sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Benchmark rates rise; Brazil votes; US service sector expands; Canada's doesn't; China holiday spending good; France stressed; UST 10yr at 5.34%; gold softer and oil eases slightly despite renewed attacks; NZ$1 = 55.9 USc; TWI-5 = 59.7

Economy / news
Benchmark rates rise; Brazil votes; US service sector expands; Canada's doesn't; China holiday spending good; France stressed; UST 10yr at 5.34%; gold softer and oil eases slightly despite renewed attacks; NZ$1 = 55.9 USc; TWI-5 = 59.7
breakfast

Here's our summary of key economic events overnight that affect New Zealand, with news benchmark interest rates are rising quickly again today, especially in the US and Europe.

But first in Brazil, they will have a run-off election for President, with no candidate getting 50% of the vote. But the first round showed surprising support for the right-wing son of a previous military officer Jair Bolsonaro who has been president before Lula and who had thrown Lula into jail on grounds that were thrown out by Brazilian courts. In this latest poll, the younger Bolsonaro won 47% of votes versus Lula’s 45%, setting up an October 25 runoff which will be a bitter affair. Local financial markets rose on the prospects.

In the US, the service sector PMIs out overnight were both in a good expansion mode, but indicated  different trajectories. The widely-watched local ISM one reported a moderating of the good expansion in August in its September update. Business activity eased back noticeably, and new orders also moderated even it both are still at very good levels.

Meanwhile, the internationally-benchmarked S&P Global one was much more up-beat. It reported a surge in activity as new order growth hit 4½ year high. Employment growth was its strongest since June 2022. But Input cost inflation reaccelerated to its steepest since November 2022 and matching the pandemic pressures.

Canada's equivalent services PMI was little-changed, stuck just below an expansion level, but they have the same cost intensification problem.

In China, official monitoring of holiday spending midway through the seven-day National Day holidays, shows foot traffic up +3.4% from last year and revenue up +5.3%. They will be happy with that.

Singapore said its retail sales growth was weak in August, coming in below July's modest level and well below the expected levels.

In France, their central bank boss has warned his country's budget is at risk of being strangled by rising interest payment costs.

In Australia, the independent Melbourne Institute Monthly Inflation Gauge increased for a third consecutive month in September, after falling in May and June. The increase was primarily attributed to transport price rises, with annual headline inflation of 4.8%, unchanged from August. (The ABS said the August CPI was 4.0%.) The monthly cost of living also increased across a range of household types (age pensioners, other government transfer recipients, employees, pensioners and beneficiaries and self-funded retirees).

The UST 10yr yield is rising, now just on 5.34%, up +6 bps from yesterday to its highest in 24 years. The 30 year yield is at 5.70%, up +7 bps and its highest since 2002 as well. The key 2-10 yield curve is now at +48 bps (up +4 bps). Their 1-5 curve is now at +61 bps (-2 bps) and the 3 mth-10yr curve is at +139 bps (+6 bps). The China 10 year bond rate is little-changed at 1.68%. The Japanese 10 year bond yield is now at 3.13%, up +3 bps from yesterday. The Australian 10 year bond yield starts today at 5.42%, up +9 bps from yesterday and a 15 year high. The NZ Government 10 year bond rate is now at 5.08%, down -1 bp from yesterday. (We are not yet back to 2023 levels. Our stress is coming in the currency exchange rate.)

Wall Street has started its week with the S&P500 up +0.7% and the Nasdaq up +0.8%. Overnight, European markets were mixed between London's +0.3% rise and Paris's -0.8% fall. Yesterday, Tokyo ended up +2.4%. Hong King was up +0.3% and of course Shanghai was closed. Singapore ended up +0.5%. The ASX200 closed unchanged. The NZX50 ended its Monday trade up just +0.1%.

The price of gold is at US$4130/oz and down a minor -US$10 from yesterday. Silver is at just under US$61/oz and up +50 USc today. 'Low' gold prices are having a very negative impact on the price of gold mining stocks.

