sign uplog in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Labour Party candidate Vanushi Walters says New Zealand needs stability and continuity, and money up its sleeve in an uncertain COVID-19 dominated world

Labour Party candidate Vanushi Walters says New Zealand needs stability and continuity, and money up its sleeve in an uncertain COVID-19 dominated world
Picture: Miroslava Chrienova, Pixabay.

By Vanushi Walters*

New Zealand, along with the rest of the world, is facing a 1-in-100 year shock due to the impacts of COVID-19. Both major parties have released their fiscal plans with how we will handle these unprecedented times and the contrast could not be more stark.

Labour’s top priority is keeping New Zealanders safe. This is a tricky virus that can’t just be ordered to go away. That’s why we’ve kept aside $12 billion in the COVID Fund to deal with the impact if there were to be another outbreak – so that we could support the health response, give businesses certainty, and cushion the blow for households.

Labour’s plan balances the need to keep debt under control while making sure services like health and education are protected from cuts. It contains our planned infrastructure investment of $42 billion over the next four years, a balanced debt reduction plan, and money for additional operating and capital investment over the next four years. Extra revenue raised from a new income tax rate for the top 2% of New Zealanders helps to properly fund health and education while keeping a lid on debt. In contrast, National are promising irresponsible tax cuts and New Zealanders know now is not the time for a quick sugar hit. It puts our essential public services at risk while the pandemic rages on around the world. It’s the definition of irresponsible fiscal management.

Thanks to our careful management, Labour’s revenue policy means operating allowances – the money set aside to cover inflation, population changes and new policies – can be increased slightly to $2.625 billion across each of the next four Budgets. National’s plan leaves just $814 million next year, and $704 million the year after, to deal with basic cost pressures across the whole Budget. Labour’s plan sets aside double that with election commitments being taken into account. National are short before you even look at extra investment into health, education, police and other essential services.

What New Zealand needs now is stability and continuity. New Zealand does not need a shambolic, divided and distracted National Party that can’t even make its own numbers add up. They missed over $4 billion from their plan which Judith Collins is calling ‘inconsequential’. These kinds of mistakes have real consequences in Government and put our recovery at risk. To fix another of their errors in their plan, National will raid the fund that pays for our roads, maintenance, safety improvements, cycleways and more. They are planning to raid a total of $10.2 billion from that fund and National’s approach would see projects around New Zealand having to be cut and jobs lost. We will keep those investments intact and keep rolling out our record infrastructure programme to create jobs.

Now is not the right time to be running down the COVID Fund for tax cuts, when the rest of the world is experiencing alarming second waves of infection. Only Labour will manage the books carefully while putting aside money for dealing with COVID-19 and protecting services like health and education. 

*Vanushi Walters is Labour’s candidate for Upper Harbour, and is #23 on the Labour Party List. She is a Director at Cogent Law and a Trustee at Foundation North.  She has taken leave from her role as a Senior Manager at the Human Rights Commission during the campaigning period. Brooke van Velden, who is the ACT Party's Deputy Leader and Wellington Central candidate, is also writing a regular column for during this election campaign.

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.


Your joking right, Labour fiscally prudent with blowing $60B on Covid ?
JA blew $16M on art, yes thats fiscally prudent.
eg $50k to someone in New York to "think about art". Yes thats money well spent.

More mainstream economic claptrap from another writer that doesn't understand the difference between a currency issuer and a currency user. Any talk of taxpayers funding the government is nonsensical as taxpayers are currency users and not currency issuers. The Government via its wholly owned central bank the Reserve Bank of New Zealand is the only legal source of NZ Dollar Currency. The Reserve Bank itself states this on its website, " The Reserve Bank has the sole right to produce currency in New Zealand".

With all respect, stick to Human Rights stuff, economics sure isnt your field of strength... gave me a good laugh though :D

Hope you charge the authors a decent fee for this Party Propaganda, and hope also that they declare it as a valid Election Expense. If it came as a flyer in my letterbox, it would make a useful firestarter, though. But Serious Economic Content it shurely ain't....

I wonder if she actually wrote any of it. Maybe a few lines here and there but some party apparatchik with Labours financial policy reigns probably did the bulk.
National tried to find a $6bill hole, light rail I think, in Labours forecast but that appeared to fall flat. Labours PREFU forecast doesn't go into sufficient detail to show this inclusion or omission. Jacinda mumbled something about it not having been costed by a case study. That doesn't stop you from including an estimate in a forecast.