In this section
Offers for readers
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 9750
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 79
- ››
The news stream
Latest news
Most commented
- 'Housing showing few signs of life' 251
- 'Dear Allan: Say sorry and thanks' 168
- 90 seconds at 9 am with BNZ 83
- 'A fish stinks from the head' 69
- Barfoots says sales stalled in August 48
- Thursday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 46
- 'Will we regret getting what we wished for?' 46
- Racism claimed in foreign ownership debate 42
- Should the RBNZ hold the Official Cash Rate at 3% until December 9 as many economists and the markets are now forecating? 17
- Alloway to step down as Allied CEO 16
Most viewed
Interest on Twitter
Top 10 at 10: MPs self-interested on property taxes; 2010 year of fiscal fallout; Japan downgrade looms; Dilbert
Here are my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 10am. I welcome your additions and comments below or please send suggestions for Thursday's Top 10 at 10 to bernard.hickey@interest.co.nz
1. Self interested? - Fran O'Sullivan points out in her NZHerald column that National MPs are prime targets for any changes in taxes aimed at property investors. Will the government be able to look past self-interest for the good of the nation?. Alex Tarrant reported in August 2008 that over half of MPs had interests in trusts.
A flick through Parliament's annual register of MPs' pecuniary interests reveals many parliamentarians could lose out if the Government moved to plug the tax loopholes that sprang up after its predecessor whacked the top personal tax rate up to 39c. More than two-thirds of the National line-up have beneficial interests in trusts (entities that the Inland Revenue believes are responsible for a $300 million hole in tax revenues at the current 33 per cent tax rate).
2. Shocking numbers - Barack Obama is set to announce a 3 year spending freeze in his state of the union address later tonight, but it turns out it only covers 12% of the budget. However, have a look at this apparently dry set of tables released overnight showing the US budget situation and forecasts. They are truly shocking. The budget deficit in 2009 was 12.3% of GDP. Net debt to GDP will rise from 37% in 2008 to 61% in 2019, assuming of course that GDP grows through period. Read it and weep and then wonder why America still has a AAA rating.
3. Chart of the century - This chart from Jim Reid at Deutsche Bank (!) explains so much about the global economy, the meltdown and what's happening now in both the economy and in politics. It shows how the profit share of the US economy taken by banks exploded after the repeal of Glass Steagall in 1999, slumped in 2008 and is now rocketing again. How much proof do Obama and American politicians need before they reign in the 'Too Big to Fail' banks and strip them of their morally hazardous government guarantees. I also wonder what the same chart would look like for Australasia. Some work for us to do. FTAlphaville has the comments from Reid on what this all means. Compulsory reading for all bankers, regulators and customers.
The Global economy would be better served by slowly bringing down the size of financials and weaning the global economy off its reliance on the sector slowly over time. However that would allow the sector to still be making larger than trend profits for many years to come which as Politicians are finding is very difficult to sell to an electorate baying for blood.
4. China tightening - A lot of markets around Asia and Australia in particular are watching what is happening inside China's banking system very closely this week. The WSJ reports that both Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and CITIC have told their branches in Beijing and Shanghai respectively to stop lending for the rest of January. I also wonder how this might affect demand for property in some parts of Auckland from mainland Chinese.
Chinese banks, which traditionally rush out loans at the start of the year, have already issued more than 1 trillion yuan ($146 billion) in new loans in the first two weeks of the year, more than double the monthly average of 400 billion yuan in the second half of last year, according to Chinese media reports, which could not be independently verified. "In responding to such a credit surge, the People's Bank of China has launched more aggressive quantitative tightening than we previously have thought," said Credit Suisse economist Dong Tao. Mr. Tao said six Chinese banks he contacted had confirmed they had suspended "new lending" across the country starting Jan. 19.
5. Smart printing ? - There's a rumble of a proposal coming from deep within the Obama administration to 'encourage' workers with retirement plans to buy 'guaranteed income streams' (annuities) with their regular 401K and other tax preferred savings schemes. This seems sensible on the face of it, but actually means that private pension funds would have to buy US Treasury bonds, which are often the investments backing their annuities. Hey presto. The US government would have found a buyer for all this debt it's printing. Here's the Bloomberg piece from January 9 foreshadowing this move.
