A drop in consumer confidence in October could mean retail spending is likely to stay subdued in coming months, ANZ chief economist Cameron Bagrie said.
A flat retail sector, hit by the October 1 GST hike, is expected by economists to give the Reserve Bank room to keep the Official Cash Rate at 3% until March next year as households restrain themselves from spending on big ticket items.
The ANZ-Roy Morgan consumer confidence index fell three points to 113.6 in October, pushed down by its 'current conditions' component which fell to its lowest point since August 2009.
Despite this, more consumers are expecting to be better off in a year's time, with a net 31% of respondents saying they expected their families to be better off financially this time next year, from net 28% in September.
"Underpinning the drop in confidence was a 25 point plummet in the question regarding whether it is a good time to buy a major household appliance," Bagrie said.
"A net 7 percent believe it a bad time to buy a major household item. It is hard to gauge how much of this fall reflected the rise in GST at the start of the month, but clearly such a large fall suggests the GST rise has been influential," he said.
"However, the decline in current conditions does not bode well for immediate appetites to spend regardless. We note that the question in regard to whether it was a good time to buy a major household item did not blip up notably pre-GST (but rather it trended up over months prior), and this leaves us suspecting that the post-GST marked decline reflects wider forces in addition to the GST rise."
A net 9% of respondents said they felt worse off now than a year ago, up from net 12% in September, Bagrie said.
A new question was introduced to the survey in October, asking respondents at what rate they expected house prices to grow (or decline) on average over the next two years.
"If the current perception proves transitory in nature, and housing were to return to expectations of old (i.e. gains in excess of income), this could be one factor forcing the RBNZ to raise interest rates," Bagrie said.
"At present, consumers' perception regarding house price gains over the coming years are cautious. House prices are expected to rise by 1.6 percent per year," he said.
"The impact of expected limited house price gains means that discretionary spending will need to be underpinned from income generation instead of wealth gains as has been the trend over the past two decades."
(Updates with chart)
Consumer confidence
Select chart tabs
3 Comments
"The impact of expected limited house price gains means that discretionary spending will need to be underpinned from income generation instead of wealth gains as has been the trend over the past two decades."
Is Bagrie talking about capital gains here?....surely over the term of the Labour fools there was no wealth gain....he seems reluctant to refer to the property ponzi scheme...why would that be!
The whole truth is there can be no increase in discretionary spending because there will be no increased income generation...the economy is winding down to a far lower level of activity where it will stay for a hell of a long time...no amount of BS from the banks about buying property will change that...but what will change it bloody fast is a rapid rise in the cost of foreign funds for the banks when they refi their loans...even the covered bond govt guaranteed stuff will not stop that rise...and guess who will be expected to pay the bill....yes it's silly Kiwi who believed the bank and borrowed heaps to buy price bloated property......
Oh and let's not leave the fiscal Elephant out of this...govt still borrowing billions, which is not surprising is it when we read of state employees walking away with $500000 a year salaries...no Tolley it did not look good.. did it! Have another bash at telling teachers the govt has not got the money....
"The impact of expected limited house price gains means that discretionary spending will need to be underpinned from income generation instead of wealth gains as has been the trend over the past two decades."
But we are also saving......paying down debt......
To me quietly browsing the stores it almost seems that the retail sector has also given up trying.....the permanent 2+ year interest free deals seem fewer....more reluctance to discount for cash either....
regards
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.