Oil prices have eased -US$1/bbl from yesterday to just over US$90/bbl in the US, while the international Brent price is down -US$1.50 to US$101/bbl. And we should note the pace of the flurry on attacks on tankers in the Hormuz region in the past few days has not slackened.  Hormuz transits have reduced again today with just eight ships exiting over the past 24 hours, no tankers escorted (0 dark with transponders off) and 5 entering for new loads (0 dark). Looming new conflict clouds the situation again. The Red Sea activity is back up to the low 20 vessels in either direction at the Yemen chokepoint, the area diverted by the Saudi attacks elsewhere. Saudi-backed Yemeni government forces staged a lightning advance overnight to retake the coast around the Bab el-Mandeb Strait.

The Kiwi dollar is down -30 bps from yesterday, now at just on 55.9 USc to a 14 month low. Against the Aussie we are down -40 bps at 80.3 AUc. Against the euro we are up +20 bps at just on 49.9 euro cents. That all means our TWI-5 starts today at just under 59.7 and down -30 bps from yesterday and a 17 year low.

The bitcoin price starts today at US$85,248 and down a very minor -0.1% from yesterday. Volatility over the past 24 hours has been modest at just over +/-1%.

Daily exchange rates

Select chart tabs

Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: CoinDesk

The easiest place to stay up with event risk is by following our Economic Calendar here ».

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

59 Comments

Russian biolabs actively working on pneumonic plague huh? 100% fatality rate if untreated. Who would have thought the fine people of the Kremlin administration would be maintaining stocks of such a lethal bioweapon? 

Maybe the "leak" was meant as a message to those defending against the spread of  the new Tsarist empire? "Don't mess with us, we're fundamentally insane". Much like their regular nuclear annihilation threats?

Up
8

"...Fervo becomes the first enhanced geothermal company to reach a key commercial milestone. The power plant synchronized with the grid about a week ago, bringing online the first third of what will soon become a 100-megawatt power plant.

The entire site could be much larger, though, with the potential to generate as much as 4 gigawatts of electricity, Fervo previously told TechCrunch.

...From groundbreaking to commercial operations, the first block at Cape Station took 23 months to complete. As Fervo refines its process, it is aiming to complete future blocks in as little as 18 months.

...While traditional geothermal power taps heat sources close to the surface, Fervo and its peers are drilling deeper because deeper rock is hotter, opening more opportunities for development."

 https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/01/worlds-first-enhanced-geothermal-power-plant-completed-in-just-23-months/

Up
4

Yep this tech would be very useful in our neck of the woods.

Up
0

fracking would help here?

Up
0

"....with news benchmark interest rates are rising quickly again today, especially in the US and Europe."

And all of this when David McLeish in yesterday's article stated... "I’d argue, high global yields aren't a warning sign of financial doom. They are a return to sanity."

But a return to sanity for who...

For the US Treasury refinancing $40 trillion of debt?

For Britain paying 6% at the long end?

For France whose spread over Germany has just blown out to euro-crisis levels?

For heavily indebted households and businesses?

Or for an AI investment boom whose economics become progressively more precarious as its cost of capital rises?

The problem isn't that 5% money is historically abnormal. The problem is that we spent fifteen years building a historically abnormal mountain of debt on the assumption that money would remain almost free.

That, I think, is the hole you could drive a truck through in his article.

And yesterday I was researching this very subject before I saw the McLeish piece and this is what I found.... warning - this is long...

......................................................................................................

LET THEM EAT CAKE - THE FRENCH CONNECTION

France is beginning to look decidedly uncomfortable.

Not because one economic indicator has suddenly gone bad, another government has fallen, or another ratings agency has belatedly discovered that Paris has been spending rather more than it collects.

The problem runs much deeper.

France has spent decades building an enormous financial superstructure on top of an increasingly diminished productive economy. Now the bond market appears to be testing the foundations.

FOLLOW THE MONEY

Years ago I did some work with Toulouse-based neuroscientist Simon Thorpe on the possibility of replacing conventional taxation with a tiny Financial Transaction Tax.

