trending lower than the national average and the asking price has been edging up for the past couple of months."

Whoi cares what the asking

Whoi cares what the asking price is? It's the buying price that matters. A few expensive homes are selling better than all the cheap ones, but only because desperate sellers are dropping their prices. That skews the numbers. It's not that the Auckers property market is doing better than anywhere else, it's just that it has more of those expensive properties for sale.

Who cares what the asking

Who cares what the asking price is? It's the buying price that matters. A few expensive homes are selling better than all the cheap ones, but only because desperate sellers are dropping their prices. That skews the numbers. It's not that the Auckers property market is doing better than anywhere else, it's just that it has more of those expensive properties for sale.

New listings are trending

New listings are trending lower because those with mortgages are sitting on their hands waiting for prices to return to "normal", unfortunately this will not happen and they eventually will be forced to sell, fundamentals as you say. With regards to days overdue, someone must be selling some properties, but there is still a major glut, and will be for years to come.

New listings dont trend lower

New listings dont trend lower when a housing market is under pressure.

It's called 'the calm before

It's called 'the calm before the storm'. Listings reduce ( when the market is under price pressure) as those that have lingering hope, wait to see if prices will rebound. When they don't all hell breaks loose~like it did in Ireland in 2009. One day, less than normal listings, the next, kapow! The market was awash with people 'leapfrogging' each other to try to get out before the next man.

Nice comparison, but I don't

Nice comparison, but I don't think so. The Irish are an emotional lot and tend to go a bit OTT!

For the real PI's, the current property market is a blessing. The stand-off has created stacks of tenants willing to pay good rent. Short term values will dip, but the end game is to have freehold property, so no harm done.

Most importantly the stand-off will weed out the speculators or 'property flickers'. They will buckle soon enough when they realise the tidy 10% capital gain will never come. They paid too much without the capital to take a hit and will suffer, but that's gambling folks.  

Could be TCL. But human

Could be TCL. But human nature dictates that people will always hang on too long with a loss if it's personal. It's easy to cut a corporate loss. But personal? Nope! So I'd venture that Kiwis are just as 'emotinal' as the Irish, and the loss avalanche is a headed our way...soon.

Avalanche? Most PI's have

Avalanche?

Most PI's have less reason to sell now than before 08. For real property investors, the only factor to force sale would be a lack of tenants. As stated the end game is freehold property to provide income and a nest egg. Many baby boomer PI's are having their mortgages and a tidy profit paid every week by tenants.

Trickle!

Increasingly the property speculators will get sick of struggling to juggle the debt and call it a day. There will be no avalanche, but a trickle of sob stories in the media of 'evil' banks forcing sales. sob sob

  Market forces. Your

 

Market forces.

Your beloved market forces.

They have betrayed you.

Like the fundamentals (which is what they are in most respects), market forces are against property investment and investors.

Those who think they are in trouble now are already beyond saving, while those who think they are safe just don't realise how much trouble they are in.

Warren Buffett says markets

Warren Buffett says markets are either driven by "greed of fear". Anyone with half a brain can sense the market is driven by fear at the moment, but it's only just starting. When you walk up a ladder you have to come down somehow. 

"The calm before the storm"

"The calm before the storm" Are you serious?? The storm was in 2008/2009 you idiot. This is what is known as a gradual recovery.

Err....no it wasn't. It's

Err....no it wasn't. It's still coming. That was the Little Wind of '08, not the Cyclone of '11.

Everyone. Many of the people

Everyone.

Many of the people on this site are wishful thinkers if they want the property market to self destruct due to lack of buyers.

The experts not long ago were predicting floating interest rates of 9% per annum.

Is that going to happen? No!!!

Are the predictions that good properties are going to drop much?. No!!!

Are the people who talk negatively continuously, going to change their attitude? No!!!!

Are these same negative people going to have a comfortable life & retirement? No!!!!

Should you try and improve your lifestyle by getting off your backsides and working? YES!!!!

 

Back to 'the retirement'

Back to 'the retirement' thing again! Those that carry their property portfolios from here on in will be the ones with an uncomfortable life in retirement. From whichever age they start from here, they will in all likely hood have large and unavoidable property related debts to service~one way or the other. Either a continuation of negative real returns, subsidised from other income ( wasted current income) and the possibility of furher taxation law changes or the funding of capital losses taken now, or progressively, over time. Why do you think the Government cut SCF loses now? Because they thought 'things are going to get better to allow us to sell'? No. It was because they see this as the last chance to at least minimise the national loss. Now, property owners are likely to be entering into the personal loss environment.

I'd say, hardly anyone was

I'd say, hardly anyone was feeling it in 08/09, people are feeling it in 2010, and by 11 it will be a s**tstorm, I love how to PI's think anything in the economy is good for them. I think you are all delusional. The last time it was so hard to buy a house people were in a depression.

