In this section
Offers for readers
Follow the news from interest
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 20830
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 295
- ››
Finance sector jobs
Lead from the front utilising your strategic, technical and leadership qualities within th...more
New Zealand
Lead from the front utilising your technical expertise in this highly attractive senior li...more
New Zealand
Customer focus, high performance, exceeding client expectations and achieving profitable g...more
New Zealand
Key leadership position in the bank. Be a part of one of the fastest growing banks in New ...more
New Zealand

The news stream
Latest news
Most commented
- Govt eyes NZ$1.4b revenue grab 63
- English defends current account blowout 61
- 90 seconds at 9 am 51
- Budget 2012 reactions 45
- Friday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 39
- Thursday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 38
- What covered bonds mean for ma and pa 32
- 'Next 5-10 years make or break for NZ' 27
- Westpac and ASB change rates down 26
- 90 seconds at 9 am 22
Most viewed
Hubbard drops Helicopter Lines and Scales into South Canterbury to bolster shredded balance sheet
By Bernard Hickey Renowned South Island investor and financier Allan Hubbard has moved to bolster the balance sheet of South Canterbury Finance by injecting his 100% ownership of Helicopters (NZ) and his 64% stake in Scales Corp into South Canterbury in exchange for new South Canterbury shares worth NZ$152.5 million and NZ$10 million in cash. "We've had a shareholder who instead of walking away has said: 'Yes, I'm going to massively support this company'," South Canterbury and Southbury Holdings Chief Executive Sandy Maier told interest.co.nz. "He has increased the equity and his investment in South Canterbury in a very large way," Maier said. The injection of equity came as South Canterbury Finance released its half year results showing a NZ$154.9 million net loss after it booked NZ$229 million of losses on asset realisations and further impairments on loans. The result and the deal announced today also breached two covenants of South Canterbury's Trust Deed, but South Canterbury said its trustee Trustees Executors had granted a waiver from compliance with these covenants. They related to having no greater than 35% of shareholder funds being to a single party (Helicopters) and the level of equity investments being greater than 100% of shareholder funds.
South Canterbury Finance owes more than 40,000 investors over NZ$1.5 billion and its survival depends on its ability to get through this year with an extended government deposit guarantee and a further capital injection that Maier said South Canterbury was still working to obtain with brokers Forsyth Barr. It may also require asset sales. South Canterbury Finance is heavily involved either as an owner or a lender to large swathes of the rural and tourism industries in the South Island. Its failure would shake the South Island economy and hammer the government's finances. South Canterbury's investors are currently covered by the government guarantee and the government has been heavily involved in monitoring South Canterbury's efforts to recapitalise and rebalance itself after heavy losses in property development lending. The government has already made a provision in its December 31 accounts (Note 19, Page 32) for net losses of NZ$776 million from finance companies defaulting under the scheme. Guarantee extension crucial Treasury is now considering South Canterbury's application for inclusion in the extension of the scheme from early October this year until the end of 2011. South Canterbury currently has a BB+ credit rating from Standard and Poor's, which is above the BB threshold set by the government as necessary for inclusion in the scheme, however Standard and Poor's has a negative outlook on the rating and has yet to comment on the latest deal. Maier said the inclusion of Helicopters and Scales added valuable earnings-generating assets into South Canterbury Finance and the price paid by South Canterbury had been judged as fair and at 'arms length' by independent advisors appointed by the government. "The earnings contributions of these two successful companies are now part of South Canterbury Finance, which materially and substantially changes the earnings profile and prospects for the Company," Maier said. In the year ended 30 June 2009, Helicopters (NZ) reported earnings before interest, tax and depreciation (EBITDA) of NZ$30.2 million and net profit after tax (NPAT) of $16.2 million. Scales Corporation reported EBITDA of NZ$35.4 million and NPAT of NZ$13.6 million. The combined results for Helicopters (NZ) and Scales Corporation were EBITDA of NZ$65.6 million and NPAT of NZ$29.8 million. This would imply South Canterbury paid 5.5 times historic profits for the businesses. Profit caution However, South Canterbury warned