sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

By Friday evening, Treatyism, Transgenderism, and Palestine may be shaping-up as the Left’s policy trifecta

Public Policy / opinion
By Friday evening, Treatyism, Transgenderism, and Palestine may be shaping-up as the Left’s policy trifecta
flood

By Chris Trotter*

What should New Zealanders expect, if, as some political number-crunchers are predicting, the Special Votes deliver a left-wing election victory?

The country has been told that “pathways to victory” are more obvious on the right of our politics than they are on the left: that everything would have to go Chris Hipkins’ and his allies’ way for the Left to pull a win out of the electoral mess thrown up on the night of Saturday, 7th November.

But what if it does? What if Kieran McAnulty emerges triumphant in Wairarapa? What if both the Greens and Opportunity pick up a seat each after the Specials count – and NZ First loses one? Most crucially, what if Qiulae Wong and Opportunity decide to lead the party’s 8-strong parliamentary contingent to the Left?

Yes, that would be a single-seat majority, an extraordinarily precarious position from which to govern New Zealand effectively. And that’s the reason why most pundits are expecting Wong and her party to go with the Right. Given the many challenges facing the country, the only responsible course for Opportunity is to provide National, Act and NZ First with a solid parliamentary majority.

More to the point, Wong herself gave the voters an important pointer to the way her mind might work its way through this vital historical choice.

In what a card-shark might describe as a political “tell”, Wong, in one of the pre-election debates, challenged Chloe Swarbrick to imagine all the bad policies she and her party could have stopped in their tracks if the Greens had been willing to go into a coalition with National.

That sounded like a line Wong had been rehearsing for some time. A line she could see herself using to justify keeping the Right in power – if that is how the electoral chips fall.

Then again, rescuing Christopher Luxon’s, David Seymour’s and Winston Peters’ political futures might prove to be three dead rats too many for what is, after all, a party propelled into Parliament by woke Wellingtonians.

At the core of such political reluctance lies what might be called the “Holy Trinity” of the contemporary New Zealand Left: the Treaty; Transgenderism; and the Tribulations of the Palestinians.

Of only marginal concern to most New Zealanders, the impact of a further three years of right-wing government on these three core issues is a powerful motivating factor for “progressive” New Zealand.

The last three years have been a nightmare for progressives. On all three of the Holy Trinity the Coalition has been forcing the pace – in the wrong direction.

The question Labour, the Greens, Te Pāti Māori, and their many extra-parliamentary allies have been asking themselves since 2023 is this: If the National-Act-NZ First Coalition is re-elected in 2026, will there be anything left to save by the time the next election rolls around in 2029?

Why else would the Public Service Association, which for most of its existence has resisted all appeals to become directly involved in the electoral process, called upon its members to “Change the Government” in 2026?

It wasn’t just the threat of mass layoffs. Conscientised public servants have spent the last three years defending the “Treatyist” gains of 2017-2023 – to the point of openly defying the directives of Coalition ministers. They were determined to make Luxon’s a one-term government.

NZ First’s efforts to roll back what it sees as the excesses of transgenderism have enraged trans activists. The defenders of the Palestinian cause have been similarly infuriated by Foreign Minister Winston Peters’ refusal to confront directly the “genocidal” policies of the Israeli government.

The firestorm of leftist fear and rage that greeted the 2026 General Election’s preliminary results wasn’t kindled by “overhang” considerations alone. At a deeper level the Left feels bitterly alienated from the slim majority of New Zealanders (or, at least, from the slim majority of the three-quarters of Kiwis who bothered to cast a vote) who persist in rejecting progressive claims on behalf of the Treaty, Trans’ Rights, and Palestine.

Test the fidelity of these leftists to democracy and the results are unlikely to be reassuring. That the masses’ support for causes which the Left considers self-evidently compelling should be so unemphatic or, even worse, undetectable, leads them to the dark conclusion that leaving the ultimate resolution of such profound moral issues to democratic head-counting is no longer acceptable.

It is possible that Mayor Wayne Brown is not the only New Zealander who thinks that “democracy has had its day.”

There will be many who object that the Left’s Holy Trinity are peripheral to the concerns of economically stressed Kiwis. That the cost of living, unaffordable housing, failing public services, inadequate wages, and child poverty are of vastly more concern to the ordinary man and woman in the street than the Treaty, Trans’ Rights, and Palestine.

This is undoubtedly the case, and one would think that it is around these issues that everyone to the left of Winston Peters might coalesce and advance on a minimum programme of relief and reform.

The reason why no such mass movement has arisen is because anyone attempting to sign-on to the Left must first sign-up to the three big issues. Any potential recruit who denies that Māori never surrendered sovereignty to the British Crown, or that trans-women are women, or that Israel is guilty of genocide, will not make it past the front desk. Or, if they do get inside the hall, be expelled the moment they reveal themselves as transphobes, racists, or Zionists.

It is the rigid enforcement of this ideological litmus test that explains the absence of a mass movement for change, the risible turnout, and why Labour, the Greens, and Te Pāti Māori could not, between them, muster more than 43.3 percent of the preliminary Party Vote.

It also explains why the moral pressure on Qiulae Wong and Opportunity to throw-in with the Left, if the formation of a left-wing government becomes possible, will be enormous.

Should Opportunity party members choose the Right, then they will become instant pariahs. Left-wing MPs will refuse to share parliamentary lifts with them. Left-wing Wellingtonians will cross the street to avoid them.

But even if Qiulae swallows the red pill, a left-wing government made up of Labour, the Greens, Te Pāti Māori, and Opportunity will find it difficult to agree on taxation, public borrowing, union empowerment, renationalisation of assets – and much else.

What they will agree upon, however, and quickly, is advancing the programme set forth in the He Puapua Report. (One of whose authors is now an Opportunity MP).

Radical constitutional change – much of it inimical to democracy as understood by most New Zealanders – will be implemented. If He Puapua offers any guide, the ratification of such changes by binding referenda is not guaranteed.

Legislation granting the fullest possible legal recognition and protection of transgender citizens, and requiring their unrestricted admission to, and participation in, all social environments and activities, will be passed with alacrity.

New Zealand will recognise the State of Palestine and impose sanctions on the State of Israel and its political leaders – most probably in the first 100 days. The new government is also likely to throw its weight behind South Africa’s charge that Israel is guilty of committing genocide in Gaza.

To limit the capacity of civil society to resist such a programme, New Zealand’s new “litmus” government may also find it expedient to pass legislation criminalising “hate speech.” Forms of expression likely to “harm” vulnerable individuals and/or groups may end up being monitored closely by the state and even suppressed if such expression can be shown to be injurious to the public good.

By such measures, New Zealand will align itself with the legislative regimes regulating freedom of expression already operating in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Canada, and Australia.

It’s a lot for a government with a majority of one to contemplate!

If the release of the Final Election Result on Friday afternoon indicates that the formation of a Labour-Green-Te Pāti Māori-Opportunity government is at least theoretically possible, then there will be many New Zealanders hoping that there is at least one MP willing to make such a government practically impossible.

Someone willing to turn the litmus paper blue – not pink.

But hoping may not be enough.


*Chris Trotter has been writing and commenting professionally about New Zealand politics for more than 30 years. He writes a weekly column for interest.co.nz. His work may also be found at http//:bowalleyroad.blogspot.com.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.