sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Wednesday's Top 10 with NZ Mint: Gerry Brownlee 'sick and tired of the whingers and moaners' in ChCh; TC3 residents in ChCh at their wits end with insurers; Bundesbank revolt catches on in Germany; Dilbert

Wednesday's Top 10 with NZ Mint: Gerry Brownlee 'sick and tired of the whingers and moaners' in ChCh; TC3 residents in ChCh at their wits end with insurers; Bundesbank revolt catches on in Germany; Dilbert

Here's my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 8 pm today in association with NZ Mint.

As always, we welcome your additions in the comments below or via email tobernard.hickey@interest.co.nz.

See all previous Top 10s here.

My must read today is #9 on what's happening on the ground in Christchurch from Rebecca Macfie.

1. Gerry's not happy  - The Press reports Gerry Brownlee is sick and tired of whinging Cantabrians.

This could easily get quite ugly for the government.

The grumpiness is welling up from the ground in Christchurch more than two years after the earthquakes started.

After you've read this, go and read #9.

It's a mess of disputes and confusion inside a multi-level matrix including EQC, the insurers, CERA, the City Council and the Government.

Here's Gerry:

"I'm a TC3 resident myself and I'm sick of these people carping and moaning,'' he said. ''The constant suggestion that somehow we've abandoned these people or forgotten about them is just the most insulting thing they could possibly say."

Brownlee said agencies had done "a great deal of work" to get clarity on the city's land condition and all the land-zoning decisions were driven by science. "They can be as grumpy as they like. I'm not making bad decisions for the future of Christchurch simply to meet the timelines some people are demanding,'' he said.

2, Mining tax hike - The state of Queensland has increased its coal royalties from 10% to 12.5%. SMH reports BHP is furious. It's not going to help Australia's faltering mining boom and may further close the 'escape valve' of Australian jobs for New Zealand workers.

3, Animated monetary policy failure GIFs - Courtesty of Mike (Rortybomb) Konzcal.

It made my head hurt a little. But it's well worth a click.

4. Keep an eye on this - China is talking very tough in its dispute with Japan over a couple of godforsaken rocks in the East China Sea. Here's the New York Times.

The bellicose bluster between China and Japan continues to grow more heated, with two armed Chinese surveillance vessels circling the disputed Diaoyu islands and the Foreign Ministry in Beijing saying that “long gone are the days when the Chinese nation was subject to bullying and humiliation from others.”

On Wednesday, an editorial in the Communist Party-controlled Global Times newspaper said “Chinese anger of more than a century toward Japan was awakened on Tuesday” with the Japanese government’s purchase of the islands from a private Japanese owner. Beijing insists the sale is invalid, of course, because the islands, while they are physically controlled by Japan, are Chinese territory.

The Global Times, with several references to lingering bitterness over Japanese depredations during World War II, said it “appears inevitable the two sides will be overwhelmed by hatred again now that more conflicts can be expected.”

5. It's not enough - Martin Wolf at the FT.com reckons the Big Bazooka is not big enough, or too big. Either way, it's not the fix to the Euro-zone crisis everyone thinks it is.

The ECB has done what it can, given the politics. The decision of the German constitutional court and the result of the Dutch election may help. But the risks of a breakup cannot be eliminated. If these are to disappear, citizens of debtor countries must see a credible path to growth, while citizens of creditor countries must believe they are not throwing money down a bottomless pit. What the ECB has done is win some time. It has not won the game.

6. Don't write off the Bundesbank yet - Wolfgang Munchau reckons the Bundesbank's Jens Weidemann is winning the debate over the Big Bazooka, even though he appears to have been sidelined by Super Mario. It's always eventually all about politics in Europe.

The day after the ECB’s decision, the German media eulogised Mr Weidmann for fighting against the infidels in the ECB. The consensus view among German commentators is that the ECB has lost its independence; that the German taxpayer will foot the bill; and that hyperinflation is around the corner. One commentator was appalled by the fact that Mario Draghi was ready to save the euro at any cost.

A poll published last week had 53 per cent of all Germans hoping that their Constitutional Court would block the European Stability Mechanism – and risk utter chaos. When he says that bond purchases border on an illegal act of debt monetising, he is expressing a consensus view among German economists, lawyers and politicians. When debates shift, one often observes that the losing side becomes pseudo-pragmatic. I am seeing more and more pro-European Germans effectively embracing the eurosceptic narrative.

7. Aussie house price plunge picked - Investec is forecasting Australian house prices will fall 20% by the end of 2014.

Investec Asset Management strategist Michael Power said while Australian property prices had fallen six per cent since 2010, he expected them to fall further in the next 18 months to two years.

