sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Christopher Luxon remains Prime Minister and National Party leader after surviving another caucus vote

Public Policy / news
Christopher Luxon remains Prime Minister and National Party leader after surviving another caucus vote
[updated]
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon addresses media after a second confidence vote.
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon addresses media after a second confidence vote. Image source: Anna Whyte/interest.co.nz

By Anna Whyte and Mandy Te

Like a cat with nine lives, Christopher Luxon remains the country’s Prime Minister and National Party leader following a second National leadership vote this year at an urgent meeting he called following leadership speculation.

Emerging after a three hour caucus meeting, reading from handwritten notes, Luxon spoke in Parliament flanked by a large group of senior MPs and National Party president Sylvia Wood.

With him were Erica Stanford, who was widely tipped to be a leadership contender, and other senior MPs such as Chris Bishop, Mark Mitchell, Simeon Brown and Louise Upston.

"There was a confidence vote in my leadership this morning at our caucus meeting, and I have the full support of our caucus. Our caucus is united and it is determined to win this election," Luxon told reporters.

Luxon began his speech calling the upcoming election "absolutely pivotal", with serious issues at stake.

"We think we have made tremendous progress as a government, rebuilding economic growth, financial discipline, restoring law and order, and certainly strengthening education and healthcare. But we also acknowledge that we have a lot more to do."

Luxon said the caucus was united and determined to win the election.

"Our focus is on National's positive plan to fix the basics and to build the future, so that we realise the incredible potential that sits in this country, and that we set it up for our kids and our grandkids so they can do better than we can."

Reporters' questions went unanswered. 

Earlier on Wednesday, National MPs descended on the Capital to decide their party's leadership future, after Luxon called an urgent Caucus meeting amid leadership speculation.

The meeting began on Wednesday at 9.30am. Being a recess week where Parliament doesn't sit, MPs were in their electorates around the country or at events this week, travelling to Wellington especially for the meeting. 

Prime Minister and National Party leader Christopher Luxon with senior National MPs and National Party president Sylvia Wood. Image source: Anna Whyte/interest.co.nz

'This issue needs to be resolved quickly'

Luxon called the meeting following speculation from media outlets including the NZ Herald, who on Monday evening reported that unhappy National MPs were making phone calls about a potential leadership change.

It also follows what was a challenging week for Luxon, who apologised for his remarks at a breakfast hosted by the Rotorua Business Chamber, was accused of inaction over Foreign Affairs Minister and New Zealand First leader Winston Peters’ racially charged comments to Green MP Lawrence Xu-Nan, and later suggested he would hold a referendum on MMP if re-elected.

Taking to social media on Tuesday, Luxon wrote: “It is clear from various media reports and conversations there is increased speculation about my leadership.”

“It is my firm belief that division and disunity are a major distraction only 90 days out from the election. I also believe this distraction is unfair to the New Zealand people, and dedicated National Party candidates, supporters and volunteers, when there is so much at stake.”

“For these reasons, this issue needs to be resolved quickly, and I am calling an urgent in-person Caucus meeting tomorrow [Wednesday] at 9:30am in Wellington to resolve the issue,” he wrote on X.

This isn’t the first time Luxon has been under pressure.

In April, Luxon moved a formal motion to confirm his leadership after reports of discontent in his caucus began to circulate and polls showed a sharp decline in public confidence. That motion was passed but reports from media say the voting wasn't unanimous, with some floating 27 - 22 and others suggesting 28 - 21 in favour of Luxon. 

'Less than helpful'

Before the Caucus meeting was over, Former Prime Minister and National leader John Key, said he didn't know if Luxon would remain prime minister.

"The weird thing in politics is the leader is first amongst equals .. It's not like a company where the board selects you or it's not like ... a sporting team where the coach decides you're captain."

Key said he was the leader of National for 10 years and he thought he; "ran the show but truthfully, you're first amongst equals. So what I can tell you is they'll either decide to have a confidence vote or not, and if they do have one, and if there's a vote, then he'll either will be or he won't be".

"But in the end, it'll be the 49 MPs sitting in that room that decide."

Speaking at the Financial Services Council conference in Auckland, Key said while he continues to support Luxon, there was not much point in him making a prediction.