Come on Nony............nonny

Come on Nony............nonny and anonononononny...... get a name and hook up where..........

we love you...................XX

 come on ya scamps...... you can rip each other to bits without the rest of us getting dizzy

trying to keep up with who's who.

unless you are arguing with yourself in which case Dr.Hyde may be a good choice for one name.

Rapidly rising rents will

Rapidly rising rents will make housing most popular investment again.... in fact it's only safe investment......  $ 1.billion + from SCF investors is ready to go...into property market...or in the banks and then into property market....

Nope. $1.6 billion will go

Nope. $1.6 billion will go into debt repayment. Either personal ( pay off the last of the mortgage, car or store card etc. ) or corporate ( banks will repay their debts to attain the new credit ratios and not lend back out. It will in effect be recycled back into the Government coffers to try and run this indebted nation of ours)

Yeah I love how everything is

Yeah I love how everything is good for property. one some, we are burning $250 million a week, do you think we pay interest on this? Yes. Do you think we will have to pay it back? Yes. Do you think it will be through increased tax? Yes. Do you think people want to live in a nation where all their taxes will go towards servicing debt? No. Do you think property prices will go up if that is the case? No.

Logic is a killer.

I know of an Aussie here that

I know of an Aussie here that has been trying to sell his North Shore property in Auckland for over 2 years - at an inflated, delusional price of course. Ive tried to tell him to get real and sell at a loss now rather than go bankrupt later but he keeps telling me, “things will get better this summer & besides I have a tenant now that covers a good % of my mortgage”. That good tenant took several months to find by the way. He has been renting over here, in Oz, with his wife and kids as he can’t afford to buy in his home city. Add to that FX losses on a rapidly unwinding NZ economy and it’s a double whammy one two punch he will be facing.

Greed does weird things to what were once rational minds it seems. In the words of George Dubya “This suckers going down”.

Shame is all I've got to say,

Shame is all I've got to say, I think people are one day going to get past housing as an investment. Personally, the only way that I would own a 1 million dollar home is if I had 10 million dollars in assets, so that it represented at the most 10% of my wealth. Normal people do not think like this. Buffett did.

So are you saying that the

So are you saying that the only way people should own an average home (around 350K isn't it?) is once their bank account balance reaches the $3.5m mark? I wonder how many home owners there'd be if that was the case.

No not at all, just saying

No not at all, just saying thats how I will be doing it, may take on some debt, but it will be the type that I will pay off in 2 years, not 20.

Lid on rental  boiling pot

Lid on rental  boiling pot has exploded!  The question is how far will it go, sky seems to be limit...good to see people are saving.. will come handy to top up rapidly rising rents

Keep dreaming

Keep dreaming

All my rents gone up 5-20%

All my rents gone up 5-20% over last 18 mths....5% for long term valuable tenants and more for others...noone said a word...people realise low rent  times are gone for good....landlords were happy with capital gains prior to 2007, but now...party is over...

Are you my former slumlord

Are you my former slumlord husband who wouldn't put showers in his houses cos he personally liked to have a bath so "it wasn't worth it"? Sounds like it.

Ruru, yes I am , it is pity

Ruru, yes I am , it is pity not seeing you reclining at the other end of the bath anymore.

Never mind something seems to have surfaced to take your place!!

Happens when the sewers give

Happens when the sewers give out...but 'fraid you're the wrong initials.

Ruru "Happens when the sewers

Ruru "Happens when the sewers give out."

Priceless!

So as people keep losing

So as people keep losing their jobs, income goes down etc you will meet the market right? People aren't saying anything to you because times are uncertain and they probably do not want to move, rest assured they will and you will most probably have to drop your rent, sorry to burst you bubble, no pun intended.

Spring sales season in

Spring sales season in AUGUST??? Yeah whatever.

Good reading today from

Good reading today from NZIER's quarterly report. Nice realistic stuff. Unlike Infometrics who predict unemployment going down to 5.3% by middle next year (what a joke those clowns are), NZIER correctly forecast it being similar to now. 20,000 construction sector jobs could go. Westin hotel dumped 100 staff today. etc etc.

the bank economists can spruik it up all they want, but NZIER are right. We will be facing lean times in the next 1-2 years, and the housing market will be going nowhere fast.

Heck, even Tony Alexander has now revised his forecast of prices edging higher to late 2011, from his original prediction of this year (but will be acknowledge he was wrong - HELL NO!!!! He's never worng, only those idiotic housing doomsdayers are ever wrong!)

I know of one property on the

I know of one property on the North Shore with a GV =$300K  but sold for $335K.  I still can't figure out why??
 

The owner bought it in 2006

The owner bought it in 2006 for $300K and then spent $35K on renovations. He sold it recently for $335K . So it still is a loss. 

He probably spent closer to

He probably spent closer to $100k on it.

I can't understand what's

I can't understand what's happening to Hamilton property!

Listing prices of at least three brand new houses in Rototuna area, have been increased by over 10K during the past one week! This is at a time when overall house listings have dropped, sales have been stagnant, and still a price increase by builders.Whats going on?

