sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

National pushes jobseeker drug testing and welfare savings as Labour targets domestic airfares and Act's David Seymour slams a 'dumpster fire' policy debate

Public Policy / news
National pushes jobseeker drug testing and welfare savings as Labour targets domestic airfares and Act's David Seymour slams a 'dumpster fire' policy debate
National leader Christopher Luxon and National's social development and employment spokesperson Louise Upston at Mills Albert Limited in Paraparaumu. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon and National's social development and employment spokesperson Louise Upston at Mills Albert Limited in Paraparaumu. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon drives a digger while at earthmoving and forestry company Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon drives a digger while at earthmoving and forestry company Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
National's Christopher Luxon gets advice before driving the digger. Image source: Mandy Te
National's Christopher Luxon gets ready to drive a digger. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon and National social development and employment spokesperson Louise Upston speak to media about the party's welfare policy. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon and National social development and employment spokesperson Louise Upston speak to media about the party's welfare policy. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon speaks to staff at earthmoving and forestry company Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon speaks to staff at earthmoving and forestry company Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
Christopher Luxon takes a selfie with staff from Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
Christopher Luxon takes a selfie with staff from Mills Albert Limited. Image source: Mandy Te
Christopher Luxon and Tim Costley on the campaign trail in Kapiti. Image source: Mandy Te
National's Christopher Luxon and Tim Costley on the campaign trail in Paraparaumu. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon receives flowers while visiting Palmers Plimmerton. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon receives flowers while visiting Palmers Plimmerton. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon walks around with the owners of Palmers Plimmerton. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon walks around with the owners of Palmers Plimmerton. Image source: Mandy Te
National's Christopher Luxon on the campaign trail. Image source: Mandy Te
National's Christopher Luxon on the campaign trail. Image source: Mandy Te
National leader Christopher Luxon.
National leader Christopher Luxon. Image source: Mandy Te

Dramatic days on the campaign trail this week saw National propose testing jobseekers for drugs, Labour wanting airlines to show what flights really cost, and ACT saying it was "no wonder the New Zealand dollar is in trouble" as the whole political conversation has lost its mind.

While the debate about the morality of billionaires continued. 

Randomised drug testing 

National announced on Thursday it would roll out randomised drug testing for people on the jobseeker benefit. It would introduce 10,000 tests a year from next year, expected to expand over time. 

While the changes from drug testing were not expected to generate any savings, other changes National proposed were estimated by leader Christopher Luxon to save $583 million over four years.

That included reducing payments for those who had been on the benefit for more than two years, penalising those who repeatedly leave employment voluntarily, doubling the stand down period to 26 weeks, and extending the benefit residency requirement from two to five years. 

Labour social development spokesperson Willow Jean Prime accused National of "moving the goalposts because National has failed to deliver" with unemployment higher than when it took office.

Transparent flight prices

Labour wants domestic airlines to show "all-in, real-time airfares so Kiwis can properly compare the true cost of flights."

Leader Chris Hipkins said the move would "open opportunities for smaller airlines to compete and give passengers more rights."

He also wants to require large airlines to give automatic refunds when flights were cancelled or significantly changed and require fair access to airport infrastructure to make it easier for small airline access. 

Labour commerce and consumer affairs spokesperson Arena Williams said the proposal would "make airlines more accountable, with greater scrutiny of fares, costs and profits and clear reporting on delays, cancellations and baggage."

Dumpster fire of policy and the Kiwi dollar

In a speech to Gravity Credit Management on Thursday morning, ACT leader David Seymour spoke of the NZ dollar falling, saying: "Normally the Kiwi dollar tracks the Aussie, but it is at the lowest point since the Canterbury quakes knocked it for six."

"It’s no wonder the New Zealand dollar is in trouble. It’s not just that the coalition might lose office. Ninety per cent of the political spectrum has lost its mind."

Seymour pointed to what he described as the ugly "dumpster fire of a policy debate New Zealand has descended into over the past five weeks", taking aim at the supermarket proposals from parties, taxes on capital and debt. 