Key said he wasn’t working the phones.

"From time to time, the odd person will ring me. I'm not going to deny that. And I give people my view on things, but I don't try and go and overly influence because I'm no longer part of it ... In the end, it's for them. I'm just a kind of person that believes in them, but I don't try and engineer it." 

He said Luxon was a very capable person with the best intentions.

“A decision is going to get made … They will make a decision because they have to ... They'll make a decision, and it'll be what it'll be, and and we'll go from there.”

Key said what was happening was “less than helpful” because New Zealand was close to an election and it could unsettle some voters.

But whatever happened today won’t change his view on Luxon, he said. 

"I've supported Christopher, and I do that, and I continue to do that because I believe in him. But I believe in that team. They're a team full of incredibly good people, and they're starting to shine over time."

"I kind of bleed blue so whoever emerges out on the other end, I'll be cheering on." 

'Infighting is not looked upon very well'

Before National's meeting came to an end, Labour finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds told interest.co.nz that while New Zealanders were worried about how they were going to pay their bills, "the National Government are worried about themselves."

"That just shows where their focus is."

It was unsettling for voters to see a major political party who is in government doing what they're doing, Edmonds said. 

"Infighting is not looked upon very well."

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

39 Comments

It is interesting that despite the many opportunities that  PM Luxon has been providing them to go after him, the Labour party have been playing on soft pedal in response. It is highly unusual, particularly in the lead up to an election, for party leaders who lead with their chin to be left alone and it might well demonstrate that the opposition see his continuing as being a bonus to their own chances? 

Up
3

“Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake” - Napoleon Bonapart (apparently)

Up
6

Their problem is that the gap between promises needing made to get re-elected, and reality, is too wide to bridge. 

But we don't get articles about that. 

Eh? 

Up
5

But we don't get articles about that. 

I think the reality of failed promises and underdelivering is becoming more and more apparent to the public by the day. The link you assert, maybe not, but the gap, definitely.

Up
2

Just listened to Hipkins on it.  Just standard nonsense.   Not an interesting reflection to be heard there. 

Up
0

Why he feels he is capable of leading labour to any victory given his failures in multiple core portfolios under the previous govt is beyond me. Delusion? Denial? Paycheck? Maybe after the next election he will come to acceptance finally.

Up
2

Yond McAnulty has a lean & hungry look...

Up
0

I didn't vote for him or them however if I was Luxon I'd give National a Final Warning.

He shouldn't / doesn't need to put up with this. The Nat white ants have clearly forgotten the dysfunctional basket case he took over. He has also demonstrated exceptional leadership in herding both the Nats & the Coalition cats into a coherent Parliamentary government.

Up
7

Honest Government Ad | Ai Data Centres

They'll be doing this no matter who the select. 

 

Up
5

So will Labour, unfortunately. I agree with the Greens recent comments on data centre's.

Its also off topic (I  know you only have 1 topic😉)

Up
8

I think the concern is that even if this 'coherent' government were re-elected under Luxon, it is looking like it will be with a smaller National caucus. Given how much Luxon gave away during negotiations to NZF and ACT on those percentages, I'd hate to see how much more they would have to concede on current numbers.

Up
3

I'd love to see how much more they'd have to concede on current numbers. 

Up
3

Difficult to give final warnings when you lack the credibility within your caucus to do so. Hence why it's come to this in the first place.

Up
2

The Final Warning would be "get in behind or I'm out of here"

 

Up
2

Surely the final warning was after the April vote. 

If Luxon emerges still the leader and Bishop etc hang around then it will result in more potential voters bailing on them 

Up
2

OMG he is staying

Up
1

No one better to replace him?

 

Ultimately then, much ado about nothing.

Up
1

Just watch the media tear into him now and I suspect,  his inability to deal with that. I don’t think I could bear to watch PM Luxon in the forthcoming live debates. The embarrassment is likely to be overwhelming. If the coalition remains in power for the next term it will be due to the efforts of ACT & NZF having to shore up National and their self made problems. It could well be that the make up of the next government sees National unable to hold a majority over the other two combined.

