Days to the General Election: 39
See Party Policies here. Party Lists here.

Banks and the Opposition have questioned the Government over its numbers, but a new Moody’s report will put a spring in the step of Finance Minister Grant Robertson

Banks and the Opposition have questioned the Government over its numbers, but a new Moody’s report will put a spring in the step of Finance Minister Grant Robertson

One of the world’s largest credit rating agencies is pouring cold water over claims future Government surpluses will be largely eroded by “fiscal slippage.”

On Monday, Moody’s released its annual credit analysis on New Zealand which gave the country top marks, retaining its Aaa stable status.

Overall, the credit rating agency expects surpluses of roughly 0.5% of GDP this and next year, slightly lower than in prior years.

But when it comes to spending, the report says the Government’s ability to restrain expenditure over such a prolonged period, to the extent it projected in December’s Mini Budget, “may be increasingly constraining.”

“In particular, large spending commitments on health, education and social assistance, which account for around 70% of total core Crown expenses.”

But Moody’s points out that any “fiscal slippages” – any deviation in expenditure from what was expected – will, if there is any at all, be small and will unlikely alter any expected surpluses.

Before the election, then Finance Minister Steven Joyce said the Government’s numbers showed it would be facing fiscal slippages during its time on the Treasury benches.

In an economic note in December, ANZ said the Government’s numbers do not give them a lot of “wriggle room.”

“…there is not a lot of room to manoeuvre if things don't go entirely to plan.

“It sets the scene for some fiscal slippage, forcing the Government to either ease back on its fiscal targets or look at reprioritising some of its spending plans,” the note said.

Meanwhile, Moody’s noted fiscal strength, which examines the overall health of the Government’s finances as one of the highest scoring categories in its assessment.

“We assess New Zealand’s fiscal strength as Very High (+),” the report said.

The low levels of Crown debt and the prospects for further fiscal surpluses over the next half decade are some of the driving factors behind this.

Moody’s gives a nod to the Government’s fiscal responsibility rules – keeping Core Crown spending at roughly 30% of GDP and to reduce public debt to 20% of GDP by 2021/2022.

Economic strength ‘very high’

New Zealand’s economic strength is “Very High (-)” according to the rating agency.

“New Zealand's economy has shown faster GDP growth than other Aaa-rated sovereigns in the past five years, which counterbalances its economic weaknesses,” it says.

These weaknesses include the economy's small size, which means it is vulnerable to “various shocks.”

Moody’s expects New Zealand’s GDP to grow at around 2.5% this and next year, which is above the Aaa medium of 2%.

But it is slower than the Reserve Bank’s growth estimates of an average of 3.2% growth over the coming three years.

Nevertheless, Moody’s is still upbeat about New Zealand’s economy.

“The stable outlook is anchored by our expectation that New Zealand will maintain strong fiscal and monetary discipline that provides the economy and financial system capacity to adjust to shocks and keeps its credit metrics consistent with an Aaa rating even in the event of such shocks materialising.”  

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.


Echo Bird, TM2, this is great news! One less thing for you to whinge and worry yourselves silly over. What's that you say? Moody's haven't got a clue? Yes, same arguments, just a different day.

While I can appreciate the last six months has been a real struggle for you both, at least try to be less doom and gloom while the Coalition navigate their way through undoing nine years of massive underfunding of this country's precious infrastructure!

Should read "government given AAA stable rating by Moody's for maintaining pointless austerity resulting in continued high underemployment, depressed wages, looming deflation and a growth strategy based solely on private debt expansion." It's the neo-liberal rating. Robertson is AAA at neo-liberalism.

Well we all know how the rating agencies did with mortgage backed securities. Paragons of predictive virtue.

You mean the ‘pointless austerity’ that got us through the GFC while the borrow and spend countries got hammered?
How’s Greece’s underemployment going?

Greece (and Weimar and Zimbabwe) is held up whenever anyone suggest that a bit of fiscal expansion is what we need to cure our current anemic growth.
Greece was a victim of the faulty design of the Eurozone (no surplus recycling mechanism) as well as political corruption, tax evasion and German and French banks that wanted to park their cash somewhere a bit more lucrative in the 2000s. Moody's helped in this by giving a lovely A stable rating to Greece in those years btw as I understand it. Once again, paragons of predictive virtue.
The cure Greece was prescribed was to run massive surpluses unheard of anywhere else and agree to even more bail out loans. Not surprisingly the economy has contracted massively as a result debt to gdp gets worse. You can't starve your economy of money and employment and expect it to recover. Austerity has worsened debt to gdp levels and definitely caused massive unemployment.

In NZ we do this as well. We starve the real economy of money through too tight fiscal policy and deliberately keep a swathe of the populace underemployed and impoverished. We rely on them borrowing to keep things afloat.

It will not end well.

Moody's are expecting surpluses of 0.5% this year and next, whereas the December 2017 Mini Budget / HYEFU said 0.9%. Sounds like slippage to me.

And what does ".. gives a nod to the Government's fiscal responsibility rules ..." mean? Moody's are expecting slower GDP growth and less of a surplus than forecast in December, so it is difficult to be confident about the prospect of reducing the public debt to 20% of GDP by 2021/22.

Your access to our unique content is free - always has been. But ad revenues are under pressure so we need your direct support.

Become a supporter

Thanks, I'm already a supporter.

Days to the General Election: 39
See Party Policies here. Party Lists here.