
Here's my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 10 am today.
As always, we welcome your additions in the comments below or via email to bernard.hickey@interest.co.nz.
See all previous Top 10s here.
My must read today is #7 on the young and the isolated in America. It's a nice companion piece to Elizabeth Davies' excellent piece on our site yesterday.
1. That crazy Chinese central bank - The mayhem on China's interbank credit markets on Thursday and Friday last week has freaked plenty of people, many of whom are questioning the Peoples Bank of China's lack of communication.
Interest rates spiked to over 20% and there were rumours a major bank defaulted.
The situation only calmed down somewhat when the People's Bank intervened to lend to one of the banks and interbank rates have since eased somewhat.
But plenty of nerves are jangled.
Here's Reuters with more detail on the lack of comment from the People's Bank. I must say it makes the RBNZ look a paragon of virtue. Perhaps we could export the RBNZ comms team to China? :)
Traders blame the absence of a clear and public signal from the central bank for panic at some smaller banks, as the cost of borrowing overnight funds spiked to as high as 25 percent for some institutions.
Those jitters spread more broadly late last week, as rumours - passed on by Chinese media outlets - that two major banks had received emergency funds from the PBOC circulated in financial markets in London and New York on Thursday.
The lenders denied the rumours, after which money markets calmed somewhat on Friday.
The panic in the otherwise arcane marketplace even sparked a flurry of activity on social media as the Twitter-like service Weibo lit up with comments from Chinese worried that a financial crisis was unfolding.
2. Et tu Bernanke? - Speaking of central bank communications, Paul Krugman is very worried the US Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke is jawboning interest rates higher much earlier than he should.
Fed officials are, consciously or not, responding to political pressure. After all, ever since the Fed began its policy of aggressive monetary stimulus, it has faced angry accusations from the right that it is “debasing” the dollar and setting the stage for high inflation — accusations that haven’t been retracted even though the dollar has remained strong and inflation has remained low. It’s hard to avoid the suspicion that Fed officials, worn down by the constant attacks, have been looking for a reason to slacken their efforts, and have seized on slightly better economic news as an excuse.
And maybe they’ll get away with it; maybe the economic recovery will strengthen and all will be well. But rising interest rates make that happy outcome less likely. And now that everyone knows that the Fed is eager to slacken off, it will be hard to get interest rates back down to where they were.
It’s sad and depressing, in both senses of the word. The fundamental reason our economy is still depressed after all these years is that so many policy makers lost the thread, forgetting that job creation was their most urgent task. Until now the Fed was an exception; but now it seems to be joining the club. Et tu, Ben?
3. Another Chinese ghost city - Matthew Niederhauser from Foreign Policy went to Chenggong in Kunming in Southern China to find some people. He found a lot of buildings, but not so many people. Click through to the pictures.
Chenggong, which means to "submit tribute," features a Central Business District dotted with dozens of office towers, a massive government compound, and 15 university campuses. Ten-lane highways crisscross the city, rolling over previously tilled fields, while farmers living in surrounding areas face eviction. Perhaps the only thing Chenggong lacks, as I saw on a trip to the city in February, is people. The municipal government claims that the population reached 350,000 in 2012, and expects one million inhabitants by 2020. Considering that the city features rows upon rows of empty buildings, that seems unlikely.
Chenggong, in short, is a ghost city. Like the better-known Kangbashi district of Ordos in Inner Mongolia, it was built in response to supposed macro trends in urbanization that would drive demand for housing and services. Beijing hopes that roughly 850 million Chinese will be urbanites by 2020, and plans to spend $6.5 trillion to encourage it. Indeed, Chinese cities will continue to grow -- but Chenggong may remain empty.
4. Another Greek meltdown - The New York Times reckons there's a chance the Greek government could fall and be replaced by Syriza, which would demand a new bailout deal. In that case, buckle up.
5. Europe remains a mess - NYT reports European ministers failed again over the weekend to agree on a set of rules for a banking union. Many believe Europe's banks are insolvent if they were ever forced to crystallise their losses on Southern European bonds and property.