Thorpe isn't a trained economist - which may have been one of his greatest advantages.

Instead of starting with the accumulated doctrine of the economics profession, he asked an extraordinarily simple question.

How much money actually moves through the financial system?

His early work using BIS payment and settlement data produced an astonishing result. Across 13 countries he examined, annual financial transactions approached US$9,000 trillion - US$9 quadrillion - against less than US$9 trillion of tax revenue.

Those gross transaction figures obviously include settlement flows, intermediated transactions and substantial double counting. But that wasn't really the point.

The point was the sheer scale of the financial machine.

France was particularly interesting because even then it was becoming obvious how financialised its economy had become while the productive economy underneath it steadily lost relative importance.

That process has continued. Manufacturing has fallen to only around 11% of French value added, while services account for close to 80%.

GDP counts all of it, of course.

But GDP doesn't ask the question that increasingly interests me.

What does the economy actually produce?

That is why I prefer what I call Productive GDP - PGDP.

France still possesses some outstanding productive companies and industries - Airbus alone makes that obvious. But there is a fundamental difference between an economy producing food, energy, machinery, chemicals, aircraft, vehicles and exportable goods, and one increasingly dominated by finance, property, asset trading and rent extraction.

€22 SITTING ON €1

Now look at what sits on top of that economy.

BNP Paribas has roughly €3.08 trillion of assets supported by only around €138 billion of accounting equity.

That is approximately €22 of assets for every €1 of shareholders' money.

Société Générale isn't vastly different, with equity amounting to only around 4-5% of assets.

We can bury this beneath CET1 ratios, risk-weighted assets, AT1 securities, CoCo bonds, Tier 2 capital, TLAC, MREL and the rest of modern banking's alphabet soup.

But none of it makes that basic arithmetic disappear.

There isn't much actual shareholders' money sitting underneath these colossal balance sheets.

Which wouldn't be quite so interesting if the market underneath those balance sheets were behaving itself.

It isn't.

FRANCE IS STARTING TO TRADE LIKE ITALY - ONLY WORSE

For decades, whenever anyone went looking for the large sick man of European sovereign debt, the finger normally pointed south.

Italy.

Something extraordinary has now happened.

French 5-year sovereign CDS - effectively the market price of insuring French government debt against a credit event - have exploded from roughly 34 basis points in early September to around 80-87.

Italy is around 66.

France's 10-year government bond yield has climbed to around 4.86%, against Italy at roughly 4.61%.

France's 30-year is around 5.42%, against Italy at about 5.16%.

And the French 10-year spread over German Bunds has blown out towards 150 basis points, compared with roughly 120 for Italy.

Read that again.

Markets are now demanding more compensation to lend money to France than to Italy across important parts of the sovereign curve.

Italy hasn't suddenly become Switzerland.

France has deteriorated.

And this is where the French Connection becomes decidedly scary.

NOW MARK THE BANKS TO MARKET

French banks inevitably hold enormous quantities of bonds, loans and other interest-sensitive financial assets. When yields rise, bond prices fall.

So imagine for a moment that these enormous French banking balance sheets were genuinely marked to market.

Forget regulatory risk weights.

Forget convenient accounting classifications.

Forget models.

Simply ask the wonderfully old-fashioned question -

What would somebody actually pay for these assets today?

With roughly €22 of assets sitting above every €1 of BNP equity, it doesn't require an enormous percentage impairment across the balance sheet before the arithmetic becomes uncomfortable.

A hypothetical 1% loss across those assets would consume roughly 22% of the equity.

Two percent - 44%.

Around 4.5% - essentially all of it.

Obviously a real bank balance sheet isn't that simple. Different assets have different durations, hedges offset exposures and many loans wouldn't suffer anything approaching those losses.

But that qualification doesn't make the leverage disappear.

It tells us where to look.

THE DOOM LOOP

France potentially contains the ingredients of the same sovereign-bank doom loop that nearly tore Europe apart during the euro crisis.

