The comment stream

Reader poll

Which of these factors is likely to have the biggest impact on our economy over the next 12 months?


Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Top 10 at 10: Hoenig my Hero; Chinese wage rises; Greek cry from the heart; Negative gearing; Dilbert

Posted in Opinion Updated

Here are my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 10 past 1pm. I welcome your additions and comments below or please send suggestions for Tuesday's Top 10 at 10 via email to

1. Chinese wages rising fast - One of the relief valves in the global economy will be a rise in Chinese wages reducing its competitiveness as the 'Factory of the World'. This would reduce the size of China's trade surpluses and make it less able to 'vendor finance' continued deficit-fuelled spending in the developed world. There are fresh signs of these fast wage rises in this LA Times piece. It will, however, add to some of the inflationary and interest rate pressures building in the global economy.

 Experts say younger factory workers, having grown up in a time of relative prosperity, will find it increasingly difficult to accept low pay and grueling work hours the way previous generations have. China's rapidly aging population also is expected to boost labor's leverage as the number of working-age Chinese dwindles to about half its current portion of the population by 2030.

Labor shortages already are being reported in many export-driven coastal provinces because of rapid development in China's interior. Several provinces and major cities such as Shanghai have had little choice but to raise minimum wages. "Most of the workers born after 1980 have a better awareness of their rights," said Liu Kaiming, an expert on migrant labor and executive director of the Institute of Contemporary Observation.

"They will choose where to work and ask for better salary." That's exactly what happened May 17, when nearly 2,000 workers at a Honda parts factory in the southern city of Foshan walked off the job to demand higher wages. About 600 of the employees were interns receiving credits for work experience as part of their school curriculum. Assembly lines were resuming production Tuesday as workers contemplated management's offer of a 24% pay increase that would bring monthly salaries to about $281, or 1,910 yuan, said David Iida, a Honda spokesman in Torrance.

2. Money stuck in vaults - Here's one of the reasons why the real easy money policies of the US Federal Reserve and the European Central Banks are having little real effect in the real economy. The Northern Hemisphere banks have the money, but are either too sick or too scared witless to lend it. This Bloomberg story explains that bank reserves on deposit with the European Central Bank (rather than being lent out to customers or other banks) have hit a record high of 320 billion euros in recent days.

Banks are parking cash with the ECB amid investor concern that a 750 billion-euro European rescue package may not be enough to stop the crisis from spreading and spilling into the banking industry. The ECB said on May 31 that banks will have to write off more loans this year than in 2009 and their ability to sell bonds may be hampered as governments seek to finance fiscal deficits.

Related Topics

“The banking crisis is back,” said Norbert Aul, an interest-rate strategist at Commerzbank AG in London. “The news flow over the past few weeks has spooked banks and since nobody knows how exposed individual financial institutions are, it’s deemed safer to park cash with the ECB rather than lend it on.”

Money market tensions are resurfacing even after the ECB started buying government bonds and said it would offer banks as much cash as they want for up to six months. Money market rates are rising, with the euro interbank offered rate, or Euribor, for three-month loans yesterday increasing to 0.704 percent, the highest this year. Banks borrowed 9 million euros from the ECB at the marginal rate of 1.75 percent, the central bank said today.

3.  APRA comfortable - Australia's chief banking regulator, APRA chairman John Laker, has told Australia's parliament it is comfortable about the level of exposures the big Four Australian banks (which means our banks too) have to the European Sovereign debt crisis, the Sydney Morning Herald reported. This is good news and reinforces the importance of the Four Pillars and our relative isolation from the rest of the world.

Local banks are seen as well-funded after raising about A$47 billion from wholesale markets this year, but could be vulnerable if the recent jitters in overseas credit markets continue or worsen. However, Mr Laker said lenders were now better prepared for any market troubles stemming from Europe than they had been after the collapse of Lehman Brothers.

''Australian banks have only very small exposures to countries in the euro area and, although spreads have been widening, global funding markets … have been more discerning about the fundamental strength of our banks,'' he said. ''We are continuing to liaise closely with Australian banks that tap offshore wholesale markets, and we are satisfied that these banks are much better placed than they were in October 2008 to deal with potential disruptions to these markets.''

