sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Brian Easton compares supermarket policies from New Zealand’s political parties and asks if any political plan can realistically lower people's grocery bills

Economy / opinion
Brian Easton compares supermarket policies from New Zealand’s political parties and asks if any political plan can realistically lower people's grocery bills
smarket
Image sourced from Shutterstock.com

This is a re-post of an article originally published on pundit.co.nz. It is here with permission.


Economists have a precise definition of a competitive market: it is where no firm is a price setter. That requires many small firms in a market with ease of entry and exit. Economic theory shows that such markets are beneficial for consumers. They may be a bit rougher for the firms because, as British economist John Hicks remarked, the advantage of being a monopoly is the quiet life.

Such purely competitive markets are rare. At the other extreme is a market dominated by a single firm – a monopoly – which has considerable discretion over setting prices. Practically, a monopoly may not supply the whole market, just most of it. (It may even find it beneficial to allow smaller firms to operate, simplifying its management.)

In between, there are many market forms. Most common in New Zealand are oligopolies, where a few firms dominate the market. Examples include air travel, hardware stores, electricity, petrol, banks, supermarkets and telecommunications. That’s a lot of consumer spending.

Oligopolies will tell you they compete against one another – but this is not the competition that occurs in a purely competitive market. If there are only a few significant firms, each firm can work out what its competitors will do so they have some control over the prices they set. There may be no need for a formal cartel – a collective conspiracy against the public – to get an outcome that an illegal cartel would generate. That is why governments intervene in highly concentrated markets.

The Coalition Government has focused its efforts on supermarkets that are ‘duopolies’ – where just two of them dominate the market. The effort has been led by Minister of Finance Nicola Willis. (She would normally be considered too busy with  economic and fiscal management to be concerned with a sector which did not involve government funding.)

The Government has not been very successful. It tried to induce up to 24 international supermarket chains to enter the market. Not surprisingly, they were not interested. The costs of entry – setting up a chain in NZ – would be high. Because of economies of scale, an entrant would need significant market share. It would be expensive to exit if they failed. Whether the consumer would have benefited much is a moot point. There would have still been only three significant competitors and implicit collective pricing would still be relatively easy.

After three years, the National Party’s election platform promises to start splitting one of the chains (Foodstuffs) into two separate entities (Pak'nSave would be one, New World and Four Square the other), while leaving Woolworths, the supermarket chain owned by Woolworths Group in Australia, untouched. That would lead to three significant competitors. The NZ First policy is similar. The Greens propose a third chain by nationalising 120 existing supermarkets into a publicly owned chain called ‘KiwiMart’. (It is not clear where it expects to find the funds to buy out existing owners.) One may be sceptical that the three significant supermarket chains will make much difference.

ACT opposes such interventions, instead favouring the reduction of planning and regulatory barriers to allow new competitors to enter the market. But such changes won’t get over the substantial costs of entry and exit. You can bet your bottom dollar that the five (of the 24) international chains which seriously investigated entering the local market discussed these barriers with the government and concluded that even if those barriers could be reduced, the costs of entry and exit would still be too high.* We can discount the ACT policies as having much effect.

From an economist’s perspective, the Labour Party’s proposal is the most interesting. It wants to force both Foodstuffs and Woolworths to separate their wholesale and retail operations, so they operate independently. Supermarket chains are oligopsonists (a rather clumsy term, analogous to monopsonist, in which the buyers control the demand for a product or service from many sellers). They exercise their market power to keep down supply prices. Almost certainly some, but perhaps not all, the price reductions will be passed onto the oligopsonists’ buyers – household consumers. Labour is arguing that the problem is ‘vertical integration’ of wholesalers and retailers – vertical integration is the business strategy where a company owns or controls multiple stages of its supply chain. John Kenneth Galbraith, the Canadian-American economist and diplomat, argued that duopsonists confronting duopolists resulted in countervailing power which benefited consumers.**

It is not clear what this proposal might mean. Would the retailers be allowed to go direct to suppliers, cutting out the wholesalers? Would the wholesalers be allowed to supply households direct, cutting out the retailers? (An increasingly feasible option, given the rising significance of home delivery.) If the answer to both questions is ‘yes’, would not that mean the market would evolve to four suppliers with a continuing oligopolistic structure? Labour might argue that four significant suppliers would result in a more ‘competitive market’ than three. (Split Foodstuffs and there would be five.)

Some have drawn attention to the success of separating Telecom into Spark and Chorus. The analogy does not work. Telecom had a monopoly on supplying the cable connection to households and businesses (Chorus’ activities), which it used to benefit its value-added services (Spark’s). That the latter were overly profitable was demonstrated by the Telecom share price falling substantially when the separation was announced. Shareholders judged that losing the connection monopoly would undermine the profitability of the value-added services. They were right; today Spark is a very ordinary firm compared to the high-flying Telecom.

The pricing of Chorus, which is still a monopolist, is restricted by a revenue cap and price-quality regulation set by the Commerce Commission. I do not think price controls would be an effective means of restraining the supermarkets. Typically, they have more than 30,000 different items (stock units) for sale – a price controller’s nightmare.

In summary, it seems unlikely that a third or fourth significant supermarket chain would undermine the oligopolistic nature of the market – a fifth might. It is not obvious that relaxing barriers to entry or price controls would have much effect either. However, I am intrigued by the possibility of measures to reduce the power the supermarkets have over their suppliers. But it would probably increase prices for consumers.

Sometimes there are no easy solutions to economic problems despite what the politicians promise.


* Almost certainly at least one of the five would have been a ‘low-cost supermarket’ chain with a different business model based on fewer items (5000 instead of 30,000) and fewer staff.

