Treasury warns of the risks from our dairy exports dominating our overall export performance, and being too concentrated with China as a customer. It finds other concentrations as well

Treasury warns of the risks from our dairy exports dominating our overall export performance, and being too concentrated with China as a customer. It finds other concentrations as well

This article is reposted from the Treasury website, here, as a Special Topic in the July 2019 Monthly Economic Indicators report


Real average growth in goods and services exports declined from 4.1% p.a. over the 1998-2008 period to 2.4% in the subsequent decade.

Unprocessed primary products have grown at the fastest pace over this period, and account for 40% of the value of merchandise exports.

Moreover, over the last decade, export concentration levels have increased. Dairy products accounted for a quarter of New Zealand’s total merchandise exports in 2018, up from 17% in 1998. Over the same period, goods exports to China’s have risen from just 3% of total exports to 25%.

This puts New Zealand at risk from shocks emanating from either China or the global dairy sector.

This Special Topic takes a closer look at the trends in New Zealand’s export concentration levels over the past two decades, and briefly discusses the risks and mitigating factors associated with this.

Export concentration levels have increased…

One way to assess concentration levels objectively is by looking at the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI).[1] The HHI ranges between zero and one, with a higher value indicating that exports are more concentrated. New Zealand’s HHI scores have increased over the last decade from both a commodity and export destination perspective (Figure 12).

Figure 12: Herfindahl-Hirschman Index for New Zealand's trade exports

Source: Treasury calculations with StatsNZ data

…but are not significantly higher than comparable countries

Figure 13 shows the HHI concentration levels for New Zealand from an export destination perspective as well as the weighted averages for two groups of countries: the OECD and the top 10 exporters in the world in 2018.[2] New Zealand's market concentration level is not significantly higher than comparable countries, although the upward trend witnessed in New Zealand since 2014 is more pronounced than in the other two groups.

Figure 13: Herfindahl-Hirschman Index market concentration: international comparison

Source: World Integrated Trade Solution (WITS)

Note: Groups weighted by export share

Significant exposure to China…

China overtook Australia as New Zealand's largest export destination by value in 2013. Exports to Australia have declined in recent years, reaching $8.2bn in 2018, compared to the 2011 peak of $10bn (Figure 14).

Figure 14: New Zealand's biggest export markets

Source: StatsNZ

Meanwhile, during 1998-2018, export growth to China amounted to $13.1bn, or 39% of New Zealand's total nominal export growth.

…and to China's dairy sector in particular

Dairy products accounted for 32% of New Zealand's total exports to China in 2018. Interestingly, New Zealand's exports to China have in fact become less concentrated than 20 years ago. This is because wool accounted for more than half of exports to China in the 1990s. Wool's importance has since waned, with dairy, wood, and meat now accounting for two thirds of total exports to China.

As a result, dairy exports have become more concentrated

The composition of New Zealand's dairy exports by country has changed drastically over the past 20 years. In 2000, dairy export destinations were diverse, with the top 10 markets each accounting for just 3% to 7% of total exports, while China did not even feature on this list.

China's demand for dairy grew rapidly in the 2000s (Figure 15), supported by an increase in incomes and urbanisation, with the latter being associated with a shift towards a more Westernised diet. New Zealand's dairy exporters arguably started benefiting disproportionately from this from 2008 onwards due to the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with China coming into effect. At the same time, the 2008 China milk scandal (the presence of melamine in milk and infant formula) resulted in consumers preferring imported milk products.

Figure 15: New Zealand's dairy exports to China

Source: StatsNZ

With China now importing about a third of New Zealand's dairy products, the sector has become more concentrated. In fact, the HHI has increased from just 0.04 in 2000 to 0.11 in 2018.

Our increasing exposure to China and dairy holds risks…

Exposure to a single market, and moreover to a single sector in this market, holds risks that are somewhat mitigated for homogenous bulk commodities where overall supply and demand are the most important drivers over the medium to longer term.

