In this section
Rural Columnists
Offers for readers
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 20832
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 295
- ››
Rural news stream
Latest news
- Never a dull moment for the NZ$ 1
- Integrated kiwifruit marketer 'proves its worth'
- Fonterra farmer rep resigns over TAF 6
- AFFCO’s union dispute finally settled 1
- April trade surplus shrinks on dairy exports 7
- Livestock prices lift farmers capital values 8
- Door open for covered bonds from non-banks 22
- Why sheep farmers convert? 4
- Fonterra to tighten TAF rules 67
- Rabobank's NZ$19.6m quarterly profit
Most commented
- Dairy commodities continue price slump 159
- Fonterra to tighten TAF rules 67
- Fonterra shareholder choices 43
- Fonterra cuts payout forecast 30
- Fay group appeals Crafar sale, again 23
- Door open for covered bonds from non-banks 22
- Fonterra to work around TAF limitations 14
- 'Hike food & drink investment' 10
- Pastoral Dairy Investments cans public offer 9
- Demand for pasture fed antibiotic free beef 9
Most viewed
- Never a dull moment for the NZ$ 1
- Integrated kiwifruit marketer 'proves its worth'
- Livestock prices lift farmers capital values 8
- Fonterra farmer rep resigns over TAF 6
- Demand for pasture fed antibiotic free beef 9
- AFFCO’s union dispute finally settled 1
- Never a dull moment for the NZ$ 1
- Fonterra cuts payout forecast 30
- Studholme dairy plant ready for sale 1
- Fonterra to tighten TAF rules 67
Opinion: Should farmers be able to sell raw milk at the farm gate? Your view?
By Willy Leferink*
The future of raw drinking milk sales from the farm gate has Federated Farmers stepping back into the fresh milk issue.
The Federation believes farmers and consumers should have the option of selling and buying raw drinking milk from the farm gate.
What we’re consulting members on is the legal means to sell raw milk from the farm gate. Not that we want to compete with the supermarkets.
Why on earth would we when you can buy two litres of fresh milk cheaper at Karori New World than at Coles in Sydney? Perhaps some have realised consumers aren’t being ripped off; let’s face it milk has fallen off the electoral radar.
What we’re talking to our members about is the old ‘five litre rule’ for selling unpasteurised or raw milk from the farm gate.
These rules are long in the tooth and come from a time when pasteurised milk in rural areas was hard to get and fridges were a luxury item.
Federated Farmers believes farmers and consumers should have the ability to sell and buy raw drinking milk.
Related Topics
It’s why we need members to complete our online survey to give us the data we need. There are several options going forward and we need their help to form the right view.
One option is to enforce requirements for a registered Risk Management Programme (RMP) on farm gate sales of raw drinking milk.
That’s unattractive at the smaller sales end of a spectrum. Even the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (MAF) believes the cost involved with an RMP would see an end to most farm gate sales.
MAF's preferred option is audited self-management, which would see farms granted an exemption to an RMP.
In return, participating farms would have to meet certain animal health and hygiene requirements.
MAF is also proposing a daily sales limit of 120 litres and six litres per customer.
Going down that road would mean greater standards around storage, transportation and a paper trail to ensure compliance. A paper trail would also help in case the worst happened.
Farmers would also have to assume legal liability for what they sell but buyers would be subject to caveat emptor; ‘let the buyer beware’.
Members would have received the survey electronically. If not, they can to ring 0800 327 646 (0800 FARMING) or email policy advisor, Ann Thompson, at athompson@fedfarm.org.nz.
The survey will give us some vital information to inform MAF about what’s really happening.
Farmers and Federated Farmers can then help MAF write workable rules and policy that will shape the sale of raw milk at the farm gate.
--------------------
Willy Leferink is Federated Farmers dairy chairperson
9 Comments
We would welcome improved
We would welcome improved opportubities to buy raw milk, and more info on participating farms. A list on the fedfarm website would suffice.
BTW when I was in Sydney early this year, supermarket milk was about $1 to $1.25 per litre. It must have gone up a lot since.
Cheers
Yes please, I would LOVE the
Yes please, I would LOVE the opportunity to purchase raw milk. Even better if this is directly purchased.
Like John, I knew from research on the internet that a purchase of a few litres was legal, but information about just WHO to approach is totally lacking.......
I thought of asking at a local Farmer's Market......wonder if that could be a suitable venue for sale?
Anne: Currently farmers have
Anne: Currently farmers have to operate under a registered Risk Management Programme in order to sell milk directly.
