Thursday's Top 10 with NZ Mint: NZX strategist calls for 10% flat tax in ChCh; Martin Wolf argues against fiscal austerity; Why central banks should sacrifice independence; Dilbert

Here's my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 10 am in association with NZ Mint.

As always, we welcome your additions in the comments below or via email to

See all previous Top 10s here.

My must read today is #1 from Ambrose on central bank independence.

1, 'End central bank independence now' - It's good to see someone come out in public and say it. Ambrose Evans Pritchard thinks the unthinkable here at The Telegraph.

This is one of the central questions to emerge from the Global Financial Crisis.

As democratically-elected governments become increasingly bogged down in fiscal policy debates that falsely compare household and government debts, someone has to be the grownup to boost the economy.

Central banks have cut rates as much as possible and the more enlightened/desperate ones are now monetising government debt to keep the boat afloat.

That often requires central banks to effectively give up their independence.

I think we'll eventually see that here too after an almighty fight between a centre-left government and the current Reserve Bank Governor.

Here's Ambrose:

Princeton professor Gauti Eggertsson has long argued that independent central banks have a “deflation bias” by their nature. This was fine during the quarter century after the Great Inflation of the 1970s, but as the inflation rate fell ever lower with each business cycle it eventually became dangerous, for there lies the dreaded “liquidity trap”.

A new paper by Paul McCulley and Zoltan Poszar argues that the taste for independent central banks goes “hand-in-hand with secular private debt cycles”. It becomes faddish during credit upswings such as the era of “monetary supremacy” from 1978 to 2008. The appeal wears off as the “deleveraging cycle” gathers force and the economy slides into slump.

2. The problem with the strong euro - The FT points out the recent euro strength is causing problems for the European economy, which has plenty of problems already.

The FT wonders if the ECB will eventually have to get off the sidelines and return fire in the currency wars -- ie by fully monetising government debt (printing money)

Even Germany’s resilient exporters have reason to worry – the euro/yen rate matters for the country’s powerful car manufacturers. Jean-Claude Juncker, Luxembourg’s prime minister, who has just relinquished his chairmanship of eurozone finance ministers meetings, warned last week that the euro’s level was “dangerously high”.

All of which means Mr Draghi needs a contingency plan up his sleeve. A first step could be Trichet-style “open mouth operations”. But the ECB could go further and offer more long-term liquidity, for instance, or lower interest rates further.

3. Flat tax in Christchurch? - NZX Head of Strategy Sam Stanley has called for a flat tax of 10% in Christchurch on TV3's Firstline. Your thoughts in the comments below please.

"I'd like to see them look at Canterbury… it would be great to see them bring in a low flat tax of say, 10 percent, within the Christhchurch, Canterbury area to encourage new businesses," Sam Stanley of the NZX told Firstline this morning.

"Ring-fence that Christchurch area and see if they can encourage new businesses to come in and activity to be fuelled out of the Christchurch zone.

4. 'Just calm down people' - Martin Wolf at makes a persuasive case against fiscal austerity when economies are flatlining, in particular in the United States.

Yet another legacy of the crisis has been a huge rise in the consolidated financial surplus of the private sector (balance between income and spending, as shares of GDP). The fiscal deficit is the mirror image of this increased private prudence. The risk is that accelerated fiscal stringency, at a time of zero interest rates, will depress the economy more than improve the fiscal outcomes. This is because fiscal multipliers are particularly high in such circumstances, as the International Monetary Fund has argued. The time to tighten fiscal policy will be when the economy is strong.

The federal government is not on the verge of bankruptcy. If anything, the tightening has been too much and too fast. The fiscal position is also not the most urgent economic challenge. It is far more important to promote recovery. The challenges in the longer term are to raise revenue while curbing the cost of health. Meanwhile, people, just calm down.

5. Heretical thoughts from Chalkie - Fairfax Media's business columnist Chalkie has picked up on last year's deeply heretical Chicago Revisited paper from the IMF that suggested a complete change in the current system of fractional reserve lending and privately created money - ie making sure all bank deposits are backed by government bonds.

The Kumhof/Benes paper proposes requiring bank deposits to be 100 per cent backed by reserves of government-issued money, which banks borrow from the state Treasury. This immediately reduces the risk of a bank run to zero.

Previous bank lending to the government can be netted off against this borrowing, resulting in a huge reduction in government debt.