that profits from Helicopters and Scales may not be so strong in the current year. Helicopters NZ provides services to the mining, agriculture and tourism industries in New Zealand, Australia and Vietnam. Scales runs packing, coldstores and shipping agency operations for apple and other primary exports in New Zealand. "The results for the current financial year will reflect more challenging market conditions and the usual uncertainties regarding currency and export realisations," it said. Maier said the forecast improvement in the Fonterra payout was helping economic activity in the regions where South Canterbury operated. "The rural sector is benefiting from the upturn in the price of milk solids which has in turn had a flow-on effect to businesses in provincial areas where the bulk of South Canterbury Finance's lending customers and assets are located," he said. "The half year result incorporates a total of $229 million of losses on asset realisations and additional allowances for impairment. The underlying trading results show a breakeven result for the six months which is creditable given the significant disruption and costs experienced during this period." NZ$13.6 million in cash Maier said South Canterbury's cash holding were currently "reasonably robust at this point in time. At this point I'm comfortable with it." Maier said there had been a steady inflow of funds in excess of redemptions through January. "The re-investment of funds has also continued at satisfactory levels as qualifying investors continued to seek the benefit of the Company's attractive rates and Crown retail deposit guarantee scheme," he said. South Canterbury had cash on hand of NZ$13.6 million at December 31, down from NZ$322.5 million a year earlier and NZ$123.3 million six months earlier. South Canterbury is currently offering 7% for a guaranteed deposit for 5 months until the end of the deposit guarantee. Asked if South Canterbury could survive without a government guarantee, Maier said: "If comes back to the government guarantee. Today's operation will clearly help," he said. He said the lack of a government decision on the extension of the guarantee was clearly an 'inhibiting' factor for South Canterbury and some other finance companies. He said it was not clear when a decision was due on both the guarantee and Standard and Poor's credit rating, which would no doubt be reviewed after this latest deal. South Canterbury 1st Half Result
24 Comments
Here's David Hillary's view below.
Here's David Hillary's view below.
http://www.lostsoulblog.com/2010/03/south-canterbury-finance-reports-hug...
Purely FYI
"Mr Hubbard has been throwing good money, no, make that good assets, after bad, and now he has run out of significant further assets. Now it is up to investors to decide if they want to throw their good money at South Canterbury Finance. I've predicted in the past investors won't do that. This explains the reluctance and smallness of the recent smoke and mirrors 'capital injection' and makes the company's future in grave doubt. The government guarantee will now be shown for what it always was: keeping institutions of questionable solvency going when they should have been shut down or restructured at creditors and shareholder's expense.
Mr Hubbard has thown everything he has into saving this company, in a possibly futile effort. Perhaps taxpayers should be thanking him for mitigating their loss incurred by Dr Cullen. Whether it is good stewardship of his resources is another question."
cheers
Bernard
Enter - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saalGKY7ifU
Enter -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=saalGKY7ifU
Wow, great reporting there, very
Wow, great reporting there, very detailed.
Equity December 2008 = $256
Equity December 2008 = $256 million
Equity December 2009 = $94 million
In between $80 million of share equity was added => $242 million of other equity was lost over the 12 months.
Of the $94 million of equity at December 2009, $84 million was attributable to deferred taxation.
Total liabilities at December 2009 were $1,895 million.
SCF can't afford another dip.
SCF can't afford another dip.
Does it mean Hubbard gets
Does it mean Hubbard gets $10m cash?
@VALENTINA: Yes - you could
@VALENTINA:
Yes - you could of course criticise him for selling HNZ and 64% of Scales for $10m (worst case, if SCF goes belly-up).
I agree with you - he is a fool, and is just out to look after the SCF investors.
(Edited for legal reasons)
Alan.
The government is already as
The government is already as far out of choices as it can get. It's only option is to singularly and exceptionally extend the guarantee. Does it matter to them if it fails in 5 months or 5 years, if that's going to be the case? But time might just provide a miracle.
alan above. what's wrong with
alan above.
what's wrong with looking after his investors in SCF?
that's what's meant to happen...isn't it!!
