Breaking news

BNZ cuts all fixed mortgage rates for terms 1 - 7 years; seven year fixed rate now 6.99%
MORE SOON

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Manager Operational Effectiveness and Assurance IT
Reporting to the Senior Manager Operational Risk Effectiveness and Assurance, the key focu...more
New Zealand
Financial Controller
Reporting to the Head of Finance - Retail and Business Bank the key focus of this role is ...more
New Zealand
Manager Finance Corporate Core - 12 Month Contract role
This role in consultation with the Financial Controller provides financial, strategic and ...more
New Zealand
IT Audit Manager - Internal Audit - Auckland
If you are motivated by the prospect of seeing the big picture, developing your team and m...more
New Zealand
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Should you fix your mortgage now or stay floating?

Choices

Banks face NZ$900 mln loss on Yellow Pages debt

Posted in News

A consortium of banks led by BNZ have officially put Yellow Pages Group (YPG) up for sale and now face a loss of around NZ$900 million as the likely sale price of up to NZ$800 million is expected to fall well short of the directories group's debts of at least NZ$1.7 billion.

The senior debt holders include lead banker the BNZ, ANZ, Westpac, Deutsche Bank, Credit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank (formerly Calyon), Barclays, Macquarie Group, Allied Irish Banks and the Royal Bank of Scotland. A sale is likely to see the shareholders, including Canada’s Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan who originally paid NZ$2.24 billion for the directories group at the top of the market in early 2007, wiped out.

An information memorandum, containing detailed financial information, will be available to potential buyers of YPG this week with indicative bids sought by the end of the month. Meanwhile, a standstill agreement on interest payments on YPG's debt mountain - the company had interest payments of NZ$154.3 million in the June 2009 year - has been extended until the end of July.

YPG issued a brief statement on Friday afternoon, via public relations company Porter Novelli, saying that in conjunction with its banking syndicate it had started a review process to assess the future ownership options for the business. Goldman Sachs JBWere had been appointed to assist with the process.

While this in itself isn't new, with the potential sale of YPG reported by interest.co.nz in April and Goldman's appointment in May, interest.co.nz was told Friday's announcement effectively signifies an authorisation agreement with the banks, who were owed NZ$1.7 billion as of June 30, last year, meaning they definitely want to sell. That means other potential solutions to YPG's capital structure problems such as a debt restructure or equity injection from existing shareholders are off the table, at least for now.

The primary task for Goldman is likely to be to get back as much of the senior debt as possible given Yellow Pages is expected to be worth significantly less than the NZ$1.275 billion owed to senior debt holders, which includes capital expenditure facilities, in today’s market.

One estimate put to interest.co.nz was that Goldman might expect to attract interest in the NZ$600 million to NZ$800 million range. That could mean a sale for as little as four to six times annual earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (ebitda) compared to the 14 times ebitda paid for YPG just three years ago. That leaves subordinated debt holders, who hold the balance of YPG's debt, about NZ$540 million at June 30 last year, facing complete loss as do its shareholders.

Some of the banks are understood to have already made provisions for a loss.

Bought from Telecom through a leveraged buyout by Hong Kong-based Unitas Capital, formerly CCMP Capital Asia, and Canada’s Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan for NZ$2.24 billion in March 2007. Of that purchase price, NZ$1.5 billion was funded through borrowings from about 36 lenders. Some of the original lenders have since sold out, including the Accident Compensation Corporation.

As of June 30, 2009 YPG had debt equivalent to more than 10 times its annual ebitda on its balance sheet.

Under its existing owners YPG needed to keep lifting its earnings, which have been declining as have those of other major companies dependent on advertising revenue, to avoid breaching its banking convents. The business last year produced ebitda of NZ$162.7 million. For the latest financial year ebitda is said to have fallen to between NZ$130 million and NZ$140 million.

A prospectus for Yellow Pages’ ultimately canceled NZ$300 million 2007 retail bond offer noted: “A breach of the financial covenants is a senior event of default and the senior participants may, at any time while the breach occurs, cancel any advance or the senior facilities in full or demand payment of the outstanding principal and all other secured money owing to the senior finance parties.”

That means the senior debt holders are effectively in the driver's seat. Goldman, which advised Telecom on its 2007 blockbuster sale of the business, was rehired to once again seek a buyer.

International private equity funds, perhaps including distressed asset buyers such as Cerberus Capital Management and CVC Capital Partners, and other directories business owners are seen as potential bidders.