** John Kenneth Galbraith (1952) American Capitalism: The Concept of Countervailing Power.


*Brian Easton, an independent scholar, is an economist, social statistician, public policy analyst and historian. He was the Listener economic columnist from 1978 to 2014. This is a re-post of an article originally published on pundit.co.nz. It is here with permission.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

11 Comments

The problem being international prices in a domestic economy....not an issue if your income is internationally competitive but we sadly live in a (comparatively) low wage economy.

Up
1

I get political at the checkout by avoiding American grapes, even though they are quite a bit cheaper.

Actually gives me a little dopamine hit.

Up
1

There's some lovely NZ ones too, albeit they've already been pressed, fermented, bottled and labelled.

Up
3

The idea of having a perfectly competitive supermarket ecosystem (from production to shelf) is incompatible with the high land prices that we need to preserve and grow national wealth. 

You can't have your cake and eat it too. Simple really.       

Up
2

In my world travels in the last 3 years I find NZ supermarkets have great selection and outstanding quality of goods. Yes somethings are more expensive but a lot are cheaper than the overseas supermarkets I visit.

People overseas are all complaining about costs as well - especially my Swiss relies who get paid very well in arguably one of the richest countries in the world.

The fact no one big wants to come to a long, isolated, small island nation with very average transport options to move goods is not really a surprise is it?

Banks the same etc etc.

or am I missing something ?

 

Up
2

There is one or two things you may be missing....the impact of subsidies and protection. We dont do either but many economies (still) do....there is a reason the likes of Saudi Arabia have low retail fuel prices.

Up
1

Agree, but they are complaining as well overseas. It’s not easy anywhere is my point. I’m not saying we can’t do things to improve competition but don’t expect miracles as I haven’t seen any on my travels in these “cheaper” places.

 

Up
1

The world has (largely) adopted the market forces mantra to greater or lesser degree...which means those in the lower cohorts are sacrificed for the benefit of those in the higher irrespective of country/economy.....some may suggest that is as it has always been but when supply gets tight (the end of growth) it becomes harder to hide.

Up
0

Perhaps missing that 

1 People can have unrealistic expectations and complaints are easy to make and cost almost nothing.

2 The poorest members and low waged workers in NZ are under real financial pressure and want their fair share.

3 We are primates and a possible perspective from Google Gemini ai follows pasted below

'Connecting contemporary public grievances over supermarket food prices and social inequity back to our evolutionary roots as primates offers a compelling lens.

Public debates—such as those on financial and economic commentary sites like interest.co.nz—frequently oscillate between blaming macro-level market forces (like New Zealand's geographic isolation and lack of retail competition) and raw human frustration over inequality, where lower-wage workers feel the pinch while others seem insulated.

Looking at this through the prism of primate behavioral biology and evolutionary psychology reveals why these economic tensions evoke such visceral emotional reactions:

1. Food as the Ultimate Currency of Survival

  • Primate Reality: In non-human primate societies, food is not merely nutrition; it is the central currency of social currency, hierarchy, and survival. Because foraging and hunting require immense energy, how food is acquired and distributed dictates social standing.
  • Modern Translation: In modern human societies, supermarkets represent the centralized "foraging ground." When the cost of food rises faster than wages, it triggers an ancient, hardwired anxiety about resource scarcity. Even though modern economies rely on complex global supply chains and monetary policy rather than troops of monkeys sharing fruit, our brains still process a high supermarket bill as a direct threat to basic survival and provisioning.

2. The Inequity Trigger (Disadvantageous Inequity Aversion)

  • Primate Reality: As seen in experiments with capuchin monkeys, primates tolerate unequal outcomes up to a point, but when they perceive that someone else is getting a better deal for the same effort, they experience sharp "disadvantageous inequity aversion"—rejecting the system, throwing tokens, or protesting.
  • Modern Translation: Public anger over supermarket pricing is rarely just about absolute numbers; it is heavily driven by relative deprivation and perceived fairness. When lower-wage workers or families face soaring grocery bills while large supermarket conglomerates or banking sectors report robust profits, it mimics the exact psychological trigger observed in primates: the sense of being short-changed. The public outcry and online commentary function as a modern, vocalized equivalent of the capuchin monkey refusing a lesser reward.

3. The Limits of "Fairness" in Dominance Hierarchies

  • Primate Reality: While primates possess mechanisms for reciprocity, they do not have a built-in concept of structural economic fairness or altruistic punishment for abstract monopolies. Dominant individuals or coalitions often monopolize prime resources based on positioning and power.
  • Modern Translation: Market structures like New Zealand's supermarket duopoly reflect a modern institutionalized dominance hierarchy. Economists look at supply chain logistics, transport costs, and lack of international competition to explain high prices. However, evolutionary psychology explains why people find these rational explanations deeply unsatisfying: humans possess an evolved moral intuition that expects cooperative networks to be fair. When essential resources like food are controlled by a few powerful entities, it clashes with our deep-seated tribal expectation that vital resources should be accessible to all members of the group.

Summary

While supermarket prices are ultimately governed by supply chains, inflation, market scale, and corporate margins, our emotional reaction to them is heavily filtered through millions of years of primate evolution. Food inflation is resisted not just because numbers on a receipt are higher, but because it violates our ancient, visceral expectation of equitable resource sharing within our troop.

Up
0

It may also have something to do with wanting to stay alive

Up
0

Its actually much better than that - our supermarkets have to add GST while other countries do not. So unless you think ours are more than 15% dearer we are getting a bloody good deal and I agree a better quality. Only NZ would be dumb enough to mess with it. 

Agree with banks too. 

Up
2