French sovereign risk rises - French bonds fall - Bank balance sheets weaken - Bank funding costs rise - The potential liability sitting behind the French state grows - Markets demand an even larger premium for holding French sovereign debt.

Around we go.

And after taxpayers were forced to rescue banks during the GFC, we were presented with another ingenious solution - bail-ins.

No more putting taxpayers on the hook. Wonderful. Except losses don't disappear because regulators change the vocabulary. Someone still wears them.

So we constructed an elaborate waterfall involving shareholders, AT1s and CoCo bonds, Tier 2 capital, unsecured creditors and, under some resolution regimes and circumstances, uninsured depositors.

The taxpayer hadn't escaped the room. We had simply developed a more sophisticated system for deciding whose pocket gets emptied first.

THE FTT IRONY

Which brings me back to Simon Thorpe.

France actually introduced an FTT in 2012 and eventually increased it to 0.4%. But it bears little resemblance to the universal model Simon and I were examining.

The French tax principally targets purchases of shares in large French-listed companies and contains substantial exemptions. Despite that comparatively hefty 0.4% rate, it raises only a few billion euros.

Thorpe's proposition turned the whole thing upside down.

France - tiny base × comparatively high rate = modest revenue.

Thorpe - enormous base × microscopic rate = potentially enormous revenue.

The French experiment nevertheless demonstrates something interesting.

An FTT has operated there for fourteen years. The financial heavens didn't fall in.

What France has never seriously tested is the much more radical proposition - stop hammering wages, productive enterprise and everyday consumption while largely ignoring the colossal financial flows coursing through an increasingly financialised economy.

Thorpe simply looked at those flows and asked why. It was a very good question then. It is an even better one now.

LET THEM EAT CAKE

France therefore isn't merely facing a government debt problem.

It potentially faces something much more dangerous - a heavily financialised economy, a diminished productive base, enormous leveraged banks and a deteriorating sovereign balance sheet sitting directly on top of one another.

Each feeds into the others.

None of this means France collapses next Tuesday. The ECB possesses enormous firepower. France remains wealthy, possesses excellent infrastructure, skilled people and some world-class industries.

But markets have an unpleasant habit of discovering vulnerabilities before politicians acknowledge them.

Right now the warning lights are beginning to flash together - sovereign CDS, 10-year spreads, 30-year yields, a steepening yield curve and the broader currency environment.

Now add the extraordinary leverage sitting inside the French banking system. Perhaps the bond market settles down. Perhaps the ECB rides over the hill again. Perhaps Brussels invents another acronym and applies another regulatory sticking plaster.

But there is a wonderful historical irony in all this. France gave the world the most famous expression ever attributed to an elite hopelessly detached from the economic reality beneath it.

Whether Marie Antoinette actually said it hardly matters - two-and-a-half centuries later, the metaphor remains perfect.

France has built an enormous financial cake on top of a shrinking productive base - and now the bond market has finally started asking who is going to pay for it.

Up
7

Are you AI-ing again? 

Just asking...

Up
5

I think he is AI

Up
2

Don’t know but the contribution on Brazil yesterday was a worthy effort. South & Central America, like iron filings to a magnet, stamping grounds for tycoons, politicians & CIA. Way back Secretary of State Seward  lobbied to invade/acquire a nation or two as a way to take the wind out of the sails of  the looming US civil war. Then there was Vanderbilt inciting and financing  rebellion for revenge on former business partners. The great zHenry Ford Fordlandia failed miserably but at least inadvertently sowed the seeds of a worthwhile soy bean industry. The CIA & Pinochet rhymes quite well and this Venezuela adventure of course. 

Up
2

Brazil is potentially a big problem. Wealthy country with corruption becoming more widespread. The Bolsonaro side could literally wreck the country forever.

But yes Colin's contributions are great.

Up
6

Jimbo... I'm quite happy to debate whether I use AI, a calculator, Google/Chrome, books, old envelopes, or a blunt pencil - you name it. It might be a long discussion though - I use all of the above.