There is "a tremendous amount of interest in the White House" in retirement-security initiatives, Borzi, who heads the Labor Department's Employee Benefits Security Administration, said in an interview. In addition to annuities, the inquiry will cover other approaches to guaranteeing income, including longevity insurance that would provide an income stream for retirees living beyond a certain age, she said. "There's been a fair amount of discussion in the literature taking the view that perhaps there ought to be more lifetime income," Iwry, a senior adviser to Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, said in an interview. "The question is how to encourage it, and whether the government can and should be helpful in that regard," Iwry said.
Needless to say, there's a few on the fiscally sceptical right who are unhappy about being forced to help fund profligate government spending and money printing. Cue outrage. Here's Jerome Corsi at WorldNetDaily: HT Troy via email.
The Obama administration appears to have come up with a novel way of financing trillion-dollar budget deficits "“ demanding IRA and 401(k) holders buy trillions of dollars in Treasury bonds. With the Treasury needing this year to see another $1 trillion in debt to finance the anticipated federal budget deficit, and the Federal Reserve about to discontinue its 2009 program of buying Treasury bonds for the Fed's asset portfolio, the Obama administration is scrambling to find ways to sell government debt without having to raise interest rates.
6. Inflation coming? - The IMF has raised its forecasts for global growth by 0.75% to 3.9% in 2010 and 4.3% in 2011. The full table is below. It doesn't see inflation being a problem. No worries then...
But the recovery is proceeding at different speeds around the world, with emerging markets, led by Asia relatively vigorous, but advanced economies remaining sluggish and still dependent on government stimulus measures, the IMF said in an update to its World Economic Outlook, published on January 26. "For the moment, the recovery is very much based on policy decisions and policy actions. The question is when does private demand come and take over. Right now it's ok, but a year down the line, it will be a big question," said IMF Chief Economist Olivier Blanchard in an IMF video interview. IMF Managing Director Dominique Strauss-Kahn has warned that countries risk a return to recession if anti-crisis measures are withdrawn too soon.
7. Big borrowing - Fitch is reporting that European governments will need to borrow 2,200 billion euros (17% 19% of GDP) from the capital markets in 2010 to roll over existing debt and raise new debt. Who will lend them all this money. Not the Japanese. The Chinese? They're too busy propping up the US dollar. Interest rates could spike, which will force these governments to cut back spending and raise taxes. Deflation and a double-dip recession beckon, I reckon.
This figure represents a marginal increase on 2009, which Fitch estimates to have been close to EUR2,120bn (17% of GDP) - itself the largest borrowing requirement seen in decades. Of the countries (EU15 plus Switzerland) covered in today's new report, gross borrowing (including maturing and short-term debt) in absolute terms is projected to be largest in France (EUR454bn) (AAA/Stable Outlook), Italy (EUR393bn) (AA-/Stable Outlook), Germany (EUR386bn) (AAA/Stable Outlook) and the UK (EUR279bn) (AAA/Stable Outlook). As a percentage of GDP, gross borrowing is expected to be largest in Italy, Belgium (AA+/Stable Outlook), France and Ireland (AA-/Stable Outlook) - all at around 25%. Fitch notes that several European governments sharply increased their stock of short-term debt in 2009, resulting in an aggregate 20% year on year increase, compared to 2008. France and Germany each covered over half of their net borrowing last year through increased treasury-bill issuance whilst for Spain (AAA/Stable Outlook) and Portugal (AA/Negative Outlook), the share was close to a third. Douglas Renwick, Author of the report and Associate Director in Fitch's Sovereign group said, "The increase in the stock of short-term debt is a source of concern to Fitch as it increases market risk faced by governments, notably exposure to interest rate shocks." Last year, financing conditions were favourable for most European governments, with low yields and increased demand from the private sector. However, 2010 is likely to be characterised by greater volatility in European government bond markets as the 'liquidity premium' enjoyed by sovereign issuers diminishes - driven by returning liquidity in other markets and a recovery in investor risk appetite, combined with market concerns over the medium-term fiscal and inflation outlook. Consequently, Fitch believes government bond yields are likely to rise, potentially quite sharply. However, it also believes it is unlikely that large, highly rated sovereigns will face hard constraints in accessing market funding on the scale required, albeit at more expensive rates.