"We're not seeing anything like the US, Irish or Spanish property bust here," the South African-based strategist told a business lunch in Sydney. "But I think over the next 18 months it could go down by double digits, 12 or even 15 (per cent). A 15 to 20 per cent (fall) would be my outside downside over the entire period."

8. Why QE III won't work - Here's PIMCO's Mohamed El Irian with his view:

 

9. Read this - Rebecca Macfie from the Listener has written a very important piece at The Listener about the delays in Christchurch.

“Insurance is a wonderful product,” says Dean Lester, who spent 25 years as an insurance underwriter and is now working to help hundreds of earthquake-hit Christchurch households make progress on their claims. “This should be the industry’s finest hour.” But it’s not. What ought to be a key tool of recovery is instead at risk of creating its own secondary disaster. Having come through the quakes, Cantabrians are being consumed by the bureaucratic liquefaction of our two-tier insurance system, and the prospect of years of fighting to get their homes back. For thousands of householders with wrecked and battered homes, trying to wrest any progress out of EQC and their private insurer involves a constant battle to piece together incomplete, fragmentary and often contradictory information.

10. Totally The Daily Show on political spin doctoring.

 

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

20 Comments

Big Gerry's screaming 'like a stuck pig ...... it seems some malcontents are not happy with the constant delays and the bureaucratic bungling in Christchurch   ........ and Gerry thinks they should like it & lump it ? .....

 

 ..... daft bugger ......

Up
0

Big Gerry certainly needs some spin doctoring!

 

Another calamity today announcing the closure (or may be not closure? The ministry doesn't even know let alone the ministers in charge) of over a dozen schools in ChCh.

 

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/7669865/13-Canterbury-schools-to-…

 

How is it that Gerry insists there has been no population exodus yet school rolls are down 10% and potentially dozens of schools will close or merge?  Easily 20,000 have left the city.  The phonebook entries support that figure, as do school roll figures.

 

Unfortunately there is a mutual hatred developing between the Minister and the TC3 victims, perhaps we should take Winston's advice (Churchill not Peters!) and fight Gerry ... on the beaches, ... in the fields and the streets ...

 

because ...we shall never surrender ... to bodged EQC repairs, and reduced indemnity payments!

 

Make the b#stards pay! 

 

Do we need lawsuits and elections to spur some action on?  Or perhaps just one of the Kaiser's pointy hats appropriately placed on the correct chair?

Up
0

Actually Gerry was there but this was the MOE show. The media jumped the embargo and mis-reported and a lot of detail has been missed.

Up
0

Hugh,

How do you respond to Brownlees insult?

He accused the survey respondents of "carping and moaning" about their situation, and said complainers were likely those who had time to "buggerise around on Facebook all day".

But you are right about this being a long-term prequake shambles, the quake has exposed the incompetant bureaucratic bungling.

Does anyone pretend that this is just restricted to Chch though?

This is the paradox for NZ, we all want the best in this that and the next thing, but we aren't really all that prepared to risk trying a different approach or hand power back to the citizens, even if there are better models overseas.

The now-professional class of politicians with no experience other than that of being a politician is a major part of the issue. How can you formulate good policy when either  occupied by trivia (the opposition) or too timid to really do necessary reforms (the govt). Scary thing is the younger politicans seem to be even worse, don't know how useful being a parliamentary staffer is to fomulating economic policy.

Up
0

The bigger councils are the worserer they are. End of story. Sorry, Auckland, you have decades of pain ahead of you.

 

Hugh, I agree with you totally.

 

My experience working inside councils showed me that (i) size matters: the bigger they are the less effective they are and (ii) once two or more agencies (councils, govt depts and agencies) are in a room  the hot air generated is in inverse proportion to the action taken.

Up
0

Interesting theory you posted there , Kumbel  : " the hot air generated ( once two or more agencies are in a room ) is in inverse proportion to the action taken . " .......

 

..... only a matter of time before WINZ or some local council appoint you as head of a committee to spend the next 5 years researching that theory  !

 

:-)

Up
0

:-) Just shoot me if I say yes (could do with the money though)

 

I know its cynical but the reality is that all public sector institutions have their own priorities and funding issues. They are not natural co-operators and when they do sit down together it is more often than not when they have no choice. So hot air and inaction are more common than outcomes that benefit the public.

 

Normally this has no more impact than being a cost of doing business but in the fluid situation in Christchurch the jockeying of too many public sector parties could be disastrous. HT Eric Crampton.

Up
0

Hugh - keep up the good work, "buggerise around on Facebook all day". Because whether you are 100% accurate or not, without what you and your colleagues are doing I think the institutions you critique would be even further away from 100% satisfactory performance, much to the detriment of all in ChCh.
 

