In this section
Offers for readers
Follow the news from interest
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 20831
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 295
- ››
Finance sector jobs
Senior Liability Underwriting Manager
Lead from the front utilising your strategic, technical and leadership qualities within th...more
New Zealand
Lead from the front utilising your strategic, technical and leadership qualities within th...more
New Zealand
Senior Liability Product Underwriter - Product Management
Lead from the front utilising your technical expertise in this highly attractive senior li...more
New Zealand
Lead from the front utilising your technical expertise in this highly attractive senior li...more
New Zealand
High Performing Senior Liability UnderwriterHigh Performing Senior Liability Underwriter
Customer focus, high performance, exceeding client expectations and achieving profitable g...more
New Zealand
Customer focus, high performance, exceeding client expectations and achieving profitable g...more
New Zealand
Head of Retail Credit -Wellington, NZ
Key leadership position in the bank. Be a part of one of the fastest growing banks in New ...more
New Zealand
Key leadership position in the bank. Be a part of one of the fastest growing banks in New ...more
New Zealand

The news stream
Latest news
Most commented
- Govt eyes NZ$1.4b revenue grab 63
- English defends current account blowout 61
- 90 seconds at 9 am 51
- Budget 2012 reactions 46
- Friday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 39
- Thursday's Top 10 with NZ Mint 38
- What covered bonds mean for ma and pa 32
- 'Next 5-10 years make or break for NZ' 29
- Westpac and ASB change rates down 26
- 90 seconds at 9 am 22
Most viewed
Summer chart series: How foreign owned NZ businesses perform much better than our own
Bernard Hickey picks out 10 charts from 2009 in a series of videos to play over the Summer break. In this video he looks at how foreign owned businesses in New Zealand produce an average 26% return on equity, while New Zealand owned businesses produce an average 12% return on equity. The chart produced by IRD for the Tax Working Group shows the spread of returns on equity. It raises questions about why foreign owned businesses are so much more profitable and whether they pay a fair share of corporate taxes.

38 Comments
<b>Bernard</b> : Seasons Greetings ,
Bernard : Seasons Greetings , big Gummy Bear !
Page 6 of that report has a graph showing trusts receipts . Trustee trusts , set up to minimise tax obligations , soared after 2001 , dramatically so . This tells me that those people who Michael Cullen specifically targeted with his new 39 % top marginal income tax rate ( the " rich pricks " ) , were savvy enough to get around it . And did so , in boat loads .
The populance are not going to let usurious tax loads be dumped upon them , without a counter-reaction .
Who the feck is the
Who the feck is the UGG Doctor ?..................Wonder if they really do cause gangrene . Ouch !
Roger - good point. It
Roger - good point. It was one made early on at the TWG conf. Am guessing Cullen knew the data too, and for a good while, so why didn't he make the obvious change? Maybe too many of those 'affected' hooked on the 'fix' by then?
Question is, how do we allow NZ smaller companies to get larger, more profitable, not sell out/stay here?
Cheers, Les.
<b>Can we separate that question
Can we separate that question into bite-sized chunks :
How to increase number of businesses formed in NZ ?
How to foster their growth .
How to encourage them to stay in NZ .
How to encourage Australian businesses (UGG !!! ) to relocate head-office , and set up shop here , in NZ .
What this tells me is
What this tells me is that Foreigners are smart... they buy our best businesses.
AND as we develop more great businesses... Foreigners will buy those too.
They are smart !!!
AND we really welcome.. "Foreign Direct Investment"... we love it..!!!
Return on equity can be
Return on equity can be a slippery measure.
Mulitinationals offen set up subsidaries with very little equity and lots of intercompany loans.
This makes the the return on equity look very good and needs to be taken into account when comparing with solely domestic firms that have no options to minimise equity in this way.
Also high returns on equity can mean highly geared and associated high risk. Its just the same as 95% mortgages give high return on equity until the market turns.
What are Foreigners - Mark
What are Foreigners - Mark ?
I'm with you roelof...let's hope
I'm with you roelof...let's hope FPH gets snapped up by a foreign mob before Labour return to do an aia on any deal. Could be a woppa capital gain coming on that buyout.
<b>Bernard</b> : Is it possible
Bernard : Is it possible that these figures are skewered by industry type , rather than by managerial competence . For instance , heavy equity / low return businesses ( such as farms ) are predominately NZ owned . Whereas the banking industry , is low equity / high return , and predominantly Australian owned .
The conclusion being that Kiwis may not necessarily be bad business operators , but certainly are poor at picking which industries to invest into .
Bernanke saying cheap money did
Bernanke saying cheap money did not cause housing bubble...and this morning I walked on water...I did...it was all over the kitchen floor.
Bernanke , the cranky ,
Bernanke , the cranky , he says cheap money didn't cause the housing bubble ? Hey bro , sis , Ma , wake up you lot , c'mon , spread yer wings , we can fly ! Oink oink .
Hey Walter : Got a
Hey Walter : Got a rip roaring NW gale blowing down here . How is it up your way ?