8. Year of the Sovereign Downgrade - Standard and Poor's warned Japan overnight it may cut its AA sovereign credit rating because the government there was reducing its debt too slowly, the NYTimes reported. Japan is a real worry. If interest rates there spike it could create all sorts of havoc. It is still the world's 2nd largest economy (just) and one of our top 5 buyers of exports.
"The outlook change reflects our view that the Japanese government's diminishing economic policy flexibility may lead to a downgrade unless measures can be taken to stem fiscal and deflationary pressures," S.&P. said. "The policies of the new Democratic Party of Japan government point to a slower pace of fiscal consolidation than we had previously expected." The AA rating puts Japan in the same category as Slovenia, Chile and Ireland. "The ratings on Japan could fall by one notch if economic data remain weak and measures to boost medium-term growth are not forthcoming" given Japan's already high government debt burden and aging population, the agency said.
9. Recession over - Britain's economy crawled out of recession in the December quarter, registering 0.1% growth, although many worry it will dip back in later this year before an election in May, FT reports.
In an inflammatory note to investors, Bill Gross, managing director of Pimco, one of the world's biggest bond funds, warned about the fragility of the UK government debt market. "The UK is a must avoid. Its gilts are resting on a bed of nitroglycerine. High debt with the potential to devalue its currency present high risks for bond investors," he said. He said the UK's mounting public debt, forecast by the Treasury to rise to 77 per cent of gross domestic product by 2013, had prompted investors to sell the pound and UK government bonds. Without swift action to cut debt levels, he said there could be a run on the pound and a collapse in the gilts market.
10. Completely irrelevant funny video - It is actually called funny video and is in German. You're safe to turn down the sound, but the German commentary somehow makes it funnier. I'm not sure why...


38 Comments
OK Bernard : If I
OK Bernard : If I can encapsulate # 2 - # 8 of your TOP 10 @ 10 : We are in a financial version of the Blues Brothers movie : We are hurtling down the highway at midnight , the car has no lights , we are wearing dark tinted sunglasses , are exceeding 100 m.ph. , and Jake ( Obama ) says to Elwood ( Bernanke ) : " More gas ( cash ) man , we're screwed anyway ! "
@Roger You forgot to include
@Roger
You forgot to include the half a pack of cigarettes!
#1 Alex Tarrant reported in
#1 Alex Tarrant reported in August 2008 that over half of MPs had interests in trusts.
Um yes...? How exactly will they "lose-out"? If the main aim was to reduce tax, they would have their assets in a company, not a trust!
#1: Don't forget that most
#1: Don't forget that most MPs also have copious rental units, which they cross-rent to each other to max their rorts. Overall they have their snouts planted firmly in the trough, & are snorting the tax breaks like it is coke.
Philly - So renting from
Philly - So renting from and to a colleague is a rort but paying rent and receiving rent from someone you don't know would be ok? EH???
David I think Philly means
David I think Philly means that if you own a rental in Wellington and your MP mate also owns a rental it does not stink so much (although perfectly legal) if you are a tenant only instead of being a landlord and as well as your own tenant. I think most politicians and public figures who engage in legal rorts like to ignore the word "integrity"
Sean, it's legal when you
Sean, it's legal when you make the rules
Re 2 USA has a
Re 2
USA has a rating of AAA because the rating agencies have a rule that commercial organisations can't have a rating higher than the sovereign rating of the country they are based in.
If they drop the USA rating, they would lose their fees from some very grumpy multinationals.