I strongly believe there is a nexus/cartel of RE agents and the builders who have joined hands in fleecing the gullible.

So government bonds instead

So government bonds instead of property investment?

Bernard is very good in

Bernard is very good in cutting sentences in half, when it suits him. For those who don’t read whole article:

  1. The volume of new listings coming onto the market fell again in August with under 10,000 for the first time since June last year. As the chart shows this is the 5th consecutive month of decline
  2. The truncated mean asking price for August was $403,423, down just 0.6% on the prior 3 month average and up 1.6% on August last year. This would indicate stability in price expectation amongst sellers
  3. The steady decline in new listings seen for 5 straight months is beginning to tell in the market with early signs of what could be a looming shortage, if sales were to take off
  4. Auckland has inventory levels closer to long term average (36 weeks vs. 33 weeks), new listing numbers were trending lower than the national average and the asking price has been edging up for the past couple of months.

The property market is

The property market is utterly screwed for the next five to ten years, at least.

Unless banks once again start having mortgage lolly scrambles, and average incomes increase significantly, the property market will remain depressed.

The spring flood of property offerings will turn into a mortgagee disaster as the existing glut becomes a super glut, while potential buyers sit on the sidelines and laugh at desperate yet still dreaming sellers.

So many people are saddled with huge mortgages which seemed like a good idea in the time of infinite capital gains mindset, but now that everything is going backwards except the size of their mortgage payments, the number of available options are small and all tough.

Many of these people are telling themselves that it's all going to be OK, and a lot of them are too blind and ignorant to even recognise just how much trouble they're really in, but that can't last...the money will have to be repaid at some point, and last I checked Duble Dipton wasn't offering any taxpayer-funded welfare bludges for mortgages.

Unless you're a Southland dairy farmer.

Nice Alen1, thanks for the

Nice Alen1, thanks for the full info

There are a lot of people sitting on the sidelines/keeping the powder dry, waiting, waiting, waiting....these are cashed up bloggers, FHB saving and increasing their deposit and now SCF depositers with principal + interest. I'm sure the list could go on. My prediction (I posted this earlier in the year) for Auckland, flat to slightly down this year then 2011 sales will pick up and prices will slowly rebound. Banks aren't lending much at the moment. In Auckland 2011 the Rugby WC is going to big for the Auckland economy. Once the economy starts to grow again, banks will lend more and interest rates (esp 2 year) will become competitive amongst the banks. Once this happens a lot of people who are trying to time the market/find the bottom will all hold hands and jump in with there money. But I'm no expert, just a humble opinion.

Kind regrads

"In Auckland 2011 the Rugby

"In Auckland 2011 the Rugby WC is going to big for the Auckland economy. Once the economy starts to grow again"

Have to disagree with that. It's been widely reported that the Rugby NZ and the Government will be making a loss on the event. Sure, private business will pick up for a seven week period and make a one time hit, then it will go back to "normal" - whatever that is at the time.

Given the anticipated eye-gouging of visitors at the time I think it would be optimistic to assume that they can afford to stay in NZ for very long and tour the rest of the country. Land - watch match - binge drink for 2 days - fly home.

People need to realise that events like this do not provide sustainable benefits. There is a big difference between spending on an event that provides a one time return on investment and unproductive infrastructure as opposed to investment which provides sustainable returns through employment and income. All of that additional infrastructure will need to be maintained at a cost in the future.

The impact of the RWC will be

The impact of the RWC will be minor at best. Some perspective;

We are expecting (hoping for) 85,000 overseas visitors to the event. We usually get about 2,500,00 tourists per year.

Most of the regular type tourists will not be coming - drunk rugby fans are unlikely to be a draw card for most. We will probably end up with fewer  visitors than usual overall.

Eden park can hold about 40,000. The rest will be watching on telly. Unless we've got a levy on take home beer sold in Britain or  Blumefontain  how is that a benefit?

Most of the figures you see on "economic benefit "are fabricated up with the intention of sucking the rest of us into paying for the fantasies of politicians/businesses/local governments/the rugby union.

Yes there are other types of

Yes there are other types of Investments apart from property and many choose to invest in them. Had a friend about 20 years ago that was convienced Angora goats were the way to go. I told him I would invest in a property and he put the same amount into goats to see how we both faired after 10 years. I won't tell you the result as it might break your hearts!

The property is still doing OK thank you.

That's what happens when you

That's what happens when you don't get out of a speculative market and hold on ( the goats!). Some made HUGE money from goats ( and alpacas, and ostriches, and pine trees and...and... property) for those that sold them to the 'investors'. Those who have made their money, and got out, are the smart-money people. It's a bit like what will happen to our last speculator market; property.

Oh, oh....forgot the one

Oh, oh....forgot the one going down as we speak.....vineyards....that's kind of property, as well!

No its not it is a highly

No its not it is a highly competitive beverage business.

You might decribe vineyards

You might decribe vineyards as "productive businesses" the type which Bernard thinks NZ needs much more of.

