sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

ASB says it may be late 2029 before house prices get back up to 2021 peaks

Property / news
ASB says it may be late 2029 before house prices get back up to 2021 peaks
House buyers with agent

ASB economists say it is the end of an era for house price gains.

Their latest Economic Note on the house price outlook says there was an almost sixfold increase in house prices over the 30 years prior to 2020.

That averaged out at about 6% growth a year and was above the average 5% annual growth in GDP over the same period. However, the report says the going has been tough since prices peaked in 2021, with prices generally "floundering." 

"Since peaking in 2021, the going has been tough," the report says.

"NZ house prices are currently about 15% below historic peaks, or just under 30% down in inflation adjusted terms, albeit with acute regional differences," ASB's economists say.

They note a number of factors have affected the market, including cyclical weakness, low net immigration, recent increases in borrowing costs, pronounced uncertainty and high existing dwelling listings.

However ASB says there are also three key structural developments affecting house prices:

  • "Potential end to the trend of easing mortgage interest rates that will reduce the likelihood of a borrowing-led increase in house prices."
  • "Low net immigration and a slowing natural increase have both acted to slow population growth. Absent a strong and pronounced lift in net immigration, it is difficult to foresee a prolonged lift in population growth."
  • "Changes to housing supply and increased intensification have shifted the effective housing supply curve outwards, providing would be buyers with more choice."

The report says the above factors may also help explain why the housing market is yet to take off despite sizeable post-2021 house price falls significantly improving housing affordability.

It says that while the house price outlook is "incredibly uncertain," the above factors are expected to "contribute to a more moderate house price recovery in the coming years, with outsized capital gains looking to be harder to achieve than in the past."

The report forecasts flat house prices for this year, with a moderate increase of around 3.5% in 2027 and future increases beyond that to be broadly inline with nominal income growth of about 5%.

"It may not be until late 2029 that nationwide house prices approach late 2021 peaks on a nominal basis," the report concludes.

ASB is New Zealand's second biggest housing lender with total loans of $84 billion as of June 30.

The comment stream on this article is now closed.


We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

26 Comments

ASB are just saying, what their failing loan book, needs to happen.

They have Zero credibility, as do other selfishly interest banks.

No way property can make any gains, while mortgages rise and rise.  The long-term, higher cost of debt funds, will destroy any debt funded asset values further.

No meagre gains, until near 2030.

Up
12

Agreed. Further ponzi growth would need more printed currency debasement supplied cheaply to lazy banks, and or another mass immigration wave that no one voted for (again). Add in significant intensification on old central house locations (Akl and Chch) adding to overall central bed numbers per sqm, I just can't see it without lots of the first two.

Up
9

Or higher immigration, or a reversal of the current youth generating wising up to do the real math on the real cost of homeownership. Doesn't matter what ingrained cultural mantra there is saying 'get on the ladder, you need to own a home', if the math doesn't add up, people will choose other options, investments, or countries to reside.

Up
1

"House price falls significantly improving housing affordability"

When I asked AI what the median house price to households income ratio was, it spat this out;

2000 = 4.5; 2020 = 6.3; 2021 = 9.8; 2025 = 7.2

To my way of thinking that statement should have read: "house price falls have made housing a little less UNafforable".

Up
12

Yes 4 to 5xDTI in 2030 would have the NZ property scene in good balance.  
Look forward to the next 4 years, of lower and lower values, to bring it to pass.

Up
8

And they wonder why young people aren't having as many children, if any. When they do the sums and consider these sums with BOTH parents still working maybe it works out, until childcare wipes out one income to cover the cost, and suddenly housing doesn't seem so appealing any more, or children, pick one at the expense of the other. 

Up
10

Exactly. The continual negative connotations around falling house prices from banks, politicians and radio hosts are tedious. The sooner we celebrate housing becoming affordable the sooner our young people will cease the mass exodus across the ditch, the sooner people will start wanting families and the sooner our communities will start to function as they should.      

