Trade Me makes concession to real estate agents on listing fees; moves back to bulk per-office fees for some from per listing fee

Trade Me Head of Property Nigel Jeffries in a video explaining the concessions to real estate agents after their 6 month revolt.

By Bernard Hickey

After months of battling each other over a controversial new per-listing fee structure, Trade Me has made concessions to real estate agency offices to allow them to pay per office again.

Trade Me announced the main changes in a statement to the NZX and detailed the shift in approach in this section of its website for agents, which included a video and a letter from Head of Trade Me Property Nigel Jeffries acknowledging "we could have done it better -- we want to start putting things right."

Smaller agents' offices in the Waikato and Hawkes Bay started revolting in early January over what they said amounted to a quadrupling or quintupling of their listing fees when Trade Me moved to a per-listing fee of NZ$159 from a flat and capped per agency fee. Here's my February 4 article documenting the revolt and a later article detailing the reaction from property vendors and industry commentators to the real estate agents' revolt.

Agents are thought to have directed thousands of listings away from Trade Me to the industry-owned Realestate.co.nz in the wake of the fee restructure announced late last year.

Jeffries said in the letter to agents he had started his job in April and had been "doing plenty of listening over the past few months" in meetings with agents around New Zealand.

"My take on what I’ve heard is that we could have done a better job of informing you directly before we rolled out the changes. We should also have provided business owners with a more flexible range of options, rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. Today’s the first step to putting things right," he said.

Trade Me said it would still offer the NZ$159 per listing fee for houses worth more than NZ$450,000, but would also resume offering a range of per-office flat fees. The per-listing fee for houses under NZ$450,000 has been cut to NZ$99.

The per-office fee for offices in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch would be NZ$1,399 per month, with discounts of up to 20% for between 19 and 100 listings, and even bigger unspecified discounts for offices with more than 100 listings.

The per office fee for offices in non-Metropolitan areas would be NZ$999 per month, with similar discounts for offices with more than 19 listings. Both 'all you can eat' 'The Sub' options included early bird discounts for offices that signed up before the end of August.

The full new rate card brochure is here.

"We know we have work to do to win back the full support of agents and business owners in some parts of the country, and we’ll be working hard to do that," Jeffries said.

"We know we help you sell houses – and if we’re making it too hard or expensive to use Trade Me Property, we’re doing it wrong!" he said.

Trade Me shares hit two year low

Jeffries said in the statement to the NZX that affordability varied between regions, vendors and offices.

“We acknowledge that the pay-per-listing model we rolled out last year works well for some business owners, but it does not work for everybody," he said.

"We have to provide better marketing options to business owners and agents selling residential properties, so they can do the best job for their vendors. We also need to offer options that better cater for the state of the market in the various areas.”

He cited Nielsen data for unique browsers over the last four weeks showing an average of more than 114,000 domestic visitors to Trade Me Property each day, which he said was triple that of Realestate.co.nz.

Trade Me shares closed down nine cents or 2.6% at a two-year low of NZ$3.43 and have underperformed the NZX 50 by more than 25% over the last year. Trade Me shares have fallen 16% since January, while the NZX 50 has risen 7%.

Commentators react

Former Realestate.co.nz CEO Alistair Helm said on his Properazzi blog the new pricing structure looked a significant win for the real estate industry "as it re-establishes the subscription model, whilst at the same time offering a scaled per-listing fee and a regionalisation of pricing."

Helm said the industry had mobilised itself to combat Trade Me's move, ranging from boycotts to advising clients not to use Trade Me, and had circled the wagons around its own realestate.co.nz website.

"There has been a clear demonstration that the impact on Trade Me’s business was being felt in both customer loyalty, as demonstrated by listing numbers, and in investor confidence, as evidenced by the share price," Helm said.

"It is my belief that this new pricing scheme will in one fell swoop patch up the issues that Trade Me Property has faced, resulting in a solid re-population of the site to full strength and full loyalty (and if not loyalty then at least patronage)," he said.

"It will not deliver the much hoped for absolute gain to the bottom line that the original pricing model of a pure per-listing fee would have delivered, but it will get the company back on track to build its business for the future."

Grant Wakelin at online real estate agency 200 Square described the move as a capitulation.

"Trade Me acknowledged they screwed up and offered a revised subscription package to agencies," Wakelin said.

"Trade Me obviously underestimated the power of real estate agencies, both individually and collectively when there is a common enemy. This hurt Trade Me financially, listing volumes have fallen over the months. They had to do something," Wakelin said.

"It really looks like www.realestate.co.nz missed a once in a lifetime opportunity to nail Trade Me Property through being passive and traditional in its thinking.  They had their foot on the throat but let it rest there when pressure would have choked their rival," he added.

(Updated with picture of Nigel Jeffries, reaction from Alistair Helm and Grant Wakelin)

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment or click on the "Register" link below a comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current Comment policy is here.

9 Comments

FYI updated with reaction from Alistair Helm and Grant Wakelin.
cheers
Bernard

Raises an interesting question
 
If an outfit like Trademe.co.nz can manage regional pricing why can't the RBNZ manage regional OCR settings?

I wouldnt mind seeing some concessions on TMs other fees as well, or at lease some regulation due to their near monolpoly in NZ. Since Sam sold out the fee growth has been gouging..

I never understood why a price of $159 per listing was such a big deal, when agents & agencies earn tens of thousands of dollars in commission per listing.
 
Surely the biggest cost of a real estate agency is the leasing cost of the agent's Audi SUV? 

I hate having to be smug, but all I can say is I told you so... (look at my comments on the article when the new fee scheme was introduced).

Yes you did :-). Now I'm hoping that your prediction for the end of Gerry's terror in Chch come true! Hope some things are going a bit better down there.

We are all smugs, TM is a ripoff merchant.  I got few things left in NZ and sold them via TM, $200 and they charged $17 fee.  Where is ebay and Gumtree when we need it?

Ebay is not your friend. Here is AUS there are no listing fees, just a flat 10% success fee. Those few things worth $200 would cost $20 to sell on ebay, and if buyer pays via paypal (as every ebay seller must accept) there is another 2.4%+$0.3 taken each transaction (success fee + postage & handling). So, for example, selling one $200 item with $20 postage will cost a seller $25.58, or 12.8%.
Gumtree is free, but it comes at a cost: time wasters and tyre kickers! I prefer to pay the 12.8%.

Yep, agreed. A major bloody rip off!