In this section
Rural Columnists
Offers for readers
The comment stream
Recent comments
- 1 of 25860
- ››
Editors choice
- 1 of 364
- ››
Rural news stream
Latest news
- A damn good idea 18
- National average market values 2013 1
- Off-road light diesel vehicles get RUC exemption
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Americans confident 5
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Downgrades coming ? 4
- S&P may cut TSB, Co-op, Heartland ratings 21
- Just add water 59
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Sinking data 2
- Purse strings loosened in Budget 2013 3
- Lowest since 2008
Most commented
- Going back is not going forward 77
- Just add water 59
- What the RBNZ's OCR decision means 54
- RBNZ holding OCR 'through end of 2013' 33
- Electrifying politics 30
- Go farming, young Kiwis 25
- Mortgage rate rises may follow opposition power policy 23
- S&P may cut TSB, Co-op, Heartland ratings 21
- Fake lamb in 'NZ' brand 21
- Fonterra may cut 300 jobs 21
Most viewed
- Tradable slaughter rights idea useful but may not be the answer 4
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Americans confident 5
- A damn good idea 18
- National average market values 2013 1
- Off-road light diesel vehicles get RUC exemption
- S&P may cut TSB, Co-op, Heartland ratings 21
- Just add water 59
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Sinking data 2
- 90 seconds at 9 am: Downgrades coming ? 4
- The Weekly Livestock report
Peter Kerr says our pastoral farming is an exclusive romantic brand, has the reassurance of science and is completely non-commodity. Is he right?

I’ll be the first to admit that the frilly, intangible, non-scientific aspects of what and how we produce our agricultural products can be a tricky little number to get your head around.
Much of what we’re good at doing as a nation is hard-edged, ‘proven’ – be it across on and off farm technical performance, engineering disciplines, the All Blacks even – all those things that you can measure and monitor.
But, for a moment let’s just sit and accept these quantifiable aspects.
What else does our agriculture offer?
In a word (and now it may get really uncomfortable) – ROMANCE.
That is, in a world that for most people (especially the ones with discretionary disposable income) is urban, concrete, and pressured, we represent an ideal.
We represent an image that is matched by a reality.
Related Topics
We are both olde world and modern; a ‘place’ where you have to work alongside nature using modern (including digital) tools, that still involves the type of honesty inherent in getting your hands dirty (literally). And, in a modern working world that mostly occurs inside a building, the thought of working outside, producing physical outputs by combining a range of inputs (climatic, prices, scientific, gut-feel) is a wonderfully beguiling thought.
Put another way, (modern, as opposed to peasant) farming, the way we do it, offers a back-story for the piece of meat in a supermarket, that very few other products can.
It is an image and reality that resonates with the heart.
But the fact that we haven’t named this (back) story means we can only deal with the cold, hard facts of matter. That’s all head stuff – and at that level all you’ve got to compete with is price.
My argument is, at an NZ Inc level, the moment we publicly and globally claim the mandate as being the world’s best at responsible pastoralism by naming our story, we provide ourselves with a completely offer to the world.
We would, in fact, step out of where we are now, and like the best movies, offer romance.
That we back this elusive romantic notion with the reassurance of science is totally synergistic, completely non-commodity. But maybe the idea of romance is naïve and unrealistic for our agriculture. Are we therefore doomed to remaining stuck in the mud?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Peter Kerr is a writer, specialising in simplifying science and technology. He has an agricultural science and industry background. You can contact him here »
This is the eighth in a series about pasture Harmonies.
The first one Branding our pastoral advantage is here »
The second one We're the only protein production systems that can say VISIT is here »
The third one Taking it for granted is costing us is here »
The fourth one Thinking beyond the actuality of how we produce is here »
The fifth one For want of a name ... is here »
The sixth one The way you'd farm if you farmed yourself is here »
The seventh one, more than the sum of its parts is here »









25 Comments
Oh please, enough already of
Oh please, enough already of this romanticized bollocks, you ever spent time on a large dairy unit in the middle of spring?
We are well past the point of trying to romanticise modern farming in a system geared to supplying bulk commodity at a (near) lowest global price....small scale UK farms would have an easier time telling a rustic digitally assisted peasant story than ours would when 40% here are struggling to even pay the bills under our existing system....
Agreed. At least your
Agreed.
At least your comment remains (for now) - mine on this contributor's propaganda get censored/deleted.