Vineyards were the 'property'

Vineyards were the 'property' of the '90's. It was a speculative as residential proeprty became in the noughties. Results will be the same.

Of course! And you get to sit

Of course! And you get to sit on the porch of your 'nearly' finished lifestyle house( had to use the rest of the cash for the vines etc), sipping from the bottle of Pinot that cost you about $1000 bucks a bottle to make, and watch the value of your land sink with the setting sun.

Most of my friends working in

Most of my friends working in the Real Estate industry agree that Auckland will have the biggest residential real estate price fall in the next 8 months. 

The indicators are high inventory of old stock, few new listings, low sales volume, low mortgage approvals etc

(No subject)

http://www.crikey.com.au/2009

http://www.crikey.com.au/2009/01/06/australias-own-ponzi-scheme-the-property-market/

 

Property is a ponzi! You must read this article. It is undeniable proof that property investment is a ponzi scheme for suckers.

A tad ancient, anon.

A tad ancient, anon.

Yeah Anon, you must really be

Yeah Anon, you must really be a complete moron if you think "property investment" by definition is a ponzi scheme. Property investment has been going on for thousands of years, with the one constant being that over the long term property values go up because of population growth. Maybe you should go and get an education before you go trying to preach about ponzi schemes. You are exactly the type of idiot that con-artists who run ponz schemes prey on.

RE agents are con-artists no?

RE agents are con-artists no? Oh no sorry, they are savvy sales-people. PI's are part of a ponzi they don't like to admit.

My sauce is telling me the

My sauce is telling me the RBA is set to start raising again and maybe another 75bps...my tea leaves report the aussie bubble is in trouble!

You gotta lay

You gotta lay off.............. the sauce Wally............it's only giving you bad news and me an ulcer.

"lay off"...I'm laying up a

"lay off"...I'm laying up a roomful of the best sauce Christov...gotta beat the gst rort and we all know what shoots up in price with gold...only the top stuff mind!

good for you Wally..!

good for you Wally..! Chateau..........?

Wally the only sources you

Wally the only sources you have are the insane voices in your crazy head.

Suck on this sauce

“…it is

“…it is difficult enough to convince some people that the economy is in fact not providing the security they desire, but is actually destroying their future completely. To explain to them that this is deliberate, that the economy is designed to self-destruct, that is another prospect altogether…

Whew...........boy you'd feel sick after that ..!

Wally I have repeatedly said ........that I sense and therefore believe...(I'm happy to be wrong)...that The Global economic meltdown has been so badly managed that you'd almost think it was planned as far as was controllable.

That the outcome would be to steal the wealth of a Gen or Two and find a new Ground Zero.. for what (they) the central banks and  whose interests they control deem to be for the Greater Good.

K.RRRRRRRRRRist............ I hope I'm so far wrong that being a fringe loon would be acceptable to me.  

Nope...you are not

Nope...you are not wrong...but expect to be made the scapegoat for the demise of all the toilet paper and for the theft of all the savings...the spin will blame the 'loons' for having caused the run on the banks. You will be run out... of what's left of town...and those who really did cause the end of time will promote themselves as the future leaders prepared to devote their time and energy to ensure the greater good for all.

I reckon the people that

I reckon the people that write that are bullish on commodities and have a vested interest, not that it isn't a good article and makes sense, but just what I think.

Anon......... almost every

Anon......... almost every comment you see here will have a vested interest bias ....including mine.

Yesssss....and are you going

Yesssss....and are you going to invest some munny anon!....are you willing to put your own munny on the table....a bet against those who predict an end for the toilet paper? All you have to do is buy heaps of long term USgovt bonds. Just takes a phone call anon!

"I reckon the people that

"I reckon the people that write that are bullish on commodities and have a vested interest..."

Just like those who are bullish on property.

Woll is agitated again. He's

Woll is agitated again. He's highlighting his words.

Wally is always

Wally is always agitated...you would be too if you'd had the hard life he has...quite sad really!

anyway here we have it direct to Wallyworld:

 

Yessirree..The wind is blowing in a different more positive direction today with a strong rebound in global equity markets. The US market has had its best day in 8 weeks rallying circa 3%. (Whilst I am reminded market rallies are always built on shaky foundations….the direction from here is still suggesting cautious range trading with buying on dips being rewarded eg BHP<$38.00 and only in key sectors and themes such as the emerging market consumer, agriculture, water, dividend stories and energy)

Short covering in banks is noticeable (as is the better bank commentary now coming from a variety of analysts). This has the potential to continue.The rally came from better US August ISM news. The July construction and the August ADP labour figures were somewhat disappointing but investors ignored them. 

The final Eurozone manufacturing PMI at 55.1 was in line with the flash estimate. Germany is now showing some moderation in momentum. France was better. The Swiss PMI was down sharply.

 

So there..and not a CAPLOCK in sight!

rock on elves

How nice of you to care

How nice of you to care Rob...I note you qualify your market enthusiam (shaky foundations)!

