Mauldin Economics' Robert Ross argues the corporate debt bubble is strikingly similar to the subprime mortgage bubble

Mauldin Economics' Robert Ross argues the corporate debt bubble is strikingly similar to the subprime mortgage bubble

By Robert Ross*

“Housing prices in the US never go down.” 

Just about everyone in America believed that in the mid-2000s.

A limited amount of buildable land and a growing population would keep housing demand strong.

So, house prices will continue to rise.

That was the thinking, anyway. 

Even some of America’s brightest minds - like former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan - jumped on the stable housing bandwagon.

It was unthinkable that the housing market could crash.

Then, the subprime mortgage crisis hit.

Never say never

When people or companies load up on too much debt - especially low-quality debt - it can lead to a crisis.

When I say low-quality debt, I mean riskier loans that have a higher possibility of not being paid back.

That’s exactly what happened during the subprime mortgage crisis.

“Subprime” was just a gentler way of saying riskier debt.

The US financial crisis that started in 2007 was triggered by the bursting of the US housing bubble.

However, this bubble formed because of weak lending standards and cheap, low-interest loans.

This let too many people borrow too much money to buy homes they really could not afford.

This tidal wave of low-quality debt would eventually crash the housing market and threaten the survival of the banking system.

What had been unthinkable a few years earlier had become a stark reality.

Rising low-quality debt is a canary in the coal mine…

From 2004 to 2006, subprime mortgages grew from 8% - near the long-term average - to 20% of the total mortgage market.

Then the housing bubble burst in 2007.

From January 2007 to March 2009, the average home price fell 20%.

The US sank into its deepest recession since the Great Depression.

And it all came back to one thing: too much low-quality debt.

History does rhyme…

This same explosion in low-quality debt is happening in another corner of the US debt market.

I’m talking about BBB-rated corporate bonds.

And just like the housing market, people think this market can never go bust.

Since the end of the financial crisis, the triple-B corporate bond market has grown to twice the size of the subprime mortgage market.

This market is an accident waiting to happen.

An epidemic of shaky debt (again)…

Corporate bonds are debt issued by companies. It’s a way for companies to raise money, and the money must be paid back. Almost every company in the world uses the corporate bond market.

But just like the subprime mortgage market, it’s the poor quality of the debt that’s the problem.

Corporate bonds are rated by credit agencies like Moody’s, S&P, and Fitch. A bond is considered investment-grade if it’s rated between AAA and BBB-.

The closer to triple-A, the safer the bond. (See credit ratings explained here).

But according to Morgan Stanley, the US has been flooded with BBB-rated bonds. That is the lowest a bond can be rated and still be considered investment grade.

In just the last 10 years, the triple-B bond market has exploded from $686 billion to $2.5 trillion - an all-time high.

To put that in perspective, 50% of the investment-grade bond market now sits on the lowest rung of the quality ladder.

And there’s a reason BBB-rated debt is so plentiful.

Too much low-quality debt will break the market

Ultra-low interest rates have seduced companies to pile into the bond market.

Corporate debt has surged to heights not seen since the global financial crisis:


Source: Wall Street Journal

But as I’ve covered here in The Weekly Profitinterest rates have risen significantly.

Since July 2016, the interest rate on the 10-year Treasury note has doubled.

And the value of corporate bonds is tied to government bonds.

When rates on government bonds rise, it makes investment-grade corporate bonds less attractive. This is especially true for bonds on the lower tiers such as BBB-rated bonds.

That’s how the bond market works. Bonds sold today with a higher interest rate make yesterday’s lower-rate bonds lose value. So, higher-rated bonds are a better deal for investors.

And that’s bad news for the companies issuing lower-rated bonds.

BBB-rated bonds have a target on their backs…

In a recession, BBB-rated bonds are the most vulnerable of all investment-grade bonds.

According to Moody’s, 10% of BBB-rated corporate bonds become what’s known in the industry as “fallen angels” in a recession.

That’s a tactful way of saying they’ve been downgraded to “junk” status.

The explosion in the number of BBB-rated bonds guarantees that we will see more fallen angels than ever before during the next recession.

And when that happens, investors that own BBB-rated bonds are going to get badly hurt.

I’m not the only one saying this. I have some pretty good company.

Former Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen thinks corporate debt levels are “quite high.”

She also thinks high corporate debt could prolong a downturn in the economy and lead to lots of bankruptcies.

This market is a ticking time bomb.


*Robert Ross is senior equity analyst at Mauldin Economics. This article is from a regular Mauldin Economics series called The Weekly ProfitIt first appeared here and is used by interest.co.nz with permission.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

5 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

Great write up. Very relevant to us in NZ. We have had sustained low interest rates in NZ for a number of years and therefore a large percentage of home owners have debt that they cant afford. The writing is on the wall. The data is starting to show cracks. Keep a close eye on big businesses, when they start having redundancies or going bankrupt its crash time.

Isn't it funny how the corporate bond market closely resembles a Ponzi. You have to sell new bonds in order to pay back the old.

Scarfie get your kiwi saver into short dated NZ gov bonds mate. I have been there for over 18 months now. IE NZ CASH

Corporate debt here in US has been talked about for years
Maudlin Mauldin

Our NZ banks used to issue bonds as a way of increasing their capital a couple of decades ago. It has been a long time since I have heard of one of our Big 4 issuing these. Now it looks like they will be required to raise even more capital, watch this space for bank bonds to make a comeback.