Up
0

This video of Shirley Boys' High School principal John Laurenson is worth a watch: 

 

http://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/7674259/Principals-in-tears-as-ministry-swings-axe

 

Let's hope, Hugh, that the disease that appears to run through many of our government institutions doesn't morph from 'foot-in-mouth' to 'foot-&-mouth', otherwise it'll be all of NZ copping it, not just Christchurch.  

 

NZ deserves better leadership than we see failing day by day, by day.

Up
0

When John Key said "We are behind you, Christchurch" after the September quake I kind of thought he meant like a No 8 in a scrum - there working with everyone else. I didn't realise he meant it in the General Haig sense: drinking champagne in a French chateau while hundreds of thousands died miles away in the trenches of Passchendaele.

 

 

Silly me.

Up
0

Gerry Brownlee is the corpulent front-man or front-runner, the one that draws the unfriendly fire. An illusionist who waves his right hand, drawing the attention of the audience away from the action or inaction as the case may be, pretending to do something when in fact nothing is happening. The dummy run.

 

He is the perfect foil for the Government and John Key who turned up for the photo-ops in the days after. At least it appeared so. Although it is possible they used a horizon backdrop of photos or a mural for him to stand in front of. He wasn't behind Christchurch. Christchurch was behind him. It was hard to tell. Anyway John Key chose well.

 

Brownlee is the equivalent an offensive line-blocker in a game of Grid-Iron, where, the offensive line block for the ball carrier to prevent the defense from tackling him, or drop back a step and form a wall to protect the Quarter Back (John Key) on passing plays. Blocking is basically trying to push the opposition player out of the way. Key is MIA.

Up
0

This government is focused on paying down debt - here are some debts they could start with:

 

  • When governments helped themselves to homeowners' money to put into EQC they pledged to stand behind homeowners devastated by natural disaster EQC have had only one job to do since its inception and that is to get ready for this scale disaster. It's time to stand behind their promises.
  • When governments helped themselves to our money to fund DSIR (and now GNS) and Ministry of Civil Defence Management they gave a promise that they would map and mitigate the risks of natural disaster - they owe us big time on that promise
  • When governments granted territorial authorities the powers to control where and how our homes and workplaces are built and whether they can be occupied and to charge us for the privilege of being told what to do they promised us safety.
  • Last but not least when a woodwork teacher finds himself riding in limousines, living in a ministerial house in Central Wellingtion, dining at Bellamy's and lording it in the Koru Club he owes the taxpayers of  TC3 properties big-time because they are paying for all his baubles whie they wait for him to do his job.

 

I know this government has a strong love of off-balance sheet liabilities but these ones just popped onto the balance sheet. Less mouth, more action please.

Up
0

Be careful what you wish for guys, the Government & Council response to the 'leaky building' crisis was to disenfranchise those who hadn't caused it (the home renovator) and re-establish trade cartels, If you keep whinging you may get a response/cure that is worse than the issue because given the option bureaucrats will institute something that theu can't be blamed for

Up
0

If you think the leaky buildings was the owner’s fault then why are you feeling sorry for home owners in Christchurch? It the same silly bureaucracy mess that made the leaky building crises such a fiasco. It’s all finger pointing and the bureaucratic two-step.

Up
0

#4

Guessing the Communist Party will be history in 5 years or less? or will the Far East be engulfed in a massive war as they try to keep the restless population happy?

Up
0

SOP for governments in times of economic downturn. Bit of bellicose nationalism to provide distraction and unity. Reminds me of the Falklands.

Up
0

Gerry knows that the amount of crap you dump on NZers is directly proportional to your popularity. The more crap the more popular you are.

Bob Parker won and National won the whole of Christchurch.

So, go home, shut up, and enjoy being craped on. I say this because i bet you wont get of your bums and take direct action.

Up
0

"law"

Funny thing you scream nothing is happening but when the "leadership" propose some action to clear the way you think its "illegal".

They cant win can they.

You act like a fanatic so why dont you just declare a one man dictatorship as you so obviously wish for....

regards

Up
0

Hugh, I must concur, I haven't left National either, they left me.

 

When can we have sensible centre right thinking return to the National Party?  Why are private rights not respected?  Why is freedom being replacing by dictatorship?  Why is Central Government expanding it's influence?  What happened to fairness?

 

I can't understand.  Is there no one in the National Party hierachy who believes in the core values that National once stood for? 

 

What a sad situation NZ finds itself in.

Up
0

NZ starts to look for alternatives....times they are a changing...backed by Govn funding no less.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/7671273/Raw-material-replaceme…

 

regards

Up
0