sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

‘Up the Wahs’: From fireworks and the All Blacks to capital gains tax, TVNZ leaders’ debate sees Chris Hipkins and Christopher Luxon clash

Public Policy / opinion
‘Up the Wahs’: From fireworks and the All Blacks to capital gains tax, TVNZ leaders’ debate sees Chris Hipkins and Christopher Luxon clash
The TVNZ leader's debate - TVNZ
The TVNZ leader's debate - TVNZ

The first election debate for the two men who want to be the country's prime minister was scrappy and fast paced, covering a large range of topics from fireworks, the arts to the tax system, AI and health insurance. 

The list of topics that host Jack Tame raised in Tuesday evening's leaders' debate was impressive - when the leaders were not bickering or talking over each other. 

A group of 100 undecided voters were tasked to rate performance, with Hipkins on 49% and Luxon on 24% while 27% remained undecided at the end of the debate. 

Performance scores by undecided voters in the TVNZ leaders' debate - TVNZ

 

Quickfire round:

  • Both won’t ban fireworks from public sale. 
  • Both agree it is the government's responsibility to financially support the arts. 
  • Hipkins believes every international artist coming to New Zealand should have a New Zealand opening act, and Luxon does not. 
  • Hipkins has not pulled a sickie "lately" and Luxon said he has not pulled a sickie.
  • On choosing between the All Blacks winning the Rugby World Cup next year or the Warriors winning the Premiership, Hipkins said “up the Wahs” while Luxon chose the All Blacks.
  • Both wished they had learnt more te reo Māori. 
  • Both could not give a yes or no answer if it was morally acceptable for any one person to be a billionaire.

When it came to increasing the Superannuation age, Hipkins said no government he would lead would raise the retirement age whereas Luxon said he would raise it from 65 to 67 over time. 

Hipkins will keep the school cellphone ban and the gang patch ban. Luxon said he would put 1000 more gang members in prison.

Both leaders said they would extend the temporary $50 tax credit for working for families if petrol prices stay high.

On the last time they had changed their mind on something, Hipkins said he changed his mind on CGT and Luxon could not think of a policy example but said he does change his mind when he gets good advice.

On whether New Zealanders without private health insurance could be confident they would receive the treatment when they need it, Luxon said yes "but there's more to do", while Hipkins said no.

Both have private health insurance.

The tax system

When it comes to the tax system, Luxon said he wanted people paying less tax not more. 

Hipkins said the tax system places way too much emphasis on salary and wage earners. “People are earning a lot of money through, capital gains, for example, that aren't being taxed, and we're one of the only countries in the world that allows that to happen."

Luxon hit back saying the capital gains tax proposal was “really unfair” and people would get “smashed” by it.

AI

AI seemed to be one of the few policy areas where the two could possibly work together.

Luxon said he thought there was some “serious dangers and evils associated with artificial intelligence”.

“What we need to do in order to deal with those dangers is work with other like-minded countries to make sure we've got the regulatory frameworks in place. We're obviously wanting to adhere to OECD principles. We spend a lot of time with our Five Eyes networks talking about the threats associated with that.”

Hipkins said there were “huge opportunities for New Zealand from AI, but we need to be eyes wide open to the fact that there are real risks, and some of those risks are here right now”.

He said it was an area where the two leaders could work “really well for the benefit of New Zealand, because not only do we have to work with other like-minded countries standing up to what is a global challenge and a global threat to find the regulatory frameworks”. 

Gaza 

Asked if he personally believed that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, Hipkins said: "There is an unfolding genocide taking place in Gaza. I believe there's a case for them to answer on that, yes."

Luxon said he thought there were "very serious questions, and again, we should be guided by the ICC (International Criminal Court) and the ICJ (International Court of Justice)."

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

9 Comments

Sadly, still, no one knows what a woman is?

 

Up
3

This has to be the worst representation that National & Labour have offered up for a prime ministership in all of its history. They are even worse than the same two offerings three years ago. Hipkins has done better by doing nothing and simply letting Luxon fumble and fritter away acknowledgment and respect for any good standing and progress the present coalition has achieved. It is incomprehensible that when such shortcomings are so glaringly obvious that a major political party should be so numb skulled that it cannot act to remove the  obvious reason for its ever declining position. 

Up
7

I haven't paid any attention to either of them regardless tbh. Voting for either is like voting for the village idiot to be mayor, which some will do anyway from habit, family identity, fear of change, and expectation of a freebie from the current lolly scramble of hollow promises. Hopefully the results of the election give us a bit more hope that there has been more intellectual discussion and debate around the country that far supersedes the paltry TV offerings we have been given.

Up
3

The only question in town, wasn't asked. 

But leadership is about the future - which clearly isn't going to replicate the past. 

Those muppets were about the past. 

Up
3

What it indicates, is that those in power see the populace as illiterate, uneducated peasants, tools to be manipulated, wooed, into giving them the ultimate goal: More power. It is sickening to think that the two largest parties in our Government treat those they serve, and rely on for a paycheck, with such a supercilious attitude.

Up
0

I listened to most of it....it was hard work and election day cannot come soon enough....however after a poor start I thought Luxon got the edge on Hipkins so was surprised at the vote of the audience.....there must be something about Luxon that most people find very off-putting.

Up
1

By the time John Key exited would suggest the public had had enough of his blue suit brigade and the complacent, conceited and careless antics in the ivory tower so to speak.  I thought though that Bill English stood outside of all of that and he ended up doing well at the election. Luxon I suggest believes he is, or should be, some sort of reincarnation of the halcyon days of Key’s first two terms. It is unbelievably naive. The world has moved on, has become more troubled and folk ain’t of mood to entertain the past and that,  they are showing.

Up
7

Thanks for summarising Anna, there is no way I could have sat through that in its entirety.

Up
9

profile,

I lasted less than 5 minutes. And to think that one of them will be the PM.

On a different issue, I recently came across a study from UC Berkeley; Why the Forcing from Carbon Dioxide Scales as the Logarithm of its Concentration. This significantly slows warming as more CO2 is emitted. 

 

Up
1