And an AI that calls itself Colin Maxwell.... REALLY???

But it might be more interesting to debate the argument.

Which part is wrong?

US debt approaching $40 trillion?

Long-term borrowing costs rising?

France's fiscal and banking vulnerabilities?

The increasing cost of capital for the AI build-out?

Or the rather obvious arithmetic problem created when highly indebted economies discover that supposedly "normal" interest rates are no longer remotely normal for the debt structures they have built?

I repeat - I have been researching this stuff for three decades.

By all means attack the argument - but for crying out loud, try bringing some numbers along.

Up
3

Hey! Colin has been up all night researching! ;-)

Up
2

I have been researching heavily for 3 decades. 

Up
4

FFS if you are going to mindlessly post AI slop at least do some basic learning about prompt engineering so we don't get a 1490 word mini essay with every post.

Up
9

And therein lies a big problem for modern society - the addiction to the bullet pointed, sound bite comment to the exclusion of reasoned, long form, detail supported discussion/debate.

Really dumbs down everything. 

Do you expect a masters thesis to be less than 1000 words now?

Up
7

Hi LouB, what you're trying to do here is a straw man. If you think the interest.co.nz comments are meant to be anything like a masters thesis you might want to compare the differences between a master thesis and an internet comments section. Have a good day.

Up
6

You raise a bigger point. 

Posts should be shorter than thesis length - but to be able to validate, it is a good idea to reference longer tomes - even including an excerpt in your text, with page ref if helpful.

My beef is with using AI at all - it is an insult to our intellects (from both sides). 

Up
4

Spacecadet... the irony is that my 1,490-word "mini essay" takes up hardly any more room on your screen than a few lines unless you actually choose to click "Read more" and open it.

Nobody is forcing you to do that.

So apparently you voluntarily opened a 1,490-word piece of "AI slop", read enough of it to count the words, and then complained about having to read it.

FFS indeed.

Mind you, I have to concede that the nom de plume you hide behind becomes rather appropriate in this instance. 😉

Up
3

Hi Colin, I certainly did not count the words in your post, there are basic tools for this that existed well before you figured out how to log into ChatGPT and use the copy and paste function on your phone. 

I'm actually trying to do you a favor, if you're going to use a tool, learn to use it properly. 

Up
1

I enjoy reading his comments. Certainly more entertaining than a few other comments here. And seemingly more relevant too.

Up
6

Despite being a slow reader/comprehender I to tap the read more as it tends to make sense with numbers to back it. And is a surprisingly easy read. As someone who can only string a few sentences together, thank you Colin 

Up
4

Have you considered the possibility that the devil is in the detail, and Colin has figured that out?

Politics sits behind all economics and that is what Colin is trying to explain. My perspective is he should continue doing what he's doing. I can't read all he puts up, but I do get through most, and invariably find it interesting.

Up
6

He is a valuable contributor - makes one think at times. 

Last I remember, he wasn't onboard with overshoot/depletion/resources/energy/collapse - but that may be a dated comment, we are all allowed to learn. I started out becoming 'green' in the 1970s; understood the need to limit reproduction (choices then 2,1,0 per couple, our 2 are now 40 and 38) and to go easy on the earth - but I kept learning. Realised society was procrastinating it's move to change ever-later, and decided to become an early-adopter of PV, off-grid and self-sufficiency. 

But I kept learning - and realised that actually, modernity is temporary. that entropy will win. Through those eyes, I can tell you the down-shift is happening. But I recently had an exchange with someone who would consider themselves MSM. I suggested they tell the truth (about overshoot etc etc). They hollered back "your truth". Nope, it a universal truth - but there we can identify the need to think clearly, and we can cogitate as to why the MSM person needed to not know. We get that with posters too: prolific but refusing to read/learn. I always ask: Why? 

