Friday's Top 10: Craig Simpson on Putin is no Hitler; regulating monopolies; Europe going down Japan's road; gold and reserves and Money for Nothing

Friday's Top 10: Craig Simpson on Putin is no Hitler; regulating monopolies; Europe going down Japan's road; gold and reserves and Money for Nothing

Today's Top 10 is a guest post from Craig Simpson, senior analyst for

As always, we welcome your additions in the comments below or via email to And if you're interested in contributing the occasional Top 10 yourself, contact

See all previous Top 10s here.

1. The argument that has prevailed in both Europe and the United States is that Vladimir Putin is no Adolf Hitler; by giving him everything he can reasonably ask for, he can be prevented from resorting to further use of force writes George Soros in an article for The New York Review of Books.

The opinion piece titled 'Wake up Europe' outlines Soros' view on the challenges Europe faces from Russia. He also notes that Europe and the United States - each for their own reasons are determined to avoid any direct military confrontation with Russia, and Russia is taking advantage of their reluctance to engage. It is important Ukraine remains independent as the collapse of Ukraine would be a tremendous loss for NATO, the European Union, and the United States.

Soros expands to say a victorious Russia would become much more influential within the EU and pose a potent threat to the Baltic states with their large ethnic Russian populations. Instead of supporting Ukraine, NATO would have to defend itself on its own soil. This would expose both the EU and the US to the danger they have been so eager to avoid: a direct military confrontation with Russia. The European Union would become even more divided and ungovernable. 

2. Jean Tirole this month received a Noble Prize in Economics for his work examining the difficulties in regulating firms with substantial market power. Mr Tirole's research is as relevant as ever, thanks to growing concern over the weight tech titans are throwing around in their corners of the economy.

An example of a firm throwing its weight around is Amazon and its treatment of book suppliers. Specifically the treatment Hachette a major book publisher has received. The two parties failed to come to agreement over a pricing model of e-books. Publishers have been trying to negotiate a minimum price for e-books and Amazon who are a major source of distribution for books is playing hardball and using its monopolistic position to squeeze suppliers. This behaviour has drawn strong criticism from Economist Paul Krugman. Krugman reckons ", the giant online retailer, has too much power, and it uses that power in ways that hurt America".

Krugman believes "Amazon is not really in the bookselling business at all; it's in the buzz business:Book sales depend crucially on buzz and word of mouth (which is why authors are often sent on grueling book tours); you buy a book because you’ve heard about it, because other people are reading it, because it’s a topic of conversation, because it’s made the best-seller list. And what Amazon possesses is the power to kill the buzz. It’s definitely possible, with some extra effort, to buy a book you’ve heard about even if Amazon doesn’t carry it - but if Amazon doesn’t carry that book, you’re much less likely to hear about it in the first place".

3. Is Europe heading down the same road as Japan? Despite some clear differences in economic situation and policy response, comparisons between the current situation in Europe and Japan’s painful experience of low growth and deflation continue to be drawn, says Louis-Vincent Gave from GaveKal Capital. Gave suggests private sector lending must be a focus for the ECB going forward if the situation is to differ from that in Japan, where credit growth was non-existent or in contract from 1995 to 2013.

Gave acknowledges the eurozone situation is particularly fragile, due to the huge debt burdens and policymakers should not ignore the potential deflationary pressure that slowing growth in China will exert.

4. Small Wairarapa vineyard scoops top Pinot Noir trophy in Europe. As a 'Pinotfile' (a lover of Pinot Noir) I was excited to hear a NZ vineyard had scored a top international trophy for Pinot Noir. Lansdowne Estate scooped the coveted Bouchard-Finlayson Trophy at the 2014 International Wine and Spirits Competition (IWSC) for its 2010 Pinot Noir. The vineyard also won two bronze medals for its pinot gris, and two silver for its syrah.

The Bouchard-Finlayson Trophy is similar to wining an Oscar for acting so it is a big deal for NZ Pinot and the small family owned vineyard.

5. John Mauldin examines gold and why the Swiss were such big sellers. At the beginning of 2000 the Swiss National Bank held 43% of the country's total reserves in gold, today that number is 8%. At the beginning of 2000, the Swiss National Bank (SNB) held roughly 2,600 tonnes of gold in its reserves and that equated to approximately 8% of total global central bank gold reserves. After a revision of the country's constitution and becoming signatories to the Washington Agreement on Gold Sales, the genie was released from the Swiss gold storing bottle.

