Small businesses lacking bargaining power front of mind for Government as it consults on strengthening protections against unfair commercial practices

Small businesses lacking bargaining power front of mind for Government as it consults on strengthening protections against unfair commercial practices

Banks, insurers and fuel retailers aren’t the only types of companies being scrutinised by authorities for the way they do business.

The Government is considering introducing greater protections from “unfair commercial practices” for all consumers and businesses.

These practices could include unfair contracts that shift risk from one party to another, make it difficult for a party to terminate a contract, or are one-sided by giving one party the ability to change the terms, for example.

They could also include unfair conduct like the use of pressure sales tactics or deceptive conduct.

Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Kris Faafoi says: “Unfair commercial practices can cause significant stress for consumers, in some cases leading to financial difficulty, while the consequences for businesses include cash flow issues, increased costs and stress.”

The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) acknowledges there are already a range of protections against unfair commercial practices covered by the Fair Trading Act 1986 and the Commerce Act 1986, but it’s consulting with the public to figure out whether there are any gaps in the legislation.

MBIE says it’s been told of a few examples of businesses treating customers unfairly, but without necessarily breaching the law.

For example, it has heard of a skincare business using aggressive sales tactics to target people with autism and the elderly in shopping malls.

As for businesses being treated unfairly, a survey MBIE did in June of mainly small businesses found 45% of businesses reported being offered “unfair” contracts in the past year.

Meanwhile 47% felt that they had otherwise been treated unfairly. The most common complaints were businesses not complying with an existing contract, misleading or deceptive behaviour, and businesses making demands over and above what was agreed in a contract.

The Minister for Small Business, Stuart Nash, is particularly concerned about how small businesses, which don’t have a lot of bargaining power when dealing with suppliers or larger companies, are impacted by unfair commercial practices.

“Small businesses can face significant cash flow issues as a result of other businesses not paying them on time as per contract terms," he says.

MBIE has released a discussion document considering the following options to plug any regulatory gaps identified: 

  • introduce a prohibition against unconscionable, oppressive, or unfair conduct
  • extend the existing protections against unfair contract terms in standard form consumer contract terms to also protect businesses

It notes how overseas protections have been used in the case of a supermarket that failed to pay agreed prices to suppliers, made persistent demands for additional payments from suppliers, imposed penalties that were not previously negotiated, and threatened to remove products from shelves.

Protections were also used in a case where contracts for office space were automatically renewed unless the customer opted out. This allowed the provider to unilaterally increase the contract price or terminate contracts, unreasonably limited the provider’s liability, and permitted the provider to keep a customer’s security deposit if a customer failed to request its return. 

Nash says: “The Government wants to build a more productive, sustainable and inclusive economy, but we won’t get there with these types of practices in the marketplace.

“At the same time, we need to strike a balance to ensure any changes are proportional to the problem. We want honest businesses to continue to compete effectively, negotiate firmly, and freely enter into contracts.”

The public have until February 25 to make submissions on the discussion document.

A new government, a more proactive approach towards commercial regulation  

On the theme of consumer protection, the Reserve Bank and Financial Markets Authority last month published a report on their inquiry into bank conduct and culture.

They’re due to publish a similar report on the life insurance sector next month.

New legislation has also passed, enabling the Commerce Commission to conduct market studies into selected industries. The retail fuel sector is the first batter up.

What’s more, the Government is undertaking several other reviews relevant to ‘unfair’ commercial practices, including:

Payment practices. MBIE considering how to improve business-to-business payment practices. Legislative and other interventions are being considered, potentially including a disclosure regime, penalties or fines for late payments, and/or maximum payment timeframes.

Consumer credit. The Government has signalled its intent to introduce legislation that’ll strengthen protections for consumers against irresponsible and high-cost lending.

Insurance contract law. Currently, some terms in insurance contracts are exempt from the Fair Trading Act’s protections relating to unfair contract terms in consumer contracts. MBIE is considering whether these exemptions should be amended or removed.

Section 36 of the Commerce Act. Section 36 prohibits anti-competitive unilateral conduct by firms with market power. The Government has signalled its intention to review section 36 on the basis that it is costly and complex to enforce, and may not be sufficiently deterring this type of anti-competitive conduct.

Consumer law. MBIE is evaluating the consumer law reforms that came into effect between 2013 and 2015. The focus of the evaluation is on the effectiveness of the individual law changes that were made. This differs from the focus of the discussion paper, which is on whether any significant gaps exist in the overall framework for protecting businesses and consumers from unfair conduct.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

7 Comments

This is a wonderful idea. Maybe Mr Faafoi could even set up some kind of commission to deal with rorts like Z Energy, IAG and Youi.

Will the wet bus ticket printer ever run out of toner?

They need to do something about all the corruption in the building materials industry. 500% markups on electrical cable/equipment and plumbing materials being the most obvious ones. The trade price is often 5 to 10x as much as the big contractors get the same materials for. I've made a couple of submissions to the comcom, but they're not particularly interested.

There is an ever growing attitude and practice by corporates, contractors, and even self employed tradesmen which is, when they fail to deliver or cock the job up,” see you in court then.” This is making victims out of the general public, particularly those that are poor and vulnerable who have no hope economically of pursuing any legal redress and even if they have the mettle to try the small claims court, it’s going to take a long time to be heard and likely a 50/50 result with no guarantee of collecting even that. Regret it is a rotten indictment on the business culture that NZ is growing, greedy and callous. That is why so much of this sort of carry on is appearing on social media. It is the only means that allows one to vent.

What this needs is for small claims awards to be paid out by MOJ so the claimant can get on with their lives and then up to the ministry to recover that from the defendant.

Well after having a heartless, former merchant banker as Primeminister for nearly a decade, the same 'screw you, I got mine' attitude that made him rich has served as a bad example and infected the Country. I believe it is the prime reason it has become socially acceptable for people to live in cars now, because no one cares anymore.

Demanding services not included in contracts from small contractors is not only common for corporates but also is a government practice, even the Commerce Commission does it.

Really