A single event in either China or the global dairy sector can lead to a substantial change in export revenues. Over the 2008-13 period, several factors resulted in a sharp increase in export revenues, but the reverse can also happen, as was the case in 2015-16.

This time around, Fonterra discovered botulism-causing bacteria in some of its whey products that had been sold to third parties to make infant formula, among other products. This resulted in a product recall and a temporary ban from China on the imports of milk powder from New Zealand. This, combined with a decline in dairy prices, resulted in a substantial decline in New Zealand's export revenues.

…but also opportunities

Although New Zealand's exposure to China carries some risk, it also presents opportunities. Table 2 shows the top dairy consuming countries in the world in per capita terms (all those with consumption above the world average), as well as China.

Table 2: Per capita dairy consumption by country
Top Dairy Consumers
(kg/capita)
1998 2018 2018-27
Annual Growth
(%)
Kazakhstan 206.8 264.1 1.4%
Pakistan 146.2 231.9 0.3%
Turkey 116.2 184.7 1.4%
Ukraine 225.7 174.2 2.0%
Australia 123.8 129.1 -0.1%
Colombia 124.4 127.3 0.6%
Russia 156.9 122.7 -0.2%
EU-28 95.7 113.7 0.0%
New Zealand 83.6 113.1 -0.1%
Norway 179.4 110.7 -1.2%
Israel 99.8 97.7 -0.5%
Canada 109.8 95.3 0.1%
United States 108.0 92.0 -0.8%
India 54.2 90.5 3.2%
Paraguay 88.3 82.1 1.9%
Brazil 71.0 81.4 1.6%
WORLD 50.5 61.8 1.1%
China 7.5 24.1 1.6%

Source: OECD-FAO Agricultural Outlook (2018)

While dairy consumption levels have plateaued in the developed world, in the world's most populous country there is still significant room for growth. Per capita dairy consumption in China expanded very quickly between 1998 and 2008 (12% p.a.), before stalling over the subsequent decade (0.3% p.a.). The sharp increase in the demand for dairy in China, supported by publically-funded advertising on the health benefits of milk, comes despite the fact that lactose intolerance levels are much higher than in the Western world.

Over the 2018-2027 period, the OECD projects that China’s per capita dairy consumption levels will grow by an average of 1.6% p.a., which implies a noticeable increase in absolute terms given the country’s massive population. Moreover, considering that consumers continue to be suspicious about local dairy products due to the 2008 scandal, foreign dairy products will continue to be in high demand.

Nevertheless, while continuing to maintain and grow our dairy market share in China, from a risk management perspective it would be prudent to expand exports to other markets in order to lessen the dependence on China. In particular, the New Zealand dairy sector should focus on countries where it is not yet well represented, while also considering whether these markets have a good appetite for dairy imports as well as strong growth potential. Figure 16 below shows New Zealand's share in the dairy imports of the top 15 dairy importers in the world. Globally, New Zealand accounted for 11.5% of total global dairy exports, and remains under-represented in some of the world's largest dairy importers. In particular, there still appears to be significant untapped potential in European Union (EU) markets, although this would be contingent upon gaining market access.

Figure 16: New Zealand share in dairy imports for top 15 global dairy importers (2018)

Source: International Trade Centre

Kiwifruit and wine offer possible sources of growth and diversification

Wine grape production increased at a rate of 4.6% p.a. during 2002-2017, increasing its contribution to total horticultural production from 25% to 42%. In the 12 months ending June 2018, the value of New Zealand's wine exports grew for the 23rd year in a row. In addition to providing a growing amount of export receipts, the wine industry is also making a significant contribution to the tourism sector. According to New Zealand Winegrowers Inc., close to a third of all holiday visitors to New Zealand visit a winery; these visitors tend to stay longer in New Zealand, spend more money, and visit more regions.

Although wine exports have grown strongly, the sector is also quite concentrated, both in terms of varietal and market.

