By Bernard Hickey
The last fortnight's dramas on financial markets is really just the sound of investors waking up to some fundamental problems in the global economy.
It is now dawning on the world's biggest fund managers that there is too much debt weighing on both households and governments in the developed world.
More importantly, they realise there will not be enough economic growth and income to repay those debts over the next 10-20 years.
That means governments might default or print money to repay the debt. Bank shareholders and bondholders may have to realise massive losses or face high inflation. Growth will be much slower and for longer than many expected. Slower economic grow might mean lower corporate profits and lower share prices.
After nearly four years of urgent fixes, emergency measures, bank bailouts, debt shuffles and government pump priming without any real improvement, there is a dawning realisation that something is broken at the heart of the global economy.
It's surprising to hear where some of these doubts about the future of capitalism are coming from.
Some of the world's biggest capitalists are now asking some fundamental questions about whether the type of globalised, free market-driven capitalism we have now is sustainable.
Bill Gross is the world's most important fund manager. He runs PIMCO, which is the world's biggest bond fund with US$1.3 trillion in assets. He commented this week that the hollowing out of America's free-spending middle classes was at the heart of the problem.
He pointed out that for several decades the engine room of America's consumer economy had been starved of income as high paid manufacturing jobs were exported to lower paid factories in China and as technological innovation replaced workers with machines. For 20 years the middle classes had made up the gap by borrowing more and governments had helped in recent years by also borrowing more to supplement their incomes.
Meanwhile, the extra profits made because of these lower labour costs were shuffled up to those on higher incomes and increasingly to an ageing group of capital owners who weren't able or willing to spend all those profits. Increasingly, wealth and income is being concentrated in the hands of those who can't or won't spend it. This is starving the consumer economy of the oxygen it needs to keep growing.
Hedge fund manager Jeremy Grantham has also picked up on this structural problem this week. He pointed to a doubling in the share of American income going to the top 1% of income earners to 20% in the last 30 years. That richest group are now hoarding that cash in the safest things they can get their hands on. Increasingly, that means gold and, ironically, US Treasury bonds, despite their credit rating downgrade this month.
Grantham has put his finger on the core problem with unfettered capitalism. It works to shift wealth to the richest, but can eventually topple over under the weight of itself when that wealth is hoarded and not reinvested or spent.
Grantham should know about how the rich work. His firm manages more than US$100 billion worth of funds and doesn't accept any amounts less than US$10 million.
Yet even he is saying it is now time to reset capitalism. He wants to see mortgage debt for America's overburdened middle classes forgiven. That means forcing bank shareholders and bondholders to take big losses. He wants to see tax rates on the wealthiest rise back to the levels seen in the 1950s and 1960s.
He is harking back to a time when America's middle classes powered the growth the world's biggest economy. They earned enough to buy the consumer goods their factories produced. Even Henry Ford, one of the most aggressive capitalists of the 20th century, decided to increase his workers' wages so they could buy his Model T cars.
These problems are not limited to America. The share of income going to the top 1% in New Zealand also more than doubled after the mid 1980s to almost 14% of income by the early 2000s. Last year's tax cuts will have worsened that.
The trickle down theory will not be enough to save capitalism. Even the biggest capitalists are realising that now.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.