"The Government is borrowing $9 billion, or two per cent of GDP, this year. Don’t worry though, as usual, it is promising a surplus in two years’ time," Seymour said.

"This relies on heroic revenue assumptions, such as the Government taking in $12 billion more this year than last year."

In response to this, Luxon, who had not seen the full remarks, said; "when you've got an economy growing at 2.6%, it's faster than Australia, it's faster than the UK, EU, Japan, Canada, the US... When you see 14% growth in Kiwis leaving Australia and coming home in the last 12 months, you see less Kiwis leaving to go overseas..."

"That says that we're actually getting on, this recovery is underway. We can see it. That's what we're talking about today. The next four years is continued growth," said Luxon.

The morality of billionaires & 'wowsers'

Speaking in the Herald Future of New Zealand Debate on Wednesday evening, ex-Prime Minister John Key described a question from TVNZ leaders' debate host Jack Tame - asking if it was morally acceptable for any one person to be a billionaire - as "nuts." 

"What sort of wowsers have we become if we're going to sit there and say, 'Oh, we're going to celebrate the Warriors and the All Blacks, and we think a bunch of other people are really good, who are sports people or artists or whatever...

"Oh, but if you've built a world-class space company like Peter Beck, oh, that's morally offensive. If you're Graham Hart and you built the best packaging business in the world, that's morally offensive," Key said. 

"That is nuts. If we want New Zealand to do better and be great, we have to have vision. We have to have ambition, and actually, collectively, we have to all say we're going to be better off because of that."

Green MP Tamatha Paul said she did think being a billionaire was immoral. 

"Billionaires don't just get there because they're better than anybody else, and it's not an isolated case of success. Often they are utilising public infrastructure to allow them to innovate. They are utilising government grants," Paul said.

"That means that they need to pay their fair share. So I'm not saying they should not exist altogether. What I'm saying is they need to pay their fair share because why do nurses, teachers, and tradies have more of a tax rate than they do?"

Both Luxon and Hipkins during the debate did not give a 'yes' or 'no' answer to the question about billionaires and morality.

Hipkins later said he did not want to see an economy where wealth could be concentrated as heavily in the hands of a small number of people. 

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

28 Comments

FFS so National puts out a policy to drug test kids on jobseeker when we already have 17% youth unemployment at the same time as cocaine use ( which is primarily white collar) goes through the roof. Seriously this country is in trouble if that’s our idea of moving ahead. 

Up
13

Agree, its probably going to put swing voters off National. The people who think that way would already be voting right. 

Up
2

Hmmm... would be surprised if drug takers/sellers/importers/manufacturers were voting Luxton anyway. I suspect its more a play to attract some of Winston's conservative voter base.

Up
0

Its not them, its the people that think benefit bashing when unemployment rate is high is pretty backwards. 

Up
6

I've got a 50-something year old girlfriend who has been on a benefit for more than 2 years. She had been volunteering at a local charity ever since losing her full time job.  One day she turned up at the volunteer job, and there was a different person sitting out front in reception (her normal workstation).  She said hello - you're new here - and the young woman responded - yes, I was just hired this week.  On enquiring with the management (as she had not seen a paid position advertised, or been told one was on offer), she was told that half the young woman's salary was being paid by WINZ.  A transition-to-work scheme. My friend was so disheartened, she quit volunteering there.  Her WINZ advisor/contact said the scheme was designed to get young people some job experience. 

Point is - it's hard out there - not only for young people - but for all ages of people.

She is embarrassed and traumatized enough with all the applications sent out which go nowhere (if you apply by Seek, for example, you get an acknowledgement of receipt email - but very, very rarely any feedback beyond that).

Further traumatizing the already traumatized with arcane tests and rules, is cruelty by any other name.

There are many, many GOOD people who cannot find work.

  

Up
11

amen      Ghost jobs

Up
7

I like the idea of random drug testing for those on jobseeker benefits.

Employees in many industries are randomly drug tested as standard practice. So if being drug free is a requirement for employment, then why not also a requirement for those receiving a benefit while seeking employment? I expect that a positive drug test by an employment applicant considerably narrows the opportunities for actually gaining employment. That raises an equity question regarding the benefit payments being a cost on the general tax paying population.