The old lending function of banks is meanwhile carried out by investment trusts that must fund their loans with money borrowed from the Treasury, or with existing government-issued money borrowed from the private sector, or with their own equity. Chalkie has necessarily over-simplified the scheme, but it is clearly a radical departure from the way the money supply is handled today.

6. A new gold standard? - So wonders Ambrose in another of his pieces at The Telegraph pointing to central bank gold purchases. The Bundesbank's decision to move its gold back from America to Germany is interesting too.

Neither the euro nor the dollar can inspire full confidence, although for different reasons. EMU is a dysfunctional construct, covering two incompatible economies, prone to lurching from crisis to crisis, without a unified treasury to back it up. The dollar stands on a pyramid of debt. We all know that this debt will be inflated away over time – for better or worse. The only real disagreement is over the speed.

The central bank buyers are of course the rising powers of Asia and the commodity bloc, now holders of two thirds of the world’s $11 trillion foreign reserves, and all its incremental reserves.

It is no secret that China is buying the dips, seeking to raise the gold share of its reserves well above 2pc. Russia has openly targeted a 10pc share. Variants of this are occurring from the Pacific region to the Gulf and Latin America. And now the Bundesbank has chosen to pull part of its gold from New York and Paris.

7. 'Cowardly politicians and the grey vote' - Mary Riddell writes at The Telegraph about cowardly politicians who kowtow to grey voters at the expense of younger generations. Sound familiar?

Horror over the fate of poorer pensioners has for too long been mixed with misplaced sentimentality over all older people. The whiff of a granny tax is enough to reduce the political classes to apoplexy – and yet the over-55s, the most privileged generation ever, own two-thirds of the UK’s housing wealth. The difficulty, for Labour and Tories alike, is that the same cohort accounts for 40 per cent of general election votes.

Too bad. Fear of the grey vote is closing off the few remaining ways of fairly redistributing resources and wealth to help poorer pensioners and hard-pressed parents alike. Generation Xploited – younger people struggling to get by – is stretched to its limits. It cannot, and will not, pick up the bill for the political cowardice afflicting those barely out of the cradle and those condemned to misery as they approach the grave.

8. Keep an eye on the Senkakus - This dispute over a few rocks in the seas between China and Japan has the potential to get ugly, Bill Bishop points out over at Dealbook.

9. How's China's elite are unmasked - Further to yesterday's piece about corrupt Chinese officials fleeing China and buying offshore property, this is a cracking story of a Chinese banking official who owned 20 properties in Beijing because she created a fake hukou ID card (a very sensitive topic in China).

Police are investigating a former bank executive who was accused of holding four hukou, or household registrations, that she used to buy many properties.

Gong Aiai, 49, a former deputy chief of Shenmu Rural Commercial Bank, was exposed in an online post on Jan 17 that said she used two identity cards, one of them fake, to buy expensive properties. Identity cards are issued on the basis of hukou. News media have reported that she owns more than 20 properties in Beijing, worth 1 billion yuan ($160 million).

10. Totally Jon Stewart on the Beyonce lip synching 'scandal'.

(Updated with fixed Ambrose quote at #6. HT Waymad; also some cartoons)

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment or click on the "Register" link below a comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current Comment policy is here.


#6 has a repeated quote from #1.
I'd also point to a quote that PDK may appreciate, again saying stuff out loud at Davos:
"Many advanced economies are continuing to live at the expense of future generations, while all central banks have achieved by flooding the world with liquidity is to push underlying problems further down the road. “We are trying to keep a speed for our economies which is simply unsustainable,” he said. Quite so."
Light dawning amongst suits.....

Usually just before the buttons give way.
Happens with the last serge.

And when the situation is beyond selvedge.

Thanks for pointing out the quote snafu at #6. Fixed now.
Nice link too. cheers

Bernard - Re. #1 I would respectfully point out that you and AEP better be careful what you wish for with regard to giving politicians more  monetary policy control.  I would suggest you carefully read what Kyle Bass has to say about this situation in Japan.   

#3 has not a few practical issues (common to international commerce) in locating the source of, or ring-fencing against freeloaders of the 'taxable income' so treated: some scenarios

  • I live in Chch, run a Web-based biz outa the garage, and sell mainly to the rest of NZ.
  • I own a local branch of an international franchise, selling outa ChristChurch mainly to residents.  (Alert common taters will spot the issue over 'management and IP' fees, remitted out of the business and shown as COGS) which prove to be remarkably flexible in seeking out tax shelter
  • I am an NZ biz located in Auckland but my Christchurch suppliers drop-ship locally.  Can I treat that bit of the biz as 'Chch'?
  • I am outside Chch but set up (what else) a garage-based 'warehouse' and have all my suppliers drop-ship to customers but declaring the source of the goods as Der Garage.
  • I am outside NZ but set up (what else) a garage-based 'warehouse'......
  • I am outside NZ, and sell exclusively to Chch customers via a NZ shell company based in (what else) a garage in Chch.

