Allan Barber looks at the confusing attempt by MIE supporters to get John Monaghan on to the Alliance board to bolster an elected MIE candidate

Allan Barber looks at the confusing attempt by MIE supporters to get John Monaghan on to the Alliance board to bolster an elected MIE candidate
John Monaghan is seeking the 'independent director' position on the Alliance Group board.

By Allan Barber

The appointment of an independent director should normally be an uncontroversial exercise, but Alliance Group has run into some public relations problems, as it seeks to find a successor to its previous chairman, Owen Poole.

The problem goes back to the attempt by Fonterra director, John Monaghan, to stand for election as a farmer director sympathetic to the objectives of the Meat Industry Excellence group at the AGM in December.

However, despite having a shareholding in a major Alliance supplier, he did not comply with the eligibility criteria as a shareholder and his application was rejected.

The next move was for Alliance shareholders and MIE members, Mark Paterson and Mandy Bell, to move a motion that Monaghan should be appointed to the vacant independent director’s position. This motion was supported by a substantial majority of more than a million votes, but the outcome was not binding on the directors.

Since the AGM the board has appointed a search consultant to conduct a search and interview candidates before submitting a final shortlist for the board to make the appointment.

The successful candidate must satisfy a series of criteria, including senior management, preferably CEO, experience, food, ideally meat, industry experience and current in depth knowledge of the Asian market.

According to Alliance chairman Murray Taggart he and Monaghan had a conversation during which they agreed that Monaghan didn’t exactly fit those criteria. Taggart was also surprised Monaghan did not already have details of the specifications which the company had made known before starting the process.

It also appears the search consultant made an appointment to interview Monaghan, but on arrival at the pre-arranged location, was told the appointment had been cancelled. Taggart assumed that Monaghan had withdrawn from consideration, but this is now being strongly denied by Monaghan, Paterson and Bell.

In an MIE press release on Monday, Paterson is quoted as saying “In talking to John Monaghan, he made it crystal clear that he has made no such decision. John is very committed to bringing his skills and experience to assist in building up Alliance Group and leading much needed reform in the red meat sector as a whole. Murray Taggart’s statement calls into question whether there was ever any serious intent by the board to consider the direction of their shareholders.”

Taggart told me he was somewhat perplexed by this, but admitted that Monaghan seems to think he, Taggart, “has been economical with the truth.”

It would appear there is something of a disconnect between MIE and Alliance Group, in spite of the fact one candidate supported by MIE did make it onto the board at the AGM as a farmer director.

Statements suggest the company is being very unwise in ignoring the clearly expressed wishes of its shareholders, although the company clearly believes it has a right to select the candidate it considers has the best skill set.

From an outside perspective it is impossible to judge which party is right.

It is quite possible Monaghan would bring much needed expertise to the board, but it is equally possible a dairy industry director would have limited value in trying to sort out a very different set of problems in the meat industry.

Time will tell!


Farms For Sale: the most up-to-date and comprehensive listing of working farms in New Zealand, here »

Here are some links for updated prices for


Allan Barber is a commentator on agribusiness, especially the meat industry, and lives in the Matakana Wine Country where he runs a boutique B&B with his wife. You can contact him by email at or read his blog here ».

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.