Up
16

Bang on.  A whole mindset shift still needs to happen.  Until house prices return to a reasonable level of affordability our major export will be smart kids

Up
8

Wasn't long ago that commenters here were slamming retirement villages for excluding capital gains from RTO contracts. Now we find there are none.

Up
1

Hence there share price has been hammered, no more easy money

Up
5

Still waiting for residents to put their hands up to share in any capital losses.

Up
3

They don't need to. Loses are on the operator

Up
1

Yes, that's my point. Plenty of noise to change the contract in the favour of residents when the market was generous, but I don't imagine that anyone is keen to take on the additional risk as well as the reward. 

Up
5

Well said mfd. 

With the "rich pricks" no longer getting richer (if ASB are right) - the usual moaners on here are going to have to find something new to moan about until 2030.   

Up
1

Hey AI - I sold a house for 3.25 mil in 2021, it's now worth 2 mil in end 2026, to get back to sale price by the end of 2029 what annual rate of increase would be needed.

17.6% annual compounding  - For jousting sticks, tell em they are Dreamin

Property value rebound calculation

Starting value (end 2026):     $2,000,000
Target value (end 2029):       $3,250,000
Time period:                    3 years

Formula:  r = (Target / Start)^(1/3) - 1
         r = (3,250,000 / 2,000,000)^(1/3) - 1
         r = 1.625^(1/3) - 1
         r = 0.1757

Required annual growth rate:   17.6% per year (compounded annually)

Check:  2,000,000 x 1.1757^3 = 3,250,000

For reference, at a more typical long-run housing growth rate of ~5–7%/year, $2M would only reach about $2.32M–$2.45M by end of 2029 — nowhere near $3.25M, so getting back to the original sale price in that window would require a fairly sharp rebound, not steady-state appreciation.

Up
5

At normal rates, it would take 7–10 years (into the mid-2030s) rather than the 3 years by end-2029 in the original scenario — confirming that a 3-year full rebound really would need an unusually sharp ~17.6%/year run, well above typical long-run housing appreciation.

Years needed to reach $3,250,000 from $2,000,000 at normal housing growth rates

Formula:  n = ln(Target / Start) / ln(1 + r)
         n = ln(1.625) / ln(1 + r)

Rate      Years needed     Reaches $3.25M around
-----     ------------     ----------------------
5%/yr     9.95 years       ~end of 2036
6%/yr     8.33 years       ~early 2035
7%/yr     7.18 years       ~early 2034

(Starting point: end of 2026)

Up
4

It’s quite possible that we don’t see the 2021 peak again for a few decades. In real terms it’s almost certain - and possible we never see such a peak (in real terms) in our lifetimes. 

Not that long ago the ‘be quick’ comments were getting great enthusiasm on this site. Just an indication of peak financial bubble behaviour. 

Up
8

Hilarious prediction there. Of course 2021 prices will be reached again in nominal terms. In fact, in many parts of the South Island, prices are already back to those levels. For Auckland and Wellington, it may take the best part of a decade.

Up
2

Should do the same for ‘house prices double every 10 years’ starting in 2021 - ie what growth rate is required from now to 2031 for a house purchased in 2021 to double in price. It isn’t happening. And it’s clear that was a property investor association fallacy used as a propaganda tool to encourage new investors - whilst  true for a while under certain conditions, it was never an absolute truth (ie something they is always true over time)

Up
1

It reminds me of the UK situation, although they are ahead a little, and have been through  two crashes in my lifetime.  In 1989 - a crash will not happen we were told.  It happened, prices fell circa 25%, and prices did not recover to 1989 values until 1998, so ten years.  

Then in 2008 as subprime hit, the same mantra - can't happen here.  It did, prices down 20% over 2008-2010.  Recovery took place, but only due to near zero base rates, and Government help in the form of 15% deposits for new home purchases.  That scheme would not have worked were mortgage rates as today - 5-6%.

I think NZ is at the denial stage of depression of this saga as in....'enough, back to rising prices, we don't do house price crashes here'. Maybe by next year they will be at the anger/bargaining stage, or maybe some are there - I am thinking of someone who recently asked,,OK, Ive reduced it but how much would you pay for the property?