This is the favoured MAF position going forward:
OPTION THREE (MAF's preferred option): Make limited amendments to conditions of sale, exempt farmers from the requirement to operate under an RMP, and require that dairy farmers meet certain animal health and hygiene requirements. This would see farmers
§ having to do a little extra around animal health and farm hygiene – Tb free, clean milking practices, clean (though not sterilised) equipment;
§ selling only at the farm gate (not delivering it to customers or sending it in a refrigerated van to a drop off point where those who had ordered it could come and collect it);
§ limiting the total volume per farm per day to 120L; maximum volume per customer of 6L (not 5L as is current)
§ storage requirements e.g. ≤ 6°C if storing it for longer than 2 hours
§ Keep records of who, when, how much is sold so that a food safety trail could be seen in case of illness, and also for enforcement of volume limit
§ Appropriate labelling
§ Farmers would be held accountable for food borne illness outbreaks and liable to prosecution, although buyers would purchase the milk on a ‘buyer beware’ basis.OPTION THREE (MAF's preferred option): Make limited amendments to conditions of sale, exempt farmers from the requirement to operate under an RMP, and require that dairy farmers meet certain animal health and hygiene requirements. This would see farmers
§ having to do a little extra around animal health and farm hygiene – Tb free, clean milking practices, clean (though not sterilised) equipment;
§ selling only at the farm gate (not delivering it to customers or sending it in a refrigerated van to a drop off point where those who had ordered it could come and collect it);
§ limiting the total volume per farm per day to 120L; maximum volume per customer of 6L (not 5L as is current)
§ storage requirements e.g. ≤ 6°C if storing it for longer than 2 hours
§ Keep records of who, when, how much is sold so that a food safety trail could be seen in case of illness, and also for enforcement of volume limit
§ Appropriate labelling
§ Farmers would be held accountable for food borne illness outbreaks and liable to prosecution, although buyers would purchase the milk on a ‘buyer beware’ basis.
I know some child health professionals who have a nazi like negative attitude towards giving children raw milk. It can be quite polarising in some circles.
One word, yup
One word, yup
why do we need the government
why do we need the government to tell us what we can drink?
A wee example of how we are
A wee example of how we are being milked in this land of the milked and Hone-Y.
In France the farmers have started selling milk DIRECT to the public, as long as processed to same STANDARD.
They had had enough of getting paid peanuts for their milk by the con-sortiums..
The STANDARD cost of 3 litres is about 1.75euros...
Compare ours.
Who is getting ripped orf...French Farmers...or ............NZ PUBLIC and by WHOM.....
FONT-error....?????
No that is not a font...error....it is par for the course....in sunny NZ.
Another example...
200gm BRIE....$1.75...NZ....here.....double....for 100gm.
CDC confirms not a single
CDC confirms not a single death in 11 years from raw milk:
http://www.naturalnews.com/034169_CDC_raw_milk.html
Besides, my doctor highly recommends the quality of raw milk.
Perhaps it is the European
Perhaps it is the European taxpayer that is getting ripped in in the massive subsidies the French farmers receive SL ;-)
Maybe..CO......but the wine
Maybe..CO......but the wine is 1Euro 30c....too...and the Beer is 39c for a 440ml can..
I like to subsidise too...where I CAN hit the bottle.....( I do luv to jest)....
The staples..of life ...eh....so far....so good. ...and I do not drink the milk...I use dairy creamer....
Way cheaper..too...in the UK....
And....yes other things are dearer.....like fuel....but cars way cheaper and smaller diesel....and the diesel don't ruin the engines...like shon-key stuff here....so last and last. and go on forever..
Even the JAP imports are way cheaper than here....and three time the distance to ship.
And houses are often cheaper, and will last a lifetime too....if ya can live 300years...
Unlike ours...which are just shacks, dressed up...and over priced and Leaky...as a rule.....which most IMMIGRANTS....will find out to their cost.
Naturally there are drawbacks.....in France as here...as Elley will attest.
Far to many Brits....escaping the doom.
But if you can succeed here, you can succeed anywhere...and the Problems are working around the idiots in Charge...same here..same there.
As you may have gathered I do not have much time for the problems...just how to work around em.
And knowledge is power....and the French have NUCLEAR....and we have....a shon-key infrastucture, that often fails......and they want to sell it orf to make money......THEY owe...
In their endless power games.....
As LABOUR borrowed their way into OBLIVION....without a nuclear explosion.
It ain't all negative.....I just like to point out the negatives.......and a few positives.
When the idiots run things.....it is small wonder we have HUGE problems...with a small population.....and shon-key tax laws and criminal minds and more GANGS and Welfare than most other NATIONS...per head of population..
TRUST ME...I have a blue chip...investment...etc.
And most of that is down to over borrowings......as a way of life....and the elderly get scammed, as the young are taught not to succeed.....and buy their own house.
No wonder we put money into PROPERTY...since 87....but the earthquakes will shake out a lot of the problems....and the slips and floods will help out too.
ALL...AT YOUR... EXPENSE....A taxpayer subsidy.........TOO.....as I am oft to REPEAT....never mind the milk, as we are milked daily.
No ZEAL-and is a wonderfull place to live.....and was even BETTER...in the good ole days....before MULDOOM and HELL-em....And Shipley...believe it or not.
Now it is just getting STUPID....a wee bit too controlling for me.
Hence why I rant.
It is a world-wide PHENOMENON....out of control...but controlling....and even the elections are RIGGED...by the BWANKERS....today.
Now if we could start again with a clean slate, wiped clean, just think what a country we could PRODUCE....plus GST of course...for SUM.