I know Jeff - hence
I know Jeff - hence it's a no brainer why 98.5% don't vote for ACT - even the Greens who like cushy nests get 5%
Yes the Register of Pecuniary
Yes the Register of Pecuniary Interests is very interesting...
http://www.parliament.nz/NR/rdonlyres/A4EB8291-1635-4F18-89C1-C09738171B...
Gerry Brownlee and John Key both own 6 properties. I couldn't see any other MP's with that many but they all seem to be busy little investors.
Still I bet that won't get in the way of them making an unbiased decision about property taxation....John and Gerry are two standup guys.
Sean - agreed... renting from
Sean - agreed... renting from yourself is dodgy!
Someone should take bets on
Someone should take bets on the chances of a land tax being passed.
I think the chances are slim. Too many vested interests amongst National and their supporters.
So what will happen is that the longer term interests of the country are once again skittled in the interests of short term politics.
I hope I am wrong as I think the proposed changes are long overdue (NZ won't keep and attract highly skilled people unless the top tax rate is cut)
Chart of the century -
Chart of the century - one way or another wealth transfers from the real to the derivative economy have to be stopped - zero sum games add little value.
Sean – agreed… renting from
Sean "“ agreed"¦ renting from yourself is dodgy
No, they are renting from each other rather than living in their own flats to maximise ttheir expense claims.
Andy_M Most are.. Bill English
Andy_M
Most are.. Bill English wasn't.
Matt in Auck: Sounds like
Matt in Auck: Sounds like a job for https://www.ipredict.co.nz/
@sam_m https://www.ipredict.co.nz/ "wealth transfers from
@sam_m
https://www.ipredict.co.nz/
"wealth transfers from the real to the derivative economy have to be stopped "“ zero sum games add little value."
I would have thought that
I would have thought that because so many MPs own investment properties, and are benefiting from the current tax laws, that they should be voided from any decision making. They would have a conflict of interest, so it is no different from someone owning shares in a company, and then making a decsion that could affect that company in a positive or negative way.
Rob, they all pay tax,
Rob, they all pay tax, so I guess there will be no decision about that either!
"Interest rates could spike, which
"Interest rates could spike, which will force these governments to cut back spending and raise taxes. Deflation and a double-dip recession beckon, I reckon."
Me too every day it looks more certain to me (spending, rising taxes, deflation, double dip recession, depression more like)...um Interest rates could spike, not residential though? "spike" as in not sustained?.... its kind of hard to imagine high interest rates AND deflation though in NZ anyway...I mean that's potentially horrendous real interest rates, great for retirees or anyone with cash / lump sums in the bank though.....ikky to debtors...ie most ppl with decent sized mortgages...(80~90%+) could fail....such a huge impact while tottering along a knife edge.
I think Steve kKeen said it right though, just like the Great Depression I think it will take 2 or 3 years of this disgust at the banksters and hardship for political change to come about.....right now the pork barrel policies and lobbyists are too strong to see change happen. until the Pollies see its fix it or the highway it wont happen.
Interesting times.
Just about every country in
Just about every country in the world has a CGT on sale of second home. It's too hard here tho. What's hard about tax, they tax every thing else!!!!
It's not just the tax
It's not just the tax it's the compliance. Accountants and lawyers will make a killing. Stamp duty could easily add $120M per year to the governments purse.
Thank you for your wonderful
Thank you for your wonderful article, I spent the lunch break.
Does the public really expect
Does the public really expect a promised swing by foxes (politicians) towards real productivity, while happily owning hen- houses "“ I say dream on. The political system is rotten to the core.
Gerald Celente on Russia today....
Gerald Celente on Russia today.... you gotta love this guy...>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8PMSZ2b7Crk
Re 7 If another recession
Re 7
If another recession is on the way in Europe, where will everyone dive into? European government bonds of course! Problem solved.
MP's with investment properties have
MP's with investment properties have always been a major barrier to any reform on land zoning and supply side issues too. Hugh Pavletich could tell us a lot about this. Labour was at least as bad as the current lot.