The Swiss National Bank went from being one of the soundest central banking institutions on Earth to just another in the morass of apologist financial institutions that lost sight of their mandates while grasping for a Keynesian free lunch, egged on by a new breed of politicians who knew nothing of the principles of sound money or, if they did, were happy to put them to the back of their minds as they extended their hands.

6. Nanoparticle Platform project. The entreprenurial folk at Google are at it again. This time they are endeavouring to fashion nanoparticles - particles about one billionth of a meter in width -that combine a magnetic material with antibodies or proteins that can attach to and detect other molecules inside the body. The idea is that patients swallow a pill containing these particles, and after they enter the bloodstream they attempt to identify molecules that would indicate certain health problems. A wearable device could use their magnetic cores to gather them back together and read what they’ve found.

Venturing into health science is not entirely new for Google as earlier this year the unveiled a contact lens that enables diabetics to monitor blood glucose levels through the tears in their eyes. As with this contact lens, Google does not intend to sell its nanoparticle pills and accompanying wearables. Instead, it will work with third party medical companies to bring the technology to market.

7. Big business cronyism. At least that is what Australian Greens MP Adam Bandt has labelled the Australian government’s decision to decline calls to hold a royal commission into the Commonwealth Bank’s financial planning arm. Finance minister Mathias Cormann announced the government does not believe a Royal Commission is necessary. Instead the government endorsed the bank’s internal Open Advice Review process as a “comprehensive” solution to addressing client concerns.

CBA's financial planning arm has been riddled with scandals over the past couple of years with stories hitting the press of financial planners working for the bank allegedly forging client signatures and then being able to resign rather than be fired for misconduct. The bank had been engaging with up to 400,000 financial planning customers who may have lost money because of shoddy advice.

8. Anyone who has lived, worked or is friends with me knows I absolutely despise marketing terminology and corporate speak. I am a simple guy and believe a spade is a spade. Job titles which are creative but don't actually tell you what someone does is another thing that grinds my gears.

As many readers and novice investors will know, the world of finance is riddled with terminology and phrases which can be deemed 'useless' and Michael Kitces, a leading financial planner and commentator in the US, has come up with some terms he thinks should be banished. No doubt there are thousands of other terms or definitions we would all like to relegate to the bin as well.

Here is an example of what Kitces would like to ban: I’m a contrarian. I’m all for contrarian investing, but there are so many opinions out there today that it’s nearly impossible to be a true contrarian anymore. You will always be able to find someone that disagrees with you these days. As James Osbourne (@BasonAsset) put it on Twitter last week: “I don’t know” may be the last true contrarian investment strategy.

9. Social media has been buzzing with eulogies to mark the end of QE3. Some of the comments via various twitter feeds have been less than complementary about the Fed, well as much as you can be in less than 140 characters.

In honour of the end of QE3 the good folk at have put together a playlist of songs to mark this occasion. As you would probably have guessed Money for Nothing by Dire Straits made the list and so too did Livin' on a Pray by Bon Jovi. Enjoy.

10. Clarke & Dawe

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.


Since it's friday, the end of the working week (at least for some), time for a wee giggle.
Here a youtube clip on the difference between US and UK TV news coverage on Ebola:

Yet US gun deaths are at 10000+ this year? v 2 or 3 ebola?

And at least 250,000 died from the Flu this year (probably world wide though).

#1 - Britain just pulled out of Afganistan, but they will be back. If ISIS is pushed out of Syria and Iraq they will establish a new base in Afganistan. They, ISIS, are NOT going away.
If NATO gets pushed, by you know who, to get tough on Rusia then China will be thrilled..
As soon as the West gets tied up with Rusia, on top of everything else then China will make its move on the disputed Islands, Tiawan and elsewhere.
World war 3 anyone.
No prizes for guessing who got the world in this mess