I am pleased to be out of copper even though it has spiked to $7600....the top is as difficult to pick as the bottom. Now there remains the task of where to move the loot. Made all the easier having read the stuff from the 'sauce' to discover the RBA is soon to ram 75 basis points onto the rate over there. Now what will that do the kiwi/aus cross me thinks. Wait for the gap to open I say. What would you do?

diversification FTW

diversification FTW

It's soon to be the end of

It's soon to be the end of anonymous contributors like me.

So, as a close-to-final observation:

For how many more months will so many posters on this site keep screaming that the housing market is about to collapse?

You have been saying this for how many years now? So...when's it going to happen?

Mind you, I urge you to keep complaining and saying housing is a bad investment.

Why?

As a PI, I know that if your views gain more general acceptance you will frighten off people who would otherwise have bought a house to lease  out. As a PI, the less competition the better for me. I can raise my rents as more and more tenants find there are less and less of me ie PIs.

Suits me then that you all scream shrill-like about how bad housing is. Do your worst to bad-mouth the property investment. I will then do my best and raise rents.

Thankyou, all of you who are helping me.

PS  And remember: property is a terrible investment, unproductive, crippling the country, the road to personal failure, riddled with rip-off artists, scamsters etc etc.

Everything is good for PI's

Everything is good for PI's hahaha

There is no need for you to

There is no need for you to depart the site anony..........As Rob O North said.....you will have your detractors as they have you.................

from time to time you have lost your rag as have we all for different reasons on different days....but............... it is all.....banter after all and no grudges held.

You are the bullish pi.... and that has it's place in the mix of things......you are easily recognised and that gives you personality.........

I may not agree with your stand on things............. but I respect your commitment and understand your frustration.

Personally I hope you sign up....get a bigger chin..... but if not good luck to you in your choice of paths.

Thank you Christov. Don't

Thank you Christov.

Don't worry I have a big chin and am happy to lead with it. No Joe Bugner either, by the way!

I'm not the only bullish PI anon on this site. But, it's not really a PI-type site this one. If a PI takes a name it is soon copied or adapted and then abuse starts eg someone is "abc", then someone signs up as the "real abc" and confuses the other posters.

But, if I am on this site as an anti-PI person like everyone else then my name will be safe.

I've long since decided property is the place that suits my personality and temperament so personally I don't struggle with the question of where I should be putting my money at any one time. If property is not much of an investment today I know that one day it will be OK, so I just wait out the bad times. I've been doing that for twenty-five years.

For me, all investing is good. If a person understands their market and is suited to that activity then I say they should go for it. Good luck to them.

Thank you once again Christov.

I agree with you Anon,it is

I agree with you Anon,it is currently a terrible investment. Values of houses in NZ are going to slip away each month over the next five to ten years and we are going to see when it finishes values that people will not perceive as being possible at this stage. It will be great for my and your children as they will be able to buy houses without our help.

Ex agent, your children will

Ex agent, your children will be broke, just like you.

sorry Anon. I cashed up a

sorry Anon. I cashed up a large portfolio in 2007/2008 as I saw the writing on the wall. No longer working as I do not need to,no tenants which is great and just enjoying the fact I was correct in following what the analysts and advisors said I should do. I speak to colleagues daily and it is getting worse by the month for them and vendors. The long awaited drop in prices is slowly grinding up momentum and it is about to get into second gear. Hold on. There will be blood on the floor from investors who are over committed in debt. The banks will not muck around.

I'm sensing a bit of

I'm sensing a bit of aggression lol, PI's are getting ancy. Go buy another house and leverage yourself to the hilt. Your generation is addicted to debt, you love owing money to people, do us a favour and go borrow some more money. When will you realize that money does not equal happiness?

i don't know why posters like

i don't know why posters like "anon(s)" are writing their farewell notes?

all you have to do is register on this site as a commenter before sept 12, give yourself a online name like i have and carry on...it's how it was before this site was upgraded!

why do you think Wally calls himself Wolly?

cause he is one.. and also someone else has pinched/registered his name....

Smart first home buyers will

Smart first home buyers will hold on for the next 2-3 years and buy when properties 5-10% lower than today. 

A word of advice to Mum and Dad investors : Try and sell your residential property investments as soon as possible before you find that your equity has disappeared. Remember there is no govt guarantee . So no bail out.

If your rent is $350 /wk,  2

If your rent is $350 /wk,  2 year's rent would come to $36,400 and 3 year's rent is $54,600.  So it makes sense to buy now if you do not foresee prices to be down more than $36,400 in 2 years.

In 2 years time with a loan

In 2 years time with a loan amt of say $300k  you would end up paying around $46K as interest and would have paid just $5k from your principal loan amt. So you would still have $295k loan amt. Add to this the cost of repairs, rates, insurance etc. 

Whereas if you are renting you just pay $36k for 2 years. and would have saved the $10k plus the other costs. And you are saved from the scenario of having to face lower equity because of the expected price drops in the next 2 years.

