Offers for readers

The comment stream

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Reader poll

Should the RBNZ hold the Official Cash Rate at 3% until December 9 as many economists and the markets are now forecating?

Choices

House value increases to be small over 2010, avoiding boom-bust cycle, Bayleys says

Posted in News

Bayleys Real Estate managing director Mike Bayley said he expects the residential property market will undergo a small "if somewhat unspectacular" recovery over 2010.

(W)hile the New Zealand economy would continue to return to health throughout 2010, house price value increases would be small, Bayley said. "And that would be good for the whole economy "“ by avoiding a "˜boom/bust' cycle."

Here is the full release from Bayleys:

New Zealand's residential property market is in for a steady "“ if somewhat unspectacular - year of recovery in both prices and sales volumes, according to the head of one of the country's largest real estate agencies.

Bayleys Real Estate managing director Mike Bayley predicted that while the New Zealand economy would continue to return to health throughout 2010, house price value increases would be small. And that would be good for the whole economy "“ by avoiding a "˜boom/bust' cycle, he said.

Mike Bayley said the supply and demand for residential property is dictated by three primary drivers:

"¢ Immigration
"¢ Employment "“ and by association, unemployment
"¢ Interest rates

Each of these specifically impacts on the residential property market, he added.

"Firstly, immigration. Net immigration levels remained well above forecasts in 2009, and there is little to suggest this influx will abate in 2010, although forecasts will obviously be revised upward to more accurately reflect the trend which emerged last year," Mike Bayley said.

"Greater Auckland is the primary location in which the majority of new immigrants settle "“ due to employment opportunities and existing ethnic-based social networks. This will ensure that Auckland's residential property market "“ both from an owner/occupier perspective and for investors - will continue to have a steady supply of new buyers/tenants coming on stream, in addition to existing New Zealanders entering the market for the first time, or looking to trade up.

"Secondly, employment. Being so intricately linked to a general economic recovery, I foresee that employment, also known as unemployment levels, will bottom out at around 93 "“ 94 percent - equating to an unemployment rate of six "“ seven per cent. What is more likely to happen for the first half of the year at least is that production capacity within existing employment will rise "“ that is upping the hours of part-timers or casual staff before taking on any additional new staff in any great numbers."

Mike Bayley said that for those in employment, this would deliver higher net incomes than perhaps seen in 2009 when businesses contracted excess employment capacity. Higher incomes = greater consumer spending capability, of which home-purchasing is an element for some.

"A more solid employment future will provide a level of psychological comfort for those who held off buying a new home or trading up in 2008/2009 because of nervousness about their employment prospects," Mike Bayley said.

"They will be in the market to buy, and will have built up sound deposits through their propensity for saving "˜for a rainy day'."

Thirdly, interest rates. The cheap medium-term cash which underpinned the stabilisation of the property market in the early to middle parts of 2009 and indeed provided a much-needed stimulus to a flagging sector at that time, is now long gone, said Mike Bayley.

"Virtually every bank economist and fiscal commentator is predicting the Reserve Bank will begin hiking up the official cash rate (OCR) some time in the second or third quarter of 2010. And, they are predicting substantial step increases of between 25 "“ 50 base points (a quarter to a half a percent) across a number of months. This could see the base rate move markedly up from its current level of 2.5 percent to somewhere around five percent," he said.

"For mortgages, that could see a floating rate somewhere around seven to eight percent "“ which in the lower and middle price brackets of the residential property market, will cap the limits some home buyers will now have available to them to purchase a home, effectively taking them out of the market for certain properties at the top of their price range.

"While higher mortgage rates do not necessarily stop people buying homes, it limits their choice - based on their ability to service loan repayments."

17 Comments

Yes the boom is over,

Yes the boom is over, we all know that. But a bust is still likely, Mr.Bayley.

<blockquote> the residential property market

the residential property market will undergo a small "if somewhat unspectacular" recovery over 2010.

When this is the most positive spin the real estate industry can come up with, things are not looking good.

Mike Bayley is starting to sound a little desperate.

In principle property can be

In principle property can be a great investment and immigration rates, employment and interest rates are all relevant factors.

The problem with Mike Bayley's analysis as I see it is that he assumes that property is always fairly priced and that changes in immigration, employment and interest rates will determine the movement.

Sometimes property can just be over-valued or under-valued as an entire class. Here's an article from yesterday's irish independent which states that Irish property prices are down 31.5% from early 2007 peak (or Euro, 100,000).

