The Pre Black Friday emails have started arriving in my inbox. I’m usually pretty good at ignoring them, but when my favourite furniture store has the perfect outdoor café style table and chairs, I just couldn’t resist the 50% off banner headline. (I will be very grumpy if that increases to 70% when the full-on Black Friday sales start). The spender in me went straight to a Freddy Mercury moment – I want it now!
Then it will be the Christmas ads, the end-of-year functions, the secret Santa, the teacher gifts, the "we should catch up before Christmas" drinks. Before you know it, the season has made a whole lot of decisions about your money without ever really asking you.
I'd like to suggest a different approach this year. Instead of a Christmas budget, make a Christmas money plan.
What's the difference between a budget and a money plan?
A couple of weeks ago I wrote about revisiting my very first money talk from 2018. Of all the things I've changed my mind about since then, budgets top the list.
The trouble with budgets is that most of them are built around restriction. A list of things you're not allowed to do. And as anyone who has ever tried a strict diet knows, restriction tends to work right up until the moment it doesn't, and then it collapses all at once. Usually somewhere around the Boxing Day sales, or seeing all the leftover sweet stuff in the fridge.
I was never very good at sticking to the Christmas gift budget for presents, each year there would be a few presents from the cat and dog, usually way over budget, when I got ‘that look’ for overspending, I would innocently reply, they had been saving their pocket money. I wouldn’t recommend this if you want a harmonious Christmas day.
A money plan starts from a different place. It begins with what matters to you, then works out how to fund that. It's flexible, it changes as life changes, and it treats you as an adult who is capable of making trade-offs rather than a child who needs rules. Once I adopted this approach, the pets no longer needed to go Christmas shopping.
Start with what Christmas is for, for you.
Before you open a spreadsheet, try asking yourself one question. When you think back on Christmases you've loved, what made them good?
I've asked this question of a lot of people over the years, and the answers are remarkably consistent. Being together. A particular meal. A tradition from childhood. The kids' faces. A long, lazy day at the beach. Hardly anyone ever says "the presents" (unless you are under the age of about 12), and nobody has ever said, "the amount we spent".
That tells you where your money matters most this season. If the heart of Christmas for you is the family lunch, then that's where generosity belongs. If it's getting away somewhere together, that's your priority. Everything else can be a little more modest without anyone feeling short-changed.
A simple festive money plan
Once you know what Christmas is for, the plan itself is quite straightforward.
First, decide on a total you can genuinely afford. Not a hopeful number, and not a number that relies on January's pay to cover it. Look at what you have now and what's coming in before Christmas.
Next, put your priorities first. Fund the things that matter most, then see what's left for everything else.
Then remember the hidden costs. Gifts get all the attention, but much of Christmas spending sneaks in elsewhere: the extra groceries, the petrol for the road trip, the bottle of wine for every host, the new outfit for the work function, the kids at home for six weeks. Give those a line in the plan too.
Finally, decide in advance how you'll handle Black Friday. Make a short list of things you were going to buy anyway, and if one of them is genuinely on special, buy it. If something isn't on the list, the discount isn't a saving. It's just spending at a slightly lower price.
The conversations that make it easier
One of the gentlest ways to take pressure off Christmas is to talk about it early. Many families are quietly relieved when someone suggests a secret Santa instead of buying for everyone, or a spending limit for the cousins, or experiences instead of things.
If you're in a relationship, talk with your partner too. Couples often carry very different Christmas money stories. One of you may have grown up with a mountain of presents under the tree, and the other with one carefully chosen gift each. Neither is wrong, but if you don't talk about it, those stories can collide on the 24th of December.
Give yourself permission to change the plan
A money plan isn't a contract. If something unexpected happens, such as a friend in need or a last-minute guest, you can adjust. That's the whole point. What matters is that you're making the choice consciously, with your eyes open, rather than looking at your bank statement in January and wondering how it happened.
Christmas is meant to be enjoyed. With a little planning now, you get to enjoy it twice: once on the day, and again in January when the bills arrive and there are no unpleasant surprises.
*Lynda Moore is a Money Mentalist coach and New Zealand’s only certified New Money Story® mentor. Lynda helps you understand why you do the things you do with your money, when we all know we should spend less than we earn. You can contact her here.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.