Plus if you can keep your

Plus if you can keep your savings of the initial home deposit in a fixed term deposit  then that helps too when you are ready to buy after 2 years. 

Lol I love when RE agents put

Lol I love when RE agents put their ads up and say stuff like "Only for the very astute investor" etc, if an investment is any good it doesn't need to be sold to you at all, you go out and get it.

Anon.............there has

Anon.............there has never been one to beat ...........A Peek at the Sea........ that is achieved by  standing on the toilet bowl and opening the louvers.

Haha, of course that one

Haha, of course that one surely was only for the very very astute investor. There were some funny ones for the Zest auckland apartments, "Nest or Invest in Zest" LOL I thought that was a good one, who invests in something that needs a catchy line to sell? Ponzi PI's me thinks

Ex Agent. If you previously

Ex Agent.

If you previously owned a real estate firm and sold real estate as you previously stated , then why the heck did you need to follow advice from analysts and advisors to sell your huge portfolio. Couldn't you work it out for yourself if you were in the business? No wonder you had to get out.

Give the guy a break...it is

Give the guy a break...it is a wise man who seek the counsel  of others,,,

Dont you get the feedback from others when making important decisions?

I make a point of it....that why I'm an EX-simpleton :-)

Nicely put.....!.. ExS

Nicely put.....!.. ExS

Because when you are in sales

Because when you are in sales and especially if you are good at it you start to believe your own press and you are incapable of being objective. That is the problem in NZ, a lot of people in the industry and the investors think property is a sure thing. I can assure you it isn't and that is now being played out in the market. As QV said in August spring is not going to fix it this year and we have more drops to come over the next few months. Even Tony Alexander is putting out the date for recovery to occur.It is years away and if you need or want to sell then do it now as prices are going to keep falling for some time. There is not one positive factor out there at present to support property prices in NZ including farms and commercials. We are still in very cautious times. People are just coping with their existing debts and cost of living expenses.

Ex agent, you are a failed

Ex agent, you are a failed business operator in the property industry. You have admitted it was all too hard for you so you got out.

Why do you comment on an industry you were a failure at and are not even in?

It is revealing that you commented at 12.08pm that advisors were telling you what to do. You were not very well suited to the business were you if you needed advisors. You failed in the business. Now you are no longer in the business.

I wonder why you comment on the industry and certainly people should pay no attention to your opinions.

I'm sure ex-agent can stick

I'm sure ex-agent can stick up for himself, but I will put my 2 cents in, obviously he made the right move and knew what was coming, I know I did and I was only 19 at the time, the fundamentals were blatantly wrong and still are, when prices drop to levels where it is possible to have postively geared properties to pay off the mortgage+rates+insurance and repairs etc, that is when it will be balanced. Ex-agent made the right moves at the right time, like a few people I know, who cashed up years ago.

19? Get out and buy boy. You

19? Get out and buy boy. You have a great future.

Sorry Anon , I just took

Sorry Anon , I just took advantage of the market and sold a very successful agency at the top. Why work when you do not need to. You might just be suprised how many agents are currently leaving and how many agencies are closing or selling at reduced values from 2008. When I talk about advisors I am talking about my lawyer and accountant which is only normal business practice. I was not a failure and still have very good contacts in the industry who are only too happy to tell me how bad it is and how worse it is getting by the month. You sound like one of the many struggling agents who are currently wondering why the heck they are in the industry which is only going to get worse. Maybe you should be looking for a new job.

Something good came out of

Something good came out of last recession for RE industry. All greedy speculators and people wanting to get rich overnight have  gone, only genuine agents are in business now.

Rapidli rising  rents will

Rapidli rising  rents will bring back genuine christian values...people will be closer to each other, young people will look after their parents and youngsters will save more instead of wasting themselves in pubs...

Rents aren't rising and

Rents aren't rising and there's no sensible reason why they would or should rise.

ex agent. There is no way in

ex agent.

There is no way in the world that you ever owned an real estate agency let alone a successful one.

You are a jhealous dreamer. What would the average lawyer and accountant know about property investment, compared to your very successful self who ran a great company?

You may have contacts in the industry who are struggling because they are known to you and follow your negativety.

You can attack me as much as

You can attack me as much as you like anon. The facts speak for themselves. It peaked in 2007, I got rid of some of them then and the last ones in 2008. Next weeks figures from QV will confirm just how strong the buyers position currently is and it is getting better by the month. Just because I got out does not make me a failure. Is Sam Morgan a failure because he sold Trade Me. I got offered fantastic money which I would not get now. I do not need to work just like Sam Morgan. I can play around with new ideas and ventures and do non paid work on community boards. What is wrong with that. Better than sitting in an office watching nothing happening and wondering what is going to happen if things do not improve. There are very few agents in NZ curently making a living like they used to. Are you in fact one of them.

ex. agent I am not attacking

ex. agent

I am not attacking you personally, just don't beleive that you ever owned a real estatate firm because of the bitter way you speak.

