PSIS to become The Co-operative Bank after being granted bank registration; 130,000 members to each have one share and be paid rebates linked to size of their business

PSIS to become The Co-operative Bank after being granted bank registration; 130,000 members to each have one share and be paid rebates linked to size of their business

By Bernard Hickey

PSIS, the former Public Service Investment Society, has announced it has been granted bank registration by the Reserve Bank and will change its name to The Co-operative Bank.

The Co-operative Bank said its 130,000 members would each be granted a share with equal voting rights in the new bank.

They may receive rebates in future related to the size of their business with The Co-operative Bank.

PSIS had its credit rating upgraded to BBB- by Standard & Poor's in May, which is the credit rating agency's lowest investment grade rating and was seen as a prerequisite to obtaining bank registration from the Reserve Bank.

Douglas Widdowson, a former adviser on domestic deposit taking oversight at the Reserve Bank, has this year been working for PSIS in risk and as a secretary to the co-operative's board, helping with the push for bank registration. PSIS is also taking on two new directors former ANZ National Bank deputy CEO Steven Fyfe and ex-president of the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions, Ross Wilson.

PSIS is piloting a lending project to small businesses through a handful of its 32 branches this year as it looks to diversify its income base without moving too far away from its personal banking bread and butter business. See more here.

The Reserve Bank confirmed PSIS had been registered as New Zealand's 21st bank, would remain a co-operative and change its name to The Co-operative Bank Limited.

PSIS chairman David Gascoigne said PSIS decided it would be better served as a bank, particularly in the wake of finance company collapses and the Global Financial Crisis when customers of many financial institutions sought the perceived safety of a bank.

“Our main focus has been the protection of our customers’ rights and privileges. Securing bank registration will not alter the way we operate, or our commitment to our customers," he said.

A series of 40 focus groups with customers in recent months had looked at the PSIS name and concluded a name change made sense. The PSIS was still perceived as a financial institution for those in the Public Service, whereas it had been open to all members of the public since 1995, Gascoigne told a news conference in Wellington.

Chief Executive Girol Karacaoglu said the co-operative model had been successful during the global economic crisis.

“At a time when investors’ faith has been shaken throughout the world, co-operatives have not only survived but thrived. People have been attracted and remained loyal to the conservative governance and risk management that’s part of the co-operative ethos. We exist solely for the benefit of our members, and their best interests are our number one priority," he said.

Gascoigne said The Co-operative Bank had no intention of being listed on the stock exchange and any change of ownership would be just as difficult as it had been in the past.

"Our constitution makes it difficult if not impossible," he said, adding each member would only have one share, which was not transferrable or saleable or giftable or able to be passed on to family members.

"It's hard to see how it could be taken over."

'Profit concious, not profit driven'

Any public flotation would also change the underlying fundamentals of the institution's nature of being profit concious rather than profit driven, they said.

Gascoigne said PSIS was not registering as a bad because of insufficient capital or any financial stress. The Co-operative bank had tier one capital of 17% of assets, well above its own target of 15% and the Reserve Bank's 8% requirement.

Its annual report shows  had total assets of NZ$1.45 billion as at March 31 and shareholder reserves of NZ$124 million. It made a profit before tax of NZ$9.3 million on operating revenue of NZ$122.1 million.

This is in stark contrast to PSIS in 1979 when its assets were frozen by the then Muldoon Government and it was placed under statutory management. It emerged from statutory management in 1987. Shortly before the statutory management it had 182,000 members and 23% of households had a link to PSIS. It also owned 9 travel agences, 3 wholesale liquor outlets and several motels and other property.

The Co-operative Bank has 90% of its assets in mortgages and 90% of its funding is from term deposits.

Karacaoglu said The Co-operative Bank's focus would remain on personal banking and it had no plans to get into commercial banking, although it would offer small business services to existing customers.

'Faster than system, but not dramatically so'

It currently had a market share of around 0.6% and aimed to grow organically by offering full banking services to its existing customers, around 65,000 were using other banks for their main banking services.

Karacaoglu said The Co-operative Bank aimed to grow lending and deposits above the rate seen in the rest of the banking system, "but not abnormally so."

He cautioned against growing too quickly.

"We're not out there to steal market share from the other banks," he said.

"Any bank that focuses on balance sheet growth ends up in disaster."

David Gascoigne, Girol Karacaoglu and Alan Bollard

(Updated with video and comments from news conference and picture of The Co-operative Bank Chairman David Gascoigne, CEO Girol Karacaoglu and RBNZ Governor Alan Bollard)

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

12 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

Updated with video interview with the CEO

Cheeky name change, I've heard it somewhere else I think.

Good on them. Thanks  Bernard.   

does anybody out there know if heartland have applied for a banking registration or are the struggling to get their books in order,because at 51cents they look like agood buy.

Heartland's hierarchy say they plan to apply by year's end. Could take some time from there though.

I have to say that I am interested in moving my banking to them.  We are with National, who have been fine, but it looks as they are going to be folded totally into ANZ. 

In any case I am sick of seeing all the profits going over the Tasman every year, would like to see them retained within NZ.

The credit rating is a worry tho, although the rating agencies don't have the highest credibility in the world.  I understand they don't do credit cards, either.

Cheers

In this modern age, the age of the cashless society, it is conceivable the "government" could one day establish a non-profit "bank" that caters just for people who dont require mortgages, or loans, or overdrafts, or credit cards. With internet banking you could only draw out up to the balance in your account. It would simply be a giant computer in a back room of the RBNZ. No infrastructure required. No buildings, or tellers. No cheques or debit cards or credit cards. Just internet banking with electrons zipping about. The only benefit of commercial banks is the extra facilities and services they offer. At great cost. I'm guessing there would be many, many people who dont want the extras, but are paying for them. You want cash-out, just go to your nearest local supermarket and scan your iPhone or ID card.

RaboDirect isn't far off ur scenario.

The one problem is, RaboBank co-mingle their in-balance customers with all their other banking customers and services and you are exposed to them going broke.

RaboDirect have fairly terrible technology (I have a list of unfixed problems as long as my arm that they're apparently not interested in fixing); I don't think you'd want to use them for purely electronic day-to-day banking.

Updated with comments from news conference and picture of registration documents being presented.

cheers

Bernard

i've been with them for 5 years or so. a good bunch. good on them.

not many branches but their online setup is nice and flexible. security is via an RSA token login system which i'm largely happy with. 

i'm more interested in the fact that they're nz owned and a co-operative, than whether i am strictly maximising my returns.  life's not all about dollars and cents.

I have been with them for nearly 30 years. They provide great service, they may not have everything, but what they do they do well