By Bernard Hickey
New Zealand has just gone through an election campaign as if in a daze.
See our Live Election night blog on National's second term win here.
We woke up the morning after that teeth-grindingly tense World Cup Final and the party that followed with a bad case of blurred vision.
National and Labour talked past each other and the voters early in the campaign with an ultimately pointless exercise in fiscal jujitsu. They sparred with each other but ultimately no one could work out who was right. There's a good case for Treasury to actually do the costings for each party's policies as well as produce the Pre-election Fiscal Update (PREFU) after this year's bout of he-said-this and he-said-that.
Both parties blithely paraded on up and down the country ignoring the storm brewing over the seas in Europe, America, China and Australia.
They were both relaxed about assuming -- and that's all it was really -- that growth will power the budget deficit back into surplus within three years. Neither were willing to address the structural deficit worth around 3-4% of GDP that they both baked in over the last six years through tax cuts, Working for Families and Interest Free Student loans.
Neither major party, and none of the minor parties, have prepared a Plan B (that we know about) if Europe's financial system and economy implodes in shower of banking collapses, production slumps, social strife and political turmoil.
Both John Key and Phil Goff simply stared off into the distance and pointed at the Treasury's PREFU forecasts for a growth revival as their fig leaf for denying the storm existed. The economic forecasts in that PREFU were finalised on September 26. That was 8 weeks ago, which is an eon in the life of financial markets.
Since then both the Greek and Italian governments have collapsed, the Spanish ruling party was voted out and Europe's economy has slumped quickly towards a deep and dangerous recession. Europe's banks are unable to borrow from each other or US money markets. Instead they are now reliant on a European Central Bank, as increasingly are the governments of Spain, Italy, Portugal and Greece. Even Germany, right at the heart of Europe, failed this week to sell its bonds.
America's Congress failed again to tackle a massive budget deficit and China's factory output fell this month for the first time since the Lehman crisis. Australia cut its official interest rates in response to a rapidly cooling economy and its house prices are now falling faster than at any time since the Lehman crisis.
Yet neither John Key or Phil Goff told the voters what they would do to shelter New Zealand from this gathering storm. Would they cut government spending? Would they increase taxes? Would they borrow even more? Or would they do all three and collectively cross their fingers that everything will be OK.
We'll find out in the days ahead if Key had a Plan B carefully written and placed in the bottom drawer or weather he will just make it up as he goes along.
I'm not sure which is worse. Knowing the politicians were preparing to break their promises or knowing the politicians had no idea what to do if they were forced to break their promises.
I'd much rather know and prepare than not know and hope it'll be alright on the night.
Either way we should get ready for New Zealand's political and economic leadership to introduce us all to a giant dose of financial Berocca.
Because the full hangover starts tomorrow.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.