By Emma Geraghty
Moves by the Commerce Commission late last year to increase competition on credit card interchange fees and cut retailers’ costs by around NZ$75 million have yet to bear fruit as retailers, banks and credit card companies are stuck in a Mexican stand-off to see who will take the first pain. Consumers, meanwhile, have also yet to see any benefits.
The first moves in this impending battle were made in early January when several independent petrol stations started adding credit card surcharges and some government departments started charging these fees for payments online. These moves followed a slew of announcements from the Commerce Commission in August and October about settlements with banks and credit card companies that removed a ban on these surcharges and removed restrictions on so-called ‘interchange’ fees charged to retailers by banks.
The commission hoped these moves would free up the market, forcing the banks and credit card companies to compete with each other and push down fees and, ultimately, prices for consumers. But this has yet to eventuate.
Instead some retailers and government departments have simply added the fees onto prices to bolster their profits, raising fears consumers will abandon credit cards and use EFTPOS and cash more often, which would cut the NZ$28.5 billion a year spent by New Zealanders using at least 3 million credit cards.
Profit windfall?
If all retailers were to add the current interchange fees of around 2% to all credit card transactions and they didn’t pass that on in the form of lower prices on all goods this would deliver a NZ$570 million profit windfall to retailers and potentially deliver a slight one-off boost to the inflation rate, adding extra pressure on the Reserve Bank to raise interest rates.
(more…)