sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Dave Ananth explains why he likes the updated view from Inland Revenue on how it will be dealing with tax disputes and settlement options, one where balanced judgements are required

Personal Finance / opinion
Dave Ananth explains why he likes the updated view from Inland Revenue on how it will be dealing with tax disputes and settlement options, one where balanced judgements are required
tax dispute

The Commissioner’s interpretation of section 6A recognises that sound tax administration must take account of the real world. The new guidelines explain how Inland Revenue approaches settlement.

On 23 December 2025, Inland Revenue issued Interpretation Statement IS 25/26, replacing its 2010 statement on the Commissioner’s duty of care and management under section 6A of the Tax Administration Act 1994.

On 18 November 2026, Inland Revenue issued Operational Guideline OG 26/01, replacing its August 2023 guidelines on section 6A settlements. The new guideline reflects IS 25/26 and sets out how Inland Revenue approaches settlement decisions.

I welcome this as a positive step by the Commissioner. Section 6A should recognise that tax administration has to operate in the real world. That matters to businesses facing a tax dispute, to taxpayers trying to resolve an issue and to Inland Revenue itself.

A tax dispute can take years. It can involve uncertain facts, difficult questions of law, substantial records, professional costs and management time. The amount Inland Revenue says is at stake is only one part of the picture. The dispute also has to be considered in terms of the evidence, the risks, the cost of continuing and what is likely to be collected over time.

Section 6A requires the Commissioner to collect the highest net revenue that is practicable within the law. The Commissioner must have regard to the resources available, the importance of promoting compliance, especially voluntary compliance, and the compliance costs incurred by taxpayers. Section 6 requires the Commissioner to protect the integrity of the tax system. These duties must be read together.

The new guidelines do not change section 6A. Inland Revenue says the 2026 guidelines use the same framework as the 2023 version because the substantive process remains unchanged. What has changed is the interpretation statement that now sits behind them. IS 25/26 replaces the 2010 statement and gives a fuller account of the relationship between sections 6 and 6A.

That is an important distinction. This is not a new statutory power, and the guidelines do not give a taxpayer an automatic right to a settlement. They explain how the Commissioner says an existing power should be used.

Applying the law and settling a dispute

The law must be applied correctly. Section 6A does not give Inland Revenue a licence to disregard the legislation or grant concessions outside the law.

But applying the law to determine Inland Revenue’s view of a taxpayer’s liability is one question. Whether to settle a dispute about that liability is another. A settlement is a compromise of the outcome. It is different from Inland Revenue changing its view after receiving new information or reconsidering how the law applies.

The new guidelines define settlement as accepting an outcome that does not fully reflect the amount the Commissioner considers payable under the law as applied to the relevant facts. They say the starting point is that, where the facts are clear and the law is settled, the law must generally be applied correctly. But they also recognise that there may be a basis for settlement even when the strict legal position is clear.

That is not an invitation to choose an arbitrary number. The decision has to be justified by the circumstances and by the duties in sections 6 and 6A. A taxpayer’s offer needs to be assessed against the real risks, costs and likely outcomes of continuing the dispute. 

Voluntary compliance matters

The most important point in the new guidelines is that Inland Revenue recognises that an overly rigid approach can undermine compliance.

That sentence matters to businesses and to taxpayers generally. A tax system depends on people complying voluntarily. If people see Inland Revenue refusing to consider the actual evidence, the prospects of success, the cost of continuing or the likely recovery, they may regard the system as mechanical rather than fair.

The opposite risk is there too. If Inland Revenue settles too readily, or accepts an offer that is too low, taxpayers may conclude that taking an aggressive position is likely to produce a discount. That would also undermine compliance. The guidelines require the Commissioner to consider both risks and to reach a reasoned decision.

This is why settlement is not simply about one taxpayer’s ability to pay or the amount offered. The Commissioner must consider how a settlement would affect the tax system as a whole. Would it encourage voluntary compliance? Would other taxpayers see the result as fair? Would the issue affect a wider group or set a precedent? Would continuing the dispute clarify the law?

Sometimes the answers will point towards continuing. Sometimes they will support settlement. The important point is that the decision should be made by considering the circumstances, not by applying an inflexible rule that every dispute must be pursued to the end.