4. The GFC 'experience' - Those crazy yanks. Now an ex-bond trader is hosting guided 'tours' of the scenes from the Global Financial Crisis in New York, The Guardian reports. I love how one of the tour guides is a Goldman Sachs employee earning a bit extra on the side...

Dwarfed by the Corinthian columns of the New York Stock Exchange's towering facade, Wall Street tour guide Tom Comerford opens a weather-beaten folder on a busy street in the heart of the Big Apple's financial district.

"I'm going to show you a toxic asset," he tells a small group of curious tourists. "You can even touch it." Comerford, a graphics employee at Goldman Sachs who leads guided walks in his spare time, gets out the front page of an inch-thick legal document that comprised a US$1.5bn collateralised debt obligation, issued in 2006. The derivative, granted a triple-A rating for its top tranches by credit agencies, went spectacularly sour, with investors losing 80 cents in every dollar.

He explains: "The collateral for this deal was sub-prime mortgages or, as we know it today, crap."

5.  Prices may rise somewhere - Some people are picking that Japanese real estate prices may have finally hit rock bottom. They are now at 36 year lows (yes thirty six not a typo) , Bloomberg reported. Japan had a property bubble that started deflating in the late 1980s. It has taken three decades for the market to be approaching the bottom. 

“The best time to invest is before things hit bottom, because if everyone were to agree we are right at bottom, they would all come rushing back in,” said Buddy Ferrie, a general manager of the investment division at property consulting firm Colliers Halifax in a phone interview in Tokyo. “If you have a longer term outlook, now is a very interesting time to be looking.”

Japan’s commercial land prices declined 6.1 percent in 2009 from a drop of 4.7 percent a year earlier, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism said in a report in March. Values are at their lowest since the ministry began collecting comparable data in 1974.

6. My hero - Thomas Hoenig is the rebel with a cause within the US Federal Reserves Open Markets Committee that sets US interest rates. The Fed's current official stance is to keep the Fed Funds Rate (the US version of the Official Cash Rate) at an "exceptionally low level for an extended period", but Hoenig is the black sheep in the family, regularly calling for higher rates and warning of inflation. Hurrah.

Hoenig spoke out again overnight, Bloomberg reported. His team of hawks is growing with in the Fed. If Obama had any sense he would appoint Hoenig Chairman of the Fed and get rid of Helicopter Ben.

“The first step toward a more normal policy is to move policy rates off zero, back toward neutral.” Hoenig said today in a speech in Bartlesville, Oklahoma. “With the improvements in market conditions and liquidity, and with an improving outlook, the FOMC would be prepared to raise the funds rate target to 1 percent by the end of summer.” Hoenig’s view hasn’t shifted since the European debt crisis last month posed a risk to the U.S. recovery.

He urged that the funds rate be raised “toward 1 percent this summer,” according to minutes of the Fed’s April 27-28 meeting. He has voted against central bank statements, saying in April the “extended period” language limited the Fed’s “flexibility to begin raising rates modestly.” Dallas Fed President Richard Fisher, James Bullard of St. Louis and Philadelphia Fed’s Charles Plosser have also expressed concerns about the “extended period” language. Richmond Fed President Jeffrey Lacker said last week he was “just sort of marginally comfortable” with the phrase.

7. A raw voice from Greece - My wife Lynn is a graphic designer who sells her digitally uploaded designs to digital scrap-bookers through a US based website. She points out to me regularly how much more she earns than me and how she has more google pages linking to her than to me. She's also part of quite a tight online community of digital scrapbookers globally. They talk about all sorts of things, often very personal, and sometimes political.

Lynn has pointed me to this plea from the heart from a Greek scrapbooker, Exogenia (pictured left), from Athens. It's not pretty and I wouldn't want to debate the economic logic of what she's saying (or try to correct her Gringlish), but it does give you a vivid feel of what real people in Greece are feeling right now.

The measures of IMF are very harsh and make a long list I will only mention the cut of salaries and pensions from 5-25%, thousands of layoffs, high taxes in everything, increase of the cost of electricity in 30% and every day government surprises us with a new one. Yesterday was announced that a widow can take the pension of her dead husband only if she is 50 years old and over. The salary of a new employee will be 550 Euros instead of the today HUGE sum of 700 Euros.