If you were successful and had made plenty then you wouldn't be so anti towards property investment as it has and always will be an excellent investment for those that know what they are doing.

You are nothing like Sam Morgan.

Congratulations on doing all your work  for the community boards or is it community work for your convictions?

Anon "I am not attacking you

Anon "I am not attacking you personally................... or is it community work for your convictions?"

Nasty and uncalled for Anon, ex agent has been totally reasonable and not offensive in his comments. You anons are all the same.

Right on Kiwidave ! I dont

Right on Kiwidave !

I dont actually agree with all Ex Agent opinions but he has a right to them with out any insensitive and ugly comments.
 

I am not bitter and I am not

I am not bitter and I am not anti property anon. Otherwise I would have sold my home. I believe I am just being honest and realistic. Property is a good investment but just like shares it is all about timing. Now is not a good time to be in it. Cash is currently king.  People who have bought property since 2007 have the risk of losing money if they sell it now and that is going to get worse for them. Why would you buy in a dropping market? I could no longer look people in the eyes and tell them to get stuck into property as an investment. But that is what agents are still doing. I think they need to examine their consciences a bit more if they have one.

  Having read through the

 

Having read through the 80% of dross on this thread I'd side with ex-agent.  2007 approx. sept was the peak of the market and it has all been downhill since then.

All the numbers and trends point to continuing inventory growth as vendors still have rocks in their heads with respect price expectations and many are unwilling to negotiate on price even though they advertise PBN.  Additionally liquidity is shot as vendors can't sell so can't buy onwards and the banks arent lending. This is key, unrealistic pricing and f all liquidity = no price discovery so no-one is really sure how low prices are (and they are lower than is being reported with 'medians'.).

How do I know? Simple, have been looking seriously at buying and after having made reasonable cash offers on property which have been rejected have concluded that the best place to be is sitting on he sidelines collecting interest on my money and waiting for vendors to get real.

It's interesting to watch the vendors who used to have cash offers on the table continue to wait with their houses on the market.

It ain't pretty out there for vendors and once the herd breaks on pricing the whole market will drop.  Real estate agents must be the game changers this spring otherwise 50% will be out of jobs.

Anon @2.25p.m.   What do

Anon @2.25p.m.

 

What do you mean you got out at 19. Are you saying you owned residential reinvestment properties or you were kicked out of your rental by the landlord?

How many properties did you own and how old were you when you first bought from your pocket mony.

I think he means 'even  a 19

I think he means 'even  a 19 year old could see that the fundamentals of property invesment made no sense'; not that he was an existing owner.

Yeah I was 19 at the time, a

Yeah I was 19 at the time, a lot of people were getting mortgages etc, people tried to talk me into buying property, I knew that the market was overpriced so decided to stay out, and will stay out for as long as I perceive prices to be unfair, don't really feel like participating in a fools game.

anon. you will be out

anon. you will be out forever.

I highly doubt that.

I highly doubt that.

I would just like to point

I would just like to point out that we are on the verge of an historic event.

Household mortgage debt (currently $169 billion) has just had its two lowest monthly increases on record, of $112m in June and $110m in July. The record increase was $2,198m in March 2007; the increase has exceeded $1,000m on 56 separate months, most recently in March 2008. (March is generally the biggest month for this statistic.) Seems like only yesterday.

Even during the recession of the early 90s, household debt increased every month without fail.

Surely it cannot be long before we see the first actual decrease on record and Bernard will throw a big party for all his dedicated readers. The deleveraging will then have truly begun.

 

.....yes, now where was I ...

.....yes, now where was I ... that's right. ..property NEVER decreases in value ... rents going UP and PRICES going down ... that means a more positive RETURN....note to thy self, get to the BANK and BORROW like there is no tomorrow !

Looking for a 3 bd, 2 bth with dbl int. access garage townhouse under 600k in the central auckland area .. no "leaky" issues (will be checked anyway) and must have eaves !

C'mon all you PI's and RE Agents .... find me something decent, as above.

Bet you can't because either:

a) the cost of such a property is way over the above price or

b) if there was such a property under $600k , the owner wouldn't want to face up to the fact their precious property has dropped back in value and are living in denial, regarding its value.

c) it is made of "porridge"

In other words IMHO this particular market is still way over-valued and does have some downward correction going forward ...... so I will just wait :)

I STILL can not understand why a city like Auckland is so overpriced, as in a good part of  San Francisco, the USD equivalent 420,000 will get you some good real estate  :)

 

 

 

 

 

I will be happy when the

I will be happy when the de-leveraging happens, when as a country our government is SAVING $250 million a week, and when we don't have a trade deficit.

Amazing how so many people

Amazing how so many people just don't seem to understand the situation. Deleveraging is a must, the only question is whether we have a huge fall in property prices now, or we just go sideways for about a decade or more until incomes catch up.

Neither of these alternatives involve property prices going up. That won't happen for a very long time.