The real issues in a settlement decision

The guidelines identify six matters for Inland Revenue to weigh, but they are not a formula. The weight of each matter depends on the case.

The effect on voluntary compliance and the integrity of the tax system is central. A taxpayer’s past compliance, the steps taken to correct an error and the likelihood of future compliance may all be relevant. So may the way the issue arose. The guidelines say a full voluntary disclosure or an application for a ruling can indicate that a taxpayer is trying to get things right and should not generally be viewed negatively in a settlement decision. Incorrect Inland Revenue guidance may also be relevant, particularly when considering penalties or interest.

The strength of the dispute matters. Risk can arise from uncertainty in the law, disputed facts, the quality of the evidence, disagreement between experts, a witness’s credibility or a procedural issue. It is not enough to say that Inland Revenue considers its legal argument strong if the evidence or procedure creates a real risk in the case.

Resources and costs matter as well. Inland Revenue has to consider the staff, legal and other resources required to continue and whether those resources could be used more effectively elsewhere. The taxpayer’s compliance costs are also relevant. In a difficult dispute, the costs of continuing may become significant for both sides.

The amount of tax at stake and the wider importance of the issue also affect the decision. A dispute that could determine Inland Revenue’s position for an industry or a large group of taxpayers may need to continue so the law can be clarified. A dispute turning on one taxpayer’s particular facts may have less precedential value. The amount involved is relevant, but no single factor decides the issue by itself.

The final consideration is the taxpayer’s ability to pay. That needs to be approached carefully. Being unable to pay the full amount immediately does not, by itself, justify reducing the tax in dispute. The question is whether settling now could produce more revenue over time than continuing the dispute and attempting collection later. If the issue is how an accepted debt should be paid, an instalment arrangement, remission or write-off may be the proper route instead.

A dispute may be settled early

The guidelines confirm that Inland Revenue can consider settlement before the formal disputes process begins, including before it issues a Notice of Proposed Adjustment. Inland Revenue must have enough information to understand the taxpayer’s position and make an informed decision. In limited circumstances, it may be sufficient to have a reasonable understanding of the amount at stake, even if the precise amount has not yet been determined.

IS 25/26 notes that the courts have not specifically considered settlement before the formal disputes process or litigation begins. The Commissioner’s view is that there is no impediment in principle, provided there is enough information to make a proper decision. That is useful for businesses and taxpayers who may be able to resolve an issue before the expense and formality of a full dispute take hold. 

The process still has to be followed. An appropriately delegated decisionmaker must consider the relevant factors and record the reasons for the decision. A settlement cannot simply be a “split the difference” figure chosen to bring the matter to a close. The guidelines also distinguish settlement from other forms of relief. Section 6A should not be used as a substitute for the proper application of debt write-off, remission or instalment-arrangement provisions.

A practical step forward

I have been involved in tax disputes on both sides of the fence, and still very much am. Section 6A has always been important in that work because it recognises that a tax dispute has to be considered in its full context. The evidence, the legal and factual risks, the costs, the taxpayer’s conduct and the likely outcome over time all matter.

Inland Revenue’s new guideline does not change the law or the settlement process. It updates the 2023 guidance to reflect the Commissioner’s fuller interpretation of section 6A in IS 25/26. The result is greater clarity about how Inland Revenue approaches a settlement and what it must consider.

A tax dispute is not always best resolved by pursuing every dollar to the end. There will be cases where the law, the evidence or the effect on other taxpayers requires Inland Revenue to continue. There will also be cases where a carefully considered settlement better serves revenue, compliance and the practical administration of the tax system.

That is what makes this a positive step. It supports a tax system that takes compliance seriously while recognising that sound administration requires judgement.


This article is general commentary, not legal or financial advice.

Sources: Inland Revenue, OG 26/01: Section 6A settlements; IS 25/26: The Commissioner’s duty of care and management; Tax Administration Act 1994, ss 6 and 6A.


*Dave Ananth is a partner at Meridian Partners and a former Inland Revenue solicitor. His practice focuses on student loans, tax disputes and negotiations with Inland Revenue. His background, profile and contact details are here.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.