Not too bad a question, is Why? CM helps in that regard; he's a plus. Others too - but if this discussion is to be useful, it has to get past the need-to-believe brigade. As indeed society does (polarisation tells us the mass are increasingly losing belief in the dominant narrative (economic growth can go forever and is always laudable). 

Up
2

That crucial question; "WHY" deliberately in capitals. We should always be asking it. But too many are threatened by it. Why that is should be understood.

I don't accept that "modernity is temporary" is a necessity. It only is when our culture is wrapped around a growth ideology. If we as a species, but especially our leaders understood the universal connections, the ideology would change to a sustainable model, reduced people, reduced consumption etc. Lust for power, greed all being drivers for politics is what is killing us all. Changing that is the challenge. Colins post on Brazil is a case in point, as is Trump. When the dominant societal narrative is asking why Trump, or why Bolsonaro then there is hope we can change to save the core. That's not happening.....

I'll repeat an observation I made a couple of weeks ago; interpretation of ancient Sumerian tablets residing in various museums across the western world suggests the sustainable population of the planet is just 500 million. Think about that.....

Up
0

Hey Colin, not a dig but try this at the end of your next prompt. AI gets far too chatty if you let it and you will get higher quality output if you tell it to distill down its response. 

"Key points only, be succinct, remove emotive language, maintain even and factual tone, do not try to sway audience, answer in 150 words or less."


Etc.
 

Up
6

Cutting and pasting machine generated text is a cop out! To verify accuracy a reader still has to trawl though hours of reference research. AI sure as hell isn't perfect and has been caught making sh!t up!

"One such limitation is that it has been known to fabricate or “hallucinate” (in machine learning terms) citations. These citations may sound legitimate and scholarly, but they are not real."

https://blogs.library.duke.edu/blog/2023/03/09/chatgpt-and-fake-citatio…

Up
3

Yea I normally tell it to "cite sources with links, preference high quality sources, order by google search results." then click through a few of them.

Also, I haven't really experienced AI hallucinations this year. The updates that came out in Jan/Feb have tidied a lot of that up. Plus, I'm on paid plans and I do notice I get less crap back vs free.

Up
1

Thank you, Matt - I appreciate your message - and point taken on distilling it -  I'm always trying to cut the fat without losing the substance. But some of these subjects are huge.... literally!

If I've learned anything from writing over the years, it's that there is no version that satisfies everyone - and attempting to do so would sand away everything distinctive, until nobody wanted to read past the first paragraph anyway.

These are forums, not central-bank minutes. Surely a little spice helps. (-:

I try to write for the reader who wants to think, and to bring in the macroeconomic and geopolitical context - not for every reader who just happens to be scrolling.

Up
2

You do very well thank you Colin, looking forward to your next analytical commentary. 

Judging by the section on France in the breakfast briefing, followin your post yesterday evening (which i read and you reposted today) I  reckon you are on point.

Up
0

No worries Colin, I think AI is an incredible tool, but it is just a tool. My main beef with AI content is that AI tends to write with a single voice. You lose a diversity of tone when everyone is using it. 

A few of the guest authors on this site are definitely pumping their articles through Claude and I feel it takes away from their writing considerably.

Up
3

I'm wondering how long now until people start speaking to each other in AI formatted language. It seems the majority of news presenting, and articles are AI tweaked. Usually formats like using not_____, not_____, just _____, but this wasn't the ____ that everyone expected, and so on. I tire of reading what feels like the same format everywhere, because as you say it feels less personable and subconsciously causes me to disconnect from the material. 

Up
4

Yup completely agree. Funny thing, I've started writing my emails super short and to the point in as a counter to the shift. But also, so you know it's obviously me. 

Up
1

Bravo. And who knows, in the not-so-distant future you may be more sought after by having the ability to do this vs the youth who are rapidly losing writing skills by offloading them to AI.

Up
1

This election could be really interesting. I was picking the existing coalition a month ago, but I'm starting to think they made the rookie mistake of peaking too soon. National's tax ads were effective, but what have they got for the next 4 weeks? Meanwhile the opposition have got a lot of ammunition they have been holding back, both in terms of policy and the current state of the country. 