* This article was first published in our email for paid subscribers earlier today. See here for more details and to subscribe.

 

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

30 Comments

But what price would you put

But what price would you put on a business solely reliant on advertising revenues as we stand on the cusp of the second leg down in the global decession? Lets remind ourselves - how do advertising revenues do during a substantial and prolonged economic decline?
Bargepole. Touch. Wouldn't.

What's that andy, Torchlight?

What's that andy, Torchlight? Oh, sorry, touch....

Oh dear, no wonder the BNZ is

Oh dear, no wonder the BNZ is tetchy.

Who was valuing these media/advertising assets (trademe, bebo, yellow)? Got a valuation done Bernard?

Those Ontario teachers would have been better investing in Vancouver crack-shacks!

Telecom must be laughing

Telecom must be laughing their heads off! Nice to see the banks are suckers too

It was a dumb amount to pay

It was a dumb amount to pay for the Yellow Pages in the first place. I rarely use them - Google is usually the way to go.

yellow pages,Crafar

yellow pages,Crafar farms.Seems to be a common thread. The banks and inept lending. Actually stupidity.Who could take any of them seriously. Next time you see the likes of B ODonovan, Tony Alexander or the other guy just think those are the guys that thought lending millions on the yellow pages was a good thing.Bright lads arent they

Good call RJ, the banks are

Good call RJ, the banks are (were) fully living in never never land. Just heard of a house in Russell with a mortgage (and presumably a supporting valuation) of $600,000 sold for $265k. Perhaps Bernard's "mate" Alan Wilkinson can confirm. LOL

Apart from an obvious question mark over the valuer, WTF were the banks thinking?
And we've only had a 5% correction from the peak?
I'm still waiting for Tony Alexander to explain how double digit credit/debt growth is anything but a disaster in the making.
I don't think he's got a clue.

So what did they borrow $1.7B

So what did they borrow $1.7B for ?

Ask the banks, they must have

Ask the banks, they must have told them something before they walked away with the dosh

Easy money at 0% interest

Easy money at 0% interest rate can make you take stupid risks. It was common knowledge that yellowpages was going to be replaced by online directories.

It is a very attractive asset

It is a very attractive asset at sub 1 billion dollars. What individuals need to understand is the separation between the holder of the debt (YPG Finance) and the entity the operates the asset (Yellow Pages Group). YPG finance has been like the proverbial "lead zeppelin", it was NEVER going to be able to service the "debt bemoth" thrust on it 2 years back. The Yellow Pages asset as an operating entity however is probably the best of its kind in the world and trades VERY profitably & used from Kaitaia to Bluff. Anything below 800 million would be an absolute steal, and might make the purchaser a significant capital gain if they were to restructure, float sell off again a year or two later or just amp up the ebitda through placing a sound modus operandi and management throughout the organisation. The assets troubles have been well reported but are fixable.

Who needs YP when we have the

Who needs YP when we have the incredible online www.zenbu.co.nz - try it, you will be impressed.

Wow, the average punter knew

Wow, the average punter knew this was going to happen..it seemed such a massive price for a sunset business...what next, an LBO of Telecom's copper network???

Printed directories are

Printed directories are history - yellow will need to move fully online. Who actually uses those books other than as doorstops?

YP scumbags bought SuperPages

YP scumbags bought SuperPages in Canada a few years ago, increasing their stake in the Canadian directory market to around 80%. Nothing heard from the Canadian competition bureau. They just bought 411.ca and Canpages, thereby increasing their hold on the directory (print) market to at least 98%. Nothing from the competition bureau in Canada, who, IMO, are probably paid-off shills who look the other way. Now, YP is essentially a bankrupt entity. I only hope Yellow Pages Group goes down the tubes as well, it couldn't happen to a nicer bunch.

I have the recycle bin ready.

I have the recycle bin ready.

RJ, Brendan O'Donovan and

RJ,
Brendan O'Donovan and Tony Alexander are economists. They don't oversee their banks' lending policies.

So what are they there for

So what are they there for Gareth? Window dressing?
I would've thought that part of their job was projecting trends so that the bank's lending was on a sound footing for the future.
Like I said before, Tony Alexander thinks double digit credit/debt growth is good thing. I have asked him to project that forward and explain how it isn't a recipe for complete disaster. Needless to say, I've not had an answer.