It strikes me as inconsistent that MP's have to divulge ownership of shares and get rid of the same, because there are conflicts of interest when it comes to making laws; but the whole country can be stuffed because of unaffordable housing and property bubbles and vested interests obstructing reform remain unscrutinised and uncondemned.
If there was a capital
If there was a capital gains tax, would not exempting one's own house create all sorts of distortions? eg instead of buying second property, some would just put more and more developing/upgrading etc into the initial property,and how would that be 'productive"?
And if there isn't a capital gains tax but a RFRM tax, this would encourage people not to freehold a rental property,hardly encouraging for lowering the debt levels of the country.
well one thing is for
well one thing is for certain. Debt in this current environment is best avoided at all costs, whether personal, business or government. Borrowing 200+million a week sure seems like suicide
Yep - these MP's have
Yep - these MP's have their snouts heavily buried into the property trough. No chance of property related taxes from this mob and those expecting to see them in the May budget will be disappointed. Probably won't even see a reduction in the top end personal tax rate.
@W. Kunz: This info is
@W. Kunz: This info is in the public domain now....but I think things have to get worse yet before MPs stop looking after themselves and their "key voting blocks" and look after NZ as a whole....maybe a year after this next dip....2011 maybe. In the USa I think its going to get there sooner, 17%+ unemployment and growing isnt going to be tolerated for two years I think....maybe that will rub off onto NZ Pollies, they see the writing on the wall....maybe not.
@Justice: the alternative is worse....at least the borrowing isnt horrendious.
regards
@ steven You are right.
@ steven
You are right. Not only politicians/ government, but also the private sector needs to change "“ our economy is in an emergency situation. The philosophy I'm advocating here since joining needs consideration.
muzza - Firsty - it's
muzza - Firsty - it's the compliance cost that would be the issue with applying CGT or any tax to owner occupied homes. Most people who own their own home and only derive income from PAYE sources don't need to file tax returns.
Secondly - any money spent upgrading owner occupied homes would be deductible from the sales price as they are capital in nature thus reducing any capital gain. Thus the incentive to spend money on their own homes is still there.
Labour leader Phil Goff has
Labour leader Phil Goff has called for a cap on public service chief executive wages so they do not get paid more than the prime minister.
Well, well, - the wheels are spinning out of control.
Does the public really expect a promised swing by foxes (politicians) towards real productivity, while happily owning hen- houses "“ I say dream on. The political system is rotten to the core.
Walter
OPPS + 4.8% huuuu !
OPPS + 4.8% huuuu !
23/1/2009
The annual MPs' pay increase, decided by the Remuneration Authority in November, resulted in Prime Minister John Key's salary jumping from $375,000 to $393,000, a rise of 4.8 per cent.
Walter
Walter : Phil Goff must
Walter : Phil Goff must have a memory shorter than that of a goldfish , as public servants numbers and their salaries ballooned as they had never dunne before , under his 9 years in gumnut . The guy is a fool . Pandering to the " envy " segment of socialism . Labour have learnt nothing , after their abject failure of 1999-2008 . Fools , idiots , & arrogant incompetents then ........... Nothing changed now . Twits !
Try local government , Phil . Councils . Where fat cats are earning over the top salaries , for doing bugger all . ..........Oooooops , can't attack them . Local government is a hot-bed of socialism , your commie supporter base .
Roger Thompson, hear, hear. It's
Roger Thompson, hear, hear.
It's time people woke up to the fact that Labour and most "leftwing" parties around the world no longer represent the "battler"; they represent special interests with their snouts in the trough. Like the bureaucrats you mention in government and councils, and like teachers unions, who are now the main obstacle to anyone who can't afford a private school, getting a good start to their life.
Even Franklin D Roosevelt (who did a lot that I disagree with) was opposed to union representation for public employees, because of the cancerous triangles of political power, support, and funding that would result.
Thanks for A Good Article!!
Thanks for A Good Article!! I have heard Credit Report For Free is a excellent place to check my credit and get my score 4 nothing. Anyone else tried it?
Post new comment