I have watched a fair amount of local media and I am starting to think the Greens will be the big winner this election. Chloe has always been smart and passionate, but she is also coming across as the most relatable, to me she seems to be quite a way ahead of the other leaders. I probably wont vote Green, but I am betting a lot of people that are struggling will want change, and she is offering the biggest change. Could the Greens get more vote than Labour - its an outside chance IMO. I think she will also pick up the young / progressive vote that Labour seem to have abandoned. 

Meanwhile I am still not sure who to vote for, and there are probably only two or three parties I've ruled out. Every other election I would know by now. 

It seems crazy that the two big parties stuck with their Chris. What a massive blunder.  Worse for National, the Chris who should have been leader will probably not even be in Parliament after the election, so they won't have an obvious replacement. If they lose Willis, Bishop and Goldsmith, who's left? Stanford and Mitchell I guess. Who would be finance minister, please not Brown!

Up
1

Perhaps do some homework before deciding? 

I'm certain you have not read the links I gave you... (but would be happy to be proven wrong).

They indicate who is nearest to being on the right track - nobody is fully - but it might be a start. Gut instinct and chosen ignorance (choosing not to become informed) are perhaps sub-par approaches. 

Swarbrick could get there from where she is but is still a BAU-assuming city-dweller. Cities, where we are headed, are sub-optimal arrangements; last time I checked, she is of the energy-blind cohort who think that cities are 'more efficient'. Still and all, her approach compared to Luxon's rabble, is like comparing an artisan silversmith with a bunch of blacksmiths - around 1945...

 

Up
4

My thoughts too PDK.

Up
3

The Greens enviro side is good (not great, but best amongst all parties). The social (Pro Hamas, Woke, Communist) is something I can't digest. I voted for them twice a decade ago. Only getting worse.

Up
7

Seeing as Labour are more Nat Lite these days, the reds have all headed off to the greens. I'm still waiting for a party understanding ecology and physics and uses these principles to work out what policy is possible and what is not. I guess the bulk of the proletariat are too immersed in the "what's in it for me immediately" bidding war, to bother thinking about the desolate wasteland all these party bribes promise down the track? 

Up
5

Values Party circa 1975. 

Borrow my copy of the Manifesto. 

At most, you'd change about 3 words. It's spot on. Society chose not to listen and will continue not to listen, until it is too late. 

Then we will need local leadership, real skills (I've spent the morning using No8 to make climbing-trellis in the garden), cheifly the ability to produce food. It'll be a long, long way from BAU. 

Up
3

I spent the morning removing shrubs and re-preparing a couple of strips of garden for what will be the fifth try to get something decent to survive north easters and westers. Now figuring out how to space 7 plants evenly, with a smaller space at each end,  caused the inherent deficiencies in arithmetic to resurface. Thank you AI, QED, seconds after asking the question. 

Up
0

Shelter is the key Foxy. Try growing under cloches. Brilliant veg can be grown under the product known as "Microclima". You can get special hoops for it, but I just use chopped up lengths of galvanised steel rod and weighted down with old chunks of wood. It can just be left floating over the patch if prefered.

Up
0

Tks kind thoughts & info.This area though is outside our front entrance two parallel rows, dry & windy location. French lavender went ok until it got woody , English type next time failed as to did gauras. Exposed to sun and wind, on a hill slope, black birds (a familiar family which we are surprisingly fond of) kick the soil everywhere. So this time Lomandra lime tuff grasses and largish river stones to surround, reduce evaporation and foil the black birds. Optimism still unbroken. Tallyho!

Up
1

Ah, you're growing ornamentals. Sounds like you're on the right track. :-) 

Up
0

A bit too nostalgic there PDK. It can be downloaded on line. I would agree with the sentiments of it, but too much is ideological. Rewrite it to fit today's audience and you'd get a positive response, but I suspet the majority would still reject it.

It does note that in 1972 when it was published the population was 2.9 million, about what most of us agree is close to the ideal population for the country.