The generation of 700 Euros will become now the generation of 500 Euros. These measures drive us in a labor dark age and the population in pauperization, they drive us into death. Who can live with 500 Euro? What will be the future of our children? Greek civilians think that it is the final solution for the Greek nation. Society will collapse. Greece will become a great concentration camp. These measures will not save our economy; they will execute the population; we will die from hunger like during the WW2.

Greece of today has more doctors than we need, we have more lawyers than France, but we don't have plumbers and the manicure girl earns more money than a girl who studied economics and works in a bank. The 90% of the population has their own house and a great number of families have two cars. We achieved all these after a 12 hours hard work in two jobs, because of the low salaries and emigration. Nobody gifted us anything.

We feel angry for the fishy publication of the German "Focus" magazine which calls Greeks lazy people who must learn to work and not dance syrtaki. It"s unfair.. Such publications of German press doesn't help, because they scratch wounds and destroy the good relations between Greek and German people.

8Negative gearing eez vonderful  - The budget on May 20 doesn't seem to have stopped the property spruikers over at PropertyTalk. Here's Rosco talking about how "The Negative Gearing still works". He makes the interesting point that the tax cuts for the rich mean they can justify even more debt to buy houses. I wonder what the banks think of this lark. Your view?

I had a client come in yesterday who is building a brand new 5 bedroom investment property in Hamilton. This particular client is building very cheaply, so this is partially why this equation isn't too bad. On completion there should be $80k equity, which does help alot.

Rent less expenses plus tax refund (not huge but includes chattels depreciation) = ($2,000) per year or $40 per week topup. Client earns $100,000, so tax cuts will save then $70 per week. So extra $70 per week tax cuts, property only needs $40, so still $30 per week better off then before, plus own property.

There is obviously two major risks 1) Interest rates going up - reasonable rate in calculation. 2) Whats in the next budget BUT, rents should also go up over the next 1-2 years. But these are long term investors, and they are looking for reasonable capital growth long term. They require 0.56% growth to match the weekly topup. They think this is easily achieveable over the next 10 + years.

9. Rare and getting rarer - China is planning to tighten up access to the rare earth metals crucial for the production globally of hybrid cars, wind turbines and other high-tech devices, the New York Times reports.

The State Council, China’s highest legislative body, is weighing a proposal to put the government in control of private and unauthorized mines that produce rare earth minerals, a strategic resource that much of the world depends on, according to China Daily, the official English-language newspaper.

Rare earth minerals are an unusual group of natural elements that are vital for high-performance electric motors in hybrid cars, wind turbines, efficient light bulbs and even missiles. China now accounts for over 90 percent of the world’s production of the minerals.

Some governments and global companies have recently expressed concern about whether China is planning to restrict exports of its rare earth minerals or force global companies to move factories to China to complete production of items using the minerals.

Here's an excellent graphic showing how deep the crippled oil well in the Gulf of Mexico is and how hard it is to work at these depths.

Click here to get a bigger version

10. Here's totally irrelevant video of the investment banker in New York who was fired for looking too is alleged. Will let you all judge for yourselves. And keep it seemly in the comments. 


We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current Comment policy is here.


#8. "Rosco talking about how

#8. "Rosco talking about how the tax cuts for the rich mean they can justify even more debt to buy houses."

Bill English is one smart dude :)

Let's have a look at Roscoes

Let's have a look at Roscoes client, shall we:

(1)"I had a client ..who is building a brand new 5 bedroom investment property ... very cheaply.. this is partially why this equation isn't too bad....there should be $80k equity" That's about right. Do the cheapest job possible for investment housing. Forget about any quality stuff.
(2)"Rent less expenses plus tax refund ... = ($2,000) per year." So still losing $2k p.a. that has to come out of the taxtake somewhere; "we" have to subsidise his client. But, hey, two grand a year isn't much.
(3) "Client earns $100,000, so tax cuts will save then $70 per week. So extra $70 per week tax cuts, property only needs $40, so still $30 per week better off then before, plus own property." Hang on there, Roscoe! What about the GST rise? Or is your client going to cut expenditure to negate the GST increase?
(4)"There is obviously two major risks .. Interest rates going up - and... Whats in the next budget." Yup. Right with those two, Roscoe. More costs and changes of an unknow nature coming your clients way.
(5)"BUT, rents should also go up over the next 1-2 years".I doubt it, but plan away for people to pay more in rent than they can afford, with no wage rises coming and higher GST for them to pay.
(6)"They require 0.56% growth to match the weekly topup. They think this is easily achieveable over the next 10 + years." Hang on, Roscoe! Just leaving the $80k equity in the bank will give them more than that.