Reality is soooo messy compared to the Utopian Dreams of academics.

Re- the spending of the future via ballooning sovereign debt; A re-assuring lie gets the treasury benches; an uncomfortable truth the privilege of watching the liars from the opposition benches.
The era of procrastination, of half-measures, of soothing and baffling expedients, of delays, is coming to a close. In its place we are entering a period of consequences…” – Winston Churchill

If you read only one thing this month then make it this: Perfect Storm; energy, finance and the end of growth, by Dr Tim Morgan, Global Head of Research, Tullet Prebon.
Even amongst the big money firms, the truth is leaking out. In case you are wondering Tullet Prebon is one of the largest inter-dealer money brokers in the world. I dont think they are in the habit of sponsoring research that they dont think is relevant.

That paper is outstanding, thanks for the link Andy.

If one asked a representative sample of the public what economics is all about, there is a very strong likelihood that the consensus answer would be “money”. The vast majority of economists do indeed frame the debate in monetary terms. The problem with this is that the economy is not, fundamentally, a monetary construct at all. Economics is really about the art of combining tangible components (such as labour and natural resources) to meet needs.
Ultimately, money is a convenient way of tokenising this process. The process itself, on the other hand, is an energy equation.

Great post Andy!
I hope Bernard reads this one nice and slowly. No doubt this will go over the head of Chaston and a few others but I'm optimistic that maybe, just maybe, Bernard will start to get it. Scientists have known this for years. Heck, PDK has been screaming this for years on this site.
Knock, knock people, reality is calling!

Just finished it. Definitely a must-read. This report deserves its own article on this site and wider publicity.

#1. Ambrose never knew Robert Muldoon then.

#3 - Flat Tax 10% in Christchurch - How exciting. Just thinking about the number of different ways it could be exploited (abused). Too easy.

#3 - Flat tax for Chch
Do you think Google, Starbucks, Facebook etc will set up their head offices in Chch?
There are enough loop holes allready.

Or how the rest of NZ would do? 

Whoops, forgot to take yer pills

#8 China V Japan
Followed a dispute between China & America on the internet some time back, think it was early 90's. Not reported in local press at time.
At the time China was preparing to take back Tiawan, by force if necessary. This led to tensions with America.
The commander of the American fleet (think it was called the 2nd fleet) told China that they would have to go through them, the American fleet, if they wanted to take Tiawan. The Chinese were reported as saying "we are not worried about you, we will just nuke you". Tensions got very hot between the two.
It was then reported that the Chinese leadership held a meeting. At that meeting it was decided they would take back Tiawan, but that they would have to prepare for war with America first.
China then set about preparing for war with America.
Is this the time? Do they now feel ready to stand up to America and face whatever the consequences may be, even war?

Japan has no oil of its own, ditto Philapines....and they will get more desperate.  A war of dwindling resources has long been mooted as a consquence of peak oil.
China's "problem" is if they want a sea war they will last about a week against the american chance in the falklands, put to sea, get sunk.  Of course no chance of putting down an oil rig from either side until one or other is defeated, so a standoff.
Another comment on it,

#6 - After this repatriation of German gold 50% will still be held overseas in the U.S and the U.K.  If physical gold is not in your own possession (preferably outside the banking system) then it's not yours.  Also why is Germany taking 7 years to re-patriate only 18% of their gold holdings.  Could it be that  the gold supposedly in the U.S is not actually there but has been sold or leased and it will take this long for the U.S authorities to replace it without forcing the price iof gold much higher.

The move from US surburbia to the inner city.
"The outward migration of people and their cars into the suburbs appears to have been slowed and actually reversed in some cases. Young people and young families are moving back into the city, drawn by the attraction of being in close proximity to their jobs, being able to walk to shopping, entertainment and recreation, and (in some cities like Portland, OR) take a short streetcar ride to these destinations. Survey after survey has revealed that many people are making the calculation that rather than spending two hours in their cars commuting, they want to move closer to jobs, recreation, shopping and the like in urban centers and have more time to spend with their families and enjoy other pursuits."

To crib from the latest headlines: Apple reports the largest corporate earnings in the history of the earth, stock down 10% as a result.