The comment stream

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Manager Operational Effectiveness and Assurance IT
Reporting to the Senior Manager Operational Risk Effectiveness and Assurance, the key focu...more
New Zealand
Financial Controller
Reporting to the Head of Finance - Retail and Business Bank the key focus of this role is ...more
New Zealand
Manager Finance Corporate Core - 12 Month Contract role
This role in consultation with the Financial Controller provides financial, strategic and ...more
New Zealand
IT Audit Manager - Internal Audit - Auckland
If you are motivated by the prospect of seeing the big picture, developing your team and m...more
New Zealand
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Should you fix your mortgage now or stay floating?

Choices

Interim payout of no more than 2.5c in dollar; massive losses expected in final washup

Posted in News Updated

Strategic Finance's receivers say debenture investors will receive an interim distribution of between 1.5 cents and 2.5c in the dollar by September 3.

(Update adds further detail).

However, the sale of the failed property financier's loan book has been delayed and most of its loan valuations have fallen "significantly" in the past six months. The receivers won't provide any overall expected recovery range until the sales process is complete and say they can't say when the next distribution will be made to investors.

In their second letter to investors, out today, John Fisk and Colin McCloy of PricewaterhouseCoopers say the total amount of the interim distribution will be between NZ$5.5 million and NZ$9.2 million. The payout will be calculated on investors' secured debenture investment as at August 7, 2008.

A letter from trustee Perpetual Trust to each secured debenture investor confirming the exact amount of the interm distribution and the payment method, by direct credit or cheque, will be sent about a week before the payout.

Sale of the loan book, which consisted of 87 loans and had a total net book value of NZ$229.1 million at February 28, has been delayed due to the "complexity" of some of the exposures and the time taken to obtain valuations on the top 20 loans. Potential buyers wanted updated valuations, and one - of a large and complex commercial development - remains outstanding.

Furthermore in the majority of cases the updated valuations were at levels "significantly below" the net loan book value as at February 28.

"As you will appreciate, this has impacted on the level of the indicative offers from the interested parties," the receivers said.

Based on the expected timing of the receipt of the last valuation, Fisk and McCloy said they now expect to receive final bids for the loan book in September.

"Once the final bids are received, we will assess the final offers against the expected realisations in the loan book and make a decision on whether a sale of the loan book will proceed, or alternatively, whether the receivers will continue to recover the loans."

They said given the sales process was still ongoing, any announcement of a final expected recovery range for investors could impact on final bids for the loans. Therefore, no final recovery prediction would be made until the sales process was completed.

"Overall, achieving loan recoveries remains challenging due to market conditions and, in certain cases, enforcement action by prior ranking security holders has resulted in nominal or no recoveries," Fisk and McCloy added.

"It is difficult to provide guidance on when the next distribution will be made. However, we are committed to making distributions to secured debenture investors as funds become available."

Indicative bids for the loan book were received on June 14. "Certain parties" were invited to a second stage of bidding with these parties now undertaking further due diligence on the loan book.

Strategic froze repayments to investors in August 2008 blaming tough conditions in the property market. Investors then voted for a moratorium in December 2008 that aimed to repay them 100% of their principal investments plus interest through asset realisations over five years. At that time Strategic's loan book was valued at NZ$477 million.

However, Perpetual Trust called in the receivers in March, with about 13,000 investors owed about NZ$417 million, after Strategic failed to generate sufficient loan recoveries for a repayment to investors' that was due in January.

Based on discussions with the borrowers, legal advisers and specialist property advisers, PricewaterhouseCoopers was continuing to implement individual loan strategies, which should maximise returns to investors, said Fisk and McCloy.

About 58% of the net loan book as of February 28 was secured through second ranking mortgages over the underlying properties.

"In a number of those loans, Strategic Finance is heavily dependent upon the actions of prior ranking mortgagees as to what funds, if any, are available to Strategic," said Fisk and McCloy.

The receivers' said they expected to issue their next report by October 29, at which point they would be able to advise on the outcome of the sales process and said by then the nature and timing of further distributions would be clearer.

Strategic, which counted former All Blacks captain and New Zealand Rugby Union chairman Jock Hobbs among its directors, was involved in financing Auckland's Soho Square development, the Sentinel Tower project in Takapuna and the Fiji Hilton.

Most loans were on a capitalised interest basis, which meant interest accruing was added to the loan balance and received on repayment of the loan, rather than being paid to Strategic on a monthly or quarterly basis.

