sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Wednesday's Top 10: Flipping trends; Why all the world can't export its way to growth; Are larger cities really more productive?; Secular stagnation; Dilbert

Wednesday's Top 10: Flipping trends; Why all the world can't export its way to growth; Are larger cities really more productive?; Secular stagnation; Dilbert

I'm back with my weekly Top 10 on a Wednesday. Here's my Top 10 links from around the Internet at 1 pm today. As always, we welcome your additions in the comments below or via email to bernard.hickey@interest.co.nz

See all previous Top 10s here.

My must read today is #3 from Gavyn Davies on a disturbing slowdown in global trade growth and what that means for global GDP growth.

1. Old trends and new trends - The Atlantic has come up with a nice piece looking at how some 'trends' have flipped and are now 'non-trends'.

The include how solar power has flipped from being expensive to being cheap, and how China's population bomb looks like busting.

Surprisingly, others include falling US carbon emissions and a real slowdown in medical cost inflation.

It's these reversals that can change your view of the global economy and the trickle-down to us.

The fall in the number of kilometres traveled in cars is the most interesting.

It's happening here and in the US.

Here's The Atlantic:

With gasoline more-or-less permanently at $4, Americans are finally adjusting their lifestyles, driving less and less even as unemployment falls. Meanwhile, rail traffic is up, with Amtrak logging a 55% gain since 1997.

2. US Productivity growth - It turns out that productivity growth is not necessarily connected to population growth in certain parts of the country.

There's a long held view that when cities grow they generate productivity growth by their workers.

This piece from Richard Florida in Atlantic Cities suggests otherwise. It has some cracking maps and charts.

Only one of the top 10 leading population growth metros broke into the top 100 in terms of productivity growth, Austin in 64th place. Six of out of the top 10 metros with the highest rates of population growth saw real declines in productivity over the course of the decade. And the average rate of economic growth across these top 10 metros was also negative, (-0.53 percent per year) and beneath the U.S. metro average (of 0.48 percent annually).

When it comes to fast growing large metros, Houston and Atlanta both experienced considerable population growth rates over the past decade, while seeing real declines in productivity over the period.

3. Why world trade growth has lost its mojo - Gavyn Davies writes in his (not paywalled) FT blog about an apparently surprising slow-down in global trade growth.

When everyone is trying to export their way to prosperity without buying much then the world has a problem.

In part, the weakness in world trade has clearly been due to the cyclical slowdowns in the eurozone in 2012, and in the BRICs in 2013. Because trade between the member states inside the eurozone is counted as part of world trade, the euro crisis has had a particularly large effect. But this effect should have been reversing by the middle of 2013, so it is disturbing to see that the decelerating trend in trade flows has continued (though there have been tentative signs of revival in the last couple of months).

The WTO’s latest projections show that the normal 2:1 relationship between trade and GDP growth will be restored gradually over the next few years, but there are many reasons for doubting this. One intractable problem is that the export-led growth model followed by many emerging economies in the last few decades seems to have run into the sands. The sluggish recovery in import demand in the developed economies looks set to continue, implying that the emerging world will need to find ways of boosting their domestic demand so that trade flows within the emerging bloc can expand more rapidly.

4. Secular stagnation - Paul Krugman writes here at the NY Times about the risk of a long period of weak demand in the global economy holding everyone back. He seems to have a point. 

This chart Krugman uses showing US debt to GDP (ie leverage) explains part of the story.

Krugman has a few ideas for solutions.

One answer could be a higher inflation target, so that the real interest rate can go more negative. I’m for it! But you do have to wonder how effective that low real interest rate can be if we’re simultaneously limiting leverage.

Another answer could be sustained, deficit-financed fiscal stimulus. But, you say, this would lead to exploding public debt! Actually, no – not if the real interest rate is persistently below the economy’s growth rate, which it will certainly be if it’s persistently negative. In that case the government can run a primary deficit even while keeping the debt-GDP ratio constant – and the higher the level of debt, the higher the allowable deficit.

OK, I’m shooting from the hip here. The main point is simply that the weirdness of our current situation may well go on much longer than anyone currently imagines.

5. Pandacam - The star of the US Government shutdown is a Panda. 

As of this morning, the camera that streams the antics of Tian Tian, Mei Xiang, and Mei Xiang's as-yet-unnamed cub has been turned off. Which is, obviously, an enormous loss to bored office workers the nation over ... but which is also, in the scheme of things, not a great sacrifice. (It's the camera, to be clear, that has been turned off; the pandas themselves will be free to frolic unfettered by the shutdown.)

7. Life on Treasury Island - This (unpaywalled) piece in AFR from Australian financial bureaucrat Jason Murphy paints an interesting picture of life on Nauru.

8. An excellent blog - This Guardian series quoting what London investment bankers really think has been cracking. It's now coming to an end. Here's the 10 best quotes from the series. 

This is my favourite.

"It's strange. Bankers are so smart, yet they get this thing wrong. They spend their lives in an office when the only truly valuable thing in life is time. It is the only thing that is not replenishable. You can always make more money, but you can never get more time. Maybe it's because death is such a taboo in our society; that people live in this illusion that their life will go on forever."

9. Totally a video about the evolution of the guitar solo. It's time for some mid-week fun. 

10. Totally Jon Stewart explaining what's really happening in Washington.

 

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

23 Comments

#1 Any article that relies on the American Enterprise Institute for its facts is a little sus. Still, doesn't hurt to be reminded of how the stuff that "everyone knows to be true" does shift over time.