Ah...Property Investors. You've got to love a dreamer.

@Nicholas Arrand Economics is

@Nicholas Arrand

Economics is all about hidding the truth under numbers and BS.

This sounds like someone I

This sounds like someone I know rebuilding a house that burned down. If it is, he is a builder, which is how/why he's getting it built cheaply.

In an hour and a half's time,

In an hour and a half's time, I'll be raising a glass of Shiraz and toasting "Amen to that, Troy"!

re 2 and 6 - and 7 for that:

re 2 and 6 - and 7 for that: there's a good reason not to lend,Bernard - the chances of it coming back decrease from here on in, and some at the top have to be smart enough to have figured that out.
Which is why the Fed is stuck - long term - at zero. No energy to underwrite the interest in the go-round - or did I mention that before...????
And the Greek lady is way up the scale from the real bottom-enders - Bangladesh, Somalia, and the rest. There is only the capability to support 2 billion on this planet, at subsistence level, maybe one billion at our level. We ran into the supply peaks, full noise and accelerating. She won't be getting it back, and we're in the same boat with so little time difference it won't matter.
Exponential math works like that.
Whattabugger. :)

Yes I was a bit taken aback

Yes I was a bit taken aback by the negative gearing still works article. It listed 2 points where things could not work as planned. Neither of them was that property can go down and leave you with a large black, black hole (called negative equity by the smooth talking yankees - bankrupt to us).

"This particular client is

"This particular client is building very cheaply, so this is partially why this equation isn't too bad."

Man, I'm glad I won't be living in that place.

Chinese wages rising? I guess

Chinese wages rising? I guess that means NZ really WILL be flooded by rich Asians looking to buy all our houses.

Those rapidly aging Chinese.

Those rapidly aging Chinese. How do they do that?

The Greek lass has better

The Greek lass has better english than the property lad

.. .. Latest shoe to fall in

.. Latest shoe to fall in Europe , Hungary ! Anyone heard of them ? Apparently the new government found that the previous regime left the books alot worse than was reported ... Where have we come across that before , Mr Cullen !

.. Luckily for the Euro , Hungary still trade in their own currency .

.. Anyone else get the feeling that the Euro is " dead man walking " ? The socialist experiment in Europe is on it's last legs .

The bumbling bloody fools

The bumbling bloody fools elected to govern and lead are proving their incompetence on a daily basis. Say hello to stimulus part two. Another round of QE and congressional porkfesting stupidity in the usa. If you don't succeed the first time round to prove what a bunch of incompetent idiots you are..have another go.
Over in Pommyland what growth they might have had is soon to be crushed as the idiots who replaced the morons in govt embark on a "bash the wealthy" plan to make absolutely certain nobody invests a dam thing in anything that might create new wealth. At it's most might mean Lord Snott is forced to hand over a hundred grand to the wasteful idiots, instead of investing it in a startup medical equipment or drug maker, that given a little time could have evolved into a dynamic billion pound business.

No:10 She is hot! wow. I'd

No:10 She is hot! wow. I'd fire all the idiots who couldn't deal with her looks and make her boss

No:7 Greece is just the

No:7 Greece is just the beginning of this world wide 'austerity' event. They only have themselves too blame. Huge numbers of countries are living beyond their means, NZ included. The 'great depression' and 'ww2' were the result of years of desperate 'austerity' plans after the 1927 crash. Ready for round 2 people? Israel seemed to want to kick it off

.. .. Ms Lorenzana ought to

.. Ms Lorenzana ought to dress more suitable . Many worker is a jerka , if pretty lady , not wearing burka .

.. .. There but for the sense

.. There but for the sense of the electorate go us : Had Labour won the 2008 election , the Keynesian spend big policies of Barack Obama would be replicated here in NZ . Goofy & Cunny exhort Wild Bill to borrow & spend more . ..