Up
5

That manifesto is just so damn good! There's a vid of Jeanette Fitzsimons on the Tube somewhere giving a brilliant speech during her "Values" days. There's no comparison with todays Greens! 

Up
2

"last time I checked, she is of the energy-blind cohort who think that cities are 'more efficient'"

As I said she is smart. 5 million people living rurally would work if we run out of energy?

Up
0

Please think before putting up these straw-man arguments. 

Justifying anything by anthropic demand (ecological arrogance by one species) is invalid. 

The question is how many can we support food-wise, ex fossil energy input (tractors, fertiliser, trucks, even plastic pipe). I suspect 5 million will be a stretch, particularly when we're starting with (dairy) degraded soils. 

Ask the other obvious, logical question: How many city-dwellers can be fed/serviced, ex fossil energy input? 

F-all, I'd suggest. 

Up
2

Put the food on an electric truck then train and send it to the city. People can walk to the station and buy it. 

Or we could cover all the farming area with houses and lifestyle blocks? 

Up
0

There you go again

Denial by strawman

Will there be electric trucks, post fossil energy? You claim to be an engineer - give me an example of an item of 'renewable' infrastructure, built by same. You can't; the 2nd Law beats it every time. 

As to the strawman - why houses, why lifestyle blocks? So unimaginative - try thinking laterally. 

I suspect there will be a reversal of the 200-year drift into cities - but quicker. I suspect the nodes that made sense in horse and foot days, will again (towns on river confluences, that kind of thing). There will be communities built, sometimes from scratch, sometimes on top of existing. 

But I repeat - that 'electric truck' comment isn't really up to the level of discussion we need to be having. Too much assumption 

Up
1

Dairy has degraded some soils (Peat). But has developed a lot of other soils with fertiliser and organic matter (Brown, recent Soils). The contamination of water (surface, ground) is a separate topic. If we are sticking to soils, Dairy's contribution is positive.

Most of the degradation has been done by sheep, in hill/steep country (cutting trees, over grazing). That sediment (fertile top soil) is clogging our estuaries and rivers.

Up
2

Yep, I'd agree with that. Bovines are soil builders, ovines are more like rabbits. The US prairies would be an example. Cattle on steep and wet country are still destructive though. Back in the '80s the road I much travelled between Winchester and Orari in South Canterbury was stoney river bed. After a decade or two of dairying it's now building a good layer of organic matter. Taken a lot of N fert and irrigation to do that though!

Up
0

Has National ruled out the Greens? Or vice versa? Didn't they do a supply agreement with them under John Key? I checked, it was just an MOU in 2008.

Up
1

No. They agreed on some policies (Home insulation), but didn't get to agree and supply. National never needed the Greens to form a goverment.

 

The Greens have indicated they will never go with this version of National. They are against everything the Greens stand for. 

Up
2

Is there a floor under the NZD?

Once upon a time when dairy prices were good, as they are currently,  this underpinned the value of the NZD. Now it seems like nobody's interested in it anymore

Up
4

Well, NZ has chosen the inflation route to rid the economy of surplus spending power. 

Up
4

This is what longstanding lack of economic performance and negative news does. People offload our currency for better performers. I wonder how the AUD will fare when their housing crash is another 2 years in.....

Up
1

Is there a floor under the NZD?

Relative to what? USD? We Aoatearoans are a myopic bunch. Wind back to the GFC and NZD and AUD crosses with JPY were walloped. NZD/JPY lost slightly more than half its value from its pre-GFC peak to its crisis trough - from roughly ¥95 per NZD1 in mid-2007 to below ¥45 in early 2009: a peak-to-trough decline of approximately 53%. 

We believe all kinds of nonsense about our currency and our economy. 

Up
1

"We believe all kinds of nonsense about our currency and our economy."

Not just our currency and economy....nor are we alone in the trait.

Up
2

It's just my subjective take but Aotearoans are more gullible in what they believe in these matters.  

Up
0