Up
6

PM Christopher Luxon says he has survived a confidence vote with "full support" of caucus

Up
0

But no Bishop standing behind him. Or Penk

Up
0

Correction! Bishop was in the wide shot 

Up
2

Correction.

Fool support.

Up
8

The fools are the MSM & anyone believing their spins.. To what end?

So obvious. The MSmedia are a bunch of captured Left fangirls, in thrall to Labours PIJF propaganda funding which was never killed until this year (supposedly) & who are currently actively promoting TOP without any policy critique to wedge the Coalition.

Up
8

Actually we are the fools , being ruled over by which ever bunch of short sighted self serving bunch we care to vote in.

PDK seems more right by the day.

Up
7

You say MSM but I think you really just mean the general public

Up
1

Unsurprising, as it would have been a hospital pass for anyone else taking the leadership. This govt is going down on Nov 7.

Up
3

Ok so he’s still prime minister after receiving full support from his caucus. So this theoretically could have been a fictional beat up made up by media just to sell more stories ? 

Up
0

It does leave me trying to recall where the story started from.

Up
0

Or Nat dissidents pumping their journalist contacts with rumours 

New factoid from this is that 22 voted against in April. 

No smoke without fire 

Up
4

Well PM Luxon saw fit to call an extraordinary caucus meeting. Did he do that then  for no other reason that he was in a panic about what the media were publishing. In other words given he is fond to dismiss the media as beater uppers why did he overreact now if he knew he had 100% backing in his party as now claimed. Once again, right on cue, obviously all is not well and good in the National Party and they could hardly  have let the cat out of the bag at a worse time.

Up
7

It is clear that there is widespread discontent within the National Party caucus about Luxon's performance and anxiety about what this means when the election campaign swings into top gear. Why else would Luxon need to call for this and the previous April vote of confidence?

What is also clear is that the various factions within the National caucus are unable to coalesce their support around an alternative which has reasonable public polling support - these being Chris Bishop or Erica Stanford. 

 

Up
4

A media beatup, start to finish.

Up
2

He didn’t receive full support though did he. That’s bluntly obvious even before he sacked Penk. 

Up
0

Luxon has lost authority. He calls Winston Peters a racist but doesn't remove him from his Ministerial posts. Does that make Winston the real PM behind the fake Luxon PM?

Luxon makes blunder after blunder. Everything from using Airforce helicopters to get back from National Party campaign meetings to infering that ACT and NZ First MPs were Numpties and Yahoos. 

Given that the National Party caucus have not replaced Luxon for a second time then they will have to own any continued poor performance. 

This turn of events could be very destructive for the centre right of politics. 

Up
7

Luxon said if people were disgusted by what Winston Peters said they could not vote for him in the election in 3 months time. I personally think that’s the most rational thing to do when he’s not part of your party. I’m no fan of Luxon in particular or any politician or party right now however I have an even lower opinion of media who seem to me will sink lower than even politicians to keep their jobs alive so stirring up a spill rumour seems just par for the course this far out from an election. And if u think Luxon calling for the caucus meeting was desperation, just have a think how hard media would have gone if he had implied they were blowing hot air yet again. They would have persisted until he had to anyway. 

Up
5

Luxon is a complete hypocrite because he announced he would not give Nash a ministerial spot in the next government if he were the PM because of his sexist comments. Yet despite Luxon acknowledging that Winston Peter's butter chicken, flatfish and return to China comments were racist he wouldn't apply the same no minister position principle. 

Up
3

Great 

Up
0

It’s the policies (vacuum thereof) that actually matter, not the chief monkey organ grinder.  Distracted from say LNG urgency, (fire ban around New Plymouth?  Compensation for putting a powder keg in the middle of an urban area?), or the imposing of Central Government will on the folks of Gisborne preventing them from trying to control forestry slash.  So many bad policies in such a short time.   

Up
4

I was listening to National Radio today.   Over excited and speculation mostly.  Some plain invention.  Because that is what they do when they know nothing.

Guyon Espiner was beside himself.  All just ridiculous.

Some even got speculating on election date.  Which is such a common distraction that the politicians have started announcing an election date early in the year.just to shut up the useless talk about it.

I think because there are so few journalists now, and they can't get about the place any more, to get something out they are reduced to interviewing their navels.

Up
2