. . See Caroline Baum's " I want it all : even better if you pay for it " , over at Bloomberg .

.. Unless Labour change their tune prior to 2011 , don't waste a single vote on these wastrals . An American fund manager labelled Michael Cullen as a buffoon , and little has changed or been learnt by his successors .

@RT "An American fund manager


"An American fund manager labelled Michael Cullen as a buffoon..."

Not to defend Cullen, but I wouldn't necessarily rate an American fund manager over wee Mike. Look at how well American fund managers have done recently.

I recall that the guy was

I recall that the guy was looking to diversify into NZ , with American pension funds . But was put off by Cullen's policies and smug utterances . It was either " village idiot " or " buffoon " that he called Cullen . The money wasn't invested here .

"Pot meet kettle" comes to

"Pot meet kettle" comes to mind. Few have ever been anywhere near as smug as those in the US finance sector. No village would have them as their idiots, and the American money men give buffoons a terrible name.

.. .. Diplomacy being a

.. Diplomacy being a necessity , now that we have a FTA with China , I have found some translations from the parks & gardens of the PRC , telling us in their English , to " keep off the grass " :

.. " Green grass dreading your feet "

.. " Protect a piece of green leaf and dedicate a share of love "

.. " Your careful step keeps tiny grass invariably green "

[ .. - and if you still don't get the message , - ]

.. " I like your smile , but unlike you put your shoes on my face "

Re #3: So, should we short

Re #3: So, should we short aussie banks or not, as suggested a couple of days ago in relation to their exposure to extreme level of mortgage landing in overheated real estate market?

Yes ! Absolutely .

Yes ! Absolutely .

Kris Sayce basically got on

Kris Sayce basically got on to it 8 weeks ago. He suggested selling CBA @ A$57 then. You may not like his views, though, as he suggests selling the guts out of the propety market, as well!

"Greek lady is way up the

"Greek lady is way up the scale from the real bottom-enders" she's maybe she shouldnt have been so dumb as to believe the snake oil salesmen she voted for....and indeed that applies to us..........

In terms of two Billion or one billion "at our level" I think that the 1 billion is only possible as long as there are a few billion supporting them, which wont be the case....

But you know the Amish get by well on low technology they seem happy enough. That or similar will probably be the future for at most 2 billion....but I suspect that that will dip considerably lower before recovering probably over 100 years plus....if AGW is ad bad as they are beginning to think then 1 billion might not even make it....


.. .. " Stick to floating

.. " Stick to floating rate , if you still want toast with coffee " says one Bnerrad Heciky [ edit function ? ] in the NZ Harold . Buddy , as sure as I am that Goldmunny Sacks will reach $US 250 / share by year's end ( my Jan. 1'st prediction ) , I am sure that Bolly will not raise the ORC in 2010 .

.. Our interest rates are still way above OECD averages . Big bond funds in Japan & the USA are just itching to charge into the $Kiwi . Why give them an excuse to ramp up our currency , and choke off exports , so soon into the " recovery " .

.. Toast & Coffee ? Ye gads man , don't they feed you properly , up in Yuckland , no wonder you make scarecrows look fat !

What if Bolly has a case of

What if Bolly has a case of 'fat finger' and presses the 5% key! that would be fun..Kiwi would go ballistic in anticipation of going ballistic...I could swap me Kiwi for euro and buy a batch on a beach in Italy or maybe one of them Greek islands and discover a lost treasure or a fresh water spring.
Think of it RT..soooo many options. But he won't will he...he'll press the "do nout" key and it'll be back to the future for Noddy.

This does not make for a nice

This does not make for a nice Sunday read!
“falsified data”

You needn't worry, because

You needn't worry, because this time IT'S DIFFERENT!

"In what's being called the

"In what's being called the country's biggest single receivership of residential investment properties, 153 rental units in Hamilton, New Plymouth and Palmerston North are for sale" radio nz

Should have the market bulls running!

Is this where dairy farming

Is this where dairy farming in Noddy is likely to go?

.. .. Well done Peter Leitch

.. Well done Peter Leitch : arise Sir Mad Butcher !