By Jason Walls
It was supposed to be Bill English’s day.
After a less than stellar start to the year from the Opposition, Bill English’s State of the Nation speech was a chance for the veteran MP to outline his party’s vision for New Zealand and to explain what the Government is getting wrong.
The good news for English is his speech delivered on many of these aspects. It was heavy on the country’s strong economic position and how National had helped to get New Zealand to this point.
He called out the Government for threatening to stifle that growth, specifically with its impending changes around employment law; and he even had a fancy new website to go along with it.
But unfortunately for English and his team of speech writers, that counts for almost nothing just hours after the speech was made.
Even with classic lines such as “the Government’s plan appears to be a nostalgic belief in trees, trains and trade unions”, the scene-setting speech was no match for the smell of blood.
Like many Kiwis, this morning I awoke to speculation that Bill English’s days as National’s leader are numbered and members of his caucus are already vying for the top job.
As the morning progressed so did the story, which continued to snowball until English took to the podium for his speech at midday.
“A bit of leadership speculation certainly turns out the journalists,” English chuckled as he began his speech. Half an hour later, English was greeted by a gaggle of journalists all armed with questions about his leadership.
English committed to “performing at the level that is going to retain confidence” and that the only decider on whether he would remain in Parliament was his own performance.
He described the speculation as “gossip” and told reporters he had strong indications he had the support of his caucus and had “no knowledge” of any leadership changes afoot.
But this won’t stop the stories and the narrative; think back to when former Greens co-leader Metiria Turei and former Labour leader Andrew Little stood down last year. Granted, the moves came under different circumstances, but the fact remains it was a media feeding frenzy in the days preceding their announcements.
Stories about the changing of the guard will continue developing as the week goes on. In question time on Wednesday afternoon, Labour MPs were not holding back with their jeers and taunts to English about this issue and will likely continue on in the House on Thursday.
Questions have already been raised about the timing of the leak, given it spilled out just hours before English’s speech.
But one thing is for sure – the day which English was planning on kick starting the year and putting the Government on the back foot took a turn for the worse.
It was certainly not Bill English’s day.
33 Comments
BE sounds more like a PM than the current PM does.
The current election system produce lightweight individuals to make governing a country like playing a family game, where showmanship is more important than leadership.
Name a few? NZ's PM, Canada's PM, AUS's PM, France's PM....
Can I play this game as well? Showmanship and politics is not a new phenomenon - John Key, Donald Trump, Silvio Berlusconi, Ronald Reagan and other more dictatorial types
Bull is a grey dullard, a bit like John Major - he wasn't particularly good either.
[ Lets leave the insults out of the conversation. Ed ]
John Keys actually understood the banking and global trade system. I doubt there has ever been a labour member who does understand both. Labour tends to produce good social policy but lacks global business experiance and national produces better business policy and understand the financial system but lacks good social policy, Its doubtful naitional spent much time in finland or sweden studying education and jail systems. In comparison new zealand is like sparta, a very spartan social backward place. And if you havnt lived in the regions for a while you should visit them for a while and then visit finland and sweden.
Bill - again, you will be constantly out smarted, and out gunned by Ardern.
And yes, thanks once more for your service, I think you meant well.
You just look tired in opposition - for goodness sake, even Hooton is frantically waving at the door.
You seem like a nice guy, so please don't become an embarrassing side show.
Are you sure you’re not getting mixed up with Trumps State of the Nation speech?
“Small business confidence is at an all-time high. The stock market has smashed one record after another, gaining $8 trillion in value. That is great news for Americans' 401k, retirement, pension, and college savings accounts.”
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2018/01/30/full-text-trumps-state-union…
Trump Touts 'Clean Coal': What Is It, Really?
https://www.livescience.com/60244-what-is-clean-coal.html
... after the election it is constructive for the Gnats to see where they failed :
I'd say that both Paula Benefit and Steven Joyce underperformed ... Joycie straight out lied about the supposed $ 17 billion hole in Labour's fiscal calculations ... poor form , old man , very poor form ...
... and they failed to see the need to promote partners ... they alienated Winston First by attempting to destroy the man over his superannuation overpayments ... a monumentally idiotic strategy by the Gnats .... and they failed to give Gareth Morgan's TOP a boost up .... plus , they didn't back up their main partner , the NZ Maori Party ...
In hindsight , it wasn't rocket science , the blunders the Gnats made ....
... my suggestion for Wild Bill is to ease Ms Bennett aside , and bring the Jacinda attack-dog Crusher Collins in as deputy head-Gnat ... groom her to be the Gnatty leader come the 2020 election ...
Be fantastic for anyone with shares in Oravida, swamp kauri could take over from dairy. I'm salivating just thinking about the amazing and entirely legitimate business that could be done with crusher in charge, would be a great boost for open for business NZ. All that NZ spring water cluttering up the place, they'd be doing us a favour taking it off our hands, we should really be paying them to take it away.
Although I'm uneasy about Collins, it's clear that a female 'stalking horse' is required in this political environment so we can get back to talking about where NZ is going rather focusing on the banal details of a pregnancy. It's notable in my circle that experienced mothers aren't drinking the Taxinda kool aid.
... agreed ... she's not my favourite either ... but she would be pragmatic choice ... as she does have Jacinda's number ... and it looks better if another woman is attacking the PM , rather than one of the Gnatty boys ...
And the Crusher is a tough no nonsense operator ... the Gnats can't afford to have a wishy-washy differing leader into 2020 ...
I think Collins is just too full of herself to be taken seriously. Would be a seriously bad choice. Joyce was Mr Competent by and large, and probably would do a good job if actually elected, but he is just not, well, pretty enough, I suspect.
Of course if Silly Billy had actually put his tax cut in our pockets we wouldn't be having this conversation, now would we? Serious oversight, I mean, I thought they knew that tax cuts take time to take effect. Duh.
The Nats need a cleanskin, everyone named has got something that would make much of the population want to upchuck. Nicki Kaye would be a contender, but not sure if her brush with the unspeakable makes going into a high stress situation a good idea, it thrives on stress and I would not wish a recurrence on her or anyone else.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.