The Bank for International Settlements, a group representing central banks including the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank, warned political leaders on Sunday that they should not expect central banks’ cheap-money policy to hold the global economy together forever. The organization, based in Basel, Switzerland, said in its annual report that politicians should do their share of “the hard but essential work of adjustment.”
The report was published a day after a political leaders’ meeting in Luxembourg had provided a vivid example of what the central bankers were complaining about. Despite debating well into the early morning on Saturday, European Union finance ministers could not agree on new rules to reduce the chances of taxpayers bearing the burden if commercial banks collapsed.
6. 'It won't work' - The Bank for International Settlements has always taken a fairly Austrian and some would say Austerian line on all the money printing that has gone on over the years. It came out again over the weekend to say the money printing is not working. It has a point. The bolding is mine. Here's the BBC report.
“How can central banks encourage those responsible for structural adjustment to implement those reforms? How can they avoid making the economy too dependent on monetary stimulus? When is the right time for them to pull back ... [and] how can they avoid sparking a sharp rise in bond yields? It is time for monetary policy to begin answering these questions,” the report said.
Mario Draghi’s rallying cry, uttered last summer at the height of the eurozone turmoil, that the European Central Bank would do “whatever it takes” to preserve the currency bloc was now being misconstrued, it warned.
“Can central banks now really do ‘whatever it takes’?” the BIS asked. “It seems less and less likely. Central banks cannot repair the balance sheets of households and financial institutions.”
7. 'Young and isolated' - Elizabeth Davies wrote an excellent piece for Interest.co.nz this week on life for an indebted student on the minimum wage in New Zealand. Here at the New York Times Harvard fellow Jennifer Silva has written a book called 'Coming Up Short: Working-Class Adulthood in an Age of Uncertainty.' It captures many of the same themes.
When and how will the young revolt? We're seeing an idea in Brazil and Turkey. In America the Occupy movement petered out.
This piece is today's must-read. It makes the great point that many of these young people blame themselves and become increasingly isolated.
These are people bouncing from one temporary job to the next; dropping out of college because they can’t figure out financial aid forms or fulfill their major requirements; relying on credit cards for medical emergencies; and avoiding romantic commitments because they can take care of only themselves. Increasingly disconnected from institutions of work, family and community, they grow up by learning that counting on others will only hurt them in the end. Adulthood is not simply being delayed but dramatically reimagined along lines of trust, dignity and connection and obligation to others.
Seeing the British establishment struggle with the financial sector is like watching an alcoholic who still resists the idea that something drastic needs to happen for him to turn his life around. Until 2008 there was denial over what finance had become. When a series of bank failures made this impossible, there was widespread anger, leading to the public humiliation of symbolic figures. But the scandals kept coming, and so we entered stage three – what therapists call "bargaining". A broad section of the political class now recognises the need for change but remains unable to see the necessity of a fundamental overhaul. Instead it offers fixes and patches, from tiny increases leverage ratios to bonus clawbacks and electrified ring fences.
9. 'As safe as houses' - Roger Bootle writes at The Telegraph about Britain's housing market and the danger of the government's subsidies for home lending. He predicted a 20% fall in British house prices. He has been receiving abuse ever since.... Sounds familiar...He makes the point that house prices are still overvalued with price to income multiples of over 6... Sounds familiar
This is a tale of two countries: London and the rest. In many ways, London has ceased to be British. It is a global city. Only New York is in the same league. At present, for the internationally mobile global elites, London property is perceived as a safe, attractive place to park your wealth – whatever the prices. The result is that prices in the capital are 7pc above the 2007 peak. By contrast, in many other regions prices are well down. For example, in the North West and Yorkshire, they are now more than 20pc below their peak, and they have fallen by more than 25pc in the North East.
Even within the capital, there is a marked divergence between outer London and prime central London. In the former, since the previous peak in early 2008, prices are still down by 2pc, whereas in the latter they are up by almost 30pc.
Interestingly, despite the large price falls outside London, house prices still look stranded in mid-air. The ratio of average house prices to average earnings is at 5.2, down from 6.3 at the peak but well above the historical average of 3.7. It is even still above the peak at the top of the previous boom in the late 1980s.