Add to that the fact GE
Add to that the fact GE supplement feed having been admitted a litle while ago, you can forget about dreaming up some old fashioned marketing story. I am not buying it. What's more, our household has decided to buy all foodstuffs certified organic whenever available. Complete boycott of the mainstream food production as we are sick and tired of being lied to by the FMCG indsutry in the mistaken belief that we are gullible consumers. Slowly but surely the tide will turn...
I think the tide is slowly
I think the tide is slowly turning - as indicated by the bigger and more desperate lies needed to maintain the neo-classical economic belief system.
The NZ National party
The NZ National party believes the future of farming in NZ is corporate, have a read of our future
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smithfield_Foods
And what did I say three
And what did I say three years back here A.J.....BingF*#*ingGo.
Corporatisation was always the agenda.
Peter Kerr's image of Kiwi
Peter Kerr's image of Kiwi dairy farming isn't resonating with the reality in your heart ?
...... he should write for Mills & Boon !
Do they do tragedies?
Do they do tragedies?
He seized her , in his strong
He seized her , in his strong manly arms ..... Clarabell felt a flush upon her cheeks , and a quiver of expectant excitement rippled through her udder as he raising the cups to her fulsome teats ..... she knew she could not hold back , she must offer up her milk , all of it , to this strong irresistable masculine force .....
..... ah , the romance of the 5 a.m. milking !
i want to know how it ends
i want to know how it ends
...... she was spent , fully
...... she was spent , fully exhausted .... she had given her all , and knew that she had satisfied her man like no other could ...... she pressed her blood engorged ruby red lips up against his ear , and whispered " moooo ! "
Moos & Boon : The Dairy Chronicles .
Peter Kerr says our pastoral
Peter Kerr says our pastoral farming is an exclusive romantic brand and is complete comedy.
"moooo ! ".......wow ! it
"moooo ! ".......wow ! it just sounds so much better than " Baaaa ! " makes a man feel a mite less sheepish too.
Are they going to pen a Watershed Down ..?
Pull the other one. A load of
Pull the other one.
A load of bull.
You have never milked a cow in yer life....Gummy...doesn't bear thinking about.
AJ - National is not the only
AJ - National is not the only political party with that belief......and that leaves NZ'ers with very limited options left in the tick box on election day.
http://www.amazon.com/Tomatol
http://www.amazon.com/Tomatoland-Industrial-Agriculture-Destroyed-Alluri...
Not just Tomatoes. Same with
Not just Tomatoes.
Same with Milk...
Same with all fruit....
Same with chickens and all other animals.
Not a natural product left any more. Hormones added, etc.
All been tampered with and bulked up for quick growth & sale. Hence profits.
There seems some correllation between increased illnesses and poor health and these altered products.
As send out from the office
As send out from the office of Phillip Palmer.
I ask you is this:
(a) a company of likeminded suppliers looking to get best return for their product, or
(b) a corporation focussed on market segment development to raise share prices.
I think almost everyone here has experience with company and business strategy and focus, I'll let you make up your own mind. (I ask you, what is the one big thing missing on the strategy...)
Subject: Fw: Council meeting notes.
Season’s Greetings to everybody in the Fonterra Family in Ward 28. ( Wairarapa.)
Please see below, a summary of the November Shareholders Council meeting.
The Director Candidate Road show is in its final day, today. The meeting in Palmerston North on Wednesday evening, was well attended, as has all the meetings in the North Island this week. Twice as many Shareholders have attended this year as opposed to last year.
It's now up to all Shareholders. If you have not already voted, then please HUNT OUT YOUR VOTING PAPERS AND CAST YOUR VOTE.
It is very important to vote, not only for the Director Candidates, but also the seven ordinary business resolutions (requiring 50% support) and two special resolutions ( requiring 75% support) to be put to the Annual Meeting on the 17th of December in Hamilton.
OF PARTICULAR IMPORTANCE IS RESOLUTION 8. The passing of this resolution will further strengthen 100% ownership and control and will put further constitutional protections around the Fund size and the Milk Price.
Unless you intend to attend the AGM in person, VOTING CLOSES AT 10.30am on SATURDAY THE 15th of DECEMBER 2012.
Please call me if you require further information.
I trust the season continues to go well for you all, and that you have a very Happy Christmas with family and friends, and a prosperous new year.
Kind regards to all,
Philip Palmer,
Councillor for Ward 28,
Deputy Chairman of the Shareholders Council.
063725752. 0272435816.
