sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Second tier US data quite mixed; Canada reports larger trade surplus; China expansion slows; dairy prices firm; Australian consumer sentiment weak; UST 10yr at 5.26%; gold firmish but oil eases again; NZ$1 = 56.2 USc; TWI-5 = 60

Economy / news
Second tier US data quite mixed; Canada reports larger trade surplus; China expansion slows; dairy prices firm; Australian consumer sentiment weak; UST 10yr at 5.26%; gold firmish but oil eases again; NZ$1 = 56.2 USc; TWI-5 = 60
Breakfast Briefing

Here's our summary of key economic events overnight that affect New Zealand, with news that although the Strait of Hormuz is essentially shut again, alternate flows of crude oil are starting to ramp up. And benchmark bond yields have eased back today.

But first, the overnight dairy auction was a full one and prices rose +1.2% in USD terms, up +3.6% in NZD terms from the prior full event three weeks ago. SMP starred again, up +4.3% while WMP was up +1.2%. But the milk fats were all lower with butter dipping slightly, butter down -1.1%, cheddar down +3.7% and mozzarella down -3.9%. However the overall result is likely enough to confirm Fonterra's recent raising of its payout forecasts.

In the US, the weekly ADP Employment pulse report recorded a 23,750 rise, continuing a trend that started in mid-August.

Meanwhile the US logistics industry has issues. Their LMI rose in September to its second-highest reading in four years, behind only June’s level. It is being driven by high and rising inventory levels and inventory costs. Transport costs are surging. Supply chain pressure is not easing.

We have reported US merchandise trade data for August before, but the same data is now out including services, and that has a similar negative result - a monster US$105.6 bln monthly deficit, worse than in any pandemic month, and only exceeded by the pre-tariff rush in 2025. So after the new tariff levels were introduced - the situation is worse.

However, the optimism survey by RCM/TIPP is marginally better in October than for September. But it remains well below 2025 levels, and those themselves were lower than pre-pandemic levels. Investors are much more optimistic now than non-investors.

Canada is reporting a wider trade surplus in August, in fact its best result since 2022. Interestingly, its surplus with the US is particularly strong.

In Asia, the World Bank has updated its growth forecasts, noting that many countries in the region are getting a very sharp boost from the AI adoption investment. China seems to be excluded from that growth pulse although the eased the rate of growth decline in this latest assessment for China, seeing a +4.3% expansion in 2027, +4.2% in 2028. Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia and the Philippines will all do better than China, they say. And of course the World Bank ignores Taiwan at China's insistence and they will do better as well. (Not doing well are the Pacific Islands, unfortunately, lumbered with high fuel costs and without the electronics industry.)

German factory orders tumbled an outsized -10.6% in August from July, but this is more about the unusual jump in the prior month. From a year ago, these order levels ae +2.7% higher. And, as with most German data, this is inflation-adjusted.

In Australia, the Westpac-Melbourne Institute consumer sentiment survey for October makes grim reading too. This is how they introduced these results: "Australian consumers remain stuck in a cost-of-living nightmare that seems to have no end in sight. At just over 80, the latest sentiment Index is amongst the forty worst reads since our monthly survey began in the early 1970s. We have had two others in this unfortunate group already this year – in April and June – with another eight recorded in 2022–23. Altogether this marks the worst period of recurring extremely weak sentiment since the disastrous recession in the early 1990s."

The UST 10yr yield is easing, now just on 5.26%, down -8 bps from yesterday and off its highs. The 30 year yield is at 5.65%, down -5 bps. The key 2-10 yield curve is now at +48 bps (unchanged). Their 1-5 curve is now at +58 bps (-3 bps) and the 3 mth-10yr curve is at +136 bps (-6 bps). The China 10 year bond rate is little-changed at 1.68%. The Japanese 10 year bond yield is now at 3.10%, down -3 bps from yesterday. The Australian 10 year bond yield starts today at 5.35%, down -7 bps from yesterday. The NZ Government 10 year bond rate is now at 5.14%, up +6 bps from yesterday and a three year high.

Wall Street moving up with the S&P500 up +0.7% and the Nasdaq up +0.6%. Overnight, European markets were mixed between London's +0.4% rise and Frankfurt's +0.8% rise. Yesterday, Tokyo ended up +1.1%. Hong King was up +1.0% and of course Shanghai was closed. Singapore ended up +0.7%. The ASX200 closed up +0.6%. The NZX50 ended its Tuesday trade little-changed.