I'll say it again all you

I'll say it again all you bright sparks who act with hindsight - superfund will be in a world of trouble in 5-10 years time with its shell assets - sure they pay the bills now but as hybrids become more popular there are going to be less stops at the petrol stations = less opportunity to sell $3 choccy bars. Super fund = ontario teachers fund in terms of stupidity (can't see the future, can only see the past)

Hey Anonymous who says it's a

Hey Anonymous who says it's a very attractive asset at sub $1 billion,

Sure the underlying Yellow Pages business makes money and it has a strong presence across the country, enabling it to tap into local advertisers. But any new owner will have to make huge strides online. Yellow Pages hasn't done well there and that's the future.

And globally this is an industry that has been under the pump. Witness US directories groups Idearc and R.H. Donnelley both re-emerging from Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection this year with new names – SuperMedia Inc and Dex One Corporation respectively – having cut their combined debt by about US$12.25 billion.

Then there's Britain’s Yell, which restructured its balance sheet late last year via a £660 million share issue.
And Telstra’s Sensis goes to court next month to appeal an Australian Federal Court judgment which said there is no copyright in Sensis' White Pages or Yellow Pages.

Sure, there are good margins there for now, but medium to long-term it looks a hard row to hoe with Google around.

Hats off to Goldman if they can get $700m or $800m this time around...

Yes, agree with Gareth

Yes, agree with Gareth Vaughan wholeheartily,YP is dying, the internet is the way to go,for this sort of advertising,YP was far too costly for small/med business.If Goldman can get $700 or $800 million they should sign the suckers up before the sunsets tonite.

Some of you guys are dreaming

Some of you guys are dreaming (or wishful thinking?), your negativity is fueled by your Yellow bias seemingly. The Yellow entity has a commanding presence in New Zealand and will always do so. The aforesaid's EBITDA is likely around the range of $150 million most people expect, I not sure where the punitive inside predictions come from, I can't find any public domain data on that. Not withstanding that, if it were around $135 million that represents a massive current profit in a recovering economy by one of New Zealands superior & favoured media advertising companies. Yellow's earnings may be slightly down, so what, other media companies have been truly "hammered". Take TVNZ's profit, it is really "down the gurgler". It was just a few months back that we read in the NZ Herald: "...TVNZ's after-tax profit for the six months to December has more than halved, and it is predicting a loss for the full year...its [6 month] earnings before interest and tax were down to $14.2m, compared with $27.7m for the first six months of the previous year..." Oops! Yellow is still NZ's strongest advertising media company recovering strongly in a rising NZ economy.

The Yellow Pages is not ever

The Yellow Pages is not ever worth anything as toilet paper or for starting a fire.

The online version is barely functional, ever since they merged everything.

If they cleaned the site up into something useful, say which fulfills its primary function, then it could be worth a few $m to a big company looking for some goodwill by offering a free online telephone directory service.

But for anything else? Zilch.

Mr Zilch, the Yellow online

Mr Zilch, the Yellow online site works well for users and is said to be growing at a very fast rate. Print operations have been said to have held up to around 90% of revenue, but with rapid Yellow online grwoth most would expect this to change. Can you think of ANY advertising media company in New Zealand with a EBITDA as impressive as Yellow Pages? I will wait with interest for your reply as to who this is & how much it is.

Having contracted there

Having contracted there briefly at online side, in my opinion the problem is that they still have that govt dept mentality (having once been). It aint compatible in todays commercial environment, let alone also being in sunset industry and/or carrying debt but they seem not to be interested to address it. Good luck to any new owners (price irrelevant) while those middle managers are still employed there.

Is it true that YP have just

Is it true that YP have just employed 100 new staff? They can't be doing too bad if they can accomodate that sort of expenditure. Or is this the last throw of the dice at the craps table?

Yes, true that new staff have

Yes, true that new staff have been inducted. This is mainly because the commissions there were recently reduced, so quite a few of the more capable salespeople (who actually hit the mark to earn comms) were forced to graze elsewhere. Others, well, perhaps just didn't like being involved with such losing proposition and/or were let go. It's gotta be tough to start fresh again with all this hanging over them.

Those "100 new staff" so

Those "100 new staff" so proudly released to the media would be allegedly just to "replace some" of those who are and have been walking through the out door for the last year or so. Some have suggested the horrendous turnover of staff may be over 100% pa in some areas of the business.

Go Yellow

Go Yellow

Re: Go Yellow. Go where?

Re: Go Yellow.

Go where?