Of course, there will always be random fools who will continue to buy overpriced property, but waiting for an idiot is a not a strategy, it's a prayer.

It's amazing how so many

It's amazing how so many people don't seem to understand that deleveraging is exactly what is going on at the moment and has been for the last 3 years.  Given that of owner occupiers only about a 1/3 have a mortgage and of those only about a 1/4 have an LVR over 50% I think we we see the sideways movement with small peaks and troughs along the way.  If you are happy to live in traditional rental areas like Manurewa or Otahuhu then there will be some really big discounts and good buying as investors offload, but in desireable owner occupier areas there won't be anywhere near as much movement.

You real estate agents and

You real estate agents and mortgage broker types just can't help yourself, can you?

Here you go again trundling out the twaddle in a desperate last-ditch bid to defend the crumbling property market.

"when our government is

"when our government is saving $250m a week" - this will happen when either the economy is powering along or several big programs (WFF, childcare, health, interest free student loans) are cut. With the October tax cuts a government surplus looks unlikely for quite a few years.

 

"when we don't have a trade deficit" - the countries without trade deficits are all manufacturing or fossil fuel powerhouses. This would require a collapse in the dollar; a collective choice not to buy expensive crap from overseas; a collective choice to save a lot more and only invest (wisely) in New Zealand... good luck with that.

 

There's more chance of a small amount of deleveraging in the household sector. This would only require house prices to drift lower; interest rates to stay low; some of the tax cuts to be used to pay down debt; and sales levels to stay at historic lows, all of which are on the cards.

 

Still, when your debt is at 90% of GDP, even putting an extra 3% towards paying it down would take decades to have an effect and would still be a kick in the guts for the rest of the economy anyway. 

For sale Beige V W . Comes

For sale Beige V W . Comes complete with a Finance Company. All offers considered.

Is the car (VW) still in

Is the car (VW) still in running order - no burst tyres, removed engine or windscreen wipers not working ? It seems the previous owner, Alan H. had some issues there.

Blew the Big End & have just

Blew the Big End & have just had a rebore from Diptons finest mechanic and Shonkey Motors of Akld & Wgtn.

The big end blew on Monday.  Only one owner .

So many people on here

So many people on here like to make up stories and facts to proof their points...

ahh...internet. :)

Today I bought seven more

Today I bought seven more houses. The bank was happy to give me a 105% mortgage in every case. They threw in a free holiday as well. And every open home I go to is packed out, with those present toasting the tremendously buoyant market with champagne and caviar. The real estate industry has never had things so good. Prices are just going up and up, with no end in sight. Everyone I talk to gushes about residential property investment, and how they are planning to build or buy more Dream Houses real soon now. Oh, will this endless summer last forever? I think so.

Buy houses, because you can't lose, and only a mug isn't in debt, and if you wait you'll miss out!

Good God what was the lender

Good God what was the lender smoking or I suspect you are full of   Rich Mastery . You must have just organised your finance through NZ Home Loans.

this man is on drugs ........

this man is on drugs ........

Go and Take ya Kingswood for

Go and Take ya Kingswood for a spin up and down the main St of Gore .

Sold our character house 2

Sold our character house 2 months ago in the low 400's. Only took 4 weeks to sell. Bought it for 190k in 2002... we had done minor garden improvements. 

Then bought a larger house in same suburb with superior decoration and extensive improvements etc for very similar price (+10k).   So there are benefits of a 'flat market'. Also mortgage repayments are significantly lower after breaking a fixed rate while selling & buying.... maybe a lot more owner-occupiers will see these benefits over the next few months....

I have a hard time

I have a hard time comprehending some of the comments on here, no wonder NZ is in such a state. People who are clearly missing some basic intelligence are those same people who are allowed to vote and who are sucked into side issues by the govt of the day. My god NZ, wake the F* up and get over your own sense of entitlement, not to mention do some reading.

The country is going doen the toilet faster than it can be propped up. House prices are going nowhere but backwards for a very long time in real terms. To think otherwise is to think that the GFC is in fact an accident or moreso is now over!!!

Yes I am a PI BTW.

I have a hard time

I have a hard time comprehending some of the comments on here, no wonder NZ is in such a state. People who are clearly missing some basic intelligence are those same people who are allowed to vote and who are sucked into side issues by the govt of the day. My god NZ, wake the F* up and get over your own sense of entitlement, not to mention do some reading.

The country is going doen the toilet faster than it can be propped up. House prices are going nowhere but backwards for a very long time in real terms. To think otherwise is to think that the GFC is in fact an accident or moreso is now over!!!

Yes I am a PI BTW.

Will house prices fall

Will house prices fall further here in NZ as it is happening in UK?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/7978210/Will-house-prices-fall-further.html

  Britons to lose the

 

Britons to lose the equivalent of a typical annual salary off the value of their home by end of next year

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/houseprices/7977167/Britons-to-lose-equivalent-of-average-salary-off-home.html