Those with more to lose are conciliatory.
We must face the fact that we need Russia, the world needs Russia. Of course we cannot solve the Ukrainian crisis without Russia. We cannot solve the Middle East crisis without Russia, whether we are talking about Syria or Iran or ISIS. Read more
The Russian president “has won because we were not ready to die for Ukraine, while apparently he was,” Ambassador Gerard Araud said yesterday at a Bloomberg Government breakfast in Washington, in remarks he said represented his personal opinion. Echoing the view of other European envoys in Washington, Araud expressed concern that the Ukraine conflict has hit an impasse, leaving Putin the winner by default.
While many observers have called Putin a geopolitical chess player, he said, the Russian leader is more a “poker player really, putting all the money on the table, saying, ‘Do the same,’ and of course we blink. We don’t do the same.” Read more

No need for chess when you hold 4 Aces.
Who has all the Ngas the EU needs? Putin  So the EU will bend over and enjoy it as,  little old ladies freezing to death this coming winter plus a few blackouts is going to look bad, to say the least.

MB, If the second scenario you paint ever comes to pass (C19th Crimean War+ USA), China, from Tibet, will be down the Old Silk Road and into the Caspian oil fields in a flash.   

#7 - A few hundred years ago the British aristocracy took power away from Kings and set up a government. This was because of the poor behavior of the Kings and their lack of democracy.
Today governments are behaving just like those Kings so maybe its time to take their power away aswell.

Re. #5 - It's a pity that you failed to mention the Swiss referendum on gold that takes place on the 30th November. The outcome will be very interesting.

Why do you think that?

Listen to the chatter.  Putin is the more reasonable.
The west goes off on tangents and always somebody has to be demonised.  Last year it was Iran.  Then ISIS came along and Iran went off the bad list.
Putin - and Russia - has had to endure a lot of misplaced criticism.  Crimea - Really.  That was just one of those endless ethnic tiffs that europe does so well.   But the West made it into a geopolitical issue.

#3. Amazing, I have just this minute heard (BBC) that the one factor the regulator was not allowed to incorporate into the modelling for the Euro Bank stress tests was - deflation. It was deemed too politically contentious. Talk about doing an Ostrich whilst all Europe is going Japanese!  Really, I have to add here, anyone who argues the NZD is overvalued today, compared to the mess in the rest of the West is wilfully blind. 

and yet deflation is the very thing that will stress the most.  take thet out and nothing else is much of an issue.

Soros is disgusting and this article is typical of the distortions presented in the mainstream media about Putin and Russia. To recap. THe Ukrainian crisis was fomented by the USA as they try to move Nato closer to the Russian border in contravention with agreements made between Reagan and Gorbachov. They spent several billion dollars to acheive this as American secretary of state Nuland boasted. They dragged a reluctant EU into the mess as evidenced by Nulands "F...K the EU phone call with the US-Ukraine ambassador. Russia was blamed for the unrest that has followed  and the mainstream media has never missed an oportunity to unfairly demonise Putin ever since. In fact he has been beyond resonable in his responses. The American EU sanctions against Russia were responded to with restrictions on food imports from the EU and the net effect has been much worrse for the EU. Once again the media has carefully toed the US line that Russia is responsible for all the ills that have resulted. 
The annexation of Crimea, after a referendum was a lot more democratic than the violent takeover in Kiev
Evidence is mounting that Ukraine was responsible for MH17. Obama Abbott and Cameron cannot change the facts that the Nazi regime they supported is guilty of this and many other atrocities.
The Russians understand that they are being targeted in an economic war with the price of oil being forced down and sanctions so they have turned to China. Once again Putin out witted the US schemes. 
Being a nuclear power Russia does not have to kowtow to the USA and is unwilling to submit to the aggressive surveilance state that is trying to control the whole world. The US  have mismanaged their own corrupt economy so need fall guys to explain the coming collapse. Soros is just another part of the obscene power stucture that is accumulating incredible wealth at the expense of the middle class and is looking to point their attention elsewhere. THe BBC and the NZ media have unquestioningly gone along with this false propaganda. I hope is going to be a little more  thoughtful in its coverage. I could provide many links to support my statements here but would just suggest people look for themselves. Google Paul Craig Roberts. Former assistant Treasuary Secretary to Reagan.  Hardly a commie sympathiser.

Your access to our unique content is free - always has been. But ad revenues are diving so we need your direct support.

Become a supporter

Thanks, I'm already a supporter.