sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Barbara Edmonds on Chlöe Swarbrick and Qiulae Wong as potential finance associates: 'If those are the cards that are handed to me by the PM, I will work with whoever are on those cards'

Public Policy / news
Barbara Edmonds on Chlöe Swarbrick and Qiulae Wong as potential finance associates: 'If those are the cards that are handed to me by the PM, I will work with whoever are on those cards'
Qiulae Wong, Barbara Edmonds and Chlöe Swarbrick.
Qiulae Wong, Barbara Edmonds and Chlöe Swarbrick.

Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick has been open about wanting the job of Minister of Finance if the Greens were to be part of the next government, while Labour leader Chris Hipkins has said he only would give it to Labour finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds. 

It has prompted comments such as those from ACT leader David Seymour: "Imagine Chlöe Swarbrick flying to New York as Finance Minister and trying to convince the bond markets that New Zealand is a sensible place to lend money."

If Labour were to enter government with the Greens and Opportunity, the party's finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds was asked if she would be open to Swarbrick and Opportunity leader Qiulae Wong as her associates.

"That's above my pay grade. You have to ask the boss when he becomes prime minister," Edmonds said during an interview with Interest.co.nz.

"I am comfortable with working with whomever the prime minister, Chris Hipkins, delegates to me as associate," she said. 

"I've got the experience in finance. This is my 17th budget I've had to work on or analyse. 

"Ultimately, for me, if I'm going to have associates, you're going to have to build that working relationship, no matter who it is, and ensuring that you have confidence in them and can delegate them the work to do so."

Finance Minister Nicola Willis' current pool of associate finance ministers includes a make up of Seymour and NZ First deputy Shane Jones.

On her personal view of Swarbrick and Wong, Edmonds said she had worked with Swarbrick on the finance and expenditure select committee for the last three years, and had "a really good personal relationship, very respectful personal relationship". 

"I don't really know Qiulae, but again, if those are the cards that are handed to me by the Prime Minister, I will work with whoever are on those cards."

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

12 Comments

Counting chickens maybe?

All I ask is that whoever holds accountability for the Finance portfolio in the coming government spend a few weeks trawling through Interest.co.nz comments over the last 2-3 years to get a broad (and I dare say relatively comprehensive) take from a well informed and highly engaged community

Up
10

government spend a few weeks trawling through Interest.co.nz comments

I hope not...

Up
8

After reading this, there'll a lot of gnashing teeth and jerking knees among the "Interest" community! :-)

Up
1

"Imagine Chlöe Swarbrick flying to New York as Finance Minister and trying to convince the bond markets that New Zealand is a sensible place to lend money."

When was the last time a NZ FM flew to NYC with cap in hand? A silly and patronizing comment.

Up
12

I thought the criticism was unfounded. Love her or hate her, she's no idiot. 

Its the kind of comment that will work against them. People love to get behind someone who has been treated unfairly  

Up
3

She is assuredly intelligent, but is it rational to conflate being generally smart with being specifically competent? 

Up
2

Who in parliament could we say is competent at present? Genuine question as it's likely we could count them on one our fingers .

Up
0

A good question, but I'm not sure I want to dig in to that particular bucket of crabs.

Up
1

Hopefully Babs has got into AI for helping her with charts. 

"Barbara Edmonds edits Facebook post incorrectly claiming Labour rapidly reduced debt — the opposite is true"

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/barbara-edmonds-deletes-facebook-post-incorrectly-claiming-labour-rapidly-reduced-debt-the-opposite-is-true/AEB4OU3ILFBPTNGT7N4O5T5WPA/

 

Up
2

Guess not. I spose they can't use interns now either.

“This isn’t some complicated forecasting dispute. Labour seems to have taken the Government’s own numbers and forgotten to reverse the signs when undoing their policy, turning a $44.8 million cost into a $44.8 million saving.”

“Hiding behind the defence that its costings were reviewed by consultants no longer holds water. We saw an almost identical problem with the Greens getting confused by negative numbers in their tax plans, and those numbers were externally verified too.”

https://x.com/TaxpayersUnion/status/2107260390342082970

Up
3

Anna missed this clanger?

"First here is what Barbara Edmonds said on Newstalk ZB:

Well, for example, a choice that we would not make is $300 million for a tobacco excise tax cut. Okay. That means there is $300 million more that is a choice. So only $12.7 billion more to find? 

This is a lie. The actual cost of a 50% reduction in excise tax on heated tobacco products has been $2.25 million, not $300 million. That is actual hard data. So Labour’s Finance Spokesperson is out by a factor of 100, in her finances."

https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2026/10/labours_fiscal_fraud.html

 

Up
3

I can envisage a certain type of animal fight between those three.

Up
0