Patrick Watson sees cracks appearing in the bull market and says now's the time to look for opportunities to take profits and reduce exposure

Patrick Watson sees cracks appearing in the bull market and says now's the time to look for opportunities to take profits and reduce exposure

By Patrick Watson*

You may have noticed stocks have stopped going straight up. By itself, that’s not scary. Bull markets and high volatility can coexist, and often did until the last few years.

No, the scary part is that bull markets fall apart slowly.

Smaller cracks accumulate to set up the big breaks. History shows 2008 was a terrible year — but the Dow had peaked months earlier, in October 2007.

Even in 2008, the bull took a long time to collapse. The Bear Stearns collapse in March was even followed by a nice rally because people thought the worst was over. But six months later Lehman went bankrupt, and then it was six more months before the final bottom in March 2009.

So, like the metaphorical frog in boiling water, you can be in the middle of a bull market’s unraveling and not even know it — or at least not know how bad it will get or when it will end.

That should worry you because right now, the number of cracks is growing while the ability to patch them up is not. Let’s look at just three of those cracks.

Photo: Getty Images

Crack #1: Cryptocurrencies

Last fall, investors went crazy for crypto, mainly Bitcoin. Prices climbed fast as “fear of missing out” caused near-panic buying in some quarters.

Panic buying is almost always a mistake, and sure enough, bitcoin fell from its peak of $19,000 in December to below $7,000 today.

Bitcoin fans are undeterred and convinced it will be back. Maybe so. But the more immediate effect is that crypto-mania soaked up a lot of uninformed risk capital that is now less able — and probably less willing — to take the risk of buying stocks.

This is important because according to Dow Theory, “distribution” is the first phase of a primary downtrend. That’s when the last buyers enter the market, buying stocks from big sellers who perceive signs of trouble. It gets worse from there… eventually a lot worse.

In this case, the distribution phase could already be near its end if those last few buyers already spent (and often lost) their cash on other, non-equity assets like cryptocurrencies.

Photo: Getty Images

Crack #2: Bond yields

We entered 2018 knowing the Fed would both raise interest rates and reduce its bond portfolio. Those two factors might have been manageable, but others soon followed.

The tax cuts Congress passed in December, combined with subsequent spending bills, are driving up the federal budget deficit faster than most expected. That’s forcing the US Treasury to sell more bonds, which puts even more upward pressure on bond yields… while the Fed is already tightening.

Higher bond yields, in turn, make stock dividends a less attractive income source. At the end of March, the S&P 500 dividend yield was 1.85% and the one-year Treasury yield was 2.08%.

Yes, stocks have capital gains potential and T-bills don’t. But the bull market is nine years old now. It could continue — but it could also reverse, handing you capital losses as well as subpar yield.

To choose stocks now, you must accept lower income in exchange for higher principal risk. A growing number of buyers don’t like that deal.

The stock market doesn’t need aggressive selling to make prices fall. Reduced buying interest could do the same thing.

Photo: Getty Images

Crack #3: Tech trouble

Every bull market has leaders. This one has depended heavily on a handful of giant technology stocks, namely Apple (AAPL), Amazon (AMZN), Facebook (FB) and Google’s parent company Alphabet (GOOGL). All these are having problems.

Apple’s expensive new iPhone X didn’t sell as well as expected, and Google Chromebooks are capturing its once-dominant position in schools and colleges.

Amazon is getting attacked by none other than the President of the United States himself, who says it is hurting small retailers and taking unfair advantage of the US Postal Service. Old-fashioned retailers are fighting back too.

Facebook’s success in gathering personal data to use for advertising has thrown the company’s whole business model into question. Regulators and lawyers are circling like vultures.

Google’s ad sales and data collection are also getting some negative attention, as is its near-monopoly position in many markets. Investors are starting to question the future.

These companies will likely survive and remain profitable. But their currently handsome profit margins probably won’t, and it’s already showing in their stock prices. That’s problematic for a bull market built on their once-reliable growth.

Photo: Getty Images

What to do

Those three cracks, plus others I haven’t mentioned, don’t necessarily mean a crash is imminent. We can’t even rule out a renewed uptrend — stranger things have happened.

For one, first-quarter earnings reports will probably look pretty good, but the tax cuts are funding share buybacks and debt reduction rather than pay raises and capital investments.

In other words, companies are effectively

  • eating dessert first while
  • avoiding their vegetables.

That’s fun for a while, but eventually makes you sick. So I still think the risk of further losses outweighs the risk of missing further gains.

A cracked vase doesn’t spontaneously heal itself. The cracks get worse with time, not better.

In the last bear market, the ideal strategy would have been to either exit near the late-2007 peak or hold on through the whole storm. Few investors did either of those. Instead, they waited and then sold at lower prices. That wasn’t the intent, but it is what happened.

If you believe the top is in, now is the time to act. At the very least, start looking for opportunities to take profits and reduce exposure. Do it on your own terms, not the terms the market gives you. You’ll be glad you did.

See you at the top.


*Patrick Watson is senior economic analyst at Mauldin Economics. This article is from a regular Mauldin Economics series called Connecting the DotsIt first appeared here and is used by with permission.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.


And keep that powder dry folks, bargains are on their way.

Crack 1 : the total value invested in cryptocurrencies worldwide is tiny , a few hundred $ billion ... as much fun as it is to watch the bubble rise and burst , it has little impact upon the real world economy ....

Crack 2 : the bond market is the elephant in the room ( unless Paula Bennett is also in the room ) ... this is the biggie to watch very closely ...

Crack 3 : we will all benefit when the giant techs Google and Facebook are brought to heal by the regulators ... as we've all benefitted since Microsoft's near monopoly on software was busted up 20 years ago ...

... Crack 4 : Donald Trump's tariff trade war with China ... oooooh .... this could turn nasty ...

Reading the title: 3 cracks... I was thinking 1) rising interest rates 2) trade wars on their way and I was curious ablout the the 3rd crack

Interest rates and stocks both rose in tandem in the 1920s and 1980s, to name just two examples. Taking profits and investing elsewhere is all well and good, but where exactly? As interest rates rise, a lot of highly leveraged property will tank, so that’s probably not a good move. Money in the bank? Hardly, given that the next bank bailouts will be funded by depositors. Govt bonds?’ll have more luck getting paid back by a drunken sailor. Maybe, just maybe, equities are rising because there’s nowhere else to go? Just asking the question that no economist seems to be asking...

Martin Armstrong has been shouting for years that US stocks DOW will be 40,000 by flow analysis and the flight to safety..definintely NOT Govt bonds.

There will be some stocks that will do well even as the majority fall. I think fast food has form for running counter to the rest of the market.

Yup they do very well in recession times due to changes in consumer habits, the restaurant treats go out the window to be replaced by cheaper alternative treats.

What will be the impact on Kiwisaver funds which many New Zealanders now think will keep going up and up always, just like property ? No easy exit is possible, people are in the long haul there.

I am struggling to work out just who this article is aimed at. There is no new or surprising content-any reasonably experienced stockmarket investor already knows that this market is overstretched.

I have been gradually increasing my cash holdings for well over a year now and currently,it represents 12% of my total portfolio. two years ago,it was around 5%. Of course,this means that I have missed some of growth,but I think that I am quite well placed to take advantage of lower prices,as and when the inevitable correction takes place.

Your access to our unique content is free - always has been. But ad revenues are under pressure so we need your direct support.

Become a supporter

Thanks, I'm already a supporter.