The price of gold is at US$4157/oz and up +US$27 from yesterday. Silver is at just under US$61.50/oz and up +50 USc today.

Oil prices have eased -50 USc/bbl from yesterday to just over US$89.50/bbl in the US, while the international Brent price is down -US$1 to US$100/bbl. And we should note the pace of the flurry on attacks on tankers in the Hormuz region in the past few days are ongoing, keeping tanker traffic essentially non-existent. Hormuz transits have reduced again today with just eight ships exiting over the past 24 hours, no tankers escorted (1 dark with transponders off) and 5 entering for new loads (0 dark). The Red Sea activity is back up to the low 20 vessels in either direction at the Yemen chokepoint.

The Kiwi dollar is back up +30 bps from yesterday, now at just on 56.2 USc. Against the Aussie we are up +20 bps at 80.5 AUc. Against the euro we are up +10 bps at just on 50 euro cents. That all means our TWI-5 starts today at just under 60 and up +30 bps from yesterday.

The bitcoin price starts today at US$85,687 and up +0.5% from yesterday. Volatility over the past 24 hours has been low at just over +/-0.8%.

Daily exchange rates

Select chart tabs

Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: RBNZ
Source: CoinDesk

The easiest place to stay up with event risk is by following our Economic Calendar here ».

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

27 Comments

Tame failed to ask the biggest question. 

And Campbell is currently likewise. 

Where is the MSM? 

Humanity is grossly overshot, structures are breaking down, competition for dwindling resources is escalating. 

But - $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Sigh

Up
4

They will never go there PDK. The political parties have to put it on the table first. And in doing so they will need to present at least the outline of a vision that will be palatable to the majority. They don't see it, they don't understand it, and therefore they cannot address it. they're not alone. Every other country in the world is the same. The only people acknowledging it are considered nutters and freaks (That's us by the way). Denial is killing the species.

Up
4

Observe the gaggle of supposed reporters elbowing  themselves into every standing political interview that is of prospect to concoct a headline and you can only conclude sadly,  that the major  purpose in mind is the advancement of said supposed reporter’s personal career. Own a headline, get noticed, do it again, that’s the ticket to success. All of that self promotion  from all of them is thus discharged into the labyrinth of the electronic media coverage to the great satisfaction of the authors and their fans, if there are any. Very stupid and annoying stuff and now you can see the inventiveness of AI being employed to supplement the lack of either intelligence or capability.  All of that, off the chest, before coffee time.

Up
5

Saudi backed Yemeni government forces are pushing the Houthis back from their gains in Yemen including regaining the town they took.

Americans are still buying Canadian, but Canadians are not buying American? That'll piss Trump off. Interestingly the Canadian government is facing some secession issues with a couple of states looking at referendums on pulling away from Canada; Quebec and Alberta. Internal politics must be interesting.

Up
1

Add France in a state of riot, re schools. 

Spain in a state of riot, re rental affordability (landlords here, take note - it's coming). 

Genocide on all Israeli-borders. 

Increase in the number of rogue states - now including the US. 

Unrepayable debt. 

Mass disenfrangisement - driving polarisation driving confrontation. 

And global entropy as the background drumbeat...

What could possibly go wrong? 

Up
2

The same issue with the leaders debate - denial. 

Up
4

You may as well end it now PDK, what point is it to live with such a terrible, negative, depressed view on the future

Up
4

He got the last sentence wrong. It should have had a positive last word. Everything collapsing to a sustainable world is not negative any more than house prices falling to a low level is negative.

Up
2

Only if you need the current regime to remain, is it depressing. 

I'm not so hamstrung. 

Up
0

Albertian and Quebec succession been simmering for as long as Canadia has existed, bit like Scotaland and the UK.  Albertians getting pissed off having to support the retirees in Quebec.  Doesn't seem like anything is going to happen on current polling.

Up
1

I did read one comment that made sense; it's democracy in action to at least poll what the people think. 

Like Scotland though, they don't think deep enough. Those states will be far better off being a part of the Canadian union. There will be downsides, but they won't be significant if you're not focussed on finding problems.

