The comment stream

Recent comments

Reader poll

Should you fix your mortgage now or stay floating?

Choices

Tender date extended, and UBNZ yet to lodge at OIO, in Crafar sale

Posted in Rural News

This high profile story continues, with announcements that the tender for the sale of Crafar properties has been extended, to allow time for interested parties to do due diligence.

Also it is interesting, that the Chinese backed bidder UBNZ has yet to relodge its application with the Overseas Investment Office, after falling short in its intial presentation.

Stronger dairy prices and Fonterra's bullish predicted payout for next season, will help boost competition for the sale.

But many will be looking for a quick closure here, as the issues of animal welfare, enviromental polution, large  expansion, and debt, were all highlighted in this family's operation, showing up some weakness in  the dairy industry's rapid expansion.

The date for tenders to be lodged for the Crafar portfolio of farms has been pushed back to give prospective buyers time to do due diligence on the properties reports The NZ Herald. Bayleys marketing agent Richard Graham said the decision was made to extend the close-off date by two weeks to July 7 because some of the information prospective buyers needed to evaluate the properties was not available as early as they would have liked.

Receivers for the farms announced last month they had signed a conditional sale agreement with May Wang's UBNZ - which is 80 per cent owned by New Zealand-based UBNZ Trustee Ltd and 20 per cent by Natural Dairy (NZ) Holdings Ltd - to purchase the farms. The sale is subject to OIO approval and the absence of a better offer. The Chinese-backed company fronting the bid has yet to relodge its application for OIO approval of the farms.

The OIO told Natural Dairy in April it needed more information about its proposed New Zealand acquisitions before it could bgin processing the application.It has yet to see the re-submitted application, together with the correct application fee, which is $22,000 per transaction.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment in the box on the right or click on the "'Register" link at the bottom of the comments. Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making these comments.

10 Comments

Maybe Natural Diary are

Maybe Natural Diary are waiting for the Yuan to be floated, at which point they will get a lot more NZ Dollars for their Chinese money thereby reducing the price.

LOL, yeah because the animals

LOL, yeah because the animals will be looked after so much better with China's animal rights record, which is probably comparable to their human rights record.

LOL, and shagging sheep isnt

LOL, and shagging sheep isnt against animial rights?

LOL no, and all these years

LOL no, and all these years you thought you within the law?

whats wrong with them buying

whats wrong with them buying the farms? as long as they pay the correct tax, employ local workforce, and doesnt compete with local industry, as i understand that most of their product will be shipped overseas as powdered milk.
Why does everything have to be so political now days?

Whats wrong, um well what

Whats wrong, um well what about the fact she owes 20 million in this country already that she definitely won't be paying back?

Also if farms are things that make very good money isn't it logical to want to keep them or am I just being crazy with that one?

It's not political, just logical.

Why are these farms being

Why are these farms being sold as one entity? Some should be listed separately so individuals and families could buy them, rather than a corporate. The average age of farm ownership and managers keep on rising in this country and we can't let that to continue, corporate farming just makes it worse. We will eventually get to the stage when very few family and generational farms exist and that will destroy the rural fabric and culture we once had

It's not too dissimilar to

It's not too dissimilar to the fishing industry is it? Over time, the small independant fishers give in and sell their small packets of quota onto the big boys who accumulate the big shares of the fisheries. Once the big boys have critical mass, they can control the price more and more and keep squeezing the little guys until they have no choice other than to sell up and exit.

in some cases the titles are

in some cases the titles are defective I do believe. Because of this and other issues it makes it a lot easier and more profitable for the real estate firm dealing with the sale.I believe the receivers should show some balls,fix the impediments and sell them individually.

I see May Wang owes money to

I see May Wang owes money to a golden funds company,you will see that Kerry Knight is behind this.Her Lawyer.And he is in there telling the others to take the 6 cents in the dollar of the 22 million see owes.This Genesis buy up is another fake jesture,you must think we are stupid over here Wang and Knight.We dont want people here that colude to make dairying an opportunity to make a fast buck.Stick to Property developements.Crafars have stuffed things up enough,bad press.
Give Crafars a break ,what a joke.They went on a buying spree with there share money,to loose with the cheques.