I think that Alan Hubbard
I think that Alan Hubbard is an honest southern man who is doing his best to look after his depositors. This is in stark contrast to the likes of all those Aucklanders who were taking dividends when their company was arguably insolvent.
Good article. As a taxpayer
Good article. As a taxpayer I have a significant issue with having to fit the bill for SCF. The guarantee was a sham driven by political motives, rather than sound economic measures. Dr Cullen once again demostrated his complete lack of understanding of the real world. How long are ordinary NZ'ers going to have to pay for his incompetence and arrogance? The guarantee was rushed through in purely a political move. Had he and Clarke taken thought about NZ'ers first, instead of their own political power, they would have created a robust guarantee scheme.
@RoTN: Indeed! ;-) @TrevorS: I
@RoTN: Indeed! ;-)
@TrevorS: I totally agree (and I am definitely not a Southern Man)!
@Bernard: Apologies for whatever it was that I put in my post, that you had to edit for legal reasons. I can't actually recall what it was, but 'sorry' in any case. I am, however, quite intrigued now!
@All: Does any ever get the 'notification' emails? I have never received a single one, and I'm fairly sure it is not a spam filter thing. I did email the webmaster, but did not get a reply. Just wondering - not a biggie.
Alan.
what notification emails....there are so
what notification emails....there are so many ?
{Sigh} I figured it was
{Sigh}
I figured it was just me.
When I post, there is a check-box that says:
'Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail'
It makes no difference if I check that box or not - I don't get any notification emails. I have checked my typing in my email address, and it is fine. I have also tried a different email address, and no change.
Alan.
Alan, Our apologies for that
Alan,
Our apologies for that feature not working for some. We're phasing out this tool and preparing to relaunch with a new software. Hang in there.
FYI on earlier editing. The 'devious' word is one that has some special legal meaning I wasn't comfortable with. It implies intent to do unpleasant things, which we certainly can't prove and I wouldn't stand behind.
cheers
Hi Bernard, No worries -
Hi Bernard,
No worries - it hasn't put me off to date!
Perhaps I should have been clearer my previous post - I was being sarcastic, but obviously it didn't work!
I have nothing but respect for Alan Hubbard, and I personally believe he has done more than anyone could have asked to keep SCF going.
Apologies again!
Alan.
Good on alan standing by
Good on alan standing by his word and doing the best for investors, I used to be with SCF for this very reason, good luck to him & SCF
Whether Hubbard suffers from an
Whether Hubbard suffers from an excess of integrity or not, he failed to do his homework.
As did so many.
I could have told him/them, from 1975 on (I was 20 at the time), that this scenario would play out about now, and that the tide can't possibly come back in.
Physics beats three-card monte, hands down.
This isn't the/a biggie for the Govt either - not if they're being properly advised (which I doubt).
They all should have read Will Catton's 'OVERSHOOT'. Quite succinct, 1982 from memory....
From the sidelines - SCF
From the sidelines - SCF has not cost the tax payer anything yet. How much has the gaurantee cost tax payers? I doubt it has even exceeded the amount contributed by gaurantee holders.
Good on Alan Hubbard for
Good on Alan Hubbard for throwing all he has at this. I really hope SCF survives, because he is doing the honourable thing.
And now I've seen it all, powereddown: you forecast this scenario in 1975 - 34 years ago? Really?
ROTFL.
Okay then, I've got my pen and paper out so I know the smart place to invest: where is the NZ and world economy going to be in the year 2043?
Mark Any relation? Just curious.
Mark
Any relation? Just curious.
cheers
Bernard
No relation at all. I
No relation at all. I come from the poor ex-farming Hubbards'.
See
See http://www.lostsoulblog.com/2010/06/rubbing-gloss-of-big-south-canterbur... for a re-evaluation of this transaction. All things considered it provides only $11.8m in capital to SCF.
The Crown, the trustee, and the auditor are likely to face more attention about this transaction when the related loans and guarantees are unwound.
This 'big' recapitalisation,
This 'big' recapitalisation, on review, only provided $11.8m in new capital, not the $152.5m booked. See http://www.lostsoulblog.com/2010/06/rubbing-gloss-of-big-south-canterbur...