Up
1

Murray, there certainly appears to have been a Saudi-backed counterattack and some territory has been recovered, so I wouldn't dispute that.

But I think “pushing the Houthis back from their gains in Yemen” rather overstates what is happening. Ansarallah still controls Sana'a and most of Yemen's principal population centres, while the so-called government side is an uneasy and often fractious collection of Saudi/UAE-backed factions rather than anything resembling a cohesive national army.

And the “Yemeni government” itself needs some context. The internationally recognised government lost Sana'a to Ansarallah back in 2014 and its successor, the Presidential Leadership Council, has largely operated from Aden and Saudi Arabia. 

Even within the territory nominally under its control, authority is divided among competing armed and political factions, some backed by Riyadh and others by Abu Dhabi. In other words, the map marked “government controlled” gives a rather misleading impression of a unified state exercising effective control over southern Yemen.

It is also worth remembering that this counterattack has required massive Saudi air support, reportedly involving around 100 aircraft, together with US intelligence and operational assistance.

That underlying fragility could become extremely important. 

Ansarallah has already demonstrated how quickly opposing lines can collapse, and if more surrounded government forces accept offers to surrender their weapons and evacuate rather than fight, today's territorial gains could reverse remarkably quickly. Riyadh may have overwhelming air power, but aircraft cannot manufacture a cohesive Yemeni force on the ground to take and hold territory.

So yes, a genuine counterattack - but I certainly wouldn't interpret it yet as the Yemeni “government” rolling Ansarallah back. This remains an extraordinarily fluid battlefield, and the supposedly government-held side may prove considerably more brittle than the map suggests.

Up
0

Front-lines have been blurry things since the beginning of air-power. 

And ranges have gotten longer. And cannon-balls now have explosive warheads and can cross whole oceans/continents (Iran/Diego Garcia, for recent instance). 

And targets are becoming energy-related (nobody targets banks or Wall St) because without energy, you are powerless. 

 

Up
2

The Ottomans controlled the coastlines both sides  of the peninsular. The interior remained wonderfully nomadic. Look at the map 1914 pre WW1.  The British were driven  out of Aden in the 60’s and only just stopped the ousters moving onto Oman in the 70s. The people of Yemen quite obviously know the best way to conduct warfare in Yemen, that history speaks for itself. Last time the Saudis got heavily involved it triggered a humanitarian crisis. Using towns firstly as fortifications and secondly in need,  the townspeople as shields,  creates very difficult nuts to crack. 

Up
1

Are you forgetting 9/11?

Up
0

Yes it's a pretty fractured state. Never the less that push back has likely diverted the Houthi's attention from ships passing in the night to the landward pressure. 

But largely I don't disagree with your comment. Next week the Houthi's may regain what they lost, or lose even more. What will come? Who knows.

Up
1

Agreed, Murray - and that last paragraph is pretty much how I see it too. This thing could look quite different again next week.

I'm not so sure, though, that the landward pressure will necessarily distract Ansarallah greatly from the “ships passing in the night”. Their maritime capability is largely an asymmetric missile/drone operation rather than something requiring huge numbers of troops, and control of the approaches to Bab el-Mandeb remains one of the strongest cards they possess.

In fact, if Saudi pressure on land increases, I wouldn't be surprised if Ansarallah placed even greater emphasis on precisely those asymmetric capabilities where they can impose costs vastly disproportionate to the resources required.

As you say, though - who knows what next week's map will look like?

Up
0

OATS, GILTS... AND GOATS - France, Britain, and the Next Sovereign Debt Crisis

To me, France and Britain increasingly resemble two heavily indebted men walking towards the same cliff by slightly different routes. One carries OATs. The other carries gilts.

And taxpayers in both countries increasingly resemble the sacrificial goats.

DEAD MEN WALKING

France has public debt approaching 120% of GDP, a deficit still running above 5%, anaemic economic growth and a political system apparently incapable of delivering anything remotely resembling the fiscal adjustment required to reverse the trajectory.

The government's great rescue plan?

Reduce a deficit of roughly 5.4% of GDP to 5%.

Seriously.

Even if Finance Minister Roland Lescure manages to get something resembling the proposed budget through a hostile parliament, this isn't fiscal repair.

It is rearranging the deckchairs while the water is already coming over the bow.