Strategic Finance's former chief executive, Kerry Finnigan, told interest.co.nz earlier this week management didn't believe it had done anything wrong during the company's demise.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

15 Comments

I wouldn't be surprised at a

I wouldn't be surprised at a payout of 20c in the $ - ouch!

 I was hoping for more like

 I was hoping for more like 20cents in the dollar ,oh well I guess it will buy a few groceries ,I just hope its not the last supper

Word is that PWC are playing

Word is that PWC are playing with fire in at least two dealings on assets.. plus having given the thick finger to one buyer who was offering mid-teens(millions) and which was known to be way-way above best current valuation.  Feed the receiver and rodger the investors !  Persuade me otherwise !!  The investors' letter is little more than a weak  attempt to justify further time and therefore fees for PWC.

Allied is interested in

Allied is interested in buying Stategic off the receiver I here!!

They want to "extract the

They want to "extract the value from the 20c". When they have finished it will be 2c

a mood of

a mood of resignation,investors get screwed over,directors shrug.c'est la vie in NZ.

what is wrong with you

what is wrong with you people!this is healthy normal behaviour.two cents in two years is an outstanding result and a credit to our oversight of the financial standards we enforce.

i wouldnt be surprised if PWC

i wouldnt be surprised if PWC act for both parties in the receivership - along the lines of National Finance 2000, and Hawkins debt collection enterprise. Fleece the investors knowing full well that there is a nice big fat return for PWC and a priviliged client whom is waiting to pick up the pieces. Investors rise up! 

Well what a fantastic effort

Well what a fantastic effort by Jock Hobbs, Brian Fitzgerald, Kerry Finnigan & co.

The Strategic assets have dropped from $417M last year to $277M a few months ago to ( 50 cents in the dollar approx ) to probably $75M now - which means that was what they were actually worth a year ago.

Maybe the 10cent offer from Australia a month or so ago was actually a ngreat offer.

Well I hope the directors and Consultants' houses become leaky homes, their wives leave them now or have extramarital affairs, their expensive wine tastes like sick, their children finally work out their fathers are not nice people and they generally spend the rest of their lives looking over their shoulders wondering if the law is going to tap them on the shoulder or an investor or one of their relatives is going to do them damage.

 

Then they may understand how all the Mum and Dad investors feel when their life savings has been lost or severly depleted.

But as Kerrry Finnigan said earlier this week " we have done nothing wrong"  - yeah right

Maybe Gareth Vaughan or

Maybe Gareth Vaughan or Bernard Hickey shoud reinterview Kerrry Finnigan and ask him what he prdicts the final figure to be for the payout and maybe Gareth and Bernard may get off tehir posteriors and do some research on what Finnigan and Co have said in the past and report how that relates to the current position.

Or is everyone in NZ now too precious to report the truth and do some investigative journalism rather than just report on someone elses report.

Earn your keep guys and show the market just how good you can be. Recent reports have been found wanting in this regard.

Property is the way to go I

Property is the way to go I reiterate!!!

Buy property today in this

Buy property today in this market and you are guaranteed loss of capital from tomorrow and that loss will get worse over the next decade or so. Borrow any money on that purchase and it will be even worse. You would have to be dumb to buy now.

I'm inclined to agree with

I'm inclined to agree with Olly Newland as regards property.In fact some types of property bottomed out in Autumn to Winter 2009.The old saying is buy in gloom and gloom is now.The Man is correct.

As for Strategic

As for Strategic Finance,yesterday I dealt with an elderly person who had money in Strategic Finance Subordinated Notes courtesy of his Financial planner[joke].Well I said,you may as well write that off your books.At least he got 60% of his ING investment back.He had Bridgecorp and SCF Preference shares[now worth 9 cents I told him.]His SCF Debentures have the govt guarantee,the PPS investments are looking a bit sick.Why doesn't the government have a go at some of these ticketclippers instead of A H .Double Standards.

Well Pirate Guy They don't

Well Pirate Guy

They don't because theyonly go for the weak ones and easy legal cases like AH and Bridgecorp - even with Bridgecorpp they have only gone them for a few minor charges compared to the real crimes committed.

The Govt needs to get serious or else we will only get " smacked by a wet bus ticket " syndrome like LIanne Dalziel offered in the last Govt. Time will tell if Simon Power is a strong Minister or a populist.