Back to the UK I see on a development near where we used to live, a £1.3m new-build is being sold fully furnished, carpets, top range kitchen etc, purchase tax (£85,000) thrown in.  So roughly £100,000 off the price.  Never trust house prices data!  

Up
5

You will need equity index funds involved if you need double every 10 years.  And these get hit in serious crashes, probably the biggest risk is the depth issue, that AI now dominates us index funds,   to protet from this perhaps invest in world index such as MSCI World.

 

The long-term historical return of the MSCI World Index has been approximately 9.1% per year in USD (gross returns, including reinvested dividends) since 31 December 1987. [msci.com], [fatfire.com]

 

Important considerations

  • The index covers about 1,280 large and mid-cap companies across 23 developed markets. [msci.com], [msci.com]
  • It is heavily weighted toward the United States (currently around 70%+ of the index). [msci.com], [fatfire.com]
  • Returns can be volatile. The index experienced a maximum drawdown of approximately-57% during the Global Financial Crisis. [msci.com], [investingi...theweb.com]
  • A reasonable long-term expectation for planning purposes is often 7% to 9% nominal returns, rather than assuming the stronger recent 10-year performance will continue indefinitely. [msci.com], [investingi...theweb.com]

For a New Zealand investor, if you're investing through a PIE fund or ETF that tracks the MSCI World, I would typically use 8% p.a. before tax and fees as a conservative long-term planning assumption.

 

 

Up
1

If you're looking for leveraged exposure to a broad developed-market index similar to the MSCI World, there are now a small number of ETFs available, although the choices are much more limited than for the S&P 500. [justetf.com], [amundietf.lu]

Current MSCI World Leveraged ETF

Amundi MSCI World (2x) Leveraged UCITS ETF Acc

  • ISIN: FR0014010HV4
  • Ticker: LVWC (Xetra), LWLD (Euronext Paris)
  • Objective: Deliver approximately 2x the daily performance of the MSCI World Index through the MSCI World Leveraged 2X Daily (Net) Index.
  • Structure: Synthetic (swap-based)
  • Management fee: 0.60% p.a.
  • Launch date: 30 September 2025 [justetf.com], [amundietf.lu]

Important Caveat

This ETF provides 2x daily leverage, not 2x the long-term return of the MSCI World Index. Because the leverage resets daily:

  • In trending markets, returns can be better than expected.
  • In volatile sideways markets, performance can be significantly worse due to compounding and volatility drag.
  • Losses are amplified, and drawdowns can be severe. [leveraged-etfs.com], [msci.com]

Alternative Approach

Many investors seeking modest leverage on global equities instead:

  1. Buy a low-cost unleveraged MSCI World ETF (or VT/VWRP/IWDA).
  2. Add leverage through a margin loan or home equity facility.

This can often provide:

  • Lower costs.
  • More control over leverage (e.g., 1.2x to 1.5x instead of a fixed 2x).
  • Less volatility drag than a daily-reset leveraged ETF.

For a New Zealand Investor

If you're investing for the long term (10+ years), I would generally view:

  1. Regular MSCI World ETF (best risk-adjusted choice)
  2. 1.2x to 1.5x leverage via borrowing (for sophisticated investors)
  3. 2x daily leveraged ETF (speculative, higher-risk choice)
Up
2

I would stay well away from the share market for the time being. It's getting crazy speculative at the moment and it's day of reckoning is fast approaching. 

Up
0

sounds like you are a share market DGMer

note my world view is not as exposed to US AI mania, or not?

Do you rate property over equity investment?

Up
1

Lots is printed cash in the share market as well. Same problem.... price totally unsupported by income. Speculative capital gain chasing again is the focus, just like another investment in NZ.

Big difference is shares usually use equity rather than debt, and price change/discovery is near instant unlike a certain asset in NZ, especially on the way down.

Up
0

We’re you making the same warnings about the housing market before the peak?

Up
1