Meanwhile France needs to finance an extraordinary amount of debt. Its 2027 financing requirement is approaching €340 billion, with planned medium and long-term bond issuance of around the same amount.

Across the Channel sits Britain.

Its headline public debt ratio is somewhat lower, but that conceals what I regard as an even deeper structural problem - Britain's desperately weak Productive GDP, or PGDP.

GDP counts almost everything involving monetary activity. PGDP asks the much nastier question when assessing the sustainability of debt -

What does the country actually produce that generates the real wealth required to service it?

Britain has spent decades hollowing out much of its industrial base while building one of the most financialised economies on earth. Property, finance, consumption and government expenditure have increasingly displaced the productive foundations upon which sustainable national wealth ultimately depends.

Measured against the productive economy sitting underneath it, Britain's debt position looks considerably uglier than its conventional debt-to-GDP ratio suggests.

THE BOND MARKET SENDS THE BILL

And now the bond market is beginning to send the bill.

British 10-year gilt yields have reached around 5.5%, while the 30-year has crossed 6%.

At those rates Britain's debt arithmetic begins eating itself.

Old cheap debt matures and gets refinanced at much higher rates. Interest expenditure rises. Government borrowing rises with it. More gilts have to be issued. Investors demand greater compensation for inflation and fiscal risk.

And around the wheel we go.

The Bank of England has already altered its QT operation dramatically. It halted sales of long-dated gilts and paused active gilt sales, rather than continuing to dump duration back into an increasingly fragile market.

That deserves far more attention than it has received.

When a central bank decides that hundreds of billions of government bonds are better left sitting on its balance sheet than being returned to the market, the market is already telling us something important.

France has a different problem.

It doesn't own the printing press.

It shares one.

Britain can therefore kick its can further down the road through sterling.

France must eventually persuade Frankfurt to kick the can for it.

Neither addresses the underlying disease.

THE €4.18 TRILLION ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM

And this is where things become considerably more interesting - sitting underneath Europe's increasingly indebted sovereigns are some of the largest Too Big To Fail banks on earth - and those banks themselves are stuffed with sovereign debt.

According to the European Banking Authority, EU and EEA banks held an extraordinary €4.18 trillion of sovereign exposures at the end of 2025.

Put that number beside their capital - those sovereign exposures represented around 232% of the entire banking system's Common Equity Tier 1 capital.

And here is the part that should make people sit up - 59.5% of those sovereign exposures were being carried at amortised cost.

In plain English, a large part of this sovereign bond mountain does not continuously pass its changing market price through the banks' reported profits or equity in the way a trading security does.

If a bank bought a government bond at 100 and rising yields subsequently drive its market value to 80, accounting classification can allow the bank to continue carrying the asset according to the amortised-cost model, assuming it can hold the bond and applicable impairment rules don't require otherwise.

That does not magically make its market value 100 again - the economic loss exists - it simply hasn't necessarily been recognised through current earnings or equity. And even the EBA now explicitly warns about this.

Unrealised losses on amortised-cost bond portfolios can have capital and liquidity consequences and can crystallise under stress through forced asset sales, collateral requirements or liquidity pressure.

Remember Silicon Valley Bank - a bond can be perfectly good at maturity and still help destroy the institution holding it if that institution suddenly needs cash today.

THE EQUITY SHOCK ABSORBER

Now put that beside the actual equity supporting these gigantic balance sheets - this is where the comfortable language of regulatory capital ratios can obscure as much as it reveals.

Take Société Générale.

It disclosed around €15 billion of French sovereign exposure, including approximately €8.5 billion of French OATs. Roughly 80% of those OATs were carried at amortised cost.

Crédit Agricole disclosed around €30.4 billion of French sovereign exposure in its banking portfolio, with approximately €19.8 billion at amortised cost. Its insurance activities contained tens of billions more.

And these are only pieces of enormously larger sovereign portfolios spread across different countries, maturities and accounting classifications.

The danger isn't that every government bond suddenly defaults. It doesn't need to. The danger is repricing. Sovereign yields rise. Bond prices fall. Fair-valued portfolios take the hit immediately. OCI portfolios erode reported equity.

Amortised-cost portfolios accumulate economic losses that may remain largely invisible to headline earnings until circumstances force recognition or sale.

Meanwhile the same sovereign stress raises the banks' own wholesale funding costs, weakens collateral values and frightens shareholders.