Them tourists got longer arms and shorter pockets today ? Tell 'em that you are on an errand of mercy , you need to sell stuff , to raise munny for a guy who is suffering from gummy- bear deprivation ( there is some truth in that ! ) .
Rogie, Kaikoura is more hot
Rogie,
Kaikoura is more hot then windy- so far.
I'm not sure in which category of business I (we) belong to. I consider myself as a Kiwi with a Swiss business culture.
For the last 3 months we cannot say we are in a recession- business is really great and November was the best since immigrating 18 years ago.
Raising money for Thomson zh zh - the richest person in Lowburn. Have you been talking (drinking) with Irish friends in Chch (Pub) ?
Have a read of this
Have a read of this and throw away the ETS tax ideas.......http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/article6974621.ece
I just made an interesting
I just made an interesting discovery from my office window. Some sparrow parents are feeding their offspring's with good food, chasing caterpillars - others feed bread found on the footpath.
<b>Walter</b> If the Japanese buy
Walter If the Japanese buy the remainder of my copper/molybdenum mine in Canada , I may very well be amongst the Fortune 400 club of Loburn .
Good to hear that trade is brisk . Maybe we are getting enough green-shoots for a vegetarian banquet .
Actually , been feted by the fine folks at Goldmoney Sacks of late . They know some excellent eateries down Cambridge Terrace , at the Art Centre end of town . Awesome ! Erdinger wheat beer on tap at Sticky's : Yum .
"The price of timber will
"The price of timber will rise by up to 10% from February due to supply difficulties and a big surge in log exports, mainly to China, according to the Timber Industy Federation"..radio nz....and it's goodbye to lower building costs which never really got here did they. Oh well, best plan a house without timber framing. looks like those shipping containers are the way to go. I think this can be logged under inflation...don't you agree Alan?
What a great long term
What a great long term NZ business (environmental) prospect - Exporting "Timber logs" to China ??
..a sparrow found some bread
..a sparrow found some bread crumb - a slavery product.
You gotta love the BS
You gotta love the BS about supply difficulties...it's trade talk for screw the buyers!
Walter... I really do hope
Walter...
I really do hope you're not suggesting someone should process logs here and make things...
Sounds like the industrialisation you alluded to in another post.
Can't we skip all the dirty stuff and sell services?
Hey! Why not just create an underclass, and rent houses to them?
Or sell fish quota!
Next you'll suggest that the taxpayer should help with the capital costs of modern saw milling.
I prefer to buy it from the warehouse on its return journey.
Much better quality than we could manage.
Foreign businesses do well compared
Foreign businesses do well compared to local businesses because they do not have enduring relationship with NZ. They usually buy a business and never reinvest significant amount of the profit back in NZ.
It is probably cheaper to
It is probably cheaper to import sawn lumber from the Russian near east and get a better grade of wood!
Timber Industry Fed. say that
Timber Industry Fed. say that exports of logs to Asia have doubled from 40 % , 6 years ago , to 80 % today , of our total . Yet the average price paid by Asian buyers is about a third of that paid by Australia . ........... . Why ? Are Asian countries taking lower grade logs ? A third !
Can’t we skip all the
Can't we skip all the dirty stuff and sell services?
No - KW of important reasons described many times, as a nation we cannot allow this to happen we need both here in NZ not mass produced, but on a high level, top quality manufactured products (Logging is "Dirty stuff"), or we have to reduce our spending.
---
I prefer to buy it from the warehouse on its return journey.
Much better quality than we could manage.
Those attitudes are the major problems here in NZ and lead to massive indebtedness up to the roof - and by the way the loss to know what quality really means.
Walter
John, Foreign businesses do also
John,
Foreign businesses do also well compared to local businesses because they do have a different culture to do business. They often reinvest profits into the business- adding quality.
Might be some ideas in
Might be some ideas in here?
"Creating a High-Value Economy", Sir John Rose, Chief Executive, Rolls-Royce plc, Address to the Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce, 10 November 2009.
http://www.thersa.org/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/249154/Rose-RSA-speech...
At least two bits I liked:
1) "And we recognise that retaining the status quo is not an option." (Sad that in NZ this seems to be our only option....)
2) As John Kaye put it:
"Taken as a whole, market economies have proved far more effective than planned economies. But this does not imply that every individual market outcome is superior to every individual planned outcome."
Left-wing, right-wing - discuss. (Watch for those spheres coming through that world.)
Enjoy.
Martin H, Roelof - am getting onto the other thing, soon... Cheers, Les.
Les, Every Kiwi but especially
Les,
Every Kiwi but especially economist/ politicians should read that link "“ think and take actions.
The reason why I'm advocating a form of central planning is our economic mess of not having important segments in our secondary economy. As many times explained unfortunately under the world- wide situation/ circumstances those segments cannot just be created by the Private Sector alone, but need assistance by the government.
Walter
<b>page 12 , LES :
page 12 , LES : The MIT are responsible for the founding of 26000 firms , with total sales of $ 2 trillion , and employing 3.3 million people . Equivalent to the GDP of the world's 11'th largest economy ............ All this , from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology .
And : China sends its' mayors to Singapore to train them to run a city state . .... " This is not an amateur sport . "
That page 12 is a doozy ! WOW !!!
The question is, what processes,
The question is, what processes, policy, energy, institutional frameworks are they using, and is it down-scaleable to here? But more importantly, do we really want to change? Or is the 'status quo' good enough? If so, for whom? Then who are whom? What are the interests of whom? Are they your long term interests?
I'd be grateful Roger, if you could precise it into two points and 4 lines please, because I've only scan read it so far. So am very impressed by your committment to go the extra inch. Cheers, Les.
Les, Rogie and others, Finally,
Les, Rogie and others,
Finally, there is some understanding/ agreement from members what I'm proposing since joining this forum. In general Sir John Rose's article is explaining more or less what I mean.
As a small and remote nation, not only economically we have advantages other nations do not have. Time for revolutionary changes the way we do economics.
Walter
Les....if only.... We in NZ
Les....if only....
We in NZ build leaky homes, not Rocket scientists.
We have STATE bludgers, not STATEMEN or men of Sir John's ilk.
MIT indeed....whatever next.....EFFICIENCY....cost effective, or heaven forbid....PROFIT. We devalue....not up-scale.
MIT probably never built a leaky home in their lives. Why should we import their methods. Sheer madness.
Even if we did.....
Where would the incentive and resources come from....this SHON-KEY GOVERNMENT.
Not on present performance.!!!!!!!!!
Or our best NZ hero...... HELL-ens & her Cohorts.
We could always re-instate HELL-en, cos she always knew best.
(Poor UN...the world will never be the same...hopefully we will improve...but I digress)
They ALL only ever know how to spend, not create and produce and add value.
Did you see the comparative INDIAN & UK wages.....
We have MCDONALDS....
We grow PINE.
End of sarcasm........sorry for the sarcasm.
HOW CAN WE EVER FIX THIS COUNTRY WITHOUT LEADERS LIKE SIR JOHN.
He must be good to work around GORDON BROWN's idiots in the UK.
Must have nearly bankrupted ROLLs as well as the COUNTRY.
Walter - given your interpretation
Walter - given your interpretation of that speech, how far does the state need to "get into the market" to make things happen? Am asking because:
http://www.interest.co.nz/ratesblog/index.php/2009/12/30/summer-chart-se...
Roger - this is the crux of it, off pages 3 and 4, where he answers the question, "What is high-value activity?":
"It has a high research and technology content;
It requires a profound understanding of the customer;
It exploits both scientific and experiential intellectual property;
It involves the definition of solutions that meet complex requirements;
It requires well-developed systems integration skills;
It involves managing data to inform responses to complex events, .... "
These outcomes are based on 'winning behaviours.' Compare to MEA's policy position and the evolutionary algorithm of a complex adaptive system comparison, as described in my book review of Beinhocker's 'Origin of Wealth', that John Kay endorses as, "The most important business book of 2006." Enable, incentivise the relevant behaviours in a 'pluralistic' way (Walter - little finger wag there to you central planners in case you start getting too pervasive and/or picking winners, in terms of firms, sectors - naughty.) and stand back from the touch paper.
Cheers, Les.
..given your interpretation of that
..given your interpretation of that speech, how far does the state need to "get into the market" to make things happen? Am asking because...
Wrong question/ approach Les. You are already looking for trouble.
Next one please.
Walter
I wrote some form of Central planning also known as mixed economy when you like the term better.
LES : He lost me
LES : He lost me at the part that the 5 lb. goose was calculated to be sucked into an engine drawing the equivalent of a squash-court full of air every second . ........... . Been out and about since then , the geese in our neighbourhood seem to be bigger than his . Does that invalidate my experiment to replicate his Rolls Royce jet engine ?............The locals were all very generous with their old vacuum cleaners ........ Roger & Out .
Often we forget the little
Often we forget the little guy, the SMB, in our discussions of the comings and goings of the Internet marketing industry. Sure there are times like this when a report surfaces talking about their issues and concerns but, for the most part, we like to talk about big brands and how they do the Internet marketing thing well or not so well.
www.onlineuniversalwork.com
I have just hit my
I have just hit my fifties and I have established a very comfortable financial position. I am a financial consultant for a highly successful international brokerage house, but it has not always been that way.
I have experienced hard times, particularly when I was younger, and it was then that I developed the bedrock of my financial resources, The Winning Way which is on offer on this web site. Once that system took off the old adage of money makes money has never been more true. The instant cash flow gave me the opportunity to try out a trading system, 100% Profit In One Year which is also on offer here and this accelerated cash into my account like there was no tomorrow. www.onlineuniversalwork.com
This is what I’ve been
This is what I've been looking for! Thank you so much for sharing this! You are a few important tips in there, i'm also bloged on http://limosbusesjets.com & just signup on http://bit.ly/4zTwpz A search on the issue, and there was agreement on most of the web log.I appreciate you as a customer for doing business with us... A customer is the most important visitor on our premises.