So what does the future hold? Prices appear to be gently rising again, but without much support from the economic fundamentals. The UK economy is probably on the up, but not by very much. In any case, I doubt whether average earnings will increase much faster. And it is possible that employment will fall back as the public sector cuts more jobs. At some stage, interest rates will have to return to normal. Admittedly, I think that is likely to be far distant. Nevertheless, it will come. At that point, unless something else has intervened to make houses more reasonably priced, there is going to be mayhem.
10. Totally John Oliver on James 'Whitey' Bulger.
(Updated with must read at #7)
23 Comments
regarding pt 6...
Central banks cannot repair the balance sheets of households and financial institutions.”
Yes.. they could have... Instead of throwing the Trillions of dollars at the Banking system... They could have divided that money between each and every citizen...
That money would have either been used to "repair household balance sheets" ... or spent..... working its way thru the economy.. circulating in a way that actually sustains and helps an economy...
It would have made a difference in the "Real" economy..
At the same time they could have dealt with the problem of having institutions that are to big to fail..
So... yes they could... But No.. they never would...
I'm being a bit harsh.. because they don't have the mandate to do this... but it is possible.
And why not?
#7 #9 It does all seem very familiar. Auckland is a bit like London in that the leafy suburbs of both look attractive and safe to people with printed money to spend and I guess Auckland is a bargain in comparison. Both are unaffordable to younger people with or without student loans. The rest of this country ( with the obvious Christchurch exception ) is not too bad in similar fashion to the UK. We have the problem of sky high building costs which underpins our house prices whereas new builds in the UK are fairly resonable.
The answer for younger people has to be to live somewhere other than where they would ideally like to be, at least for a few years.
Twas ever thus.
Bootle is always worth reading - and one of my first Housing-related blog posts was from Rees-Mogg (link in the blerg is long since rotted away - InterWeb compost) who pointed out exactly what our youngsters are now, to their horror and our discomfort, discovering.
One solution, which I advocated then and still do, is to (somehow?) encourage self-builds: a combination of factory/modular bits, own sweat, tradies only for found, electrical, plumbing final connection etc.
It would require amongst other things the complete trashing of the LBP bally-hoo (which, interestingly, does not apply to Commercial builds....AFAIK) and a complete overhaul of the consents process - central, NZ-wide type approvals etc to get away from the madness of varying TLA's and stoopid bureaucrats with the power to delay everything regardless of opportunity costs.
There'd be a lot of dead bodies (zombies?) to wade through before any of this was happening, of course.
My father-in-law tried that. It didnt work, cost way more as the tradies were a) expensive, b) hardly did any work, c) left before completion as someone else was willing to pay them more, d) I had to go in and fix things like built in wardrobes as the doors didnt run....as best I could as the frames themselves were not square by 6mm+. I also had to repair 2 doors and replace one as the "professional" had cut the knob holes in the wrong place. 5% was held back and never paid, but more than that was spent fixing the awful work.
Plumbing in some areas (all as owner occupier?) you can do yourself (I do), without too much issue. Theoretically you can also do your own wiring but try and find someone to check it out for sign off and do the final connection.
Foundations are no biggee either btw, in fact easy, the painful bits like I said is when you are obliged to use tradies...it just gets too hard too fast.
regards
With respect to Stephen, Waymad is right.
Where you pull it in, is in limiting what the tradies do. My plumbing happens all within 2 metres, kitchen and b/room vanity back-to-back, shower at one end of the vanity, HW cylinder at the other, WM underneath, in's and out's thru the one exit. You can be smart about power, and SIP eliminated nail-guns and gib-stopping.
I could still build for $500 sq/m, without sweating over it.
I'm with you PDK...tradies and the like when the red tape rules...otherwise DIY and take your time...massive gst savings as well. I noted the roof repairs post that storm took place asap without the silly scaffolding costs...that madness is adding up to $5000 to the cost of every house...thankyou idiot govt...bureaucrats sure suckered you lot and now we have to pay plus gst of course...thieving knows no end.
"It came out again over the weekend to say the money printing is not working. It has a point." Personally no I dont think it does, beyond showing how dogmatic and blinkered BIS is.