And bank equity has one particularly unpleasant characteristic.

It is the thin shock absorber underneath an enormous pile of assets.

BNP Paribas alone operates a balance sheet of roughly €3 trillion.

Société Générale is around €1.7 trillion.

Crédit Agricole Group is well above €2 trillion.

Move asset values by what appears to be a trivial percentage across balance sheets of that size and suddenly the number isn't trivial at all when measured against ordinary shareholder equity.

That is why the share price matters. Investors don't have to wait for a sovereign default. Once they begin questioning asset values, funding costs, sovereign exposures and the credibility of the government supposedly standing behind the banking system, bank equity can fall extraordinarily quickly.

Then the feedback loop begins - Falling bank shares undermine confidence - Credit spreads widen - Funding becomes more expensive - Collateral requirements increase - Assets have to be sold - Those sales push prices lower - Which creates further losses -Which destroys more equity.

.... slowly - then suddenly.

WHEN THE SOVEREIGN AND THE BANK BECOME THE SAME TRADE

And now we arrive at the truly dangerous part.

Banks own sovereign bonds.

Sovereigns stand behind banks.

Banks provide the credit supporting the economy that produces the tax revenue supporting the sovereign.

When sovereign bonds fall heavily enough, bank balance sheets weaken.

When banks weaken badly enough, governments are expected to stand behind them.

But what happens when the government standing behind the banks is itself the source of the market's concern?

That is the sovereign-bank doom loop.

France is particularly interesting because BNP Paribas, Crédit Agricole and Société Générale operate gigantic internationally interconnected balance sheets while the sovereign standing behind them is itself moving deeper into debt.

Britain has HSBC, Barclays, Lloyds and NatWest sitting inside one of the world's most interconnected financial centers while its own sovereign borrowing costs have climbed towards levels not seen for decades.

And these institutions don't exist inside neat national boxes.

They lend internationally. They finance trade internationally. They transact derivatives internationally. They borrow internationally. Their collateral moves internationally.

Their counterparties include banks, pension funds, insurers, hedge funds and asset managers across America, Europe and Asia - which means the problem doesn't stop at Dover or the Rhine.

FROM PARIS AND LONDON TO EVERYWHERE

This is where a French or British sovereign crisis could mutate remarkably quickly into a global financial event. The transmission mechanism isn't mysterious.

Sovereign yields rise. Bond prices fall. Collateral values decline. Leveraged positions require additional margin. Investors sell whatever they can sell rather than necessarily what they want to sell. Liquidity disappears from supposedly liquid markets. Bank funding spreads widen. Credit tightens. Asset prices fall further.

And suddenly institutions thousands of kilometres away discover that the French or British sovereign crisis they supposedly had little exposure to is sitting inside their counterparty book.

We've seen this movie before. In 2008 the supposedly contained problem was American subprime mortgages. During the Eurozone crisis it was supposedly Greece.

In September 2022 it was supposedly a temporary liquidity problem among leveraged British pension funds.

Financial crises have an irritating habit of revealing connections everybody assured us were perfectly manageable right up until the moment they weren't. And this time there is one enormous difference.

The sovereign balance sheets expected to extinguish the fire are themselves increasingly part of the fire. The governments aren't standing safely outside the burning building holding the hose - they are inside it.

THE PRINTING PRESS ISN'T A FACTORY

Britain possesses monetary sovereignty, which means it can probably postpone the reckoning longer.

But that may ultimately be as much curse as blessing, because it allows successive governments to kick the can further down the road without confronting the monetary architecture producing the problem.

And a printing press cannot manufacture productive capacity. It cannot manufacture energy. It cannot rebuild an industrial base overnight. It cannot create export competitiveness by decree. And ultimately it cannot print the real goods and services required to give sterling purchasing power.

France has the additional constraint that its printing press sits in Frankfurt.

So both countries will continue reaching for the familiar remedies - higher taxes, spending restraint around the margins, accounting adjustments, financial repression and central-bank intervention whenever markets become sufficiently disorderly.

Anything except confronting the architecture itself.

THE REFORM NOBODY WILL DISCUSS

My own solution is considerably more fundamental - what I call the Three Pillars.

Public-utility money creation and banking, so society captures the enormous economic rent currently attached to privately created credit and can direct new money towards productive rather than predominantly speculative purposes.