Council meeting 27 and 28 November
Co-operative Affairs
Governance Representation Review - Insiders discussion
Board/Council interface - Governance, the SOIs, TAF, Contract Milk
SOIs
SVM
TAF Bookbuild
Milking Time Windows
Governance and Representation Review
Jason Minkhorst, Managing Director RD1
Regional Engagement Group
Other business
Committee Reporting
Performance Committee
Representation Committee
Governance and Ethics Committee
Co-operative Development Committee
· Presented their ideas for optimising the UYCP and Fonterra in Action Seminars for 2013.
mist42nz, Who are 'The
mist42nz,
Who are 'The friends of Fonterra who recieved %100 of their requested share allocation'?
Is this the Banks or just some form of mepotisim?
Not living in NZ Im finding it harder to keep up with whats happening, afaid it doesn't look good for you lot.
Andrewj
This article may explain the
This article may explain the situation for you AJ.
http://www.stuff.co.nz/waikato-times/business/8054297/NZ-Inc-put-out-about-Fonterra-allocation
Eligible ex Fonterra suppliers had to have ceased supplying milk after the initial TAF vote (which was nothing more than a misleading PR white-wash campaign led by Henry and fellow board lackeys), so I think that was within three years.
Chalkies evocation of David Parkers bi partisan stance on the percieved debt owed by Fonterra is illustrative and symptomatic with the tradegy that is the demise of the co-operative dairy industry (excluding Westland and Tatua) and the undermining of agricutural structures which fundamentally support the traditional family farm in general. The ultimate price of Fonterras debt seems to be foreign ownership, evidenced by allocation of share or units or securities or whatever you want to call them to foreign domiciled investment firms. Although Chalkie is jumping up and down about NZ INC not receiving a greater allocation, lets face it, the kiwi investors would have just clipped the ticket for a few peanuts, onselling the securities to investors with deeper pockets and greater domestic political clout, that being foreign domociled. But as the horse has bolted on the co-op industry, I'm sympathic with his point, why not let kiwis clip the ticket on the way through?
It is misleading and intellectually unsound to suggest we are better off since the formation of Fonterra, as David Parker and members of the opposition frequently do. Fonterras performance has been mediocre at best, little different to the nearest co-op competitors. Verticle integration has only allowed executive pay packets and governance renumeration to skyrocket, lapping up any streamlind saving. We sell commodity products, reacting nimbly to market requirements is dramatic exageration. The NZ consumer is not better off, the only real benefactors being a few politicians who formed investor owned competitor companies on the back of DIRA subsidised milk, and priviledged Fonterra shareholders who have had 100+ years of cooperative development capital, earnt on the back of previous generations efforts, transfered to their balance sheets, via the cooperatively undermining Fair Value Share. The investor owned competitor companies have hardly driven innovation through genuine competition as argued DIRA will insure.
So would I be right in
So would I be right in thinking this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism
ending in this
By Don Kirk in Crony Capitalism Insidious Socialism, Ethics, Socialism's "intellectual suicide"
Yesterday’s New York Times has an article on the 70 year old Wen Jiabao, prime minister of the People’s Republic of China and leader of the Communist Party, retiring with a personal fortune estimated at 2.7 billion dollars. His mother was a school teacher her entire life, his father tended pigs during the Cultural Revolution, and Mr. Wen has been a government functionary his entire life, growing up as a boy “in extreme poverty.”
Clearly Mr. Wen never accumulated his family fortune as a risk-taking capitalist. Just as clearly, the morality of communism is government-sanctioned theft. Whether capitalist or communist, as Acton noted long ago, “Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”
I don't know why when lord Acton gets quoted they never finish the quote? I will
Great men are almost always bad men."
One could be forgiven for
One could be forgiven for thinking so. Deregulation, DIRA and FVS was going to foster a dynamic innovative progressive dairy industry that will deliver worthwhile progress to farmers and NZ. Still waiting.
I don't know, but gut feeling I would agree with Colin Ridens comments above about the imbalances inherent in neo classical economic dogma, in the sense the percieved wealth creation from leveraging historic cooperative capital hasn't enhanced farmers self determination and actualisation, but ironically increased our debt burden and subservience to others.
Agreed Omnologo. But a few
Agreed Omnologo.
But a few did, and for the most part still are doing, very well out of the changes.
That was probably no accident, but it appears we now need to extend the earlier changes to keep the wealth trickling up.
Great men are almost always
Great men are almost always bad men."
Hah - you don't even have to be great in New Zealand - just plain old self serving greed suffices as justification.
we could make 'great'
we could make 'great' relative i suppose.