I mean just show us where the reverse of money printing (less govn spending / austerity) has worked? ie no where. On top of that traditional "money printing" has ended up in the hands of the ppl, and with too little productive capacity we've seen "pull" inflation. This time the QEing isnt money in ppls pockets, its the offer of more debt. Joe blogs wont take on more debt, but the merchant banks who the Fed handed the money to have used it to push up prices in commodities and emerging markets, push inflation. This means Joe bloggs with no more money in his wallet, has less descretioanry money in a productive sector with overcapacity, so the last 4 or 5 years have been deflationary for the bulk of ppl.
Also consider that money printing isnt going on in isolation, ie if the CB prints but that Govn does austerity as do ppl/consumers, we are looking at a NET effect. The best we could say is the printing or QE effect has so far stopped deflation across the board, but its done it by pumping up some sectors while others look dodgy.
With the way things look we can forget inflation IMHO for now and some years out. Until we see capacity constraints, lowering un-employment and wage rises, raising the OCR (or whatever. stopping QE) will be tantamount to slitting the economy's throat and the blood loss will be messy to say the least.
regards
Beg to differ. "The fundamental reason our economy is still depressed" is DEBT - everywhere, as in 2007/8. And nothing has been done about that, other than perhaps policies that make it worse.
Quote of the day I reckon. "....too big to fail are too big to exist"
Lies dam lies and MTA loggying!
"New Zealand car owners' reluctance to dump their old bangers is contributing to a growing national car fleet and making the roads less safe, the Motor Trade Association says".Herald
They said "less safe" but they mean 'less profitable'
The thing that makes me laugh is the most likely thing to change this is the new warrant rules where old cars are on six month warrants and newer cars on yearly. Makes It that much more of a hassle to own a pre 2000 car it doesn't seem worth while. But it was mta that was against the warrant changes!
Well we pretty much now have "world cars", So a car made for the EU regs (toughest?) gets sold everywhere. In the UK the MOT (=WOF) is 12months as are oil changes, here 1/2 that is "recommended"....by the MTA who are the garages representative...The MTA isnt there for the punter its there for the other side....its members who pay it.
In terms of age my car is 1995, it failed the last warrantee because someone broke an indicator lens in the 2 days between when Id checked it out and took it for a WOF....I do simple monthly checks myself and keep a good eye on it and basic service it myself, oh and drive it gently, ie 90~95 on the motorway....6months is no biggee.
regards
Jeez steven...90 to 95...I keep to 70 and move over to let the fools pass...getting 16ks per litre in a big diesel 4wd
Suspect you are on to something. The Lowest road deaths for a while show deaths to date this year of 120. Still 120 more than anyone would like of course, but given we are very close to half way through the year, a good result historically.
Be careful with that one, what would be a more accurate figure is deaths per kilometer driven.
Thats correct.....the MTA is there for its members and no one else.....Its not less safe really, just not as safe as it could be. Its members are I assume suffering from lack of business due to the financial problems of its fodder, us. We are now driving less kms per year with cars that need less maintenance...Now one thing is I suspect sure, more and more ppl are not looking after their cars, certianly I look at tyres almost automatically and the number of balding ones seems more frequent, which means no WOF, which probably means they are not paying insurance either....wonder if there is any stats on that as a trend, would show hardship in our economy.
regards
#9 not this rubbish again about house price multiples being fundamental. There is no rule that says that house prices must be three times average income. House prices are relative to supply and demand and what people can afford to spend. if people couldn't afford current prices there would be thousands of mortgagee auctions and there wouldn't be people queuing up to buy Auckland property.
http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2013/05/14-5
Following up on a series of questions first posed during a Senate Banking Committee Hearing earlier this year that left her concerned that the nation's largest banks weren't only "too big to fail" but "too big to jail," Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) on Tuesday sent a strongly worded letter to the heads of the SEC, the Justice Dept, and Federal Reserve demanding a better explanation about how these large financial institutions continue to avoid criminal trials or more aggressive prosecution by government regulators.