A broad, extremely low-rate Financial Transaction Tax, capable of replacing much of the existing burden imposed upon productive labour, enterprise and consumption.

And gold as the external umpire - not a nineteenth-century gold standard, but an asset outside somebody else's balance sheet capable of imposing discipline upon international monetary settlement.

Nothing remotely approaching that scale of monetary reform is presently being seriously discussed in Westminster, Paris or Frankfurt. Instead they debate whether next year's deficit should be 5.4% or 5%. Whether another tax should rise.Whether another spending programme should be trimmed. Whether another tranche of government bonds should be sold, bought, reinvested or quietly left sitting on a central-bank balance sheet.

They are treating the symptoms while protecting the monetary architecture producing the disease.

OATS, GILTS... AND GOATS

And that brings us back to where we started.

France has its OATs. Britain has its gilts. Both have governments carrying enormous accumulated debts against productive economies increasingly incapable of comfortably servicing them.

Both have enormous TBTF banking systems sitting directly in the transmission mechanism. And both have political establishments offering incremental fiscal tinkering to problems that increasingly require fundamental monetary reform.

I don't suggest either France or Britain defaults tomorrow. Nor am I predicting that BNP Paribas, Société Générale, HSBC or Barclays suddenly collapses.

Nobody knows which domino falls first - or exactly when. But that isn't really the point. The fragility is already being built into the system.

Every additional percentage point of sovereign yield increases the refinancing burden. Every fall in bond prices increases pressure somewhere else on somebody's balance sheet. Every additional round of government borrowing creates still more sovereign paper that somebody has to own. Every central-bank intervention designed to suppress the immediate consequences buys time while reducing the incentive to confront the underlying problem. And every year the productive base fails to keep pace with the mountain of claims sitting above it, the eventual adjustment becomes more difficult.

France and Britain aren't Greece. They sit at the heart of the European and global financial system. Their sovereign bonds are collateral. Their banks are counterparties. Their currencies are reserve assets. Their financial institutions are woven through virtually every important market on earth.

That is why the next European sovereign crisis - if it comes from one of these two - could look very different from the last one. This time the governments aren't standing safely outside the burning building holding the hose. They are inside it - along with the banks.

And when the political response inevitably arrives, history tells us who will be expected to carry the burden - Depositors - Savers - Pension funds - Businesses -Workers - Taxpayers.

The people who ultimately pay when governments choose inflation, currency debasement and financial repression rather than admit that the debts themselves have become unsustainable.

So perhaps the title isn't quite as flippant as it first appears.

OATs in Paris.

Gilts in London.

And if these two debt-doom-loops are allowed to continue until the bond markets finally call time - no prizes for guessing who gets to be the Goats.

Up
1

Joe Blogs lays out France's problem too...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozSD58FtVrI

Up
0

Lol

Up
1

THE LEADERS DEBATE - and the Wernerian elephant sitting smack bang in the center of the New Zealand economy

There was a lot of focus, and much gnashing of teeth, on how dismally NZ's economy is doing in comparison with its peers, which was the one thing they got right.

It was so painful to witness, that I had to take it in small stop-start doses, just to avoid the temptation of lobbing something very heavy through the TV screen. Meanwhile, my partner only lasted 30 seconds in front of the screen, and a couple more within earshot.

And the elephant that these two macroeconomic illiterates - and apparently most of the people advising them - utterly miss? - there isn't just one New Zealand economy - there are two.

There is the productive economy that actually grows food, manufactures things, develops technology, builds productive infrastructure, earns export income and produces the additional goods and services from which our real standard of living ultimately comes.

And sitting alongside it is an enormous financialised property economy built around existing houses, land, mortgages and ever-rising claims upon the same underlying stock of assets.

Our politicians obsess endlessly about the combined headline GDP number while apparently remaining blissfully unaware that how bank-created money is divided between those two economies may be one of the most important determinants of our economic performance.

This is where Professor Richard Werner's work becomes impossible to ignore.

Only around 23% of NZ's total bank lending goes to the entire business sector.

But even that dramatically overstates the amount reaching genuinely productive enterprise, because around 36% of business lending itself is property-related.

Strip that out and the number collapses to just 14.7% of total bank lending.

And even that isn't productive capital investment.