Up
0

Well he's dead right that death is a taboo subject.   Oops.

Up
0

Boom boom, Mr Ralph

Up
0

#2  non productive big cities.   Auckland is not productive.  It'sjust big.   The average Aucklander is a female polynesian living in Otatahu.  Possibly employed. 

Not a group noted for it's economic weatlh.  I go back to Auckland frequently and it looks like a poor town to me.  And thats visually as I leave the airport.  My peers there have the priviledge of contributing almost all their disposible cash to a mortgage.  And are stuck with that lifelong, certainly some decades longer than us.

Can't afford it's own infrastructure.  Couldn't afford to build non leaky houses.

Where on the map is the probably midpoint for exports in New Zealand.  Look on the map folks and see where the line of the Waitaki runs.  It'sa long way south of Auckland. 

This is not an Auckland bash.  I am an Aucklander (ex) and I like going back.  But I also feel sorry for the place.

Up
0

Haha, your comment is so bad it's actually good, or at least funny. 

 

"This is not an Auckland bash" - just add that to the end of any sentence and it means you can say whatever you want before.  A bit like saying "now don't take this the wrong way, but..."

Up
0

You'd hate Sydney.

Up
0

     Last time I looked, couple of months ago, Auckland's contribution to the nation's productivity was a wooping 1 1/2 % greater than its proportion of the population.  Really hitting above its weight there.  Not.

     Gee, turns out Nick Smith et al's beatup of ACC four years ago was fiction (like that wasn't obvious at the time).  Good old Nick got us to pay thru the nose yet again.  I nominate him for the Order of the Dubya, those who meet or exceed their level of incompetence.

 

Up
0

I nominate him for the Order of the Dubya, those who meet or exceed their level of incompetence.
 
Unless the order can be awarded 'post ministerial ranking' you may have to be quick.

Up
0

.

Up
0

.. that's bullsh*t , man ... I can't agree with your point ....

Up
0

Maybe I should have used a full stop instead.

Up
0

Doesn't he ever get tired of being on the idiocy side of every issue?

Up
0

.. " he " who ?

 

You / me / steven / Bernard Hickey ...

 

Justin Case you've mist it OMG_WTF , there's plethora of serious competition around here for the title of champion of being on the idiotic side of every issue ...

 

... my money's on steven  .. ..  go you good thing !

regards

Up
0

He must be from Auckland.

Up
0

Loved the history of the guitar solo , Bernard ...

 

..  " Fact Man " looked alot 'like a younger version of you !

 

... but he has better moves ... that guy can rage ....

Up
0
Up
0

... according to that Roy Morgan poll the Greens have lost 25 % of their supporter base since September 26 , Winston has been abandoned by 31 % of his followers ... and Colin the Conservative is 33 % more popular this week , than last ...

 

Does anyone still take these polls seriously ?

 

... get some gin soaked prunes into yer porridge , mate ... you'll soon forget Roy Morgan , prunes'll give you a better run for your money than any politician ever will ...

Up
0

Looks like a fairly standard reversion to the mean poll, pretty much everyone has moved back towards their long term trend lines from the last poll. Labour having a honeymoon.

Up
0

Greens have been trending up for a while, so cant say its just a mean revision at the expense of the Greens.

Honeymoon, yes, and the fact we see one is positive.....if we'd seen diddly that would have been a worry. The Q is can Cunliffe/Labour eat a couple of % of National's vote. Taking the Green's % is utterly pointless so really Cunliffe wants teh swing voter and middleground....Labour swinging to the left could be worse for left wing seats in the house.

regards

Up
0

hahaha...panic that Cunliffe is now looking at the PMs job GBH?

Ive long thought that the Green's gains were from their quite left policies and nothing at all due to ppl discovering their green "morals"  So the Greens have taken votes off Labour, hardly surprising given the last 2 leaders were in-effectual (Yet Goff was quite good on policy etc).  In comes Cunliffe more charasmatic and left leaning so electable.  The result isnt too surprising....the interesting thing will be the trend for the next 2 or 3 polls. Will Cunliffe gain further at the expense of the Greens or will that flatten out....or will the greens vote recover.  I think it will flatten or worsen myself.

regards

 

 

 

 

Up
0

.. just a mild panic attack on my part , that we havn't undone any of the seriously dopey welfare bribes of the Clark/Clark era , before we take another lurch to the left with Labour , in 2014 ...

 

My glimmer of hope is that Cunliffe will do a " Rudd " ( not you  Les , your brother Kev ! ) , and revert to type .... snarl at the make-up ladies , and such .... let the public catch a glimpse of the real personality behind the toothsome smiling facade ...

 

.. failing that , it's onwards with the entitlements brigade , granting us ever increased government packages and hand-ups , at the expense of the productive private sector ... climbing the Greecey pole to become an egalitarian mediocratic bankrupt state .....

Up
0

Well JK's mask sure is slipping isnt it.

Of course we had one set of bribes countering the Brash bribes, those that would have over-heated our housing market even more.....and caused an even bigger '*pop*'

yeah great.....thank god not.

We have past a paradgym, no more up whomever is in Govn....

regards

Up
0

going to be an interesting trend to watch...

regards

Up
0