Sauvignon Blanc accounted for 86% of New Zealand's total wine exports in 2018, compared to around half of the total in 2001. New Zealand has been successful in carving out a niche market in Sauvignon Blanc, which has supported export volume growth. Meanwhile, New Zealand's wine exports predominantly go to three countries, namely the US, the UK, and Australia. In 2018, these three countries accounted for 76% of New Zealand's total wine exports in value terms. While exports to these countries dominate, there has also been robust growth in exports to Canada, the Netherlands, and China.

New Zealand's kiwifruit exports have been on an upward trajectory over the past two decades, with export values growing at an average rate of 8.4% p.a. over the 1998-2018 period (Figure 17). In 2017, kiwifruit once again overtook wine as New Zealand's largest horticultural export earner.

Figure 17: New Zealand exports of kiwifruit and wine

Source: StatsNZ

FTAs may boost trade, but possibly also concentration levels

New Zealand currently has 10 active FTA's in place, with a further three that have been concluded but are not yet in force, and a number of others that are at varied stages of the negotiation process. While FTAs tend to boost trade levels, they may also have the by-product of an increase in concentration levels. That being said, reaching an agreement with India that will open up the country's dairy sector to New Zealand would serve to lessen our dependence on China. India's dairy market is the largest in the world in absolute terms and is projected to continue growing strongly. New Zealand's dairy exports to India are currently taxed at the most-favoured-nation (MFN) weighted average tariff rate of 43.1%. Talks on New Zealand's FTA with India are ongoing, as are negotiations on the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), which also includes India. These FTA's could be the key to improved access to the potentially lucrative Indian market. Furthermore, negotiations with the EU on an FTA's are also ongoing, which if successful would give New Zealand improved access to some of the world's biggest dairy importers, among other benefits.


Notes

  1. [1] The HHI is calculated by taking the sum of the squares of market shares in an industry, and is usually applied to competition economics.

  2. [2] The top 10 exporters in 2018 in descending order were China, USA, Germany, Japan, South Korea, Netherlands, Hong Kong, France, Italy, and the United Kingdom, according to data from the International Trade Centre.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

10 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

Well this was Govt strategy under the National/Fed Farmers Govt. Dairy and China...with a flag lopped in to try and appease the masses..

.. truth be told , it was Helen Clark who opposed the Commerce Commission when Fonterra was being established as a monopolistic co-operative , under chairman Craig Norgate ... PM Clark wanted an old school diary giant to dominate NZ farming , and to export under one banner only ..

This trade war. A war between state-owned enterprises and the free market.
New Zealand should seek to increase its dairy (and other) exports to markets other than China.

Side note - China needs to end its human rights violation of Falun Gong and better justify why they have 1,000,000 detained prisoners in detention camps.

China should stop its currency manipulation and intellectual property theft of technology. They don't play by the same rules as other industrialised democracies.

The communist party priority is to maintain power.
New Zealand should remember who their historic allies are and seek stronger economic ties with these countries.

Based on mouths to feed shouldnt this be the case?

A useless warning.

Show farms and coops which countries they could sell with such steady and large volumes.

Even those countries exist, their economis will probably depend on China.

A better suggestion would be to secure NZ as a guaranteed supplier of many products to China.

Government officials should work along this line!

And enslave ourselves to the chinese dictatorship?? No thanks. Look how they treat their own people when things get rough. What do you think they'll do to us if they get the chance?

Well said. Communism in China has resulted in the loss of hundreds of millions of its own people.

I smell a rat. We should lessen our dependency on China and strengthen economic ties with other countries.

While the likes of China, India and Vietnam push harder to increase R&D in order to boost their hi-tech exports to the world, NZ should focus all its intellectual capacity on ways to sell more fruits and milk to these "third-world" countries.

May be we should charge them more and use the extra income to develop other markets and move up the value chain instead of being a low price raw material and commodities price taker.