SFO boss hopes to firm up Hubbard position soon, 3rd statutory manager's report due this week

SFO boss hopes to firm up Hubbard position soon, 3rd statutory manager's report due this week

Serious Fraud Office (SFO) director Adam Feeley hopes the organisation will decide within weeks whether to charge Allan Hubbard or close its investigation.

Feeley told interest.co.nz the SFO’s investigation team was in the process of finalising its second interim report into Hubbard and related entities. The SFO would be considering the second report with its external counsel in the next couple of weeks, he said. It would consider three options – charging, continuing the investigation or closing the investigation.

Although he said he couldn’t predetermine a decision at this stage, Feeley said he hoped the SFO would be in a position to make a firm decision in terms of either laying charges or closing the investigation.

“However, there may be some tidying up matters that take a few additional weeks,” Feeley said. “If we continue the inquiries we will say so immediately. Any public comment on a decision either to charge or not charge is likely to be some weeks away.”

The SFO had put “substantial” resources into the investigation.

Third statutory manager's report due this week

Meanwhile, Hubbard’s statutory managers, Trevor Thornton and Richard Simpson from accounting firm Grant Thornton, are due to release their third report this week. It is likely to be either on Wednesday afternoon or Thursday morning, a Grant Thornton spokesman said.

Hubbard, his wife Jean, Aorangi Securities and seven charitable trusts associated with the Hubbards were placed in statutory management by Commerce Minister Simon Power, following a Securities Commission recommendation and investigation involving the Companies Office, on June 20. The Registrar of Companies referred a number of matters relating to Aorangi Securities to the SFO to investigate potential breaches of the Crimes Act.

In late August, after receiving the first interim report, Feeley said the SFO would make further enquiries, noting there were now issues in relation to Hubbard Management Funds (HMF) that required consideration.

This came after the statutory managers’ second report which said there was an “alarming gap” between the income Aorangi was receiving from its loans and investments and the amount it needed to pay out to its investors, and that Hubbard had over stated HMF's position by at least 25%.

In their first report the statutory managers said they had frozen NZ$70 million in HMF, a vehicle they weren't previously aware of where the accounts were hand written.

And this month the freezing of Hubbard's financial affairs also extended into trusts linked to HC Partners, the Timaru accountancy practice formerly known as Hubbard Churcher. The Government has added Hubbard Churcher Trust Management Ltd, Forresters Nominee Company Ltd to the statutory management, plus Temple Bar Family Trust and Barns Charitable Trust. Prime Minister John Key has also rejected calls from Hubbard supporters for a public enquiry into the Government's handling of Hubbard.

The original seven trusts placed into statutory management were; Te Tua Charitable Trust, Otipua Charitable Trust, Oxford Charitable Trust, Regent Charitable Trust, Morgan Charitable Trust, Benmore Charitable Trust, and Wai-iti Charitable Trust.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

3 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

[sung/rapped to the mid-90’s song/rap ‘Regulate’ by Warren G]

He had a clear balance sheet, a clear conscience, too
Allan H was on the street, at home Timaru
Need investors for his scheme, so he can get some dosh
Just rolling in the Minor, doesn’t want to look too posh

Just hit the high-end of the OCR
On a mission trying to bust the gov’mint guarantor
Seen a car of old girls, ain’t no need to tweak
Fund advisors know what’s up with Aorangi

So he hooks a left, and overrides his rulebook
Sees profits buying land so he said “let’s do this”
He jumped out the Morris, and said “what’s up”
The locals all love him so their money gets unstuck.

Sees B. Hickey peepin’ him, so he glides and swerves
These haters lookin so hard; his funds could hit the curb
Won’t they think of better things than investigative tricks
He sees his board and auditors all in a mix

Aorangi jacked, he’s breaking himself
He can’t believe they’re taking all his wealth
They took his trusts, they took his forex
He looks at the audit, says “damn, what’s next?”

They got him all hemmed up and they all around
Ain’t none of them caring if it’s euro or pounds
They wanna investigate real quick before he starts to clown
Call the SFO in and lay them busters down

Profit’s all in my head
I think I’m going down
I can’t believe this is happening in my own town
If I still had wings I would fly
Let me stop and chill
I glanced in the Press and see my homey Bill

Seven trusts on the clip, most in the hole
Bill E is about to make moral hazard turn cold
Investors droppin’ and yellin’
It’s a tad bit late
John Key and William E had to regulate….

Search http://www.charities.govt.nz/ for each of these Charitable Trusts

They either (a) dont exist, or (b) the Govt has drawn cone of silence over them or (c) they have only been set up since the GFC. 

By all means charge Allan hubbard> keep him going, just stop all those other people  over loading the Hubbard Managed Funds with the above average returns.