It also includes working capital, refinancing, acquisitions and other business borrowing that may create little or no additional productive capacity.

So after all the houses, mortgages, property investment and property-related business lending have been stripped away, less than 15 cents in every dollar of New Zealand bank lending even reaches the starting gate of the non-property business economy.

The proportion actually financing new machinery, factories, technology and additional productive capacity must be significantly smaller again.

And then they wonder why productivity growth is pathetic. They wonder why wages struggle. They wonder why our tradable sector struggles. They wonder why infrastructure continually falls behind.

They wonder why genuinely productive SMEs complain about access to capital while somebody with sufficient equity in three houses can borrow another million dollars to buy a fourth.

Follow the credit.

This is precisely why I keep banging on about Productive GDP - PGDP.

Headline GDP happily mixes activity generated by the productive economy with an enormous amount of activity generated around property, finance, consumption and government expenditure.

PGDP asks a much more uncomfortable question.

How much additional productive capacity are we actually creating underneath all that financial activity?

Because creating another million dollars of mortgage credit against an existing Auckland house may increase bank assets, household debt, property prices and all sorts of associated economic activity.

But New Zealand hasn't acquired another factory. It hasn't acquired another machine. It hasn't produced another export. And it hasn't necessarily increased by one dollar the productive capacity from which that additional million-dollar financial claim must ultimately be serviced.

That is the distinction our political debate completely misses. We have spent decades feeding credit into one economy and then expressing astonishment that the other one is anaemic.

Until somebody standing for Prime Minister understands who creates the money, where that newly created credit goes, and the enormous difference between credit used to inflate existing assets and credit used to create new productive capacity, these leaders' debates will continue to be bad theatre.

They can argue about tax rates, government spending, the OCR and whether headline GDP grew by two-tenths of one percent until the cows come home.

But the Wernerian elephant will still be sitting smack bang in the centre of the New Zealand economy.

We keep measuring the economy that credit inflated - while starving the economy that actually has to produce the goods and services to pay for it.

Up
1

Well said. 

Don't disagree at all.

But ask: Why? 

The answer is: A growing reduction in real possibilities. 

Which I call the Limits to Growth. 

Up
0

PDK, you are turning this into Limits to Growth again, but that completely misses the point I was making.

Nothing I wrote requires infinite physical growth on a finite planet. My point is about allocation.

Whatever physical resources, energy and ecological carrying capacity are available to us, we can either direct capital towards improving the productive capacity and efficiency of the economy - better machinery, technology, infrastructure, energy efficiency, food production and useful goods and services - or we can create enormous quantities of bank credit to bid up the price of houses and land that already exist.

Those are radically different economic outcomes.

In fact, if your Limits to Growth argument is correct, Werner's credit-allocation argument becomes more important, not less.

If energy and resources are constrained, wasting most of our money-creation capacity inflating existing asset prices becomes even more absurd. We should be squeezing every possible unit of useful productive output from the resources we have.

That is precisely why I distinguish headline GDP from Productive GDP - PGDP.

I am not arguing for infinite consumption.

I am asking why less than 15 cents in every dollar of NZ bank lending even reaches the non-property business economy, before we further deduct refinancing, acquisitions, working capital and everything else that doesn't directly create additional productive capacity.

That's a monetary architecture question, PDK - not a Limits to Growth argument.

You are arguing about the size of the cake. I am pointing where the biggest slices end up.

Up
1

 We should be squeezing every possible unit of useful productive output from the resources we have.'

No.

We should be identifying the three types of resource; Finite, Renewable and Sink. 

The first we need not to use, or100% recycle. The second we need not to use beyond it's renewal rate. The third we need to not fill at faster than its absorption-capability rate.

We're beyond all three, by some margin.

So any financial architecture built upon exponential growth (and speaking in percentages confirms that it does) is doomed to recorrection. Whether through jubilee, inflation or collapse. 

Up
2

The first we need not to use, or100% recycle.

How can we feasibly 100% recycle anything given the 2nd law of thermodynamics as you keep stating. Seems odd this would slip past you of all folk.

Up
0

Our politicians obsess endlessly about the combined headline GDP number while apparently remaining blissfully unaware that how bank-created money is divided between those two economies may be one of the most important determinants of our economic performance.

Paragraph of the day, solid work Colin.

Up
0