Offers for readers

The comment stream

Recent comments

Join the Interest community to be a registered commenter so you can:
- Edit your comments
- Avoid the CAPTCHA
- Vote on comments
Register Here

Already registered? log back in here ..

Forgotten your password? No problem! Click here

Finance sector jobs

Market Risk Manager
Unique opportunity to become an integral member of this highly respected market leading te...more
Australia
Senior Project Manager - APAC
Newly created role to manager projects across the Asia Pacific region within a worldwide l...more
Australia
Chief Financial Officer
Chief Financial Officer Location flexibleCompetitive Remuneration...more
Australia
Business Development Manager - Wholesale Sales
An opportunity has become available for an experienced Business Development Manager to joi...more
Australia
efinancialcareers.com

Reader poll

Who do you think should be appointed Reserve Bank Governor to replace Alan Bollard when he retires in September?

Choices

Opinion: Tracking the de-leveraging Tsunami

Posted in News

There is an eerie moment before a Tsunami hits when the water retreats from the beach. The water is sucked out to sea, leaving the fish flapping and the seaweed exposed as the Tsunami gathers itself before rushing in to destroy everything in its path.

In years to come investors and economists alike will see 2008 as the year debt was sucked back out of the world's financial and property markets. This year will be seen as that moment before the Tsunami of the worst recession in 80 years wreaked havoc on the global economy for at least the next decade.

It's worth explaining how de-leveraging works and why it is such a powerful force. Over the last 6 years interest rates were kept low globally in the wake of the 9/11 attacks and investment banks in the Northern Hemisphere were let off the leash to indulge in massively leveraged lending to all and sundry for all sorts of assets.

The most popular type of lending was home mortgage lending to consumers by banks and pension funds either directly or through a myriad of intermediaries using securitisation and "˜insured' lending backed by investments banks and insurers using strong credit ratings. The power of that leverage was enormous. It doubled house prices in most western property markets over that 6 year period.

Estimates vary about how much borrowed money was pumped into property markets over that period. Some estimate it was at least US$3 trillion (NZ$5.8 trillion). Others point to the value of Credit Default Swap instruments outstanding at the end of 2007 of US$600 trillion (NZ$1,153 trillion) as a fair estimate. I think a number closer to US$15 trillion (NZ$28.8 trillion) is more accurate. That is about 534 times New Zealand's annual GDP. It's a number too big to comprehend.

But what we're seeing now is a good portion of that money being sucked back out of the property market either through force or through debt not being rolled over. Sucking the money back by force through mortgagee sales, foreclosures and liquidations is the most dangerous type of de-leveraging and is what has caused so much havoc on global financial markets in the last 6 months.

The de-leveraging debt spiral goes like this. Borrowers can't pay their interest. The lender is forced to book a provision for the lower value of the loan. This reduces their equity capital to back their other loans. The bank is forced by investors, depositors or regulators to raise fresh capital to ensure its capital backing is strong enough to keep its credit rating or retain its special status as a bank or just retain confidence.

If they can't raise fresh capital they must raise cash by liquidating the loan. They force a mortgagee sale or foreclosure. That drives down asset prices, which in turn forces the bank to acknowledge lower asset values across their entire loan book. This forces more capital raisings or asset sales. You get the picture.

It is a debt death spiral that can only stop when asset values stop falling or capital has been replenished with enough cash. Essentially, this is the deleveraging Tsunami that sucks debt out of the property market and then destroys the value of that property.

New Zealand's banks borrowed NZ$72 billion from foreign banks and investors in the 5 years to 2008. It virtually doubled house prices. Some of that will be sucked back home over that coming decade. This is the reason why I believe house prices will fall 30% from their 2007 peaks and not recover to that level for another decade.

* This article first appeared in my weekly column in the Herald on Sunday.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

10 Comments

I think it's time to

I think it's time to sit back and see, now Bernard. You have made the point you believe in, as every respected jounalist should, and only time will tell if it's just another tide going out, your eerie quiet before the tsunami. ( Personally I have headed for the high ground that you and Gareth have advocated for some time now). But you run the risk of flogging the dead horse too much, and that's not a sight that can achieve any more than you have, and I think you run the risk of turning the masses off your message.

I disagree - most of

I disagree - most of the masses haven't even started to wake up to the message yet. Fortunately a few other journalists are starting to realise that things are no longer so rosy, here is Rod Oram telling it as it is:

http://www.stuff.co.nz/sundaystartimes/4792205a6445.html

Oram discovered the crisis when

Oram discovered the crisis when his puppet masters Labour got dumped,prior to that it was Labours business as usual,if he had pointed out the obvious in August ,when we had the Prefu ,he might have gotten better kilometres.

Well that's certainly one interpretation

Well that's certainly one interpretation on his conversion...........

I agree with andy. Underestimating

I agree with andy.
Underestimating the severity and complexity of the economic worldwide situation, not facing reality by the media and talking openly leads into mismanagement of finances and planning.
I think the media should take far more initiatives to educate and inform the public and......
As an example with councils/ government having big plans/ projects I question where the money is coming from to pay. Sleep well !

It all depends on how

It all depends on how much risk aversion overseas lenders will have with us. Nevertheless, RBNZ is going big on providing liquidity to banks with housing asset based securities. If overseas lenders are highly risk averse with us, then our dollar will fall further; high domestic inflation will strip of anyone having cash deposits forcing them to invest in housing as a matter of shielding against inflation. In other words, the house prices may not fall 30% in NZ dollar terms but a lot in terms of other currencies. Only when banks insist on higher owner equity such as 30% or more and stop lending over million dollars on a single mortgage, a bigger fall is plausible. At the moment the fear of bigger losses to banks is driving monetary polices, which in a way reward those who took excessive risks.

This is the time when

This is the time when all the smart people who cashed up in the good times (and did not invest in finance companies) will make their fortune. Buying shares in public utilities, commodities and large strong companies while the prices are down, buying waterfront land, buildings with government tenants and other properties in valuable locations will set up the next generation.

@Valentina ....will your idea create

@Valentina

....will your idea create the next generation or the next bubble ?
Unless we aren't more productive in NZ (Export) I don't see any improvements.
To really be successful and to overcome the recession the next generation has to bring morality/ responsibility not greed into our economy.

"will set up the next

"will set up the next generation."

Those who made their money out of house price inflation (and got out in time) certainly set a lot of people up as asset inflation isn't wealth creation, it just presents a charge elsewhere in the economy (ie they become someones burden).

When financial moral hazard runs

When financial moral hazard runs high, deleveraging may not fully happen. Excessive unproductive spending by the governments will keep the inflation fairly high. Given this high rate of inflation, the true interest rate return after tax does is negative for cash. The past monetary policies did not encourage saving but rather encouraged unproductive housing investments. In the name of fighting recession, the revised monetary policies are helping undue risk takers. Only those excessively leveraged will be affected. All assets including cash carry a risk. This risk of cash is deliberately kept high, both in good and bad times.