It wasn't reduction in immigration or reduced employment or interest rates (central bank's have been cutting these fast) which crashed the market in Ireland (or California et al). It was just generally un-affordable and in a speculative bubble. Over-valued as a class.

http://www.herald.ie/national-news/house-prices-fall-euro100k-2025110.html

"Mike Bayley said the supply

"Mike Bayley said the supply and demand for residential property is dictated by three primary drivers:

"¢ Immigration
"¢ Employment "“ and by association, unemployment
"¢ Interest rates"

I think he meant demand was affected by these factors not supply. Interesting all property people never list the following factors affecting demand - arguably more important:

* expectations of future price increases
* affordability - maybe interest rates is a part of this.
* money supply (AKA easy credit from banks)

Where is 'President of Property'

Where is 'President of Property' and his/her "Rabble rabble rabble: I make the most money thanks to my well thought out portfolio and the high immigration rate"? Possibly one of the 300 being investigation by IRD for tax evasion?

Someone surely has to add some spin for a laugh! Give themselves some comfort now faced with marginal capital gains at best, yeah?

More BS from Bayley.

More BS from Bayley.

Luke, <blockquote> Where is ‘President

Luke,

Where is "˜President of Property' and his/her "Rabble rabble rabble: I make the most money thanks to my well thought out portfolio and the high immigration rate"?

They are too busy trying to rapidly exit their 'well thought out portfolios'.

As Wally says usual BS

As Wally says usual BS

I see a small dip

I see a small dip in the next couple of months as landlords/investors dump some of their properties due to tax changes and then a slow climb back to the level now by Spring.

I bet this is what

I bet this is what he chants to imself in the mirror!!!!!!!

Maybe I'm a property-novice ,

Maybe I'm a property-novice , but I thought the Bayley fellow made a realistic and measured argument . Tony Alexander has voiced similar sentiments , in favour of modest price increases .

Clearly we aren't gonna see a rip roaring bull market . So the other option available is the serious bear market , a'la Bernie's 30 % fall . And what scenario will trigger that , and make the Bayley & Alexander ( hmmmmm , B & A , sounds like a lemonade ) prognostications wildy inaccurate ?

nz unemployment benefit claimants up

nz unemployment benefit claimants up 13% in december-- to 66000
http://bigpondnews.com/articles/Business/2010/01/22/NZ_unemployment_bene...

What does Mike Bayley and

What does Mike Bayley and Paula Bennett base their thesis of an "economic recovery" on? Hope and conjecture? It seems so. What's coming over the next couple of years for NZ and Aus will absolutely hammer the economy as the great asset bubble bursts. Get ready folks!

Remember... the US sub-prime mortgage meltdown was a direct result of TOO MUCH DEBT and the recession is the medicine, NOT the disease.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/3252178/IRD-to-target-prop

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/3252178/IRD-to-target-property-rorts

Inland Revenue is zeroing in on 300 property investors believed to have dodged millions in taxes, including one who could be hit for not disclosing $8 million of profits.

The investors are the top end of a group of 2000 identified as failing to pay $214m in tax on properties they bought and sold in the past four years. Inland Revenue assurance group manager Martin Scott said the 300 cases under the microscope involved investors who turned over 20 or more properties each during that period.

"We are looking at a number of potential prosecutions, including a case where nearly 60 properties were sold, and income and profit of about $8m was not disclosed."

He did not say how much of the $214m in unpaid tax the 300 could be liable for, but the revenue owing on $8m could be as high as $3m, depending on the investor's tax status. New Zealand does not have a capital gains tax for family homes, but tax must be paid by people in the business of buying other property to sell for profit. Frequent purchases and sales over a short period is a key indicator of a profit motive.

The other 1700 investors under investigation bought and sold at least six properties each during the past four years.

Clearly Mr Bayley, the "Big

Clearly Mr Bayley, the "Big 4" banks, property investors et al love this "spin" .... yes keep on spewing forth the BS to justify your existence Mr Bayley, I have heard it for centuries, even worked in your domain with others in the same ilk as you.... a very distasteful experience indeed.

You and I know there has never been these conditions in NZ's or the world economy before and yet the same old dribble is regurgitated by you and others, as you all have a vested self interest in this arena.

Please stop trying to insult our intelligence and expect us to believe anything that is written by you and your cohorts. I have developed very "selective reading" skills over the years when it comes to property and any article on property, as the first thing I do is look at the writer THEN decide whether it is worth reading or not.

RT - Alexander has endorsed

RT - Alexander has endorsed Infometric's earlier prediction of 25% increases over the next couple of years - to me that more than a slight increase, and its simply not going to happen
pwilkie - yes, unemployment is far from done here, despite the best efforts of those with vested interests claiming it is

Doesn't seem like anyone who

Doesn't seem like anyone who posts here has lost their jobs....

Post new comment

The information entered here will appear with your comment.