So thumbs up for me.

 

Up
4

It sounds great in theory, but it's a dud in reality when considering the term drug-free. It will simply push more into harder drugs that leave the body faster to avoid detection. This is the precise issue seen, for example, in the likes of FIFO jobs out of Perth. Workers can be off for a week and consume meth or cocaine, with it leaving their system within 72 hours and pass a random test on retirn to the work site, but if they were to have consumed any cannabis they could likely fail up to 2 weeks after. A supporting factor for the rampant meth and cocaine issues they have in Australia currently. 

Up
8

And what do you do with those taking drugs? Leave them on the streets homeless with no food? 

Up
8

"Tough on crime, pretty relaxed about the causes of crime"

Up
6

This lot should spend more time working out how to solve the problems we all face, creating some jobs around the country, fund a hospital or two, decent kids' lunches, etc. And stop picking on the very people they've spent three years creating more of. Does it really matter if someone is puffing on a joint while sitting on a couch during a working day? I think I'd rather smoke opium rather than listen to more of their hopium. 

Up
9

Agree. Smoking weed is a misdemeanour offence like speeding. In fact it's much less dangerous than speeding. Should we also cancel the dole for a speeding ticket?

Unless you have a job interview lined up, what does it matter. Its pure right wing publicity rather than an effective policy. 

Up
8

Couldn't agree more - and how despicable they are for using it to gain more publicity/attention.

Can't National campaign on some kind of positive, innovative, never-tried-before policy?  All I hear from them is excuses, negativity and punitive s#!t. 

 

Up
5

its because they are about to lose and getting desperate

 

Up
3

They're just trying to pull some conservative votes from NZF and Act from conservatives (more likely older cohort).

Up
2

Might as well try and attract the older voter, given that they are the largest voting bloc in NZ.

Up
0

I think this is not so much about tracking drug users but signalling to the right wing that 'we are hard on beneficiaries'.   They don't expect to pick anyone up - just to reiterate a story about beneficiaries being lazy.   In fact, drug tests are a common process for people prior to appointment to a role and is where you would pick up those who are users.

Up
1

MPs drug tested? 

Just asking 

T bf it's not really something I worry about to much, I only consume lawfully available drugs making me as pure as driven snow.

Great punching downwards by National, hit them again just for fun .

Up
13

Punching downwards sums it up about perfectly. 

Up
4

Yes, I'd love to see Luxon peeing in a cup to get tested.  A$$hole.

Up
4

I'd prefer not to actually see it but each to their own ;)

Up
5

there is some sick stuff on the internet

Up
0

LOL.

Up
1

When asked about National leader Christopher Luxon's promise that more jobs were coming online, with the 5.6% unemployment rate expected to decline, co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick said, "People can't work Luxon's ghost jobs".

"We currently have the highest unemployment in 11 years," she added, "and as many economists and commentators have pointed out, those predicted fiscal metrics are oftentimes very rosy and overly optimistic."

Liking Chloe more every day. 

Up
6

Sadly National is making it easier to like her....

Up the Tahs

I have time for her, I believe ever government needs a decent opposition

Up
7

Slippery slope judging billionaires as being immoral. Is Ms Paul really casting the first stone?

I have no problem with billionaires paying more tax but morality is irrelevant. Poor people can be just as immoral as rich people.

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition...

Up
3

So stupid, $49 alternaleaf appointment $50 bag and you are on legal meds... they cannot kick you off benefit

 

These guys are as Nutty as Squirrel shit (stolen off John Grisham)

 

 

Up
9

That two years is a bit steep when higher unemployment  started about two years ago for those who were gainfully employed and are actively seeking employment. "penalising those who repeatedly leave employment voluntarily" About three or four years ago chatted to a bricky on a construction site and I asked did not some of his work require assistance. The answer was yes but the unemployed youngster sent by WINZ lasted a day then never pitched up again. The youngster would no doubt also have picked up some skills even if not in an apprenticeship.

Up
1