Although politicians might seem divided on climate change, a working group that interviewed 74 MPs on their views maintain there's more alignment on climate change among MPs than the politicians think.
“The MPs' views suggest that the principal opportunity for greater cross-party engagement lies in letting go of the desire for complete agreement, and in building on the existing, more modest shared foundation,” a report by the Members of Parliament Climate Consensus (MPCC) Working Group, released on Wednesday, said.
The MPCC Working Group came together after being "dismayed" by what members saw as an "increasing silence" about climate change. The group comprises community leaders, professionals and advocates. Members include former Labour MP and minister Marian Hobbs and former chair of Transparency International NZ Suzanne Snively.
In the lead up to releasing its report on Wednesday afternoon, the group approached all 122 MPs in the 54th Parliament to ask about their perspectives on climate change. Members of the MPCC project group met with MPs who agreed to take part and could find time to talk.
Of the 122 MPs approached, 74 MPs took part in the report with meetings taking place between October 2025 and September 2026. Some MPs had multiple meetings.
Three ACT MPs, all 15 Green MPs, all 34 Labour MPs, 17 National MPs and five NZ First MPs took part.
The MPCC said they did not lobby and met with MPs to listen to their answers to these questions:
- What are your general thoughts and understandings about climate change?
- What are the challenges that you identify with climate change or that are linked to climate change?
- What, if anything, would you like to do related to climate change, either in your role as MP or personally, and what difficulties do you perceive in achieving this?
MPs’ statements to the MPCC were anonymised and not verbatim quotes, as the group said it wanted MPs to speak freely and frankly as individuals.
“In our analysis we gave particular consideration to the views of MPs in the coalition parties so that their lower participation rate in this project did not skew our understanding,” the group said.
“We also reviewed public statements by non-participating MPs to get a general sense of their views. We have tried to ensure this report reflects adequately the views across all participating parties.”
Here’s what MPs agreed on
The group said based on the comments from meeting with MPs, the foundation for “effective” cross-party action consisted of:
- Acceptance that climate change presents long-term risks and opportunities
- Concern for future generations
- The need for stronger resilience and adaptation
- The importance of remaining economically sound both as a government and as a nation
- A desire for stronger public engagement and political commitment
The group said statements from current MPs showed that they wanted to do something about climate change but were not aligned on what to do, however there was a call for cross-party action.
One MP said: “Climate change should be cross-party, something we should all agree on. It’s not a party-vs-party issue, it’s a NZ issue.”
Another MP said they would work with anyone in Parliament to make sure progress was made while another politician said “the problem isn’t developing consensus, it’s the lack of initiatives.”
The report found that MPs largely agreed that:
- Climate change is real and induced by humans
- A coherent response must be developed
- The science should be followed
- NZ needs to develop its crisis response capability so the country is better prepared for floods, slips, heat waves, storms and other climate events
- Renewables and electrification will be a major focus
- NZ needs to be confident of public support for making changes
- Some form of an Emissions Trading Scheme will probably be part of the country’s response
The report said: “The majority of MPs in the 54th Parliament wanted to do something more to address climate change. With the 2026 Election of our 55th Parliament, it’s time for real action.”
“The three ingredients for that are: leadership with a future vision; cross-party agreement on the pathway ahead and the development of a process that can support cross-party collaborative climate change policy regardless of our 3-year election cycles.”
Economic incentives
When it came to the role of central government in handling the issue, the report said MPs spoke about economic incentives far more often than other reasons to act.
One MP said farmers had raised the issue of the shortness of the electoral cycle which can lead to uncertainty of future decision-making and disincentivises investment in climate adaptation and progress in long-term industries like theirs.
Another said: “Government can't keep paying out market value when climate disasters destroy homes, for example. While insurers and banks have a role in terms of pricing for environmental risk, they are not yet up to speed on this aspect of their work. Government needs to think through its own response to climate disasters.”
Another MP said it was only a matter of time before ratings agencies started factoring the country’s “lowered climate response” into its ratings, while another said “[we should] avoid paying for NZ's liabilities due to not meeting its commitments; keep the funding on-shore by devoting more financial resources to climate change mitigation here.”
Where MPs had different views
The report said there were some consistent themes that popped up in their conversations with MPs which include balancing policy priorities, working in a competitive political context, ‘ideology’ and polarisation, the scale and urgency of NZ’s response to climate change, and the social license to act on climate change.
MPs' views on these topics differed considerably, the report said.
There was less agreement on a range of questions such as:
- What to do to respond to climate change
- How quickly to respond
- How much NZ should/must spend on climate response
- How, whether, and to what extent to protect agriculture
- Whether NZ should aim to mitigate climate change as well as adapt to it
Some MPs think leadership is lacking
Some MPs raised that Māori and Te Tiriti o Waitangi should play a larger role with one MP saying “don’t leave climate change to politicians, work with iwi and community groups.”
Another said: “The challenge [for NZ's response to climate change] is to understand the purpose of the Treaty, Māori culture and Māori special rights. Māori are well placed to have a specific strategy within the climate change strategy. The policy is tikanga for Māori. It needs to be embedded.”
Some MPs also raised concerns for future generations while others thought leadership was missing in action.
Of those who had strong views on leadership, the report said: “These MPs generally said the willingness to act is there, as is the public demand for climate action, but we lack leadership and reasonable ideas on what would make a difference."
One MP told the group that there was no “strategic thinking” about climate change currently, claiming it was not factored into plans for potential managed retreat and infrastructure planning.
Another MP said while the Climate Change Commission was giving free and frank advice, the challenge was getting leaders to listen to the “difficult advice which does not suit their short term interests.”
Mitigation
Mitigation was a divisive topic among the MPs interviewed.
“They agreed, however, in identifying mitigation as the central issue shaping their views," the report said.
The report said mitigation was sometimes dismissed as unnecessary due to “lingering doubts about climate science and what efforts would be effective”.
“Some MPs felt that mitigation is not New Zealand’s responsibility as they consider global warming a problem created by large countries. Some claimed it is too late to address mitigation. Some argued our country is too small for our climate mitigation efforts to have any significant effect on the global problem.
“Altogether, these MPs expressed concern that mitigation could be unnecessary, unfair to New Zealand, or ineffective.”
The report said other MPs were adamant that mitigation had to be central to a NZ climate strategy.
“They felt that focusing only on climate resilience and adaptation would mean responding to the symptoms of the problem instead of the cause. In the long term, in their view, addressing only the symptoms is both expensive and ineffective.”
There was another set of MPs who sat between those two positions with the report saying they were focused on the “importance of transitioning to renewable energy sources without linking this to mitigation”.
“Their aim could be to make energy more affordable, to reduce vulnerability to international disruptions of the fossil fuel supply chain, or to respond to shifts in market demand. The result is that many more MPs would accept climate mitigation via reducing the use of fossil fuels than is apparent from what they have to say about climate change.”
So what now?
The group said this project shows that common ground exists already.
“We should not expect them to agree on everything, or always to be right. But they should be prepared to examine the evidence, question their assumptions and exercise their own judgement, including when doing so is politically uncomfortable.
“The question is not whether our representatives have sufficient common ground on which to act, but whether they are prepared to use it. We, our land and our seas, expect nothing less."
The report said this would require MPs to look beyond the positions of their parties and “work where cooperation is possible, even when agreement on broader questions remains elusive”.
“It also requires them to question whether the political constraints they perceive are as fixed as they believe, or whether some could be overcome through a willingness to engage with colleagues across party lines.”
The group said all political parties support fairness so they should work at building consensus.
“There is more alignment around climate change in Parliament than the politicians think.”
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.