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/breakingnews/IMF-backs-Japans-monetary-easing-30207337.html
Tokyo - The International Monetary Fund on Friday endorsed the aggressive monetary easing measures taken by the Bank of Japan in April."The economic recovery is gaining traction, driven in large partby the adoption of the new Quantitative and Qualitative Monetary Easing (QQME) framework," the IMF said.
http://www.webofdebt.com/articles/mythjapan.php
Myths About the “Lost Decade”Japan’s finances have long been shrouded in secrecy, perhaps because when the country was more open about printing money and using it to support its industries, it got embroiled in World War II. In his 2008 book In the Jaws of the Dragon, Fingleton suggests that Japan feigned insolvency in the “lost decade” of the 1990s to avoid drawing the ire of protectionist Americans for its booming export trade in automobiles and other products. Belying the weak reported statistics, Japanese exports increased by 73% during that decade, foreign assets increased, and electricity use increased by 30%, a tell-tale indicator of a flourishing industrial sector. By 2006, Japan’s exports were three times what they were in 1989.
The Japanese government has maintained the façade of complying with international banking regulations by “borrowing” money rather than “printing” it outright. But borrowing money issued by the government’s own central bank is the functional equivalent of the government printing it, particularly when the debt is just carried on the books and never paid back.
Implications for the “Fiscal Cliff”All of this has implications for Americans concerned with an out-of-control national debt. Properly managed and directed, it seems, the debt need be nothing to fear. Like Japan, and unlike Greece and other Eurozone countries, the U.S. is the sovereign issuer of its own currency. If it wished, Congress could fund its budget without resorting to foreign creditors or private banks. It could do this either by issuing the money directly or by borrowing from its own central bank, effectively interest-free, since the Fed rebates its profits to the government after deducting its costs.
A little quantitative easing can be a good thing, if the money winds up with the government and the people rather than simply in the reserve accounts of banks. The national debt can also be a good thing. As Federal Reserve Board Chairman Marriner Eccles testified in hearings before the House Committee on Banking and Currency in 1941, government credit (or debt) “is what our money system is. If there were no debts in our money system, there wouldn’t be any money.”
Properly directed, the national debt becomes the spending money of the people. It stimulates demand, stimulating productivity. To keep the system stable and sustainable, the money just needs to come from the nation’s own government and its own people, and needs to return to the government and people.
Have this with your coffee and toast...
Why Over 90% of the People Will always be Slaves - The God Gene!
http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article41075.html
Have this with your coffee and toast...
And the latest Case Schiller US Housing market report:
The Case-Shiller 20-City Index rose by 1.7 percent in April, with all 20 cities again showing substantial gains. Prices are now up by 12.1 percent from their year-ago levels and have risen at a 21.5 percent annual rate in the last three months.
San Diego had the most rapid price increase at 2.8 percent, followed by Minneapolis, Los Angeles, and San Francisco at 2.7 percent. Prices rose by 2.6 percent in April in Miami, with prices rising in Las Vegas by 2.3 percent. At the other end, prices rose by just 0.1 percent in Cleveland and by 0.7 percent in Detroit and Denver.
The same punters may want to choke on their toast as the US prepares Freddie Mac and it's sibling Fannie Mae for re-privatisation - this will allow the elite to settle upon the efforts of the currently buoyant bottom feeders. Read more
Freddie Mac (FMCC) is preparing to market mortgage securities that will share with investors the risk homeowners don’t repay their government-backed loans, according to a person with knowledge of the plans.
The government-controlled mortgage financier, which typically covers losses after defaults, hired Credit Suisse Group AG to manage its first deal and plans to meet with potential investors in cities including New York, Boston, Chicago and London starting next week, said the person, who asked not to be named because terms aren’t set.
The offering reflects an effort by the Federal Housing Finance Agency to reduce the role of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in the residential-mortgage market, where government-backed loans now account for more than 85 percent of lending. The FHFA, which has overseen the firms since they were seized in 2008, has been directing them to raise how much they charge to guarantee their traditional mortgage bonds and asked them to each attempt to share risk this year on $30 billion of home loans.
Insurers and bond buyers, including hedge funds and real-estate investment trusts, have been awaiting the transactions and expressed interest in profiting from the new program, in which firms other than Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will bear some of the initial losses after mortgage defaults. The bonds may pay more than traditional mortgage securities.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.