This article was first published in our email for paid subscribers this morning. See here for more details and to subscribe.
By Gareth Vaughan
Kiwibank says its current "special, limited time" home loan offer is proving its most successful yet with extra staff assigned to meet demand from both existing and new customers seeking to lock in the state owned bank's 4.99% one-year rate.
Spokesman Bruce Thompson told interest.co.nz the bank expects to lend up to NZ$100 million through the special offer, which has been running for a week. Furthermore he said the offer wasn't a loss leader and the New Zealand Post subsidiary was making an "acceptable" return on writing one-year home loans at 4.99%.
Thompson said an extra five or six staff with lending experience had been drafted in to Kiwibank's call lines to make sure customers, and potential customers, get a quick response. Interest in the offer, available to borrowers with at least 30% equity in their homes, was particularly strong over the weekend, he said.
"This would have to be our most successful 'special'," said Thompson.
Launched on April 26, the offer reduced Kiwibank's previous advertised one-year fixed-term interest rate of 5.65% by 66 basis points. It also gives Kiwibank the lowest advertised one-year rate by a bank. The next lowest is HSBC's 5.29%, which is only available to that bank's premier customers who must have either a minimum of NZ$500,000 in home loans with HSBC, or at least NZ$100,000 of savings and investments with HSBC. And after that is Westpac's 5.59%. See all advertised bank home loan rates here.
Thompson said Kiwibank wasn't "picking up vibes" that other banks were matching its offer, although interest.co.nz has heard from one mortgage broking firm that ASB is prepared to.
'Most successful one yet' likely to lend about NZ$100 million
Kiwibank has been running 'special, limited time" mortgage offers, typically for about three weeks, on and off since early 2011. Thompson said the current one was set to be its most successful yet.
"Initially expectations were for (the offer to run for) around three weeks based on the cost of funding (and secured funding) and volume being balance between new and existing customers," said Thompson. "(But) if the demand remains we may extend an extra week."
"We’d expect anywhere between $50 million and $100 million being lent (including to both existing and new customers) for any of these specials and this one certainly looks like being up at the top of that range. New customers would be around half of that, but note that’s extra to our normal business/volumes."
Asked how the 4.99% rate compared with Kiwibank's current overall cost of funding, Thompson said: "This is a tighter margin than the rest of our card, but not a loss leader. We are making an acceptable return."
In its interim results briefing in February Kiwibank said it was 87% funded through customer deposits. The bank is currently advertising one year term deposit rates of 2%, with interest paid on maturity, for minimum deposits of NZ$1,000, 4.5% for minimum deposits of NZ$5,000 with interest paid at maturity, and 4.6% for minimum deposits of NZ$10,000 with interest paid at maturity. It's offering 4.45% for minimum deposits of NZ$5,000 if interest is paid monthly, and 4.55% for minimum deposits of NZ$10,000 when interest is paid monthly. See all advertised bank term deposit rates here.
'Customers' seeking certainty'
Meanwhile, Thompson said the key drivers of demand for the current "special" offer appeared to be home loan customers' seeking some level of certainty given speculation about where interest rates were headed.
"There does not seem to be a perception that rates will fall and financial commentators in Australia are making reference to a decoupling between the Official Cash Rate and bank rates." Thompson said. "We are getting a 50/50 split between existing Kiwibank and new customers inquiring about the rate."
Kiwibank's last "limited time, special" offer was a 5.39% fixed six month offer that ran during February and March. In January it ran an offer of 5.99% per annum for four years, reducing its standard four-year home rate by 80 basis points and undercutting rivals. During last November and December it offered a six-month fixed term rate of 4.99%, reducing its existing rate by 66 basis points. Customers taking up that offer, which Kiwibank said featured the lowest rate ever offered by the bank, also required 30% equity in their home.
KPMG's recent annual Financial Institutions Performance Survey Review of 2011 noted Kiwibank grew loans by 10.9% to NZ$11.582 billion, which although stronger growth than its rivals, was its lowest percentage growth since the bank's inception in 2002.
11 Comments
Its really sad that a New Zealand entitity is effectively destroying other New Zealand owned financial insitutions through its wanton actions to grow market share at all costs - even when it is unsustainable and unable to fund its own captial growth.
The Goverment should impose the market discipline of a shareholder who demands a return on investment rather than more and more money tipped into a black hole purely to try and grow market share.
Its about time Kiwibank was either partially privatised, or sold to NZ Super Fund so that some commercial discipline is placed upon their operations.
There are no other NZ owned entities of scale....plus this is a small offering at $100million, hardly market tilting.
Market disapline like I see private companies have? where financial commentators say there is no value left in the NZX as they have all been gutted?
uh no thanks.
regards
I completely disagree with the comment above!
This is Kiwibank attracting high quality business (lvr 70% or less), while making little/some profit (according to the above)
While this kind of business doesnt help their profits, it helps their true equity position, so if it all turns to custard, they are in a better position than had they not done this drive.
For all the 90-95% loans out there, and it sounds like Kiwibank do their share of those, its great to see (as a shareholder heh) Kiwibank making smart moves to protect my (tax) investment!
What on earth is AAA above on about.
We have had an effective quadopoly with the big Aussie Banks holding interest rates artificially high and ripping cash out of our country. (And you don't have to have a smoke filled room to collude. You can do it without communicating)
Perhaps AAA above works for those banks and is upset that Kiwibank is not playing the game. Obviously AAA would like them bought back under control - for the other banks benefit.
Notably this offer is for 70% or less, so what is the indiscipline in that !!
If banks were making profits that were reasonable, they would all be charging 3.99%. And competing around the edges of that.
Kiwibank's making at best 60 basis points on the special, something not sustainable for acceptable returns for its shareholders over the short-term, but clearly it has a longer-term bent . The hope will be that these new borrowers will remain with them and start paying reasonable rates once it expires in a year
That may or may not be true, but should they stop lending ? If they do, we will have that collapse in the housing market that you're suggesting. Rather, what I suggest you thinking is that you know lending better than them, and that they should only be lending in ways that you think more appropriate - I don't know you, so maybe you do know more than them ?
Arguably as a government entity, KiwiBank's marginal cost of funds could presumably be considered as the government bond rate- currently approximately 3.7%, so 4.99% seems a fair margin on top. It could well be that interest rates will come down before they go up; giving them more margin upside presumably. Given the profits of the big four, they can hardly cry about this from Kiwi Bank.
Good luck raising funding at 3.70%! Look where Kiwbanks 1 year term deposit rate is - 4.60%. That's a margin of 0.39% - not enough to cover cost of capital. I'd suggest that 1 year offshore funding would be just as expensive, if not higher.
Who is going to invest in Kiwibank at 3.70% - would you?
You maybe in a retail mindset....banks can offer funding as a senior ie all but guaranteed debt so it could be this is the case for the sum in question, Kiwibank may have got say $100million at 3%. Look at US treasury's paying 1.75% I think it is...a lot of ppl are happy to invest at a negative rate of return (after inflation) for some reason.....Also Notice kiwibank will only do that when you have 30% of your own money tied up....maybe they want to reduce their leverage, maybe these mortages go into a specific pool to cover that senior debt....so really they may well have a method in their madness, we just dont know its detail.
regards
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.